Serine Protease Inhibitors as Good Predictors of Meat Tenderness: Which Are They and What Are Their Functions?

Since years, serine proteases and their inhibitors were an enigma to meat scientists. They were indeed considered to be extracellular and to play no role in postmortem muscle proteolysis. In the 1990's, we observed that protease inhibitors levels in muscles are a better predictor of meat tenderness than their target enzymes. From a practical point of view, we therefore choose to look for serine protease inhibitors rather than their target enzymes, i.e. serine proteases and the purpose of this report was to overview the findings obtained. Fractionation of a muscle crude extract by gel filtration revealed three major trypsin inhibitory fractions designed as F1 (Mr:50-70 kDa), F2 (Mr:40-60 kDa) and F3 (Mr:10-15kD) which were analyzed separately. Besides antithrombin III, an heparin dependent thrombin inhibitor, F1 and F2 comprised a large set of closely related trypsin inhibitors encoded by at least 8 genes bovSERPINA3-1 to A3-8 and able to inhibit also strongly initiator and effector caspases. They all belong to the serpin superfamily, known to form covalent complexes with their target enzymes, were located within muscle cells and found in all tissues and fluids examined irrespective of the animal species. Potential biological functions in living and postmortem muscle were proposed for all of them. In contrast to F1 and F2 which have been more extensively investigated only preliminary findings were provided for F3. Taken together, these results tend to ascertain the onset of apoptosis in postmortem muscle. However, the exact mechanisms driving the cell towards apoptosis and how apoptosis, an energy dependent process, can be completed postmortem remain still unclear.

Biomarkers of meat tenderness: present knowledge and perspectives in regards to our current understanding of the mechanisms involved.

Biomarkers of the meat quality are of prime importance for meat industry, which has to satisfy consumers' expectations and, for them, meat tenderness is and will remain the primary and most important quality attribute. The tenderization of meat starts immediately after animal death with the onset of apoptosis followed by a cooperative action of endogenous proteolytic systems. Before consideration of the biomarkers identified so far, we present here some new features on the apoptotic process. Among them, the most important is the recent discovery of a complex family of serpins capable to inhibit, in a pseudo-irreversible manner, caspases, the major enzymes responsible of cell dismantling during apoptosis. The biomarkers so far identified have been then sorted and grouped according to their common biological functions. All of them refer to a series of biological pathways including glycolytic and oxidative energy production, cell detoxification, protease inhibition and production of Heat Shock Proteins. Some unusual biomarkers are also presented: annexins, galectins and peroxiredoxins. On this basis, a detailed analysis of these metabolic pathways allowed us to identify some domains of interest for future investigations. It was thus emphasized that mitochondria, an important organelle in the production of energy from carbohydrates, lipids and proteins are a central element in the initiation and development of apoptosis. It was therefore stressed forward that, in fact, very little is known about the postmortem fate of these organelles and their multiple associated activities. Other topics discussed here would provide avenues for the future in the context of identifying reliable predictors of the ultimate meat tenderness.

Inhibition of human initiator caspase 8 and effector caspase 3 by cross-class inhibitory bovSERPINA3-1 and A3-3.

Serpins are a superfamily of structurally conserved proteins. Inhibitory serpins use a suicide substrate-like mechanism. Some are able to inhibit cysteine proteases in cross-class inhibition. Here, we demonstrate for the first time the strong inhibition of initiator and effector caspases 3 and 8 by two purified bovine SERPINA3s. SERPINA 3-1 (uniprotkb:Q9TTE1) binds tighly to human CASP3 (uniprotkb:P42574) and CASP8 (uniprotkb:Q14790) with k(ass) of 4.2x10(5) and 1.4x10(6) M(-1)s(-1), respectively. A wholly similar inhibition of human CASP3 and CASP8 by SERPINA3-3 (uniprotkb:Q3ZEJ6) was also observed with k(ass) of 1.5x10(5) and 2.7x10(6) M(-1)s(-1), respectively and form SDS-stable complexes with both caspases. By site-directed mutagenesis of bovSERPINA3-3, we identified Asp(371) as the potential P1 residue for caspases. The ability of other members of this family to inhibit trypsin and caspases was analysed and discussed.

Calpain 1 binding capacities of the N1-line region of titin are significantly enhanced by physiological concentrations of calcium.

Calpain 1, an ubiquitous well-known calcium-dependent intracellular protease, was recently shown to bind tightly to the proximal end of the I-band titin segment in a calcium-dependent manner [Raynaud et al. (2005) FEBS J. 272, 2578-2590]. In the present work we identified the titin Ig-domain of concern by this interaction and the role of calcium in this interaction using a recombinant fragment of titin spanning the I2-I6 region and its subfragments. The heterodimeric form of calpain 1 binds to this titin fragment with a very high affinity ( K d = 5.1 +/- 0.2 x 10 (-7) M) at much lower calcium levels than those saturating the high-affinity binding sites of the peptidase ( K d = 25 microM). Investigation of this interaction with I2-I6 subfragments clearly showed that the dimeric form of calpain 1 binds exclusively to the Ig-domain I4 of titin with an affinity similar to that of the whole I2-I6 segment. As for the I2-I6 fragment, this interaction is calcium regulated. Calcium was shown to bind tightly to titin ( K d = 1.9 x 10 (-7) M), causing an oligomerization of the titin segment. At physiological calcium concentration (10 (-6) to 10 (-8) M), the prevailing form of the titin fragment is a trimer, suggesting that calpain 1 binds to this titin structure. From the present findings, it was concluded that calcium binding to titin increased the amount of bound calpain 1 (up to 40% of the total calpain 1) and that this bound calpain 1 might constitute a reservoir for this peptidase. In this context, we proposed a schematic diagram of this series of calcium-dependent events with the inherent unanswered questions. These events are probably under a complex regulation involving undoubtedly different yet unidentified proteins.

Purification of the skeletal muscle protein Endopin 1B and characterization of the genes encoding Endopin 1A and 1B isoforms.

In the present work, a new endopin-like serpin designed mEndopin 1B was purified from bovine muscle. Biochemical characterizations (amino acid sequencing and Maldi-Tof mass spectrometry peptide mapping) demonstrated that the purified protein is different from the previously described Endopin 1, renamed mEndopin 1A. The genes and cDNA of both endopins were characterized. The cDNA sequence of mEndopin 1B encodes a predicted protein of 411 amino-acids with a molecular mass of 43808Da. The mEndopin 1B gene comprised four coding exons and an additional 5' untranslated exon. The reactive site sequence of mEndopin 1B is somewhat different from that of mEndopin 1A. Nevertheless, both serpins have a similar peptidase inhibitory pattern against examined proteases (elastase, trypsin, plasmin and chymotrypsin). The high expression of both mEndopin 1A and 1B in bovine serum and tissues and their high efficiency to inhibit elastase (k(ass) approximately 10(6)-10(7) M(-1) s(-1)) suggested that these serpins might play a major role in inflammatory processes.

Muscle endopin 1, a muscle intracellular serpin which strongly inhibits elastase: purification, characterization, cellular localization and tissue distribution.

In the present work, an endopin-like elastase inhibitor was purified for the first time from bovine muscle. A three-step chromatography procedure was developed including successively SP-Sepharose, Q-Sepharose and EMD-DEAE 650. This procedure provides about 300 microg of highly pure inhibitor from 500 g of bovine diaphragm muscle. The N-terminal sequence of the muscle elastase inhibitor, together with the sequence of a trypsin-generated peptide, showed 100% similarity with the cDNA deduced sequence of chromaffin cell endopin 1. Hence, the muscle inhibitor was designated muscle endopin 1 (mEndopin 1). mEndopin 1 had a molecular mass of 70 kDa, as assessed by both gel filtration and SDS/PAGE. According to the association rates determined, mEndopin 1 is a potent inhibitor of elastase (kass=2.41x10(7) M(-1).s(-1)) and trypsin (kass=3.92x10(6) M(-1).s(-1)), whereas plasmin (kass=1.78x10(3) M(-1).s(-1)) and chymotrypsin (kass=1.0x10(2) M(-1).s(-1)) were only moderately inhibited. By contrast, no inhibition was detected against several other selected serine proteinases, as well as against cysteine proteinases of the papain family. The cellular location of mEndopin in muscle tissue and its tissue distribution were investigated using a highly specific rabbit antiserum. The results obtained demonstrate an intracellular location and a wide distribution in bovine tissues.