Symptom management outcomes. Do they reflect variations in care delivery systems?

OBJECTIVES: Symptom management is increasingly recognized as a critical element of patient care, particularly in managing chronic illness. However, research on outcomes related to symptom management is in its infancy, except for the symptom of pain. This symptom was therefore chosen as a prototype to review the state of the science regarding relations between organizational variables and symptom management outcomes and to illustrate the issues regardless of the symptom managed. This article discusses pain outcome measures appropriate for acute and cancer pain, proposes attributes of the care delivery system that may affect outcome measures, and identifies challenges associated with this type of research. METHODS: Review of quality assurance studies raises issues concerning the adequacy of currently used outcomes for pain and satisfaction with pain management. Although considerable effort has been expended in developing pain measurement in adults and children, critical issues for examining pain management outcomes include deciding what perspectives should be used as the most valid indicator of the pain outcome and when the measures should be obtained. RESULTS: Critical concerns are raised about the measure of satisfaction with pain management and its appropriateness as the end-result outcome. A key issue is whether respondents actually disentangle satisfaction with pain management from satisfaction with other aspects of care, including caring dispositions of health-care providers. Finally, the question is raised: Are pain outcomes affected by organizational context? CONCLUSIONS: Although the answer to this question is unknown, a few research studies suggest that organizational context is likely to influence pain outcomes. It is clear, however, from ongoing work that until several conceptual, methodological, and analytic challenges are resolved, research is unlikely to capture the influence of variations in care delivery systems on symptom management outcomes.

Multisite clinical research: a challenge for nursing leaders.

The need for the application of research-based data to diversified healthcare systems has led to more attempts by nurse researchers to investigate phenomena across clinical sites. Nurse executives increasingly are asked to justify resource allocation among organizations, and must compare patient-care practices within complex systems that are often geographically distant. This article describes the pitfalls encountered and the progress made by researchers during a 4-year multisite, multimethod clinical investigation collecting clinical outcome and organizational context data from seven hospitals.

Evaluating a pediatric pain management research utilization program.

Research-based pain assessment and management innovations are not fully utilized in clinical nursing practice. Thus children continue to suffer despite strategies that could eliminate or significantly reduce their pain. An educational program was developed and implemented to integrate state-of-the-art pain assessment and management strategies into the clinical practice of pediatric nurses. This article reports on evaluation of the research utilization process during development and implementation of the program. The program included formal classes, development of instruments for pain assessment and documentation, ongoing consultation on pain management strategies, and designation of a unit-based staff nurse liaison. Findings illuminated the process through which nursing staff on one unit came to learn about new ideas, try those ideas in their clinical practice, re-invent certain strategies to better meet their needs, and, ultimately, to adopt innovations deemed helpful in their work.

Cancer pain guidelines: now that we have them, what do we do?

Addressing the what, who, when, where, and how of implementing the AHCPR guidelines is an attempt to simplify what may be an overwhelming process. Use the suggestions presented in Figure 1 to formulate an action plan, and remember to assign a time frame and individual accountability. The commitment to moving the guidelines from the bookshelf to the bedside begins now. Using a process such as this will assist efforts to improve care of patients in pain. It is our hope that a year from now the copy of the AHCPR cancer pain guidelines on your shelf will not be covered with dust but rather will be a well-worn text translated to practice.

Child's health self-concept scale: its development and psychometric properties.

The Child's Health Self-Concept Scale (CHSCS) is an instrument designed to measure the collection of perceptions a child has concerning health and health-related behaviors. Its development was based on perceptions of children regarding "healthy" and "unhealthy" children. The original instrument was critiqued, revised, and tested. The estimation of reliability and validity was accomplished through a sample of 940 children. Critical analyses of the findings led to the conclusions that the CHSCS had moderate stability and high internal consistency reliability, evidence of content validity, but no evidence of construct validity. Additional research is needed to evaluate its potential usefulness for nursing research and practice.