Antagonism of vaccine-induced HIV-1-specific CD4+ T cells by primary HIV-1 infection: potential mechanism of vaccine failure.

Prior immunity to HIV-1 elicited by vaccination may modify subsequent responses upon exposure to infectious HIV-1. An HIV-1-uninfected person entered in a vaccine trial that included immunizations to HIV-1(LAI) envelope with a recombinant vaccinia vector and recombinant protein developed envelope-specific CD4+ T cell responses, including proliferative and cytolytic responses, but was not protected from a high risk HIV-1 exposure. CD4+ T cell clones derived from blood at the peak of vaccine-induced immunity recognized and lysed autologous target cells expressing four distinct regions within the HIV-1(LAI) envelope region; three of these CTL clones also recognized targets expressing envelope from a similar viral subtype, HIV-1(MN). The epitope specificity of CD4+ clone 9G8, recognizing both HIV-1(LAI) and HIV-1(MN) envelope, was within the 571-590 amino acid envelope region. Sequence analysis of the first infectious autologous strain revealed two amino acid mutations within this region. The 9G8 CTL clone induced by immunization failed to recognize targets expressing the corresponding CTL epitope from the infecting virus. Moreover, a peptide based on the epitope sequence of the infecting isolate antagonized the vaccine-induced CTL clone such that the CTL clone was no longer able to recognize the vaccine strain or HIV-1(MN) epitope. These findings suggest a potentially novel mechanism associated with vaccine failure whereby the infecting virus may not only escape from CTL activity, but also alter the ability of CTL to recognize other variants in an individual.

Immune responses elicited by recombinant vaccinia-human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) envelope and HIV envelope protein: analysis of the durability of responses and effect of repeated boosting.

Previous studies indicate that immunization with recombinant (r) vaccinia-human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) gp160 and boosting with baculovirus-derived HIV-1 rgp160 results in stronger cellular and antibody responses than those following either vaccine alone. The durability of immunity over 1 year was evaluated in 12 recipients. Both cellular and binding antibody responses remained detectable but diminished, and neutralizing antibodies were absent. To boost immunity, rgp160 was given again 1 year after the initial boost. Reboosting elicited strong HIV-specific lymphoproliferative responses. Binding antibody levels also rose dramatically, and the magnitude of the peak responses was significantly greater following the 2-year than following the 1-year boost. However, neutralizing antibody titers were low (1:10-1:20) and detected in only 4 of 12 persons. Moreover, persistent CD8+ cytolytic responses were not induced. Thus, although repeated rgp160 boosting after vaccinia-envelope priming can augment selected immune components, an altered regimen may be necessary to achieve protective long-term immunity to HIV-1.

Safety of and immunological response to a recombinant vaccinia virus vaccine expressing HIV envelope glycoprotein.

In a randomised phase I trial of a recombinant vaccina virus vaccine expressing the gp160 envelope gene of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIVAC-1e) 35 healthy, HIV-seronegative males, 31 of whom had a history of smallpox immunisation and 4 of whom were vaccinia naive, were vaccinated and then boosted 8 weeks later with HIVAC-1e or standard NY strain vaccinia virus. The frequency, duration, and titre of virus isolation from the vaccination site and occurrence of local side-effects were similar between the two groups of vaccinees. Vaccinia-naive (vac-n) subjects shed virus from the vaccination site for longer and at a higher titre than did vaccinia-primed (vac-p) individuals (19 vs 7 days and 10(7) vs 10(5) pfu/ml, respectively). In-vitro T-cell proliferative responses to one or more HIV antigen preparations developed in 13 of 16 vaccinia-primed subjects inoculated with HIVAC-1e. T-cell responses were, however, transient and in no subject did antibodies to HIV become detectable. The 2 vaccinia-naive subjects vaccinated with HIVAC-1e showed strong T-cell responses to homologous and heterologous strains of whole virus and to recombinant gp160 protein that remained detectable for over a year; antibodies to HIV envelope also developed in both. Recombinant vaccinia virus vaccines induce T-cell priming to the foreign gene products in most individuals. If used as the sole immunising agent they will be most efficacious in vaccinia-naive individuals.