Dose-time relationships for elicitation of contact allergy to para-phenylenediamine.

Skin-sensitizing chemicals exhibit dose-response relationships for the elicitation of contact dermatitis. Previously, considerable work has been carried out in which the elicitation of allergic skin reaction has been examined as a function of the applied concentration. However, the relationship between exposure time, dose and response has not been explored in any depth. The present work has extended our initial assessment of the relationship between both exposure time and concentration for para-phenylenediamine (PPD) in a group of 19 PPD-allergic volunteers. The results clearly demonstrate that a relationship exists between both exposure time and concentration. Positive responses to PPD were directly proportional to exposure time: at 5 min 16% responded; at 15 min, 38%; at 30 min, 50%; and at 120 min, 69%. A similar direct relationship was found between concentration of PPD and response: after 120 min, 22% of patients had responded to 0.01%, and 69% to 1% PPD. All exposures for 1 and 2 min were negative. Subsequent evaluation using repeated 5 min open application testing demonstrated a cumulative effect, as after 8 days 39% of the panel reacted, more than double the number that reacted to a single occluded 5-min treatment. It was noted that there was marked subject variability in exposure time and dose required to elicit an allergic response. These results are of relevance for the general interpretation of patch test data, especially with regard to risk assessment.

Benzalkonium chloride neutralizes the irritant effect of sodium dodecyl sulfate.

When benzalkonium chloride (BKC), a cationic surfactant, is added to sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), an anionic surfactant, and used in patch testing, on the basis of their known physicochemical interaction, it is possible to predict that there will be a tendency towards a reduction in the expected irritant response when compared to SDS alone. The aim of this study was to investigate whether BKC could reduce the irritant response to SDS when applied after the SDS exposure. 54 non-atopic adult volunteers were recruited for the study. 20% SDS was applied for 2 h under occlusion. 1% BKC was then applied to the same site. Various controls, including SDS application followed by water for 2 h, were included. The irritant reaction was assessed at 24 h and 48 h. 40 of the 54 subjects had some reaction when SDS was applied for 2 h followed by either benzalkonium chloride or water control under occlusion. In comparison to water control, where BKC was applied after SDS, 20 of the 40 responders had a weaker reaction but only 4 had a stronger response. This study shows that BKC applied to skin exposed to SDS attenuates the resulting irritant reaction.

The effect of patch duration on the elicitation of para-phenylenediamine contact allergy.

To study the length of exposure time required to elicit para-phenylenediamine (PPD) allergic reactions, patients known to be allergic to PPD were recruited and patch tested. A group of 7 patients were patch tested with 1% PPD in pet. for 15 min, 30 min and for 120 min. The remaining 9 patients were patch tested with 1%, 0.3%, 0.1% and 0.01% PPD for 15 min, 30 min and for 120 min each. With exposure for 120 min, 11 of 16 subjects reacted to 1% PPD and 2 of 9 reacted to 0.01%. With exposure of 15 min, 6 of 16 reacted to 1% PPD and 0 of 9 reacted to 0.01% PPD. This study showed marked inter-individual variability in eliciting a reaction to the PPD molecule on patch testing, with regard to both the exposure time and the concentration required.