The transfer of disc pressure to adjacent discs in discography: a specificity problem?

STUDY DESIGN: In vivo experimental study. OBJECTIVE: The primary objective of the study was to investigate pressure transmission to adjacent discs during discography. A secondary objective was to quantify the transmitted pressure, both in contrast injected and noninjected porcine intervertebral discs. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Discography is used to before surgery identify painful discs. A pain response during discography that is concordant with the patient's experienced back pain is regarded as an indication that the injected disc is the source of pain. However, the sensitivity and specificity of discography are matters of debate. Pressure-controlled discographies have been reported to reduce the number of false-positive discs using low pressure criteria. Preliminary data indicated a transfer of pressure from an injected to an adjacent disc during discography. Pressure transmission in vivo during lumbar discography, not reported before might, if clinically present, contribute to a false-positive diagnosis. METHODS: Thirty-six lumbar discs in 9 adolescent pigs were investigated. Intradiscal pressure was recorded during contrast injection, using a 0.36/0.25 mm fiber-optic pressure transducer inserted into the nucleus pulposus via a 22 G needle. The pressure was measured simultaneously in 2 adjacent discs during contrast injection into 1 of the discs at pressures up to 8 bar. Transmitted pressure was recorded both in noninjected discs and in discs that were prefilled with contrast. RESULTS: Thirty-three discs were successfully examined. During contrast injection, there was an intradiscal pressure rise in the adjacent disc with a median value of 16.0% (range, 3.2-37.0) over baseline pressure. There was no significant difference in pressure increase between the noninjected and prefilled discs (P < 0.68). CONCLUSION: Discography of porcine discs induces a pressure increase in adjacent discs. A similar pressure transfer during human clinical discography might elicit false-positive pain reactions.

The immediate effect of repeated loading on the compressive strength of young porcine lumbar spine.

The human spine is exposed to repeated loading during daily activities and more extremely during sports. Despite this, there remains a lack of knowledge regarding the immediate effects on the spine due to this mode of loading. Age-specific spinal injury patterns has been demonstrated and this implies differences in reaction to load mode and load history The purpose of the present study was to investigate the impact of cyclic pre-loading on the biomechanical properties and fracture patterns of the adolescent spine in an experimental model. Eight functional spinal units from four young porcine spines were harvested. The functional spinal units were cyclic loaded with 20,000 cycles and then axially compressed to failure. The compression load at failure, ultimate stress and viscoelastic parameters were calculated. The functional spinal units were examined with plain radiography, computer tomography and MRI before and after the loading, and finally macroscopically and histologically. The median compression load at failure in this study was 8.3 kN (range 5.6-8.7 kN). The median deformation for all cases was 2.24 mm (range 2.30-2.7 mm) and stiffness was 3.45 N/mm (range 3.5-4.5 N/mm). A fracture was seen on radiograph in one case, on CT and macroscopically in seven, and on MRI and histologically in all eight cases. The cyclic loaded functional spinal units in the present study were not more sensitive to axial compression than non-cyclic loaded functional spinal units from young porcine. The endplate and the growth zone were the weakest part in the cyclic loaded functional spinal units. Disc signal reduction and disc height reduction was found on MRI. The E-modulus value found in this study was of the same order of magnitude as found by others using a porcine animal model.

Corticomotor excitability of back muscles is affected by intervertebral disc lesion in pigs.

Morphological and behavioural changes in back muscles are common in back pain and injury. Recent data indicate a rapid reduction in the size of the multifidus, a deep back muscle, within 3 days of experimental intervertebral disc (IVD) injury in pigs. A reduced neural drive may contribute to this. We investigated changes in corticomotor excitability following IVD lesion by evaluation of the response of back muscles to electrical stimulation of the motor cortex. Motor evoked potentials (MEPs) were studied in 12 Swedish landrace pigs before injury, immediately after abdominal incision, immediately after L3-4 IVD lesion with a scalpel, and 15 min later. In two animals, responses were also evoked by descending volleys excited at the level of the mastoid processes (cervicomedullary evoked potentials) without motor cortex activation. In five animals, a sham procedure was followed without IVD lesion. MEPs were recorded in short (deep) and long (superficial) fibres of the multifidus at L3-5 on the lesioned side and at L4 contralaterally with intramuscular wire electrodes. Although the MEP amplitude increased in several muscles after incision, at 15 min after IVD lesion only the MEP amplitude of the deep L4 multifidus on the lesioned side was increased [36% (SD 15%), P < 0.05]. There were no changes in MEP amplitude after 15 min at adjacent or contralateral levels. The response to cervicomedullary stimulation reduced slightly. This suggests that the increased MEP amplitude was due to changes in cortical excitability. These data indicate that IVD lesion induces localized increases, and not decreases, in the excitability of cortical inputs to the deep paraspinal muscles that cross a lesioned disc.

Bulging of the inner and outer annulus during in vivo axial loading of normal and degenerated discs.

STUDY DESIGN: Comparison of in vivo biomechanical outcomes between experimental and control group animals. OBJECTIVE: To quantify the in vivo bulging response of the inner and outer annulus in animals with and without disc degeneration. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Prior attempts to quantify the load-deformation response of the inner annulus have most often relied on in vitro preparations. Unfortunately, to visualize the inner annulus, these in vitro approaches rely on disc modifications that may result in nonphysiologic behaviors. In response to this problem, in vivo techniques were developed to quantify regional bulging of the inner and outer annulus during applied axial loading. METHODS: Two groups of pigs were tested: a normal group and a group having disc degeneration that was induced surgically 3 months earlier. Eight adolescent pigs were evaluated and for each animal, a miniature servohydraulic actuator was attached to the third and fourth lumbar vertebrae to deliver a cyclic axial loading protocol (300 N, 1 Hz, 10 cycles) whereas regional deformations of the annulus were visualized ultrasonically via retroperitoneal access. RESULTS: For the normal animals, image analysis demonstrated a significantly greater bulging of the inner annular region when compared with the outer annular region. In animals with disc degeneration, the inner and outer annular regions were equal in their bulging response, which ranged from 0 bulging to 37% greater than the average response of the normal animals. CONCLUSIONS: This work supports prior in vitro studies that observed maximal disc bulging in the inner annulus and minimal bulging in the external annulus. Results for this in vivo study suggest that this normal bulging gradient is lost with degenerative disc disease. Compared with in vitro approaches, this new in vivo technique has the potential to demonstrate disc behavior in a variety of loading conditions and/or with a variety of induced disc pathologies.

Plasmin-matrix metalloproteinase cascades in spinal response to an experimental disc lesion in pig.

STUDY DESIGN: Proteinases were immunohistochemically stained to analyze degenerated discs and paradiscal tissues in comparison to contiguous control tissues in an experimental porcine model of intervertebral disc degeneration. OBJECTIVE: The aim was to analyze plasmin and metalloproteinases known to participate in mutual activation cascades. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Comparison of the degenerated discs and paradiscal structures with control tissues disclosed accumulation of plasmin and induction of matrix metalloproteinases (MMP), MMP-1 and MMP-2 in the discs, but some other MMPs in reactive and remodeling tissues. MATERIAL AND METHODS: In 6 domestic pigs, the cranial L4 endplate was perforated to penetrate the nucleus pulposus. Three months later, the animals were killed and the experimental and the contiguous control vertebrae, complete with their intervertebral discs, were excised and subjected to histologic and immunohistochemical examinations. RESULTS: Immunohistochemical analysis disclosed increased expression of MMP-1 and MMP-2 in the traumatized and degenerated intervertebral discs. Some MMPs were also induced in all paradiscal structures (bone marrow, vertebral bone, and spinal ligaments), or decreased in already scarred areas. The common denominator for all the anatomic sites studied was accumulation of plasmin. CONCLUSION: Fibroblast collagenase (MMP-1) and gelatinase A (MMP-2), capable of degrading native and denatured collagen, were induced in degenerating intervertebral discs. Use of an experimental model enabled demonstration that biomechanical destabilization and degeneration of the disc also affects all other paradiscal structures, which are subjected to proteolysis and/or reparative fibrosis apparently representing remodeling of the spine subjected to pathologic stress. Profiling of various MMPs and plasmin, known to participate in mutual activation cascades, suggests that plasmin could activate pro-MMP-1, pro-MMP-2, pro-MMP-3, pro-MMP-7, pro-MMP-9, and pro-MMP-13 and alone or/and in cooperation with MMP-3 initiate at least 2 mutual MMPs activation cascades driven by activated MMP-3 and MMP-7.

Rapid atrophy of the lumbar multifidus follows experimental disc or nerve root injury.

STUDY DESIGN: Experimental study of muscle changes after lumbar spinal injury. OBJECTIVES: To investigate effects of intervertebral disc and nerve root lesions on cross-sectional area, histology and chemistry of porcine lumbar multifidus. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The multifidus cross-sectional area is reduced in acute and chronic low back pain. Although chronic changes are widespread, acute changes at 1 segment are identified within days of injury. It is uncertain whether changes precede or follow injury, or what is the mechanism. METHODS: The multifidus cross-sectional area was measured in 21 pigs from L1 to S1 with ultrasound before and 3 or 6 days after lesions: incision into L3-L4 disc, medial branch transection of the L3 dorsal ramus, and a sham procedure. Samples from L3 to L5 were studied histologically and chemically. RESULTS: The multifidus cross-sectional area was reduced at L4 ipsilateral to disc lesion but at L4-L6 after nerve lesion. There was no change after sham or on the opposite side. Water and lactate were reduced bilaterally after disc lesion and ipsilateral to nerve lesion. Histology revealed enlargement of adipocytes and clustering of myofibers at multiple levels after disc and nerve lesions. CONCLUSIONS: These data resolve the controversy that the multifidus cross-sectional area reduces rapidly after lumbar injury. Changes after disc lesion affect 1 level with a different distribution to denervation. Such changes may be due to disuse following reflex inhibitory mechanisms.

Prevalence of low back pain and sickness absence: a "borderline" study in Norway and Sweden.

AIMS: Low back pain (LBP) is a major public health problem in both Norway and Sweden. The aim of the study was to estimate the prevalence of LBP and sickness absence due to LBP in two neighbouring regions in Norway and Sweden. The two areas have similar socioeconomic status, but differ in health benefit systems. METHODS: A representative sample of 1,988 adults in Norway and 2,006 in Sweden completed questionnaires concerning LBP during 1999 and 2000. For this study only individuals in part or full time jobs, (n = 1,158 in Norway and n = 1,129 in Sweden) were included. RESULTS: In Norway the lifetime prevalence was 60.7% and in Sweden 69.6%, the one-year prevalence was 40.5% and 47.2%, and the point prevalence 13.4% and 18.2% respectively. There was a significantly higher risk of reporting LBP in Sweden, even after controlling for gender, age, education, and physical workload. There was no difference in risk of self-certified short-term sickness absence (1-3 days), but it was a 40% lower risk of sickness absence with medical sickness certification in Sweden compared with Norway. CONCLUSION: The prevalence of LBP was higher in the Swedish area than in the Norwegian. The risk of self-certified sickness absence, however, showed no differences and the risk of medically certified sickness absence was lower in the Swedish area. This contradiction might partly be explained by the economical "disincentives" in the Swedish health compensation system.

Vertebral fractures and separations of endplates after traumatic loading of adolescent porcine spines with experimentally-induced disc degeneration.

BACKGROUND: Abnormalities of the intervertebral discs have been found in a high frequency among young elite athletes. Several studies have also reported that the adolescent spine, especially the vertebral growth zones, is vulnerable to trauma. However, there is incomplete knowledge regarding the injury mechanism of the growing spine. In this study, the injury patterns of the adolescent porcine spine with disc degeneration were examined. METHODS: Twenty-four male pigs were used. A degenerative disc was created by drilling a hole through the cranial endplate of a lumbar vertebra into the disc. Two months later the animals were sacrificed and the degenerative functional spinal units (segments) were harvested. The segments were divided into three groups and exposed to axial compression, flexion compression or extension compression to failure. The load and angle at failure were measured for each group. The segments were examined with magnetic resonance imaging and plain radiography before and after the loading and finally examined macroscopically and histologically. FINDINGS: The degenerated segments required considerably more compressive load to failure than non-degenerated segments. Creating a flexion injury required significantly more load than an extension injury. Fractures and/or separations of the endplates from the vertebral bodies were seen at the margins of the endplates and in the growth zone. Only severe separations and fractures could be seen on plain radiography and magnetic resonance imaging. INTERPRETATION: The weakest part of the adolescent porcine lumbar spine with experimentally-induced degeneration, when loaded in axial compression, flexion compression or extension compression, was the growth zone, and, to a lesser extent, the endplate. Degenerated discs seem to withstand higher mechanical loads than non-degenerated discs, probably due to altered stress distribution.

Fracture patterns of the adolescent porcine spine: an experimental loading study in bending-compression.

STUDY DESIGN: To expose functional spinal units from adolescent porcine to mechanical flexion-compression and extension-compression to failure. The biomechanical, radiologic, magnetic resonance imaging, and histologic characteristics are described. OBJECTIVES: The aim of the present study was to investigate the fracture pattern of functional spinal units from adolescent porcine lumbar spines in in vitro compression loading and bending. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: In several studies, it has been shown that the adolescent spine, especially the vertebral growth zones, is vulnerable to trauma. A high frequency of abnormalities affecting the spine has been found among athletes participating in sports with high demands on the back. The etiology of these abnormalities is still a controversial issue. METHODS: Sixteen functional spinal units obtained from eight adolescent male pigs were used. Eight functional spinal units were exposed to flexion-compression and eight functional spinal units to extension-compression loading to failure. They were examined with plain radiography and magnetic resonance imaging before and after the loading. The functional spinal units were finally examined macroscopically and histologically. RESULTS: Fractures/separations were seen in the growth zone anteriorly and more frequently, posteriorly in functional spinal units exposed to flexion-compression. In the extension-compression group, such injuries occurred only anteriorly. Only large fractures could be seen on plain radiographs and on magnetic resonance imaging. Macroscopically, a fracture/separation could be seen in 15 cases and histologically in all 16 cases. The median angle at failure for the flexion group was 17 degrees (range, 12-19) and for the extension group 17 degrees (range, 13-19 degrees). The median ultimate compression load in the flexion-compression group was 1894 N (range, 1607-3138 N) and in the extension-compression group 1801 N (range, 1158-2368 N). CONCLUSIONS: The weakest part of the growing porcine lumbar spine, when compressed into flexion- or extension-compression, was the growth zone. The injury was more extensive in extension loading than during flexion loading. Growth zone injuries of the adolescent spine may go undetected on plain radiographs and magnetic resonance imaging.

In vivo porcine intradiscal pressure as a function of external loading.

BACKGROUND: Spinal loading during daily activity as it relates to the ability of the intervertebral disc to sustain its integrity has been a major issue in spinal research. The purpose of this investigation was to establish the relationship between the intervertebral disc pressure in the nucleus and the load applied to the motion segment in an in vivo porcine model. METHODS: Nine domestic pigs were used in this study. A miniaturized servohydraulic testing machine was affixed to the lumbar spine via four intrapedicular screws, which were inserted bilaterally into the L2 and L3 vertebrae. A pressure needle was inserted through the lateral part of the L2-L3 disc annulus and into the nucleus pulposus. Force, deformation, and intradiscal pressure data were collected during a loading scheme that consisted of applying a set of constant loads in increasing order, that is, 50, 100, 150, 200, and 250 N. Each load was applied for 30 seconds followed by 30-second restitution. RESULTS: Intradiscal nucleus pressure was found to correlate to the applied load in all cases. Linear regression analyses resulted in the following equation: intradiscal pressure (MPa) = 0.08 + 1.25E(-3)(load, N), r(2) = 0.81, n = 8. Intradiscal pressure was also highly linearly dependent on the stress. The intrinsic intradiscal pressure was found to be 81 +/- 5 kPa. The results also indicated that the pressure within the disc exhibited a creep behavior. CONCLUSION: In conclusion, pressure in the nucleus of the porcine intervertebral disc was linearly related to the applied load and stress.

Experimental disc degeneration due to endplate injury.

The aim of this study was to create an experimental model of disc degeneration that closely mimicked human disc degeneration. In six domestic pigs, an L4 cranial endplate perforation into the nucleus pulposus was made. Three months postoperatively, compressive testing was performed on the L2-L4 motion segments, and intradiscal pressure was measured in the intervening discs. Histochemical and morphologic examinations were made on the excised degenerated and adjacent discs. A significant reduction in water content was observed in the outer anterior annulus of the degenerated disc. In the nucleus, the proteoglycan content was significantly reduced, as well as the cellularity, although not significantly. The nucleus lost its gel-like structure and was discolored, and there was delamination of annular layers. Intradiscal pressure in the nucleus was significantly lower in the degenerated disc. In conclusion, experimental degeneration of the intervertebral disc induced by endplate penetration resembled human disc degeneration, as exemplified by biochemical and structural changes.

Intervertebral stiffness of the spine is increased by evoked contraction of transversus abdominis and the diaphragm: in vivo porcine studies.

STUDY DESIGN: In vivo porcine study of intervertebral kinematics. OBJECTIVES: This study investigated the effect of transversus abdominis and diaphragm activity, and increased intra-abdominal pressure on intervertebral kinematics in porcine lumbar spines. BACKGROUND: Studies of trunk muscle recruitment in humans suggest that diaphragm and transversus abdominis activity, and the associated intra-abdominal pressure contribute to the control of intervertebral motion. However, this has not been tested in vivo. METHODS: Relative intervertebral motion of the L3 and L4 vertebrae and the stiffness at L4 were measured in response to displacements of the L4 vertebra imposed via a device fixed to the L4 vertebral body. In separate trials, diaphragm and transversus abdominis activity was evoked by stimulation of the phrenic nerves and via electrodes threaded through the abdominal wall. RESULTS: When intra-abdominal pressure was increased by diaphragm or transversus abdominis stimulation, the relative intervertebral displacement of the L3 and L4 vertebrae was reduced and the stiffness of L4 was increased for caudal displacements. There was no change in either parameter for rostral displacements. In separate trials, the diaphragm crurae and the fascial attachments of transversus abdominis were cut, but intra-abdominal pressure was increased. In these trials, the reduction in intervertebral motion was similar to trials with intact attachments for caudal motion, but was increased for rostral trials. CONCLUSIONS: The results of these studies indicate that elevated intra-abdominal pressure, and contraction of diaphragm and transversus abdominis provide a mechanical contribution to the control of spinal intervertebral stiffness. Furthermore, the effect is modified by the muscular attachments to the spine.

Sensorimotor control of the spine.

The spinal viscoelastic structures including disk, capsule and ligaments were reviewed with special focus on their sensory motor functions. Afferent capable of monitoring proprioceptive and kinesthetic information are abundant in the disc, capsule and ligament. Electrical stimulation of the lumbar afferents in the discs, capsules and ligaments seem to elicit reflex contraction of the multifidus and also longissimus muscles. The muscular excitation is pronounced in the level of excitation and with weaker radiation 1 to 2 levels above and below. Similarly, mechanical stimulation of the spinal viscoelastic tissues excites the muscles with higher excitation intensity when more than one tissue (ligaments and discs for example) is stimulated. Overall, it seems that spinal structures are well suited to monitor sensory information as well as to control spinal muscles and probably also provide kinesthetic perception to the sensory cortex.