Extracting phosphorus and other elements from lake water: Chemical processes in a hypolimnetic withdrawal and treatment system.

Hypolimnetic withdrawal provides a way to remove phosphorus (P) from eutrophic lakes, but the method is still rarely combined with water treatment for capturing this P. Thus, little is known about the chemical interactions of P and other elements upon the treatment of hypolimnetic lake water. We investigated these chemical processes in a hypolimnetic withdrawal and treatment system (HWTS) in which hypolimnetic water is first led into a treatment unit for dissolved P (dP) precipitation and subsequently filtered before being circulated back into the lake. We studied three different field-scale treatment unit setups and water treatments (aeration only, aeration + calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH)2), aeration + biopolymer) to compare their effectiveness for dP removal and the geochemical properties of the resulting precipitate. In the aeration only treatment, most of the dissolved iron (dFe) (91-95%) and dP (71-91%) were removed when sand filters were used. The addition of Ca(OH)2 and biopolymer enhanced Fe flocculation, leading to more effective removal of dFe (d99-100%) and dP (88-95%) from the water. Regardless of the water treatment method, dP was always precipitated by amorphous Fe oxides formed in the hypolimnetic water upon aeration. The P content of the resulting precipitates was somewhat lower than expected (2 439-4 145 mg kg-1), which may be linked to chemical interactions between Fe and other components in the hypolimnetic water, such as organic matter. The precipitates also contained some heavy metals such as copper and zinc. We conclude that all the tested water treatments were effective in removing dP from hypolimnetic water, but the enhanced precipitation by the addition of treatment chemicals is beneficial when a mesh or other rapid filtration method is used, or when there is only negligible accumulation of dFe in the hypolimnion of the treated lake. Depending on the water treatment method and the water chemistry of the treated lake, the precipitate may have potential for nutrient recycling, although it may sometimes require preliminary processing to enhance bioavailability for plants and to reduce the concentration of heavy metals.

Diet shifts and food selection of perch Perca fluviatilis and roach Rutilus rutilus in humic lakes of varying water colour.

The field data from four humic lakes suggested that water colour may have both direct and indirect effects on inter- and intra-specific interactions of perch Perca fluviatilis and roach Rutilus rutilus. The results agree with suggestions that, compared with R. rutilus, P. fluviatilis may be an inferior forager on zooplankton in highly coloured water. As an indirect effect, water colour decreases the coverage of macrophytes and limits suitable littoral habitats, benefiting R. rutilus over P. fluviatilis. Perca fluviatilis benefiting from complex habitats does not have the advantage in macrophyte-poor highly coloured water.

Feeding efficiency of planktivorous perch Perca fluviatilis and roach Rutilus rutilus in varying turbidity: an individual-based approach.

The feeding rate of perch Perca fluviatilis showed high individual variation at low and moderate turbidities, when one individual had consumed more Daphnia pulex than any other fish, whereas no such variation in feeding efficiency was observed with roach Rutilus rutilus. There was a significant decrease in total consumption of D. pulex by P. fluviatilis with increasing turbidity, but no correlation was observed in the case of R. rutilus. The results suggest that the difference in the ontogeny of P. fluviatilis and R. rutilus may be detectable as behaviour-related species-specific trait differences in the early planktivorous feeding stage of the two common species.

Food niche segregation between two herbivorous cyprinid species in a turbid lake.

The diet and growth of two cyprinids, roach Rutilus rutilus and rudd Scardinius erythrophthalmus, in the clay-turbid Kirkkojärvi basin in Lake Hiidenvesi (Finland) were studied. Young R. rutilus fed mainly on detritus, molluscs, chironomids and zooplankton, while older individuals consumed mostly detritus, molluscs and filamentous algae. In the food of S. erythrophthalmus, detritus was less prevalent and animal food and plants contributed to most of the diets. The animal food of S. erythrophthalmus consisted mostly of surface insects. Of the plant food, the macrophytes Potamogeton obtusifolius and Ranunculus circinatus had the highest representation, while the proportion of filamentous algae was low. The growth rate of S. erythrophthalmus was significantly higher than that of R. rutilus. The results suggested that the species composition of vascular macrophytes was not favourable for R. rutilus. Small submerged species suitable for R. rutilus were absent and they fed on filamentous algae and detritus, which resulted in a slow growth rate. The results suggested that in a clay-turbid lake the food spectrum is more suitable for S. erythrophthalmus than for R. rutilus. In such conditions, R. rutilus may have no benefit from its generalistic feeding abilities.