Influence of an additional locking screw on fracture reduction after volar fixed-angle plating-introduction of the "protection screw" in an extra-articular distal radius fracture model.

BACKGROUND: Though, volar fixed-angle plating has become increasingly popular to treat distal radius fractures no studies are available comparing the mechanical properties of different screw configurations to fix the plate to the shaft. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of an additional locking screw directly proximal to the fracture site and to assess if such a screw might be protective against secondary loss of reduction after volar fixed-angle plating. METHODS: Ten Sawbones radii were used to simulate an extra-articular distal radius fracture model (AO/OTA 23-A3). In the first group (n = 5), volar fixed-angle plates (Aptus Radius 2.5, Medartis, Switzerland) were fixed to the radius shaft with a single nonlocking cortex screw in the oval hole and with two locking screws in the holes proximal to the long hole (LLNx); in the second group, the plates were fixed identically as in the first group, but an additional locking screw was inserted into the plate-hole distal to the oval hole, proximal to the fracture site (LLNL). After embedding, specimens were tested with a servohydaulic material testing machine under cyclic axial loading with 800 N for 2,000 cycles. Axial stiffness, elastic axial deformation (elastic dorsal tilt angle), and plastic deformation (plastic dorsal tilt angle) were recorded. RESULTS: After 2,000 cycles, stiffness was 761.6 (+/-59.5) N/mm in group LLNx and 628.9 (+/-37.6) N/mm in group LLNL without significant difference. Elastic deformation and elastic tilt angle were 1.05 (+/-0.08) mm and 3.9 (+/-0.3) degree in group LLNx. In group LLNL, elastic deformation and elastic tilt angle were 1.27 (+/-0.08) mm and 4.7 (+/-0.3) degree, respectively. Plastic deformation and plastic tilt angle were significantly higher in group LLNx (p < 0.001). After 2,000 cycles, dorsal tilt angle was 1.9 (+/-0.3) degree in group LLNx and 0.7 (+/-1.0) in group LLNL. CONCLUSION: This study showed the mechanical superiority of volar fixed-angle plates with a "protection screw" in an extra-articular fracture model. Further clinical investigation is needed to verify the results.

Micromotion at the fracture site after tibial nailing with four unreamed small-diameter nails--a biomechanical study using a distal tibia fracture model.

BACKGROUND: Intramedullary nailing is the treatment of choice in tibia fractures allowing for closed fracture reduction and internal fixation. Small-diameter nails that preserve the endosteal blood supply act as load-sharing devices after proximal and distal locking. Despite fracture healing is influenced by movements at the fracture gap, no data are available reporting on the micromovements at the fracture site if small-diameter nails were used. METHODS: Using a Sawbone distal tibia fracture model, we assessed offset, elastic, plastic, permanent, and overall deformation at the fracture site for four small-diameter tibia nails (Expert, Synthes, Saluburg, Austria; Connex, ITS Spectromed, Lassnitzhöhe, Austria; Versanail, DePuy, Vienna, Austria; T2, Stryker, Vienna, Austria) after mechanical testing with a servohydraulic material testing machine. Cyclic loading was performed with a sinusoidal load of 700 N (+/-600) for 40,000 cycles representing 6 weeks of full weight bearing. RESULTS: Offset deformation was significantly higher for the Connex nail when compared with other nails (p < 0.001). Regarding elastic deformation, no significant difference was recorded between the implants. Plastic deformation was significantly lower if the Connex nail was used (0.134 [+/-0.053] mm; p < 0.001). Elastic deformation did not exceed 0.7 mm and plastic deformation did not exceed 0.4 mm. Regarding permanent and overall deformation, no significant difference between the implants was recorded. CONCLUSIONS: Considerable deformation at the fracture gap can be assumed even after partial weight bearing with 100 N. Despite comparable material properties, differences in axial micromotion were recorded among the nail types used in this series. The number of distal locking screws (three or four) did not substantially influence the axial movements at the fracture gap.

Factors influencing interlocking screw failure in unreamed small diameter nails--a biomechanical study using a distal tibia fracture model.

BACKGROUND: Unreamed tibia nails with small diameters are increasingly used for fracture fixation. However, little is known about the fatigue strength of proximal and distal interlocking screws in those nails. To date, no data are available reporting on mechanical differences of solid compared to cannulated tibial nails. The aim of this study was to assess the fatigue strength of proximal and distal interlocking screws of solid and cannulated small diameter tibia nails. METHODS: We created a distal tibia fracture model (AO/OTA 43 A3) using 16 Sawbones. After fracture stabilization with one of four different nail types (Expert Tibial Nail, VersaNail, T2 Tibial Nailing System, Connex), mechanical testing was performed in three loading series (40,000 cycles each) with incremental loads. Timing and type of interlocking screw failure were assessed. FINDINGS: Interlocking screw failure was observed significantly earlier (after a mean interval of 57,042 cycles) in cannulated tibial nails (VersaNail, T2) compared to solid nails (after a mean interval of 88,415 cycles; P < 0.001). Proximal interlocking screw failure was recorded if oblique screws were used proximally (VersaNail, T2, Connex). No distal interlocking screw failure was recorded in the Connex nail. Two- and three-part fractures of proximal or distal interlocking screws were observed in all specimen. INTERPRETATION: Proximal and distal interlocking screw failure has to be considered in small diameter nails in case of delayed fracture healing. To support our results, further experimental studies and clinical series are necessary.