[Expert assessment of medical treatment errors--a new responsibility for the medical service of health insurance]. / Die Begutachtung ärztlicher Behandlungsfehler--eine neue Aufgabe für den Medizinischen Dienst der Krankenversicherung (MDK).

During the past few years there has been an enormous increase of inquiries for medical certificates concerning suspected mistakes in medical treatment (medical malpractice). The profound changes of the social circumstances and the social law (e.g. section 66 SGB V) are responsible for this situation. The legal involvement of the "Gesetzliche Krankenversicherung" (GKV) and the "Medizinischer Dienst der Krankenversicherung" (MDK) into social legislation concerning the expert opinion are mentioned. The general development of the judgement of medical malpractice and its legal background, which bases on the contract between doctor and patient, is shown. As a practical example serves the description of the procedure of judging medical malpractice in the MDK. First statistical results, which have been developed since summer 1997 in Hamburg are presented. Some interesting tendencies are obvious: orthopedics and surgery are involved with more than 50%. "Characteristic mistakes in therapy" are the most important question for the expert opinion. Creating a medical certificate concerning medical malpractice takes about 6-12 weeks. This tendency is decreasing because of fast learning procedures, caused by the increasing demand of expert opinions. The medical judgement of medical malpractice will become one of the main tasks of the medical service in health insurance. The "MDK's" have to adapt to this change in tasks in medical, legal and organisation-technical respect, if they want to offer competent and up to date judgement in future times.

Responsiveness to interferon alpha treatment in patients with chronic hepatitis C coinfected with hepatitis G virus.

BACKGROUND/AIMS: Patients with chronic hepatitis C are often coinfected with the new identified Flaviviridae-like agent, termed hepatitis G virus (HGV). The aim of the study was to investigate the responsiveness of hepatitis G virus to interferon alpha and to evaluate whether a hepatitis G virus coinfection negatively influences the outcome of treatment in chronic hepatitis C. METHODS: One hundred and fifteen patients with histologically proven chronic hepatitis C were treated with interferon alpha and investigated for the presence of hepatitis G virus coinfection by nested polymerase chain reaction with primers from the helicase region of hepatitis G virus. All patients received at least 3 MU (range 3-6) interferon alpha thrice weekly for at least 6 months (mean 8, range 6-12). Polymerase chain reaction products of seven pre- and post-treatment hepatitis G virus positive patients were directly sequenced for identification of sequence variability during the follow-up. RESULTS: Eighteen (16%) patients were coinfected with hepatitis G virus. Although nine (50%) of these patients became HGV RNA negative during interferon alpha therapy, only three patients (17%) remained HGV RNA negative at the end of follow-up (mean 24 months). The rate of sustained response of chronic hepatitis C was not significantly different between patients with hepatitis C virus infection and HCV/HGV coinfection (19% vs 28%). Severity of liver disease as determined by alanine aminotransferase levels, histology and hepatitis C virus viremia was not significantly different in patients with hepatitis C virus or HCV/HGV coinfection. Sequence analysis of the helicase region revealed that our isolates all belonged to the hepatitis G virus and not to the GBV-C like genotype. No amino acid exchanges during the observation period of up to 48 months were observed, indicating that this region is highly conserved. CONCLUSIONS: The responsiveness of hepatitis G virus to interferon alpha in chronic HCV/HGV coinfected patients is similar to that observed in chronic hepatitis C. Hepatitis G virus coinfection seems not to interfere with the efficacy of interferon alpha treatment in patients with chronic hepatitis C.

Treatment of chronic hepatitis C with interferon alpha: long-term follow-up and prognostic relevance of HCV genotypes.

To evaluate the importance of hepatitis C virus (HCV) genotypes for the long-term response to interferon alpha (IFN alpha) therapy, we retrospectively investigated 81 patients with chronic hepatitis C treated within two randomized multicenter studies with comparable inclusion criteria. Forty patients received recombinant IFN alpha 3 MU three times a week for 12 months and 41 patients lymphoblastoid IFN alpha 3 or 5 MU three times a week for 6 or 12 months (total dosage 216-720 MU). The patients were followed up for up to 4 yr (2-4 yr, mean 3.2 yr). A sustained remission defined as normalization of aminotransferases and negative PCR for HCV-RNA was achieved in 23% of patients treated with recombinant IFN alpha and in 25% of the group with lymphoblastoid IFN alpha therapy. All patients with sustained remission showed a normalization of aminotransferases during the first 3 months of therapy. Determination of HCV genotypes revealed a major prevalence of type 1 (77%) versus type 2 (5%) and type 3 (18%). The response rate was significantly higher in patients with type 2 and 3 infections (75 and 73%) than in patients infected with genotype 1 (37%) (p = 0.005). Sustained remission was observed in 13% for genotype 1, in 75% for genotype 2, and in 33% for genotype 3 (differences between type 2/3 versus type 1, p = 0.03). There were no significant differences between responders and non-responders concerning age, level of aminotransferases before therapy or the dosage and type of IFN alpha administered. The data indicate that the determination of HCV genotypes may have prognostic relevance in the responsiveness to IFN alpha therapy.

[Prognostic relevance of hepatitis C virus genotype for responsiveness to interferon-alpha]. / Prognostische Relevanz der Hepatitis-C-Virus-Genotypen für das Ansprechen auf Interferon-alpha.

The influence of hepatitis C virus (HCV)-genotypes on the responsiveness to interferon- (IFN-alpha) was studied in 116 patients with proven chronic hepatitis C. 88 of 116 (76%) patients were infected with HCV-genotype 1, 7 (6%) with HCV-genotype 2, and 21 patients (18%) with HCV-genotype 3. All patients received at least 3 MU recombinant IFN-alpha-2a, 2b or lymphoblastoid IFN-alpha tiw for at least 6 month (total IFN-alpha dose per patient 216-720 MU, mean 360; treatment duration 6-12 month, mean 8). The follow-up after cessation of therapy was 9-48 months (mean 25). Sustained normalization of the aminotransferase levels was observed in 20 (17%) of the 116 patients. 10 of the 88 (11%) patients with HCV-genotype 1, 7 of the 21 (33%) patients with HCV-genotype 3 (p < 0.02), and 3 out of the 7 patients with HCV-genotype-2- infection achieved a sustained remission. No response was observed in 58 (66%) and 3 (14%) patients with HCV-genotype 1 and 3 infections, respectively (p < 0.002). All but one of the sustained responders remained HCV-RNA negative during the entire follow-up. There were no significant differences between the sustained responders and the group of non-responders and responders with relapse in relation to age, pretreatment aminotransferase levels, histological activity index, or given IFN-alpha dosage. HCV-genotyping is helpful in evaluating the responsiveness to IFN-alpha and will be of importance considering the indication of therapy.

[Long-term follow-up of chronic hepatitis C after treatment with recombinant interferon alpha-2a]. / Langzeitbeobachtung der chronischen Hepatitis C nach Behandlung mit rekombinantem Interferon alpha-2a.

As part of a multicenter randomized study 40 patients with chronic hepatitis C (HCV)-infection, 28 kryptogenic and 12 posttransfusional, were treated with recombinant interferon alfa (IFN alpha-2a) for 1 year in a dosage of 3 x 3 Mio. units per week versus dosis escalation after 8 and 16 weeks in serological non-responders. 36 of the 40 patients were followed over 3 years. The rate of patients with normalization of aminotransferases was 42% after two months of therapy, 28% at the end of treatment, 28% after 1 year and 23% after 3 years of follow-up. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for detection of HCV-RNA became negative after two months of treatment in 73%, at the end of therapy in 63%, after 1 year follow-up in 63% and after 3 years in 35%. All patients with persisting remission maintained HCV-RNA negative. Dosis escalation was realized in 8 patients without increase of responder rate. Antibodies against IFN alpha-2a developed in 4 (10%) patients without remarkable influence on the IFN-effect. Histological improvement at the end of treatment was observed in 61% including all patients with serological remission. The data support the prognostic relevance of the course of aminotransferases. If aminotransferases are not normalized during the first two months the treatment can be terminated. Persisting normalization of aminotransferases during 1 year after therapy and negative HCV-PCR result indicate maintaining remission.

[Orthotopic liver transplantation in hepatic cirrhosis: on the problem of infection of the transplant with persistent hepatitis viruses]. / Orthotope Lebertransplantation bei hepatitischer Zirrhose: Zur Problematik der Infektion des Transplantates mit persistierenden Hepatitisviren.

269 orthotopic liver transplantations (OLT) were performed in 253 patients at our institution from September 1988 to May 1992. 121 patients had end-stage cirrhosis secondary to viral hepatitis type B, delta, or type non-A non-B and C respectively. Reinfection of the graft by persistent viruses is a potential complication in these cases. Passive immunization with anti-HBs hyperimmunoglobulin (HIg) can prevent clinically relevant reinfection of the graft in patients with hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection and low replication rates. Patients with high replication rates will rarely benefit from OLT. Patients with hepatitis delta virus (HDV) infection usually experience HDV reinfection of the graft with subsequent chronic hepatitis although prophylaxis with anti-HBs-HIg was performed. Treatment with interferon alpha had no apparent effect on the incidence of graft reinfection with HBV in this series, but the replication rate of HDV was reduced. Persistent hepatitis C viruses (HCV) usually infect the graft; this was demonstrated in 17 patients by means of the polymerase chain reaction. HCV infection usually causes a mild form of acute hepatitis with transition to a chronic course. Therefore the significance of persistent viral infection lies in the potential for chronic hepatitis in the transplanted organ rather than in the danger of acute injury of the allograft.

Follow-up of recurrent hepatitis B and delta infection in liver allograft recipients after treatment with recombinant interferon-alpha.

Reinfection of the graft with hepatitis B virus (HBV) and hepatitis delta virus (HDV) is a potential complication in patients undergoing orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT). Therefore, we added recombinant interferon-alpha (rIFNa) to the standard immunosuppressive regimen in 11 patients who received transplants following liver failure attributed to cirrhosis B (n = 10, with HDV co-infection in four cases) or fulminant hepatitis B (n = 1). Patients were treated with rIFNa for periods ranging from 2 to 3 months between the first and the 13th month after OLT. All patients received immunosuppressive treatment with low-dose corticosteroids, azathioprine and cyclosporine. Anti-HBs hyperimmune globulin was also administered. None of the patients showed evidence of severe allograft rejection. Seven patients suffered HBV reinfection of the graft with histological signs of acute hepatitis in five cases and transition to chronic hepatitis in one patient. Treatment with rIFNa did not prevent or reduce HBV replication. Reinfection of the graft with HDV was demonstrated by PCR in four patients co-infected with HDV. During treatment with rIFNa liver biopsy specimens from three reinfected patients were transiently negative for HDV antigen but not for HDV RNA, and the sera from two patients were transiently negative for HDV RNA. The data indicate that rIFNa can reduce HDV replication in reinfected liver allografts.

[Long-term treatment of cryptogenic hepatitis C using recombinant interferon alpha]. / Langzeitbehandlung der kryptogenen chronischen Hepatitis C mit rekombinantem Interferon alpha.

In a pilot study 15 patients with cryptogenic chronic hepatitis non-A, non-B received human recombinant interferon alpha (rIFNa) at a dosage of 5 million units 3 times per week for periods of up to 4 months, followed by an additional 4-month course of treatment with 2 million units 3 times per week after an observed reduction in serum aminotransferase levels. Ten of the 15 patients demonstrated antibodies to hepatitis C virus (HCV). Pretreatment histological examinations revealed evidence of chronic aggressive hepatitis in 12 patients, 4 with signs of cirrhosis, and chronic persistent hepatitis (CPH) in the remaining 3 cases. Normalization of serum aminotransferase levels was documented in 9 patients (7 anti-HCV-positive), and a significant reduction occurred in 2 additional anti-HCV-positive cases. Follow-up biopsy at 8 months in 7 of the 11 responders documented improved histological findings in every case. Five patients with CAH in the initial study had discrete residual portal inflammation or mesenchymal reaction in the second histological examination. Clinical follow-up is currently at 12 month, and 3 anti-HCV-positive responders have normal aminotransferase levels. The data show that a subset of patients with chronic hepatitis C will demonstrate remission of disease after an 8-month course of treatment with rIFNa.