The influence of fracture etiology and type on fracture healing: a review of 104 consecutive tibial shaft fractures.

This study was conducted to determine retrospectively the factors which influence fracture healing and risk for nonunion in patients with tibial shaft fractures. One hundred consecutive patients with 104 tibial shaft fractures and a mean age of 40 (14-85) years were reviewed. Fractures were classified according to the AO classification system. There were 22 open fractures and 52 comminuted fractures. Thirty-eight fractures were caused by high-energy trauma. Fracture pattern, soft-tissue condition, level of energy of the trauma, malalignment, and treatment methods were identified. The influence of these factors on the time of hospital stay and sick-leave, delayed union, and nonunion were calculated. Normal healing occurred in 61 fractures with a mean healing time of 17 weeks, delayed union in 27 with a mean of 35 weeks, and nonunion in 16 with a mean of 69 weeks. The relative risk of developing nonunion in open fractures was 8.2 (CI = 2.9-10.5) and 2.9 (CI = 1.2-3.2) in fractures exposed to high-energy trauma. This study showed that the soft-tissue condition and level of trauma energy are good predictors for the development of complications. Considering these risk factors at an early stage in the planning of treatment might reduce the risk of nonunion. ergy level of the trauma, fracture comminution, initial fracture displacement, treatment method, contamination, and associated injuries will influence fracture healing. Conservative treatment has in general been recommended for undisplaced closed or grade I open fractures caused by low-energy trauma [15, 18, 21]. However, conservative treatment of a tibial shaft fracture means immobilization of the lower leg for a long period of time, especially if healing is delayed. Thus, it is important to consider the risk of healing complications when planning the appropriate treatment method in the early stage after the injury. The purpose of this study was to analyze complications such as delayed union and nonunion and to identify factors which affect the healing of tibial shaft fractures.

Bone debridement and limb lengthening in type III open tibial shaft fractures: no infection or nonunion in 9 patients.

We retrospectively reviewed a consecutive series of 9 patients with tibial shaft fractures and extensive soft tissue damage, who had completed treatment by means of bone resection and distraction. 4 patients had type IIIB fractures and 5 type IIIC. The median follow-up time after bone resection was 27 (12-43) months. All patients were treated with debridement of devitalized soft tissue and resection of dead bone at the fracture site. The median bone shortening was 4 (3-9) cm. Equal limb-length was restored by proximal corticotomy and lengthening. A free vascular flap in 5 patients and a local flap in 4 patients corrected the soft tissue loss. All soft tissue transfers were successful, except in 1 case, which healed after a new free flap was made. The median union time of the fracture was 8 (4.5-28) months from the injury and 7 (3-10) months from the time of bone resection. There were no deep infections or nonunions and no secondary amputations. This series shows that bone debridement and limb lengthening, with a multidisciplinary approach, is often successful in salvaging limbs at high risk of amputation.

Salvaged limbs after tibial shaft fractures with extensive soft-tissue injury: a biopsychosocial function analysis.

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study was to perform a biopsychosocial function analysis of the outcome in patients with a salvaged leg after tibial shaft fractures associated with extensive soft-tissue injury. METHODS: A retrospective review of 18 consecutive patients with tibial shaft fractures and extensive soft-tissue damage with a mean Injury Severity Score of 31 was undertaken. All patients were assessed for their physical function, psychological status, and general function. RESULTS: The range of motion and torque of the ankle joint were severely affected. The knee joint was affected, but only with regard to the torque during concentric muscular activities. Nottingham Health Profile scores showed that the general and social function for these patients were significantly affected. Five of 18 patients suffered from depression. CONCLUSION: Salvage procedures should be advocated if possible, but careful selection of patients on the basis of mental and social factors is crucial for the outcome.

Postural control and torque of the knee joint after healed tibial shaft fracture.

Muscular atrophy occurs as a consequence of trauma and immobilisation. This cohort comparison study was conducted to evaluate the limb function after healed tibial shaft fractures, which were treated by casting versus nailing. Balance (as centre of pressure) and muscle strength (as torque of the knee joint during knee extension) have been measured in 27 patients with tibial shaft fractures with a mean age of 39 (19-73) years, 1 year after fracture healing. Fourteen patients were treated by intramedullary nailing 'nailed group' and 13 by plaster cast with or without minimal internal fixation 'casted group'. Centre of pressure was measured on a force platform. Knee extension torque was measured during isometric and concentric muscle actions by an isokinetic dynamometer. Centre of pressure tended to be more towards the uninjured leg in patients who had been treated by plaster cast (P<0.05). Side-to-side differences for isometric torque were significantly higher within the casted group (P<0.05). Patients with tibial shaft fractures treated by intramedullary nailing showed better postural control, one-leg standing test, and side-to-side differences for isometric muscle strength compared with patients treated by cast. Therefore, we recommend intramedullary nailing as a better method of treatment for tibial shaft fractures, with regard to recovery of muscle function.

Displaced tibial shaft fractures: a prospective randomized study of closed intramedullary nailing versus cast treatment in 53 patients.

Of 53 patients with unilateral, displaced and closed or grade 1 open tibial shaft fractures, 27 patients (group I) were randomized to treatment with an intramedullary nail and 26 patients (group II) to treatment with a plaster cast. 12 fractures in the latter group were considered stable enough for treatment with only a cast (group IIa), while 14 fractures in group II showed redisplacement during reduction under anesthesia or at 1 week follow-up. Therefore, these fractures were stabilized with cerclage or screws (group IIb), which was a prerequisite for continuing cast treatment. The mean time-to-union was 19 weeks for group I, and 25 weeks for group II. 6 patients in group I and 16 in group II had delayed union. The Nottingham Health Profile index scores on physical mobility, social isolation, work ability, and sexual life were significantly better in group I than in group II at 3 months after injury. Delayed union, malunion, and restricted range of motion at the ankle joint were common complications when these fractures were treated with a cast. We recommend intramedullary nailing for these fractures.