A randomised trial of primary tamoxifen versus mastectomy plus adjuvant tamoxifen in fit elderly women with invasive breast carcinoma of high oestrogen receptor content: long-term results at 20 years of follow-up.

BACKGROUND: Long-term analysis of a randomised trial in Nottingham comparing tamoxifen versus surgery as initial treatment demonstrated that in oestrogen receptor (ER)-unselected cases, surgery achieved better local control, with no difference in overall survival. It was suggested that for patients with ER-rich tumours, local control and survival may be comparable. We now present long-term follow-up of a randomised trial designed to address this clinical scenario. PATIENTS AND METHODS: One hundred and fifty three fit elderly (≥70 years) women with clinically node-negative primary invasive breast carcinoma <5 cm of high ER content [histochemical (H) score ≥100] were randomised 2:1 to primary tamoxifen (Tam) (N = 100) or mastectomy with adjuvant tamoxifen (Mx + Tam) (N = 53). RESULTS: With median follow-up of 78 months, there was no statistically significant difference in 10-year rates of regional recurrence (9.0% versus 7.5%), metastasis (8.0% versus 13.2%), breast cancer-specific survival (89.0% versus 86.8%) or overall survival (64.0% versus 66.0%) between Tam and Mx + Tam; however, local control was inferior with Tam (local failure rates 43.0% versus 1.9%; P < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Irrespective of the degree of ER positivity, surgery achieved better local control. However, there was excellent and similar survival in both groups. Tam could be considered in those who are 'frail', refuse or prefer not to initially undergo surgery.

A randomised trial of mastectomy only versus tamoxifen for treating elderly patients with operable primary breast cancer-final results at 20-year follow-up.

A recent Cochrane review of trials involving elderly women with operable primary breast cancer showed no significant difference in overall survival between surgery (±adjuvant tamoxifen) and primary endocrine therapy using tamoxifen. We report the final results of a randomised pilot trial comparing primary tamoxifen and wedge mastectomy as initial treatment in this population. One hundred and thirty-one women >70 years with early operable primary breast cancer (<5 cm), unselected for oestrogen receptor (ER), entered the trial in 1982-1987. Sixty-eight patients were allocated to tamoxifen only and 67 to wedge mastectomy only, as primary treatment. At 20 years of follow-up, the median time to local failure was significantly shorter in the tamoxifen arm though approximately one-fifth of patients in this group did not develop local failure requiring mastectomy. There was no difference in regional recurrence, distant metastases or overall survival between the mastectomy and tamoxifen arms. In this small study, primary endocrine therapy achieved local control in 30% of those surviving at 5 years and 20% at 10 years, unselected for ER. The primary therapy used did not significantly affect regional recurrence, incidence of distant metastases or overall survival. Primary endocrine therapy should certainly be considered in those patients with ER positive tumours and who are unfit (based on life expectancy) for or refuse surgery.

Effect of dietary GLA+/-tamoxifen on the growth, ER expression and fatty acid profile of ER positive human breast cancer xenografts.

Gamma linolenic acid (GLA) possesses a number of selective anti-tumour properties including modulation of steroid receptor structure and function. We have investigated the effect of dietary GLA on the growth, oestrogen receptor (ER) expression and fatty acid profile of ER+ve human breast cancer xenografts. Experimental diets A, B, C, D were commenced after subcutaneous implantation of 40 female nude mice with the MCF-7 B1M cell line (Group A = control diet: B = control diet + GLA supplement: C = control diet + tamoxifen: D = control diet + GLA + tamoxifen; 10 mice/group). The mice were terminated when tumour cross-sectional area reached 250 mm(2). ER H-scores were assessed by immunohistochemical assay and fatty acid profiles by gas-liquid chromatography of termination tumour samples. Groups C and D displayed significantly slower tumour growth (p =.0002, p =.0006) with trend for slower growth in B (p =.065) compared to control Group A. ER was significantly reduced in all groups compared to A (p <.0001) with Group D (combined therapy) displaying markedly lower ER expression than with either therapy alone (p =.0002). There were significantly raised levels of tumour GLA and metabolites in the two groups (B and D) receiving GLA (p <.0001). This xenograft model of ER+ve breast cancer has demonstrated significantly lower tumour ER expression in those groups receiving GLA, an effect which appears to be additive to the reduced ER expression resulting from tamoxifen alone. The effects of GLA on ER function and the possibility of synergistic inhibitory action of GLA with tamoxifen via enhanced down-regulation of the ER pathway require further investigation.

Change in expression of ER, bcl-2 and MIB1 on primary tamoxifen and relation to response in ER positive breast cancer.

Pre-treatment oestrogen receptor (ER) expression in breast cancer predicts for rate of response to endocrine therapy but not for the quality or duration of response (DofR). ER is known to be down-regulated by anti-oestrogens. This study has tested the hypothesis that the degree of down-regulation of ER and the ER-regulated marker bcl-2 are associated with the quality and duration of tamoxifen response. 80 patients with ER+ve breast cancer (H-score > 10) receiving primary tamoxifen (n = 51 Stage I-II elderly; n = 29 Stage III) underwent sequential tumour biopsies for immunocytochemical assessment of ER, bcl-2 and the proliferation marker MIB1. Median follow-up is 45 months. By 6-months on therapy three patients had attained complete response (CR), 27 partial response (PR); 44 static disease (SD) and six progression (PD) by UICC criteria. Greater decrease in ER and bcl-2 H-score from pre-treatment to 6 weeks (p = 0.035, p = 0.037) and ER and bcl-2 H-score from pre-treatment to 6 months (p = 0.058, p = 0.036) were significantly associated with better quality of response (CR/PR vs SD/PD). Greater 6-week and 6-month reduction in bcl-2 H-score (p = 0.041, p = 0.036) and 6-week reduction in MIB1 (p = 0.013) were significantly correlated with longer DofR. This study demonstrates that greater down-regulation of ER and the ER-regulated protein bcl-2 on primary tamoxifen are significantly associated with a better quality of response and bcl-2 and the proliferation marker MIB1 a longer duration of response in ER+ve breast cancer.

INK4a gene expression and methylation in primary breast cancer: overexpression of p16INK4a messenger RNA is a marker of poor prognosis.

Frequent deletions or mutations of the INK4 gene, which encodes the cyclin-dependent kinase 4 inhibitor p16INK4a, have been documented in various human cancers, but little is known about the role of this tumor suppressor gene in primary breast cancer. We examined p16INK4a mRNA expression and its relationship with cyclin D1 and estrogen receptor (ER) expression in 314 primary breast cancers using Northern blots probed with a p16 exon 1alpha-specific cDNA. Tumor samples overexpressing p16INK4a were predominantly ER negative with low levels of cyclin D1. Cyclin D1 and ER mRNA levels in the high p16INK4a expressers were significantly lower than those in the remainder of the population (P = 0.0001). Furthermore, the mean p16INK4a mRNA level in the ER-negative tumors was significantly higher than that in the ER-positive group (P = 0.0001). Because the INK4 gene is frequently inactivated by de novo methylation, we investigated the frequency of INK4a exon 1alpha methylation in a subset of 120 primary breast cancers using methylation-specific PCR; 24 of these were methylated. These findings indicate that high expression of p16INK4a and reduced expression due to de novo INK4a methylation are frequent events in primary breast cancer. In a subset of 217 patients for whom detailed clinical data were available, high p16INK4a mRNA expression was associated with high tumor grade (P = 0.006), > or = 4 axillary lymph node involvement (P = 0.004), ER negativity (P = 0.0001), and increased risk of relapse (P = 0.006). The significant negative correlation between p16INK4a and ER gene expression raises issues regarding their functional interrelationships and whether high p16INK4a expression may be associated with a lack of hormone responsiveness in breast cancer.

Gamma linolenic acid with tamoxifen as primary therapy in breast cancer.

Gamma linolenic acid (GLA) has been proposed as a valuable new cancer therapy having selective anti-tumour properties with negligible systemic toxicity. Proposed mechanisms of action include modulation of steroid hormone receptors. We have investigated the effects of GLA with primary hormone therapy in an endocrine-sensitive cancer. Thirty-eight breast cancer patients (20 elderly Stage I-II, 14 locally advanced, 4 metastatic) took 8 capsules of oral GLA/day (total = 2.8 g) in addition to tamoxifen 20 mg od (T+GLA). Quality and duration of response were compared with matched controls receiving tamoxifen 20 mg od alone (n = 47). Serial tumour biopsies were taken to assess changes in oestrogen receptor (ER) and bcl-2 expression during treatment. GLA was well tolerated with no major side effects. T+GLA cases achieved a significantly faster clinical response (objective response vs. static disease) than tamoxifen controls, evident by 6 weeks on treatment (p = 0.010). There was significant reduction in ER expression in both treatment arms with T+GLA objective responders sustaining greater ER fall than tamoxifen counterparts (6-week biopsy p = 0.026; 6-month biopsy p = 0.019). We propose GLA as a useful adjunct to primary tamoxifen in endocrine-sensitive breast cancer. The effects of GLA on ER function and the apparent enhancement of tamoxifen-induced ER down-regulation by GLA require further investigation.

Overexpression of cyclin D1 messenger RNA predicts for poor prognosis in estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer.

Cyclin D1 is a key cell cycle regulatory protein with demonstrated oncogenic activity in a variety of malignancies. Cyclin D1 mRNA and protein are overexpressed in approximately 50% of primary breast carcinomas; however, the pathophysiological consequences of increased expression remain unclear. To investigate the functional sequelae of cyclin D1 mRNA overexpression, we analyzed clinical outcome in relation to the cyclin D1 mRNA level in 253 primary breast cancer patients (median follow-up, 75 months) with particular reference to estrogen receptor (ER) status and endocrine response. Overall, with the exception of the relationship between cyclin D1 mRNA expression and the ER, cyclin D1 mRNA was not associated with other clinicopathological features such as age, menopausal status, axillary lymph node status, vascular invasion, tumor size, type, and grade. However, in patients with ER-positive tumors (n = 182), high levels of cyclin D1 mRNA were associated with increased risk of relapse (P = 0.0016), local recurrence (P = 0.025), metastasis (P = 0.019), and death (P = 0.025). In contrast, there were no clinical correlations with cyclin D1 expression in ER-negative disease (n = 71). In 33 patients who received endocrine therapy for their primary or recurrent breast cancers, there was an apparent association between a high cyclin D1 mRNA level and a shorter response duration within the ER-positive subgroup (P = 0.04). Our findings indicate that overexpression of cyclin D1 mRNA correlates with a worse prognosis within the ER-positive breast cancer phenotype and may be a contributing factor to the development of endocrine resistance in ER-positive disease.

BRCA1 expression levels predict distant metastasis of sporadic breast cancers.

The role of BRCA1 in progression of sporadic breast cancers has to date been equivocal, although preliminary studies on small numbers of samples have suggested an association between expression levels of this gene and acquisition of an invasive phenotype. We have further reasoned that loss of oestrogen receptor positivity may have a detrimental effect on BRCA1 expression. In order to test this hypothesis and extend earlier investigations we have applied a sensitive RT-PCR procedure to determine the associations between BRCA1 expression and a variety of clinical parameters in a sample cohort derived from sporadic breast tumour specimens. We have established that BRCA1 and ER mRNA expression are closely associated (p=0.013), indicating a possible functional relationship between these 2 genes. We have further identified an association between low levels of BRCA1 expression and acquisition of distant metastasis in sporadic disease (p=0.019). In light of our findings, we suggest that suppression of BRCA1 has a role to play in progression of a significant fraction of sporadic breast cancers and may additionally prove to be a useful, novel, prognostic marker for this disease type.

Endocrine response and resistance in breast cancer: a role for the transcription factor Fos.

We have previously demonstrated that elevated Fos expression may be important in de novo endocrine resistance in breast cancer. However, changes in Fos expression during endocrine response and subsequently on acquisition of resistance are unknown. This study immunocytochemically monitors Fos protein within sequential biopsies from primary human breast cancer patients obtained pre-treatment (T1), during tamoxifen therapy (T2, T3) and on disease progression (T5), examining in parallel proliferation [i.e., MIBI (Ki67) immunostaining, mitotic activity], cellularity and endocrine response. Significantly diminished Fos, proliferation and cellularity were observed after 6 weeks of therapy in patients exhibiting a better quality and/or duration of response, while modest Fos increases and a maintained proliferation and cellularity were seen in poorer responders. Decreases in Fos, proliferation and cellularity at 6 months similarly hallmarked better responders. We confirmed a significant association between de novo resistance and elevated Fos and proliferation. Additionally, however, these parameters increased at the time of disease relapse over pre-treatment and "on therapy" values. Our data indicate that tamoxifen response involves a reduction in both tumor cell proliferation and cell survival, potentially entailing diminished Fos protein expression in better-responding patients. Our data are also supportive of elevated Fos expression being involved in the departure from endocrine control inherent in both primary and acquired resistance.

EMS1 gene expression in primary breast cancer: relationship to cyclin D1 and oestrogen receptor expression and patient survival.

The EMS1 and CCND1 genes at chromosome 11q13 are amplified in about 15% of primary breast cancers but appear to confer different phenotypes in ER positive and ER negative tumours. Since there are no published data on EMS1 expression in large series of breast cancers we examined the relationship of EMS1 expression with EMS1 gene copy number and expression of mRNAs for cyclin D1 and ER. In a subset of 129 patients, where matched tumour RNA and DNA was available, EMS1 mRNA overexpression was associated predominantly with gene amplification (P = 0.0061), whereas cyclin D1 mRNA overexpression was not (P = 0.3142). In a more extensive series of 351 breast cancers, there was no correlation between cyclin D1 and EMS1 expression in the EMS1 and cyclin D1 overexpressors (P = 0.3503). Although an association between EMS1 mRNA expression and ER positivity was evident (P = 0.0232), when the samples were divided into quartiles of EMS1 or cyclin D1 mRNA expression, the increase in the proportion of ER positive tumours in the ascending EMS1 mRNA quartiles was not statistically significant (P = 0.0951). In marked contrast there was a significant stepwise increase in ER positivity in ascending quartiles of cyclin D1 mRNA (P = 0.030). A potential explanation for this difference was provided by the observation that in ER positive breast cancer cells oestradiol treatment resulted in increased cyclin D1 gene expression but was without effect on EMS1. The relationship between EMS1 expression and clinical outcome was examined in a subset of 234 patients with median follow-up of 74 months. High EMS1 expression was associated with age > 50 years (P = 0.0001), postmenopausal status (P = 0.0008), lymph node negativity (P = 0.019) and an apparent trend for worse prognosis in the ER negative subgroup. These data demonstrate that overexpression of EMS1 mRNA is largely due to EMS1 gene amplification, is independent of cyclin D1 and ER expression and, in contrast to cyclin D1, is not regulated by oestrogen. Independent overexpression of these genes may confer different phenotypes and disease outcomes in breast cancer as has been inferred from recent studies of EMS1 and CCND1 gene amplification.