The Mutability of Yeast Prions.

Prions replicate by a self-templating mechanism. Infidelity in the process can lead to the emergence of new infectious structures, referred to as variants or strains. The question of whether prions are prone to mis-templating is not completely answered. Our previous experiments with 23 variants of the yeast [PSI+] prion do not support broad mutability. However, it became clear recently that the heat shock protein Hsp104 can restrict [PSI+] strain variation. This raises the possibility that many transmutable variants of the prion may have been mistaken as faithful-propagating simply because the mutant structure was too sturdy or too frail to take root in the wild-type cell. Here, I alter the strength of Hsp104 in yeast, overexpressing wild-type Hsp104 or expressing the hypo-active Hsp104T160M mutant, and check if the new environments enable the variants to mutate. Two variants hitherto thought of as faithful-propagating are discovered to generate different structures, which are stabilized with the hypo-active chaperone. In contrast, most transmutable variants discovered in cells overexpressing Hsp104 have been correctly identified as such previously in wild-type cells without the overexpression. The majority of transmutable variants only mis-template the structure of VH, VK, or VL, which are the most frequently observed variants and do not spontaneously mutate. There are four additional variants that never give rise to different structures in all cell conditions tested. Therefore, quite a few [PSI+] variants are faithful-propagating, and even the transmutable ones do not freely evolve but can only change to limited structural types.

Mutable yeast prion variants are stabilized by a defective Hsp104 chaperone.

Gorkovskiy et al. observed that many [PSI+ ] prion isolates, obtained in yeast with the mutant Hsp104T160M chaperone, propagate poorly in wild-type cells and suggested that Hsp104 is part of the cellular anti-prion system, curing many nascent [PSI+ ] variants. Here, we argue that the concept may require reassessment. We induced [PSI+ ] variants in both the wild-type and the mutant background. Three new variants were isolated in the T160M background. They exhibited lower thermostability, possessed novel structural features, and were inherently mutable, changing to well-characterized VH, VK, and VL variants in wild-type cells. In contrast, VH, VK, and VL of the wild-type background, could not change freely and were lost in the mutant, due to insufficient chaperone activity. Thus, mutant Hsp104 can impose as much restriction against emerging prion variants as the wild-type protein. Such restriction conserved the transmutable variants in the T160M background, since new structures mis-templated from them could not gain a foothold. We further demonstrate excess Hsp104T160M or Hsp104∆2-147 can eliminate nearly all of the [PSI+ ] variants in their native background. This finding contradicts the generally held belief that Hsp104-induced [PSI+ ] curing requires its N-terminal domain, and may help settling the current contention regarding how excess Hsp104 cures [PSI+ ].

A complete catalog of wild-type Sup35 prion variants and their protein-only propagation.

Twenty-three prion variants of the wild-type Sup35 protein are obtained, including 19 novel ones and 4 previously documented, namely, VH, VK, VL, and W8. Their uniqueness and non-composite nature are demonstrated. Specific infectivity is generated de novo for most variants by adding prion particles to solutions of a purified Sup35 N-terminal fragment, thereby supporting the protein-only composition. Sup35 prions isolated by other laboratories are identified within the collection and found to fall into a narrow set of five variant types that are readily inducible in vivo by Sup35 overexpression. The work establishes an unambiguous and extensive collection of prion variants, demonstrating that a protein, by itself, in the absence of genetic and conformational co-factors, could adopt a great number of structures. In light of recent high-resolution structures of other amyloids, we discuss how the diverse folding is achieved in spite of apparent contradiction to the classical paradigm that a protein's structure is uniquely determined by its sequence.

Forms and abundance of chaperone proteins influence yeast prion variant competition.

[PSI+ ] variants are different infectious conformations of the same Sup35 protein. We show that when [PSI+ ] variants VK and VL co-infect a dividing host, only one prevails in the end and the host genetic background is involved in winner selection. In the 5V-H19 background, the VK variant dominates over the VL variant. The order of dominance is reversed in the 74-D694 background, where VL can coexists with VK for a short period, but will eventually take over. Differential interaction of chaperone proteins with distinct prion variant conformations can influence the outcome of competition. Expanding the Glycine/Methionine-rich domain of Sis1, an Hsp40 protein, helps the propagation of VL. Over-expression of the Hsp70 protein Ssa2 lowers the number of prion particles (propagons) in the cell. There is more reduction for VK than VL, causing the latter to dominate in some of the 5V-H19 and all of the 74-D694 cells tested. Consistently, depleting Ssa1 in 74-D694 strengthens VK. Swapping chromosomal alleles of SSA1/2 and SIS1 between 5V-H19 and 74-D694, including cognate promoters, is not sufficient to change the native dominance order of each background, suggesting there exist additional polymorphic factors that modulate [PSI+ ] competition.

Amino Acid Proximities in Two Sup35 Prion Strains Revealed by Chemical Cross-linking.

Strains of the yeast prion [PSI] are different folding patterns of the same Sup35 protein, which stacks up periodically to form a prion fiber. Chemical cross-linking is employed here to probe different fiber structures assembled with a mutant Sup35 fragment. The photo-reactive cross-linker, p-benzoyl-l-phenylalanine (pBpa), was biosynthetically incorporated into bacterially prepared recombinant Sup(1-61)-GFP, containing the first 61 residues of Sup35, followed by the green fluorescent protein. Four methionine substitutions and two alanine substitutions were introduced at fixed positions in Sup(1-61) to allow cyanogen bromide cleavage to facilitate subsequent mass spectrometry analysis. Amyloid fibers of pBpa and Met/Ala-substituted Sup(1-61)-GFP were nucleated from purified yeast prion particles of two different strains, namely VK and VL, and shown to faithfully transmit specific strain characteristics to yeast expressing the wild type Sup35 protein. Intra- and intermolecular cross-linking were distinguished by tandem mass spectrometry analysis on fibers seeded from solutions containing equal amounts of (14)N- and (15)N-labeled protein. Fibers propagating the VL strain type exhibited intra- and intermolecular cross-linking between amino acid residues 3 and 28, as well as intra- and intermolecular linking between 32 and 55. Inter- and intramolecular cross-linking between residues 32 and 55 were detected in fibers propagating the VK strain type. Adjacencies of amino acid residues in space revealed by cross-linking were used to constrain possible chain folds of different [PSI] strains.

W8, a new Sup35 prion strain, transmits distinctive information with a conserved assembly scheme.

Prion strains are different self-propagating conformers of the same infectious protein. Three strains of the [PSI] prion, infectious forms of the yeast Sup35 protein, have been previously characterized in our laboratory. Here we report the discovery of a new [PSI] strain, named W8. We demonstrate its robust cellular propagation as well as the protein-only transmission. To reveal strain-specific sequence requirement, mutations that interfered with the propagation of W8 were identified by consecutive substitution of residues 5-55 of Sup35 by proline and insertion of glycine at alternate sites in this segment. Interestingly, propagating W8 with single mutations at residues 5-7 and around residue 43 caused the strain to transmute. In contrast to the assertion that [PSI] existed as a dynamic cloud of sub-structures, no random drift in transmission characteristics was detected in mitotically propagated W8 populations. Electron diffraction and mass-per-length measurements indicate that, similar to the 3 previously characterized strains, W8 fibers are composed of about 1 prion molecule per 4.7-Å cross-ß repeat period. Thus differently folded single Sup35 molecules, not dimeric and trimeric assemblies, form the basic repeating units to build the 4 [PSI] strains.

Inter-allelic prion propagation reveals conformational relationships among a multitude of [PSI] strains.

Immense diversity of prion strains is observed, but its underlying mechanism is less clear. Three [PSI] prion strains--named VH, VK, and VL--were previously isolated in the wild-type yeast genetic background. Here we report the generation and characterization of eight new [PSI] isolates, obtained by propagating the wild-type strains with Sup35 proteins containing single amino-acid alterations. The VH strain splits into two distinct strains when propagated in each of the three genetic backgrounds, harboring respectively single mutations of N21L, R28P, and Gi47 (i.e. insertion of a glycine residue at position 47) on the Sup35 N-terminal prion-forming segment. The six new strains exhibit complex inter-conversion patterns, and one of them continuously mutates into another. However, when they are introduced back into the wild-type background, all 6 strains revert to the VH strain. We obtain two more [PSI] isolates by propagating VK and VL with the Gi47 and N21L backgrounds, respectively. The two isolates do not transmit to other mutant backgrounds but revert to their parental strains in the wild-type background. Our data indicate that a large number of [PSI] strains can be built on three basic Sup35 amyloid structures. It is proposed that the three basic structures differ by chain folding topologies, and sub-strains with the same topology differ in distinct ways by local structural adjustments. This "large number of variations on a small number of basic themes" may also be operative in generating strain diversities in other prion elements. It thus suggests a possible general scheme to classify a multitude of prion strains.

Strain-specific sequences required for yeast [PSI+] prion propagation.

Amyloid polymorphism underlies the prion strain phenomenon where a single protein polypeptide adopts different chain-folding patterns to form self-propagating cross-beta structures. Three strains of the yeast prion [PSI], namely [VH], [VK], and [VL], have been previously characterized and are amyloid conformers of the yeast translation termination factor Sup35. Here we define specific sequences of the Sup35 protein that are necessary for in vivo propagation of each of these prion strains. By sequential substitution of residues 5-55 of Sup35 by proline and insertion of glycine at alternate sites in this segment, specific mutations have been identified that interfere selectively with the propagation of each of the three prion strains in yeast: the [VH] strain requires amino acid residues 7-21; [VK] requires residues 9-37; and [VL] requires residues 5 to at least 52. Minimal polypeptide segments capable of encoding prion conformations were defined by assembly of recombinant Sup35 fragments on purified prion nuclei to form amyloid fibers in vitro, whose infectivity was assayed in yeast. For the [VK] and [VL] strains, the minimal fragments approximately coincide with the strain-specific sequences defined by mutations of the N-terminal portion of the intact Sup35 (1-685); and for the [VH] strain, a longer Sup (1-53) fragment is required. Polymorphic structures of other amyloids might similarly involve different stretches of polypeptides to form cross-beta amyloid cores with distinct molecular recognition surfaces.

Transformation of yeast by infectious prion particles.

We present methods to prepare infectious Sup35 protein aggregates and use them for genetic transformation of yeast. The protein aggregates are prepared from bacterially expressed recombinant protein, which is converted to amyloid fibers by extended incubation or by nucleated growth using yeast prion particles as seeds. The aggregates are introduced into yeast by a modified spheroplast transformation protocol. The phenotype of the yeast transformants is further characterized by robust prion strain typing methods. The methodology can be used to introduce different [PSI(+)] particles to many laboratory yeast genetic backgrounds. It can be adapted for applications in other yeast prion systems as well.

Strain-specific morphologies of yeast prion amyloid fibrils.

Mass per length (mpl) measurements on single amyloid fibrils that specifically propagate the [VH], [VK], and [VL] strains of the yeast prion [PSI] reveal unanticipated differences in their structures. Many fibrils have approximately 1.0 prion molecule per 4.7-A cross-beta repeat period, which is consistent with a self-replicating model built by parallel beta-sheet hydrogen-bonding of like prion peptide segments, but other fibrils are definitely heavier. The predominantly straight fibrils of the dominant [VH] strain have a bimodal mpl distribution, corresponding to components with approximately 1.0 and 1.2 prions per repeat. Fibrils of the weaker [VK] strain, which are almost all wavy, have a monodisperse mpl distribution with a mean of 1.15 prions per repeat. The recessive [VL] strain sample has approximately 1.05 prions per repeat in single fibrils and includes approximately 10% double fibrils, which are rare in the duplicate [VH] and [VK] samples. All of these samples were assembled from purified recombinant Sup35 prion protein by seeded growth on nuclei extracted from yeast bearing the three [PSI] strains. Infectious and noninfectious spontaneously assembled fibrils of the recombinant prion protein also display different heterogeneous morphologies. The strain-specific morphological differences we have observed directly confirm the structural prediction of the protein-only prion theory but do not have an obvious molecular explanation.

Protein-only transmission of three yeast prion strains.

Key questions regarding the molecular nature of prions are how different prion strains can be propagated by the same protein and whether they are only protein. Here we demonstrate the protein-only nature of prion strains in a yeast model, the [PSI] genetic element that enhances the read-through of nonsense mutations in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Infectious fibrous aggregates containing a Sup35 prion-determining amino-terminal fragment labelled with green fluorescent protein were purified from yeast harbouring distinctive prion strains. Using the infectious aggregates as 'seeds', elongated fibres were generated in vitro from the bacterially expressed labelled prion protein. De novo generation of strain-specific [PSI] infectivity was demonstrated by introducing sheared fibres into uninfected yeast hosts. The cross-sectional morphology of the elongated fibres generated in vitro was indistinguishable from that of the short yeast seeds, as visualized by electron microscopy. Electron diffraction of the long fibres showed the 4.7 A spacing characteristic of the cross-beta structure of amyloids. The fact that the amyloid fibres nucleated in vitro propagate the strain-specific infectivity of the yeast seeds implies that the heritable information of distinct prion strains must be encoded by different, self-propagating cross-beta folding patterns of the same prion protein.