INSECT PHYLOGENOMICS. Response to Comment on "Phylogenomics resolves the timing and pattern of insect evolution".

Tong et al. comment on the accuracy of the dating analysis presented in our work on the phylogeny of insects and provide a reanalysis of our data. They replace log-normal priors with uniform priors and add a "roachoid" fossil as a calibration point. Although the reanalysis provides an interesting alternative viewpoint, we maintain that our choices were appropriate.

Phylogenetic placement of the anamorphic tribe Ustilaginoideae (Hypocreales, Ascomycota).

Tribe Ustilaginoideae (Hypocreales, Ascomycetes) is made up of three anamorph genera, Munkia, Neomunkia and Ustilaginoidea. Species of Munkia and Neomunkia develop on the culms of bamboo (Chusquea spp.) and have a neotropical distribution while species of Ustilaginoidea infect the florets of various grasses and are pantropical in distribution. In this study we evaluated the phylogeny of the tribe and assessed hypotheses regarding its affinity to clavicipitalean teleomorphic groups. To support phylogenetic analyses, morphology of representatives of several key species of Ustilaginoideae was examined also. Phylogenetic analyses using sequences of the large subunit of the ribosomal RNA gene suggest that members of Ustilaginoideae are distinct from teleomorphic genera of Clavicipitaceae and that Ustilaginoideae should be recognized as a monophyletic group within Hypocreales. However, phylogenetic analyses did not resolve the placement of Ustilaginoideae in Clavicipitaceae or Hypocreaceae, suggesting that it might be a distinct lineage within Hypocreales. This evaluation supported the monophyly of tribes Balansieae and Clavicipeae in the family Clavicipitaceae.

Phylogeny of Trichoptera (caddisflies): characterization of signal and noise within multiple datasets.

Trichoptera are holometabolous insects with aquatic larvae that, together with the Lepidoptera, make up the Amphiesmenoptera. Despite extensive previous morphological work, little phylogenetic agreement has been reached about the relationship among the three suborders--Annulipalpia, Spicipalpia, and Integripalpia--or about the monophyly of Spicipalpia. In an effort to resolve this conflict, we sequenced fragments of the large and small subunit nuclear ribosomal RNAs (1078 nt; D1, D3, V4-5), the nuclear elongation factor 1 alpha gene (EF-1 alpha; 1098 nt), and a fragment of mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase I (COI; 411 nt). Seventy adult and larval morphological characters were reanalyzed and added to molecular data in a combined analysis. We evaluated signal and homoplasy in each of the molecular datasets and attempted to rank the particular datasets according to how appropriate they were for inferring relationships among suborders. This evaluation included testing for conflict among datasets, comparing tree lengths among alternative hypotheses, measuring the left-skew of tree-length distributions from maximally divergent sets of taxa, evaluating the recovery of expected clades, visualizing whether or not substitutions were accumulating with time, and estimating nucleotide compositional bias. Although all these measures cast doubt on the reliability of the deep-level signal coming from the nucleotides of the COI and EF-1 alpha genes, these data could still be included in combined analyses without overturning the results from the most conservative marker, the rRNA. The different datasets were found to be evolving under extremely different rates. A site-specific likelihood method for dealing with combined data with nonoverlapping parameters was proposed, and a similar weighting scheme under parsimony was evaluated. Among our phylogenetic conclusions, we found Annulipalpia to be the most basal of the three suborders, with Spicipalpia and Integripalpia forming a clade. Monophyly of Annulipalpia and Integripalpia was confirmed, but the relationships among spicipalpians remain equivocal.

Multiple data sets, congruence, and hypothesis testing for the phylogeny of basal groups of the lizard genus Sceloporus (Squamata, Phrynosomatidae).

Several data partitions, including nuclear and mitochondrial gene sequences, chromosomes, isoenzymes, and morphological characters, were used to propose a new phylogeny and to test previously published hypotheses about the phylogenetic positions of basal clades of the lizard genus Sceloporus and the relationship of Sceloporus to the former genus "Sator". In accord with earlier studies, our results grouped "Sator" as internal to Sceloporus, and both support a hypothesis of transgulfian vicariance for the origin of the former genus "Sator" on islands in the Sea of Cortez. Robustness of support for internal nodes in our best tree was established though widely used indices (bootstrap proportions, decay values) but also through congruence among independent data partitions. Several deep nodes in the tree recovered by several methods, including equally weighted and differentially weighted parsimony and maximum likelihood models, are only weakly supported by the traditional indices. This methodological concordance is taken as evidence for insensitivity of the deep structure of the topology to alternative assumptions.

Phylogenetic relationship among termite families based on DNA sequence of mitochondrial 16S ribosomal RNA gene.

Termites (Order Isoptera: Class Insecta), are comprised of a complex assemblage of species, with considerable variation in life history, morphology, social behaviour, caste development and ecology. At present, isoptera is divided into seven families, fourteen subfamilies, approximately 270 genera and over 2000 species. Phylogenetic hypotheses currently available for termite families and genera are based on a limited number of morphological characters and lack rigorous cladistic analysis. In this paper we report on phylogenetic relationships among ten termite genera of five families based on a DNA sequence analysis of a portion of the mitochondrial 16S rRNA gene. Parsimony and distance analysis of DNA sequences supported the existing hypothesis that Mastotermitidae is the basal lineage among extant termites. Kalotermitidae was not found to be a sister taxon of Mastotermitidae as existing hypotheses suggest, but was most closely related to Rhinotermitidae and Termitidae. Representatives of Termopsidae were more basal relative to those of Kalotermitidae. The utility of 16S rRNA nucleotide sequence analysis for inferring phylogenetic relationships among termite families, subfamilies and genera is discussed.

Use of rRNA secondary structure in phylogenetic studies to identify homologous positions: an example of alignment and data presentation from the frogs.

The alignment of ribosomal RNA (rRNA) by computer requires assumptions about the evolutionary costs for gaps in the alignment that are undefinable when uniformly applied across the entire molecule. The conservation of rRNA secondary structures exceeds that of its nucleotides, and therefore it is recommended that secondary structures guide decisions about the assignment of homologous positions for phylogenetic studies. Suggestions for alignment, data presentation, and character description are made in the context of an example from frog large subunit nuclear rRNA. Realignment improved congruence with previously published morphological conclusions and the format used in data presentation facilitated the description of character-based conclusions at each node in the cladogram. The data presented allow a discrimination between the fully resolved shortest tree and conclusions that the data actually support with any reasonable confidence: a monophyletic Pipanura, Neobatrachia, and Ranoidea without further resolution within the Neobatrachia.

Mosquito large subunit ribosomal RNA: simultaneous alignment of primary and secondary structure.

We report the sequence and propose a secondary structure for the cytoplasmic large subunit (5.8S and 28S) ribosomal RNA of the mosquito, Aedes albopictus, in an aligned format that incorporates secondary structure comparisons with Homo sapiens, Drosophila melanogaster, and Escherichia coli ribosomal RNAs. This format facilitates comparison of subtle differences between models, allowing nucleotide by nucleotide analysis at each position of discrepancy. Comparison of the A. albopictus large subunit ribosomal RNA gene with those from other species revealed new compensatory base changes. The aligned format focuses attention to the specific contribution of the A. albopictus sequence by facilitating comparison with the sequence of another dipteran, D. melanogaster. This is the second report of a complete large subunit rRNA sequence from an arthropod, and the first 28S rRNA sequence for a member of the lower Diptera (Nematocera).

Efficient transfection of mosquito cells is influenced by the temperature at which DNA-calcium phosphate coprecipitates are prepared.

Transient expression of a heat-shock protein-chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (hsp-CAT) recombinant plasmid was used to define the parameters that influence transfection of cultured mosquito cells using DNA-calcium phosphate coprecipitates. The efficiency of the calcium phosphate procedure was strongly influenced by the growth state of recipient cells, and by the temperature at which the coprecipitate was prepared. Under optimal conditions, which included formation of the DNA-calcium phosphate coprecipitate at 50 degrees C, transfection frequencies were up to tenfold higher than those obtained using the previously described polybrene procedure.