Predictors of the Level of Shared Decision Making in Vascular Surgery: A Cross Sectional Study.

OBJECTIVE: Although patients with vascular diseases often face multiple treatment options with different risks and benefits, the application of shared decision making (SDM) remains low. In SDM, clinicians and their patients work together to decide upon the treatment option that best fits the patient's situation and preference. This study aimed to reveal predictors of the extent to which the SDM process occurs in vascular surgery. METHODS: This was a cross sectional cohort substudy of the OVIDIUS trial, a multicentre, randomised, stepped wedge trial on the effect of implementing SDM supporting tools. The data of outpatients visiting university and general hospitals and suffering from abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAAs), intermittent claudication (IC), or varicose veins (VV) were used. Consultations were audio recorded. SDM levels were scored independently by two evaluators, using the OPTION-5 instrument, on a scale from 0% (no SDM effort) to 100% (exemplary SDM effort). Possible associations between the OPTION-5 scores and patient, clinician, and consultation characteristics were investigated using multivariable linear regression analysis. RESULTS: Of the 342 patients included (AAA, n = 87; VV, n = 143; IC, n = 112), 60% were male and mean age was 64 years. Overall, the SDM score was relatively low; mean ± SD 33.8% ± 13.2%, mainly due to insufficient support for the patient in deliberating their options. Regression analysis showed that the mean SDM scores in consultation with patients with IC and patients with VV were -9.9 (95% confidence interval [CI] -13.2 - -6.5; p < .001) and -12.7 (95% CI -17.3 - -8.0; p < .001) points lower than in patients with AAA, respectively. Consultations by a resident in training or nurse practitioner resulted in a -8.6 (95% CI -13.1 - -4.0; p < .001) and -4.2 (95% CI -7.9 - -0.42; p = .029) point lower SDM score than by a surgeon, respectively. A consultation longer than 30 minutes resulted in a 5.8 (95% CI 1.3 - 10.3; p = .011) point higher SDM score than consultations lasting fewer than 10 minutes. CONCLUSION: In this study, it was found that SDM can still be improved, especially by helping patients understand and deliberate about their options. Spending time weighing up the options, notably with patients with IC and VV, will help improve the SDM process. Training in SDM consultations is important, particularly for junior clinicians.

Improving Shared Decision Making in Vascular Surgery: A Stepped Wedge Cluster Randomised Trial.

OBJECTIVE: Different treatment options are available and feasible for various vascular surgical disorders. Hence, vascular surgery seems an area par excellence for shared decision making (SDM), in which clinicians incorporate the patient's preferences into the final treatment decision. However, current SDM levels in vascular surgical outpatient clinics are below expectations. To improve this, different decision support tools (DSTs) have been developed: online patient decision aids, consultation cards, and decision cards. METHODS: This stepped wedge cluster randomised trial was conducted in 13 Dutch hospitals. Besides the developed DSTs, training on how to apply SDM during the clinician patient encounter was used in this study. Data were obtained via questionnaires and audio recordings. The primary outcome was the OPTION-5 score, an objective tool to assess the level of SDM, expressed as a percentage of exemplary performance. Main secondary outcomes were patients' disease specific knowledge, consultation duration, and treatment choice. Factors influencing OPTION-5 scores were studied using linear regression analysis. RESULTS: Included in the study were 342 patients with an abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA; n = 87), intermittent claudication (IC; n = 143), or varicose veins (VV; n = 112). Audiotapes of 395 consultations were analysed. Overall the mean OPTION-5 score significantly improved from 28.7% to 37.8% (mean difference 9.1%, 95% CI 6.5% - 11.8%) after implementation of the DSTs. Also, patient knowledge increased significantly (median increase: 13%, effect size: 0.13, p = .025). The number of patients choosing non-surgical treatment choices increased, with 21.4% to 28.8% for patients with AAA and doubled (16.0% to 32.0%) among patients with IC. For surgeons, the SDM training and for patients the decision aid significantly and independently increased OPTION-5 scores (p < .001 and p = .047, respectively). CONCLUSION: Introducing DSTs improves the level of shared decision making in vascular surgery, improves patient knowledge, and shifts their preference towards more non-surgical treatments. The SDM training for clinicians and the decision aid for patients appeared the most effective means of improving SDM. TRIAL REGISTRATION: NTR6487.

[A complication of coronary angiography in a female patient with systemic sclerosis]. / Complicatie van coronairangiografie bij een patiënte met sclerodermie.

Systemic sclerosis is an autoimmune connective tissue disorder characterized by microvascular obliterations of the skin, lungs, and heart. Pulmonary hypertension is a potentially life-threatening complication of systemic sclerosis and coronary angiography is indicated for diagnosing this complication. A 79-year-old woman, who suffered from systemic sclerosis and Raynaud's syndrome, presented with a cold, painful, ulcerated right hand. It appeared that arterial occlusion of the radial artery had occurred following coronary angiography. Symptoms initially worsened, but improved following treatment with bosentan. This complication could have been avoided by performing the coronary angiography via the femoral artery. This case study emphasises the importance of taking medical history and comorbidities into account when carrying out invasive diagnostic procedures.

Thrombogenicity and related biological properties of heparin bonded collagen coated polyester and human umbilical vein prosthetic vascular grafts.

BACKGROUND: Multiple factors contribute to the process of prosthetic graft failure. Some of them are specifically related to the biological behavior of the used materials. To pursue the ideal substitute for the autologous vein graft, many materials have been taken into consideration. Of these, polyester (Dacron) and human umbilical vein (HUV, Dardik) bypass grafts have gained much attention in vascular surgical practice over the years. This study compares the results of both in vivo and in vitro investigations on graft thrombogenicity and neo-intimal formation in collagen-coated heparin bonded Dacron and in HUV bypass grafts. It is an adjunct to our clinical comparison of graft materials in infrainguinal arterial reconstruction. METHODS: In 12 adult Beagle dogs, a patch was sewn onto the abdominal aorta (Dacron, n = 6; HUV, n = 6). At defined interval times, thrombocyte aggregation was measured with nuclear imaging of 99mTechnetium labeled platelets. Post-mortem histological analysis of the interface between the native vessel wall and the patch was performed in all animals. RESULTS: At 4 h (2.67, SD = 0.77) and after 2 weeks (2.21, SD = 0.28) after implantation, significantly higher thrombogenicity was measured in the HUV grafts compared to Dacron grafts (1.98, SD = 0.10 and 1.98, SD = 0.11, P = 0.02 and 0.025, respectively). At 4 weeks, no significant difference could be found (HUV, 2.26; SD = 0.29; Dacron, 2.11; SD = 0.16; P = 0.23). Measurement of 'neo-intimal' thickness after explantation of the patch at 28 days after the initial procedure showed a significant difference: in HUV grafts the mean thickness of the inner lining was 0.76 mm (SD = 0.50), compared to 0.16 mm (SD = 0.10) in the Dacron grafts (P = 0.013). CONCLUSION: HUV grafts showed a higher thrombogenicity at 4 h and 2 weeks after insertion of the graft compared to Dacron grafts. At 4 weeks this difference is not present. After 28 days the inner ('neo-intimal') lining is significantly more pronounced in HUV grafts than in Dacron grafts.

Assessment of prosthetic vascular graft thrombogenicity using the technetium-99m labeled glycoprotein IIb/IIIa receptor antagonist DMP444 in a dog model.

INTRODUCTION: Prosthetic graft patency greatly depends on graft thrombogenicity. The concept of graft thrombogenicity is poorly understood and difficult to measure or quantify. In a study we tested the experimental radiopharmaceutical DMP444 and developed a suitable dog model. This agent is a radiolabelled ((99m)Technetium) glycoprotein IIb/IIIa receptor antagonist with a high affinity for activated platelets. It binds to platelets that are intimately involved in thrombus formation. The agent does not affect thrombocyte function, when used in a dose necessary for imaging. DMP444 does not require platelet harvesting and processing. Early imaging of thrombocyte aggregation sites such as vascular prostheses is possible within 4 hours after injection. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Adult Beagle dogs weighing 12-15 kg were used for the experiments. In 16 dogs a prosthetic patch was sewn onto the abdominal aorta (Bovine pericard: n=4, Dacron: n=6, Human Umbilical Vein: n=6). Imaging cycles after injection of (99m)Technetium-labelled DMP444 were performed on days 1, 7, 14 and 28 after surgery. RESULTS: We noticed differences in thrombus formation on the tested graft materials. The bovine pericard patches (n=4) showed a relatively high rate of thrombocyte aggregation. In the Dacron patches (n=6) aggregation was not seen. In 1 of 6 cases of human umbilical vein patches a measurable focal aggregation was recorded. CONCLUSION: The method outlined in this study is a relatively simple and reproducable method to visualize thrombocyte aggregation.