Quality in Non-GxP Research Environment.

There has been increasing evidence in recent years that research in life sciences is lacking in reproducibility and data quality. This raises the need for effective systems to improve data integrity in the evolving non-GxP research environment. This chapter describes the critical elements that need to be considered to ensure a successful implementation of research quality standards in both industry and academia. The quality standard proposed is founded on data integrity principles and good research practices and contains basic quality system elements, which are common to most laboratories. Here, we propose a pragmatic and risk-based quality system and associated assessment process to ensure reproducibility and data quality of experimental results while making best use of the resources.

A fluorescence-based thiol quantification assay for ultra-high-throughput screening for inhibitors of coenzyme A production.

Here we report the development and miniaturization of a cell-free enzyme assay for ultra-high-throughput screening (uHTS) for inhibitors of two potential drug targets for obesity and cancer: fatty acid synthase (FAS) and acetyl-coenzyme A (CoA) carboxylase (ACC) 2. This assay detects CoA, a product of the FAS-catalyzed condensation of malonyl-CoA and acetyl-CoA. The free thiol of CoA can react with 7-diethylamino-3-(4'-maleimidylphenyl)-4-methylcoumarin (CPM), a profluorescent coumarin maleimide derivative that becomes fluorescent upon reaction with thiols. FAS produces long-chain fatty acid and CoA from the condensation of malonyl-CoA and acetyl-CoA. In our FAS assay, CoA released in the FAS reaction forms a fluorescence adduct with CPM that emits at 530 nm when excited at 405 nm. Using this detection method for CoA, we measured the activity of sequential enzymes in the fatty acid synthesis pathway to develop an ACC2/FAS-coupled assay where ACC2 produces malonyl-CoA from acetyl-CoA. We miniaturized the FAS and ACC2/FAS assays to 3,456- and 1,536-well plate format, respectively, and completed uHTSs for small molecule inhibitors of this enzyme system. This report shows the results of assay development, miniaturization, and inhibitor screening for these potential drug targets.

Miniaturization and automation of an ubiquitin ligase cascade enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay in 1,536-well format.

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) are a long established and widely used assay format for drug discovery and diagnostics. They offer many advantages over homogeneous assay formats, including high sensitivity and separation (wash) steps that remove detection-interfering compounds. Many high-throughput screening assays are now performed in miniaturized formats (1,536- and 3,456-well plates) for higher throughput and lower reagent consumption. With miniaturization, separation steps in assays such as ELISA can become difficult to implement. Here we report on the implementation of the Kalypsys, Inc. (San Diego, CA) 1,536-well plate washer to enable the successful miniaturization and full automation of an ELISA that monitors ubiquitin ligase activity. The 1,536-well plate ELISA was robust and used for the high-throughput screening of a large screening collection (>1 million compounds).

Ultra-high-throughput screening for antagonists of a Gi-coupled receptor in a 2.2-microl 3,456-well plate format cyclicAMP assay.

3',5'-Cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) is a common intracellular second messenger that enables cells to respond to external stimuli. Measurement of intracellular cAMP concentrations is thus widely used for studying guanosine triphosphate binding protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), which make up a large class of pharmaceutical drug targets. Although several assay technologies exist to measure cAMP, most are not suitable for ultra-high-throughput screening (uHTS), as is often required for screening large (greater than 1 million) chemical libraries for the identification of suitable leads for drug development. Here we report that the enzyme fragment complementation assay, a homogeneous gain of signal assay based on complementation of two fragments of a beta-galactosidase enzyme, is compatible with uHTS requirements of a 2.2-microl total assay volume in 3,456-well plate format. We describe the miniaturization of this assay into 3,456-well plate format exhibiting comparable sensitivity and plate statistics to those of a 384-well assay and the application of this assay in uHTS for the identification of antagonists of a Gi-coupled receptor.

Development of the high throughput screening assay for identification of agonists of an orphan nuclear receptor.

Retina-specific nuclear receptor (RNR), also known as PNR and NR2E3, is an orphan nuclear receptor expressed exclusively in photoreceptor cells of the retina. Here we describe homogeneous cell-based resonance energy transfer assay for identification of RNR agonists using beta-lactamase as the reporter gene. Bacterial beta-lactamase reporter construct containing GAL4 response elements was randomly integrated into the genome with subsequent selection of responsive cell pools by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. Chimeric RNR (RNR hinge and ligand-binding domains fused to GAL4 DNA-binding domain) was stably transfected into mammalian Flp-In Chinese hamster ovary cells using Flp-mediated recombination into a single pre-integrated Flp recombination target site. Since no RNR ligand could be used as a control for monitoring the development of the RNR assay, we developed a parallel cell line with the functionally related well-characterized thyroid hormone nuclear receptor. This parallel thyroid hormone nuclear receptor system was used as a "guide" in optimizing the RNR assay for ultra-high-throughput screening in 3,456-well nanoplate format. The assay was successfully used to screen a large compound collection for RNR agonists. In this study we demonstrated the feasibility of developing and optimization of the high-throughput screening-compatible assay for the orphan nuclear receptor in the absence of its cognitive ligand.

A cell-based ultra-high-throughput screening assay for identifying inhibitors of D-amino acid oxidase.

Enzymes are often considered less "druggable" targets than ligand-regulated proteins such as G-protein-coupled receptors, ion channels, or other hormone receptors. Reasons for this include cellular location (intracellular vs. cell surface), typically lower affinities for the binding of small molecules compared to ligand-specific receptors, and binding (catalytic) sites that are often charged or highly polar. A practical drawback to the discovery of compounds targeting enzymes is that screening of compound libraries is typically carried out in cell-free activity assays using purified protein in an inherently artificial environment. Cell-based assays, although often arduous to design for enzyme targets, are the preferred discovery tool for the screening of large compound libraries. The authors have recently described a novel cell-based approach to screening for inhibitors of a phosphatase enzyme and now report on the development and implementation of a homogeneous 3456-well plate assay for D-amino acid oxidase (DAO). Human DAO was stably expressed in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells, and its activity was measured as the amount of hydrogen peroxide detected in the growth medium following feeding the cells with D-serine. In less than 12 weeks, the authors proved the concept in 96-and then 384-well formats, miniaturized the assay to the 3456-well (nanoplate) scale, and screened a library containing more than 1 million compounds. They have identified several cell-permeable inhibitors of DAO from this cell-based high-throughput screening, which provided the discovery program with a few novel and attractive lead structures.

A miniaturized cell-based fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay for insulin-receptor activation.

This report describes the development, optimization, and implementation of a miniaturized cell-based assay for the identification of small-molecule insulin mimetics and potentiators. Cell-based assays are attractive formats for compound screening because they present the molecular targets in their cellular environment. A fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) cell-based assay that measures the insulin-dependent colocalization of Akt2 fused with either cyan fluorescent protein or yellow fluorescent protein to the cellular membrane was developed. This ratiometric FRET assay was miniaturized into a robust, yet sensitive 3456-well nanoplate assay with Z' factors of approximately 0.6 despite a very small assay window (less than twofold full activation with insulin). The FRET assay was used for primary screening of a large compound collection for insulin-receptor agonists and potentiators. To prioritize compounds for further development, primary hits were tested in two additional assays, a biochemical time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay to measure insulin-receptor phosphorylation and a translocation-based imaging assay. Results from the three assays were combined to yield 11 compounds as potential leads for the development of insulin mimetics or potentiators.

Identification of small molecule antagonists of the human mas-related gene-X1 receptor.

The recently identified mas-related-gene (MRG) family of receptors, located primarily in sensory neurons of the dorsal root ganglion, has been implicated in the perception of pain. Thus, antagonists of this class of receptors have been postulated to be useful analgesics. Toward this end, we developed a cell-based beta-lactamase (BLA) reporter gene assay to identify small molecule antagonists of the human MRG-X1 receptor from a library of compounds. Single-cell clones expressing functional receptors were selected using the BLA reporter gene technology. The EC50 for the MRG agonist peptide, BAM15, appeared to be comparable between the BLA assay and the intracellular Ca2+ transient assays in these cells. Ultra high-throughput screening of approximately 1 million compounds in a 1.8-microl cell-based BLA reporter gene assay was conducted in a 3456-well plate format. Compounds exhibiting potential antagonist profile in the BLA assay were confirmed in the second messenger Ca2+ transient assay. A cell-based receptor trafficking assay was used to further validate the mechanism of action of these compounds. Several classes of compounds, particularly the 2,3-disubstituted azabicyclo-octanes, appear to be relatively potent antagonists at the human MRG-X1 receptors, as confirmed by the receptor trafficking assay and radioligand binding studies. Furthermore, the structure-activity relationship reveals that within this class of compounds, the diphenylmethyl moiety is constant at the 2-substituent, whereas the 3-substituent is directly correlated with the antagonist activity of the compound.

Miniaturization of whole live cell-based GPCR assays using microdispensing and detection systems.

Cell-based beta-lactamase reporter gene assays designed to measure the functional responses of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) were miniaturized to less than 2 microL total assay volume in a 3456-well microplate. Studies were done to evaluate both receptor agonists and antagonists. The pharmacology of agonists and antagonists for target GPCRs originally developed in a 96-well format was recapitulated in a 3456-well microplate format without compromising data quality or EC(50)/IC(50) precision. These assays were employed in high-throughput screening campaigns, allowing the testing of more than 150,000 compounds in 8 h. The instrumentation used and practical aspects of the assay development are discussed.

A beta-lactamase-dependent Gal4-estrogen receptor beta transactivation assay for the ultra-high throughput screening of estrogen receptor beta agonists in a 3456-well format.

Estrogen action is mediated via two estrogen receptor (ER) subtypes, ERalpha and ERbeta. Selective ER modulators with balanced high affinity for ERalpha and ERbeta have been developed as therapeutics for the treatment of a variety of diseases, including hormone-responsive breast cancer and osteoporosis. Recent data based primarily on the evaluation of ER-knockout mice have revealed that ERalpha and ERbeta may regulate separate and distinct biological processes. The identification of ERbeta specific ligands could further enhance our understanding of ERbeta biology. In addition, compounds targeting ERbeta may prove useful as therapeutic agents with activity profiles distinguishable from that of estradiol. To discover novel selective ligands for ERbeta, we developed and characterized a cell-based Gal4-ERbeta beta-lactamase reporter gene assay (GERTA) in CHO cells for the ligand-induced activation of the human ERbeta. The sensitivity and selectivity of this assay were found to be comparable to those of an ER ligand-binding assay. The assay was optimized for screening in an ultra high throughput 3456-well nanoplate format and was successfully used to screen a large compound collection for ERbeta agonists. Compounds identified in a primary screen were tested in an in vitro ligand-binding assay to characterize further the selectivity and potency for ERbeta.