Quality of information concerning cervical disc herniation on the Internet.

BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Many Americans seek and are influenced in their decision making by medical information on the Internet. Past studies have repeatedly found information on most medical Web sites to be deficient and of low quality. Physicians must remain aware of the quality and reliability of the information available on the Internet for patient education purposes. PURPOSE: To assess quality and authorship of Internet Web sites regarding a common cervical spine disorder, cervical disc herniation. STUDY DESIGN: The present study is a systematic quality assessment survey of Web sites concerning cervical disc herniation. METHODS: Fifty relevant and unique sites were identified. The five most popular search engines were used to identify 100 Web sites using the search term, "cervical disc herniation." Using a validated technique, three orthopedic surgeons independently generated content quality scores and accuracy scores, then integrated into a single final total summary score for each Web site. RESULTS: Four of the five identified top-scoring Web sites were found to be commercial and one was academic. Most of the Web sites were found to be physician sponsored, followed by academic and commercial. CONCLUSIONS: There is wide variability in Web site quality, with most of the Web sites failing to be sufficiently comprehensive and accurate. Physicians treating patients with cervical disc herniation must remain vigilant in guiding their patients to proper information on the Internet.

End organ effects of high-dose human equivalent methylprednisolone in a spinal cord injury rat model.

STUDY DESIGN: Interventional study. OBJECTIVE: To analyze the histologic effects of high-dose human equivalent methylprednisolone on the pulmonary, cardiac, intestinal, renal, hepatic, and splenic tissues in a spinal cord injury rat model. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: There are numerous investigations of various medical interventions for the treatment of acute spinal cord trauma. Currently, the only generally accepted medical intervention in an acute spinal cord trauma is the intravenous administration of high doses of methylprednisolone. Although it has been nearly 2 decades since the first National Acute Spinal Cord Injury Study investigated the role high-dose steroids might play in the treatment of acute spinal cord trauma, controversy still exists regarding the efficacy of this treatment. To our knowledge, no study has examined the role of high-dose methylprednisolone in organ systems other than the spinal cord in an acute spinal cord injury model at the histologic level. This study attempts to characterize end organ histologic response to human dose equivalent (HDE) intravenous methylprednisolone administration in a rodent model of acute spinal cord injury. METHODS: A total of 48 Sprague-Dawley rats were divided equally into control and experimental groups. Each group was subdivided into 6 sets of 4 animals each, according to intervals after injury. Groups 1-6 consisted of animals euthanized at 0, 4, 8, 16, 24, and 48 hours after spinal cord injury. Paraplegia after lower thoracic laminectomy was achieved using a standardized Allen weight drop technique. Within 1 hour of injury, experimental animals were treated with HDE methylprednisolone, infused for 23 hours continuously. Liver, kidney, lung, intestine, spleen, and heart were harvested at variable intervals after injury and prepared for histologic examination. These slides were analyzed with microscopic staining techniques and compared in a blinded manner by a qualified pathologist. RESULTS: Of all the end organs analyzed, the spleens were most affected. Lymphocytic depletion was seen in as little as 4 hours after methylprednisolone infusion and continued until 48 hours. Pulmonary tissues variably showed interstitial congestion and eosinophilic alveolar collections. Intestinal mucosal tissues showed edema and autolyzed mucosa from 16 hours onwards. Cardiac, kidney, and hepatic tissue did not differ significantly from controls. CONCLUSIONS: Histologically, HDE methylprednisolone caused significant splenic lymphocytic depletion changes in as little as 4 hours. This trend of end organ lymphocytopenia continued to progress until 48 hours. Pulmonary eosinophilic infiltrates were seen from 8 until 24 hours. Intestinal mucosal edema and necrosis were seen in samples at 16 hours throughout 48 hours. This study was designed to evaluate end organ changes seen in an animal model of an acute spinal cord injury treated with HDE methylprednisolone. Study animals were infused with HDE methylprednisolone given according to the National Acute Spinal Cord Injury Study II protocol. The kidney, lung, cardiac, intestinal, splenic, and hepatic tissues from the aforementioned animals were then sectioned and analyzed using histologic staining techniques by a qualified pathologist.

Surfing for scoliosis: the quality of information available on the Internet.

STUDY DESIGN: A cross section of Web sites accessible to the general public was surveyed. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the quality and accuracy of information on scoliosis that a patient might access on the Internet. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The Internet is a rapidly expanding communications network with an estimated 765 million users worldwide by the year 2005. Medical information is one of the most common sources of inquires on the Web. More than 100 million Americans accessed the Internet for medical information in the year 2000. Undoubtedly, the use of the Internet for patient information needs will continue to expand as Internet access becomes more readily available. This expansion combined with the Internet's poorly regulated format can lead to problems in the quality of information available. Since the Internet operates on a global scale, implementing and enforcing standards have been difficult. The largely uncontrolled information can potentially negatively influence consumer health outcomes. METHODS: To identify potential sites, five search engines were selected and the word "scoliosis" was entered into each search engine. A total of 50 Web sites were chosen for review. Each Web site was evaluated according to the type of Web site, quality content, and informational accuracy by three board-certified academic orthopedic surgeons, fellowship trained in spinal surgery, who each has been in practice for a minimum of 8 years. Each Web site was categorized as academic, commercial, physician, nonphysician health professional, and unidentified. In addition, each Web site was evaluated according to scoliosis-specific content using a point value system of 32 disease-specific key words pertinent to the care of scoliosis on an ordinal scale. A list of these words is given. Point values were given for the use of key words related to disease summary, classifications, treatment options, and complications. The accuracy of the individual Web site was evaluated by each spine surgeon using a scale of 1 to 4. A score of 1 represents that the examiner agreed with less than 25% of the information while a score of 4 represents greater than 75% agreement. RESULTS: Of the total 50 Web sites evaluated, 44% were academic, 18% were physician based, 16% were commercial, 12% were unidentified, and 10% were nonphysician health professionals. The quality content score (maximum, 32 points) for academic sites was 12.6 +/- 3.8, physician sites 11.3 +/- 4.0, commercial sites 11 +/- 4.2, unidentified 7.6 +/- 3.9, and nonphysician health professional site 7.0 +/- 1.8. The accuracy score (maximum, 12 points) was 6.6 +/- 2.4 for academic sites, 6.3 +/- 3.0 for physician-professional sites, 6.0 +/- 2.7 for unidentified sites, 5.5 +/- 3.8 for nonphysician professional sites, and 5.0 +/- 1.5 for commercial Web sites. The academic Web sites had the highest mean scores in both quality and accuracy content scores. CONCLUSION: The information about scoliosis on the Internet is of limited quality and poor information value. Although the majority of the Web sites were academic, the content quality and accuracy scores were still poor. The lowest scoring Web sites were the nonphysician professionals and the unidentified sites, which were often message boards. Overall, the highest scoring Web site related to both quality and accuracy of information was www.srs.org. This Web site was designed by the Scoliosis Research Society. The public and the medical communities need to be aware of these existing limitations of the Internet. Based on our review, the physician must assume primary responsibility of educating and counseling their patients.