Demand management in plastic surgery for low priority procedures: the Welsh experience.

INTRODUCTION: Health Commission Wales (Specialist Services) [HCW] are responsible for resource allocation and demand management in plastic surgery for the population of Wales (2.9 M). Since 2004, all low priority plastic surgery referrals have been screened by a single HCW Case Officer against clinical inclusion criteria before the referral is passed to the provider. Only patients fulfilling these criteria proceed to an outpatient appointment, although there is an appeals procedure. Revised guidelines were introduced in 2006. Our aim was to investigate the effectiveness of the process and the impact of the revised criteria. METHODS: The Case Officer's database was used to determine numbers of index procedures referred and those disallowed before and after the policy change. RESULTS: Since 2004 9,654 referrals have been screened. In 2005-6, 32.5% failed to meet the inclusion criteria and were disallowed. In the year after the policy revision fewer low priority patients were referred (1720 vs. 2013) and more (46.6%) were declined. Body contouring / abdominoplasty were particularly affected with 73.2% not compliant with funding criteria. CONCLUSION: The Welsh model is an efficient, effective and equitable system for demand management, which amounts to thousands of requests per year. After 2006, tighter guidelines have resulted in a higher proportion of patients not meeting the criteria for funding, particularly for body contouring / abdominoplasty procedures. Difficulties remain however in determining reproducible and clinically appropriate criteria for patients seeking plastic surgery following massive weight-loss. Whilst this process streamlines the provision of NHS plastic surgery for the people of Wales, there is a potential impact on specialist training.

A prospective evaluation of the Modified Hand Injury Severity Score in predicting return to work.

Hand injuries are the main cause of work-related disability in young adults. We have devised the Modified Hand Injury Scoring System to quantify hand, wrist and forearm injuries. This study aims to determine its value in predicting ability and time taken to return to work after such injury. Prospectively-assigned MHISS at presentation was compared with demographic, injury, employment and quality of life information 40-52months after acute hand or forearm injury. MHISS score was the only variable investigated found to predict ability to return to work. Factors not associated included age at injury, occupation, hand injury side or dominance, main earner status and compensation-seeking. Median time to return to work increased from 30 to 760days for Mild and Major MHISS categories respectively. Injury severity quantified using MHISS is an important determinant of return to work after hand or forearm injury. Only 60% of patients return to work following a Major injury and may take over a year to do so. Such information may allow the patient to make early informed personal financial and retraining decisions after their injury.

Twenty-four hours or 10 days? A prospective randomised controlled trial in children comparing head bandages following pinnaplasty.

The perceived benefits of bandaging for 10 days following pinnaplasty have been questioned by previous studies. The problems arising from these dressings are many [Powell BWEM. The value of head dressings in the postoperative management of the prominent ear. Br J Plast Surg 1989;42:692-4. Bartley J. How long should ears be bandaged after otoplasty? J Laryngol Otol 1998;112:531-2. Wong MC, Sylaidis P. Head dressings for pinnaplasty: a tradition not supported by evidence. Br J Plast Surg 2001;54:81-2], including their slippage [Powell BWEM. The value of head dressings in the postoperative management of the prominent ear. Br J Plast Surg 1989;42:692-4. Bradbury ET, Hewison J, Timmons MJ. Psychological and social outcome of prominent ear correction in children. Br J Plast Surg 1992;45:97-100. Jeffery SLA. Complications following correction of prominent ears: an audit review of 122 cases. Br J Plast Surg 1999;52:588-90]. Eighty children were recruited into a prospective randomised controlled trial comparing the use of a head bandage for only 24 h with a standard practise of a 10-day head bandage. A preoperative measurement of the lateral ear projection (LEP) was made. The outcome measures recorded during the two planned postoperative visits at 10 days (visit 1) and 2 months (visit 2) were: patient satisfaction score, LEP, complications and any unscheduled hospital visits associated with the surgery. There was no significant difference in LEP and patient satisfaction between the two groups at both the scheduled postoperative visits. Differences between the groups in the number of unscheduled visits (p=0.21) did not reach statistical significance. The findings indicate that it is safe and effective to use head bandage for only 24 h following surgical correction of prominent ears. This study shows no benefit from the application of a formal head bandage for any longer than 1 day.

Reconstruction of disruptions of the deep transverse metacarpal ligament of the ring finger using the A1 pulleys.

There is little information in the literature regarding the clinical features, investigation, diagnosis and treatment of closed rupture of the deep transverse metacarpal ligament. We demonstrate a case with previously undescribed features and describe the surgical management.

Long term follow-up of c-myc, p53 and proliferation measurements in malignant melanoma.

AIMS: We report a prospective study examining the prognostic significance of the c-myc oncoprotein, p53 tumour suppressor gene and proliferation rate measurements in malignant melanoma. METHODS: Flow cytometry (FCM) was used to measure the expression of c-myc, p53 and proliferation parameters in patients who had received an injection of the thymidine analogue bromodeoxyuridine prior to surgery. RESULTS: Sixty-seven patients had successful FCM measurements of the three parameters. c-myc was detected in 97% of patients with a median cell positivity of 62%. The median p53 positivity was 13%. The median potential doubling time (T(pot)) of the tumours wasf 9.4 days. In univariate analysis, each of the parameters showed an association with survival in metatstatic disease with rapid proliferation (p=0.006) or overexpression of c-myc (p=0.038) related to poor survival whereas increased positivity for p53 predicted better survival (p=0.013). CONCLUSIONS: These data indicate that laser cytometric technology can be used to obtain quantitative data on oncoproteins expression and cell proliferation rates in clinical samples of malignant melanoma.

Structure of type I and type III heterotypic collagen fibrils: an X-ray diffraction study.

The molecular packing arrangement within collagen fibrils has a significant effect on the tensile properties of tissues. To date, most studies have focused on homotypic fibrils composed of type I collagen. This study investigates the packing of type I/III collagen molecules in heterotypic fibrils of colonic submucosa using a combination of X-ray diffraction data, molecular model building, and simulated X-ray diffraction fibre diagrams. A model comprising a 70-nm-diameter D- (approximately 65 nm) axial periodic structure containing type I and type III collagen chains was constructed from amino acid scattering factors organised in a liquid-like lateral packing arrangement simulated using a classical Lennard-Jones potential. The models that gave the most accurate correspondence with diffraction data revealed that the structure of the fibril involves liquid-like lateral packing combined with a constant helical inclination angle for molecules throughout the fibril. Combinations of type I:type III scattering factors in a ratio of 4:1 gave a reasonable correspondence with the meridional diffraction series. The attenuation of the meridional intensities may be explained by a blurring of the electron density profile of the D period caused by nonspecific or random interactions between collagen types I and III in the heterotypic fibril.

Vaccum assisted closure: an alternative strategy in the management of degloving injuries of the foot.

A case of a degloving injury to the foot is presented in a patient who also sustained severe contralateral lower-limb trauma. We report a technique for salvaging the foot by replacing the degloved skin as a full-thickness graft and securing it using the vacuum-assisted closure (VAC) device. A good outcome was achieved and technical tips are provided to facilitate reproduction of the procedure.

Coding plastic surgery operations: an audit of performance using OPCS-4.

Accurate coding is essential for local and national data reporting and for contracting. It is also integral to clinical governance. This study aimed to assess the accuracy of coding in Morriston Hospital plastic surgery theatres and coding office, to reaudit and address poor practice. A third coding system, a computerised logbook developed by the senior author, was not analysed in this study. Fifty operations coded using OPCS-4 were compared with a gold standard for overall accuracy, primary and procedural codes. Results were discussed with all relevant staff and reaudit took place 3 months later. The data were analysed using the paired Student's t -test for intergroup comparisons and the unpaired test for intragroup assessment. At initial audit, the coding office was significantly better than theatre staff in overall accuracy (78% vs 43% respectively P<< 0.01) and in procedural codes (98% vs 42%, P<< 0.01) but there was no difference in primary codes (62% vs 74%). At reaudit the only significant improvement was in overall accuracy of coding office records, although the clinical coders were now significantly better at recording primary codes than theatre staff (76% vs 56%, P< 0.05). The conclusions were that the quality of coding in theatre was poor and should stop. Clinical coders performed better but 1/3-1/4 of essential codes were inaccurate. This may have been due to limited understanding of terminology and techniques, difficulty reading operation notes and complexity of OPCS-4. Recommendations included closer cooperation between surgeons and coders to support and improve clinical coding performance.

Hypospadias repair: the influence of postoperative care and a patient factor on surgical morbidity.

More than 200 surgical techniques have been advocated for hypospadias repair and perfection is still eluding us. The purpose of this paper is not to comment on a surgical technique, but to highlight the importance of postoperative care on the eventual surgical outcome. Two hundred six children undergoing primary hypospadias surgery from 1984 to 1994 at Mount Vernon Hospital were analyzed. The mean age of surgery was 3.8 years (range, 8 months-17 years) and our mean follow-up was 6.1 years. Various surgical techniques were used. During 1989, we changed our postoperative regime and patients were mobilized early (within 48 hours) compared to the strict-bed rest-till-catheter-out regime before 1988. This significantly reduced our fistula rate from 22% to 9.8% (chi squared p = 0.0016). Patient factors such as pulling on the catheter, urinary obstruction/blocked catheter, erections, straining due to constipation, and interference with dressings influence surgical outcome negatively. One of these patient factors was documented in all of our 33 patients who developed fistulas. In 6 patients (3.5%), a patient factor was present without any complication. This is highly significant statistically (chi squared p < 0.0001). The type of urinary diversion, period of urinary diversion, type of dressing, catheter size, and anesthetic regime did not influence outcome significantly.

Regeneration through a long nerve graft used in the correction of facial palsy. A qualitative and quantitative study.

A surgical technique has been developed for the correction of established unilateral palsy in man. A long (20 cm or more) sural nerve graft is anastomosed to a facial nerve branch on the unaffected side and its distal end left lying free in the cheek of the affected side. After regeneration times of 5.5-14.5 months, the distal end of the graft is joined to a free (pectoralis minor) muscle graft. In due course the muscle graft contracts in unison with the unaffected side giving near normal symmetry to facial movements. In 30 cases (ages 6-52 years) qualitative and quantitative examination was made of the distal end of grafts taken at the time of joining the graft to the muscle. Total axon counts, myelinated plus non-myelinated, confirmed abundant regeneration when compared with total axons in the supplying facial nerve; myelinated fibres remained small (mean diameter 2.5 micrometers) over the range of regeneration times. Quantitation included non-myelinated axons because they probably have the potential to become myelinated once the nerve is functional. Numbers of regenerating axons were not correlated with age, nor with regeneration time. Lack of a distal connection did not appear to lead to secondary degeneration of the regenerated myelinated fibres. These were maintained in an 'immature' state for many months. This observation is of practical interest since it has been suggested that delayed connection to the distal target may have a deleterious effect on the outcome of the procedure.

Is permanent congenital facial palsy caused by birth trauma?

OBJECTIVE: To study the relation between traumatic birth and the development of permanent facial palsy in the newborn. DESIGN: Retrospective case control study of children with 'congenital' facial palsy. SETTING: Two tertiary referral centres for patients with facial palsy. SUBJECTS: 61 children with established facial palsy. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Odds ratios of recognised factors for birth injury: maternal primiparity, high birth weight, and the use of obstetric forceps at delivery. RESULTS: 13.2% of those studied had forceps assisted delivery compared to 10.2% in the normal population (odds ratio 1.34; 95% confidence intervals 0.61 to 2.97) 39.6% were born to primiparae compared to a national rate of 36.7% (1.13; 0.65 to 1.96) and only 18.9% weighed more than 3500 g at birth (0.37; 0.19 to 0.74). CONCLUSIONS: There is no association between the development of permanent 'congenital' facial palsy and recognised risk factors for birth injury. These data suggest an intrauterine rather than a traumatic aetiology.

Risk of cancer in relatives of patients with cutaneous melanoma.

BACKGROUND: Cutaneous malignant melanoma (CMM) is a recognized feature of the Lynch type II cancer-family syndrome and the Li-Fraumeni's syndrome. A significant contribution of these syndromes to the total burden of CMM would be reflected in an increased risk of nonmelanoma cancers in first degree relatives. METHODS: Pedigrees were taken from 85 patients with CMM using a family history questionnaire. The relative risk of death from all cancers and individual cancers in first degree relatives was calculated. RESULTS: Of the 85 questionnaires, those of 79 patients were completed and of adequate quality for analysis. The first degree relatives of CMM patients showed no increased risk of cancer death, the relative risk of cancer death being 1.0. Six patients (7.6%) had first degree relatives with CMM. One patient had a family history compatible with the dominant transmission of a predisposition to cancer. CONCLUSIONS: It is important to establish whether an increased cancer risk is present in relatives of patients with malignancies so that screening programs may be offered. This study provides little evidence to support seeing relatives for noncutaneous malignancies in the absence of a dominant family history of predisposition to cancers. The increased frequency of CMM in relatives suggests that relatives of CMM patients should be counseled on protection from the sun and examination of the skin for melanoma.

The Misti Gold bio-oncotic gel filled breast prosthesis: an acceptable alternative to silicone?

Concern about the use of silicone gel as a filler for breast prostheses has stimulated interest in other materials. We have evaluated the Misti Gold prosthesis which contains a "bio-oncotic" gel of low molecular weight Polyvinylpyrrolidone (PLASDONE 24AUK). Our experience of its use in breast augmentation is that the aesthetic results obtained with retromammary placement are inferior to those obtained from a silicone gel filled prosthesis. Nonetheless there are theoretical advantages for its use which will need to be considered in the light of recent regulatory decisions.

Malignant change in trichilemmal cysts: a study of cell proliferation and DNA content.

We have examined proliferative activity in a series of pilar and trichilemmal cysts using an antibody to proliferating cell nuclear antigen. In benign lesions proliferative activity was confined to the basal layers of the squamous epithelium. Lesions showing malignant change showed increased proliferative activity and were not confined to the basal layer. These findings were correlated with studies on DNA content using flow cytometry.

Tumour proliferation assessed by combined histological and flow cytometric analysis: implications for therapy in squamous cell carcinoma in the head and neck.

The two techniques of flow cytometry analysis (FCM) and immunohistochemical localisation of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) incorporation after in vivo administration, were combined to study proliferation in squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck region. Care was taken in this study to ensure that similar material was processed using both techniques such that comparisons could be made. FCM underestimated the labelling index (LI) in tumours classified as diploid compared to the histological evaluation of the tumour cells within those tumours (4.6% vs 17.1%). However, in aneuploid tumours, the FCM LI (10.7%) was similar to that obtained from histology (13.5%). Indeed, proliferation assessed by the combination of histology LI and FCM duration of S-phase (Ts) indicated that diploid tumours had a shorter median potential doubling time (Tpot) of 2.1 days compared to aneuploid (2.8 days). Despite the heterogeneity of proliferation evident histologically within the specimens, there was not a wide variation in the results of FCM analysis when multiple samples from resections were studied. Using FCM data alone, 46% of the tumours showed a Tpot of less than 5 days. When the Ts from the FCM data was combined with the average histological LI, 84% were less than 5 days and with the maximum LI, 99% were within this time interval. Compared with previous estimates, the proportion of tumours possessing proliferative characteristics which may indicate the need for acceleration of treatment seems to be much larger.

The exposed total knee replacement prosthesis: a new classification and treatment algorithm.

The increased frequency of total knee replacement arthroplasty (TKRA) has been reflected in the number of patients with exposed prostheses referred to this unit. An algorithm has been developed to assist in the preoperative assessment of the wound and this has been tested on 25 patients with wound breakdown following TKRA. The grade of exposure so derived predicts the most appropriate surgical management. The algorithm, grading system and proposed management are described.

Assessment of burn injury in the accident and emergency department: a review of 100 referrals to a regional burns unit.

Accurate assessment of the extent of thermal injury in the accident and emergency (A&E) department is essential if appropriate resuscitation and referral to a specialist unit is to occur. However, review of 100 referrals to a regional burns unit confirms that assessment is often inaccurate, and usually undertaken by no one more senior than a casualty officer, leading to suboptimal treatment and referral. Severe thermal injury should be assessed by a team of senior doctors, according to the major trauma protocol, and casualty officers should receive better training in the assessment of less extensive burns.