Electron arc irradiation of the postmastectomy chest wall with CT treatment planning: 20-year experience.

PURPOSE: Since 1980, electron arc irradiation of the postmastectomy chest wall has been the preferred radiotherapy technique at the University of Utah for patients with advanced breast cancer. We report the results of this technique in 156 consecutive Stage IIA-IIIB patients treated from 1980 to 1998. METHODS: CT treatment planning was used in all patients to identify chest wall thickness and internal mammary lymph node depth. Computerized dosimetry was used to deliver total doses of 50 Gy in 5-1/2 weeks to the chest wall and the internal mammary lymph nodes with electron arc therapy. Patients were assessed for local, regional, and distant control of disease and for survival. Univariate and multivariate proportional hazards were modeled using a hierarchical nonproportional semiparametric model testing the following prognostic factors: age, stage, tumor size, number of positive lymph nodes, estrogen receptor status, and dose. End points evaluated included disease-free survival, cause-specific survival, and overall survival. RESULTS: Eighty-one percent of patients were at high risk for local-regional failure because of > T2 primary tumor or > 3 positive axillary lymph nodes. The median number of positive lymph nodes was 5, and the median tumor size was 3.5 cm. Actuarial 10-year local-regional control and overall survival were 95% and 52%, respectively. In multivariate analysis, the only factor prognostic for disease-free survival, cause-specific survival, and overall survival was the number of positive lymph nodes (p < 0.001). The 10-year rates of local-regional control for patients with 0, 1-3, 4-9, and > or = 10 involved lymph nodes were 100%, 98%, 93%, and 89%, respectively. The only rates of acute and chronic radiotherapy toxicity > or = 2 by RTOG/EORTC criteria were skin related and observed in 44% and 10% for acute and late reactions, respectively. CONCLUSION: These data demonstrate excellent local-regional control rates with electron arc therapy of the postmastectomy chest wall in patients with advanced breast cancer. Our 20-year experience with electron arc radiotherapy has demonstrated the safety and efficacy of this technique. The advantage of this technique is that the internal mammary lymph node chain can be easily encompassed while the dose to heart and lung is minimized; it also obviates match lines in areas of high risk.

Intensity-modulated radiosurgery/radiotherapy using a micromultileaf collimator.

Intensity modulation with inverse treatment planning for 3 clinical stereotactic radiotherapy cases were directly compared against forward planning techniques using beam modification by enhanced dynamic wedge. Dose-volume histogram (DVH) analysis demonstrated that a significant reduction in dose to neighboring critical structures can-be achieved through intensity modulation patterns determined from inverse planning, while a marginal change is achieved in the target volume dose uniformity. This study also demonstrates that the intensity modulated dose patterns generated from inverse planning may differ significantly from the intuitive beam modified patterns developed in the forward planning model. These results suggest that one advantage of intensity modulated radiosurgery/radiotherapy with inverse planning is the significant reduction in dose to normal tissue and critical structures, with its coincident implications for dose escalation studies.

Application of enhanced dynamic wedge to stereotactic radiotherapy.

Stereotactic radiotherapy has developed into a useful treatment technique in which conformal dose distributions can be delivered with precision and accuracy. In some cases, the position of the target volume relative to surrounding critical structures demands careful evaluation of fixed beam paths so that dose to these critical structures can be minimized. Micromultileaf collimators aid in conforming dose to the target volume but may not allow adjustment of an individual beam's intensity (intensity modulation) in an effort to achieve dose uniformity throughout the treatment volume. Enhanced dynamic wedge (EDW) is demonstrated to be a valuable tool in improving the dose distribution in stereotactic radiotherapy treatments in which these fixed, conformal fields must be used due to constraints in beam trajectories. Four cases are presented which show the potential for gain in dose uniformity with the addition of EDW. These cases represent typical applications of EDW to conformal stereotactic radiotherapy.

Comparison of interpolated vs. calculated micromultileaf settings in dynamic conformal arc treatment.

Stereotactic radiosurgery has developed into a technique where patient positioning and treatment delivery can be performed with submillimeter precision. Achievement of this level of precision has allowed margins to be significantly reduced, and in some cases, removed altogether. Joined with these reductions in treatment margin has come a desire to shape the radiation beam, further limiting dose to normal tissues. Initial applications of shaped radiosurgery fields utilized circular blocking apertures in an attempt to shape the beam to these small volumes. The resultant dose distributions conformed well to spherical treatment volumes but were inadequate for situations where the volume of interest was irregular in shape. Other techniques, such as applying these circular apertures through multiple isocenter positions to a single volume, have been investigated as possible ways to better conform dose distributions to these irregularly-shaped volumes. Recent technological advances allow the use of micromultileaf collimators which dynamically shape the beam by adjustment of individual leaves as the gantry rotates through the are. With margins potentially so tight, accurate evaluation of these dynamically adjusting treatment parameters becomes critical. Our current treatment planning software evaluates adjustments of the leaf positions in increments of 10 degrees and then does a linear interpolation between increments. Treatment delivery, however, is performed with adjustment in leaf position more consistent with a 1 degree increment. This paper compares the individual position of each leaf as determined for the 10 degrees interpolation to required changes in leaf position when the calculation is performed at increments of less than 10 degrees. Our data suggest that there are instances where improvements can be seen when corrections in leaf positions are made at these smaller increments.

Dosimetric evaluation of a specialized radiotherapy treatment technique for scleredema.

Scleredema adultorum of Buschke is an unusual manifestation of diabetes mellitus that can result in painful indurations and thickening of the skin with associated limitation of motion, and has been previously reported to be responsive to radiotherapy. We report on the method employed to treat a severely affected patient by means of opposed photon fields and multiple electron fields encompassing his entire neck, arms, and thorax.

Dosimetric advantages of enhanced dynamic wedge in small field irradiation for the treatment of macular degeneration.

Exudative macular degeneration is a process that affects the central retina and is the chief cause of blindness in people over 55 years old. Radiation appears to improve or stabilize visual acuity in some of these patients, although definitive clinical studies are ongoing. The delivery of radiation in patients with macular degeneration is unique and challenging because of the location of the surrounding structures, such as the lens and the opposite retina. The "standard" treatment technique has been an anterior oblique beam 20 degrees above lateral to limit dose to these structures. In preference to the undesirable hot spot caused by this single-beam technique, we have employed a superior and inferior oblique pair utilizing the Enhanced Dynamic Wedge (EDW). Couch rotation was used to establish the desired treatment angles. The anterior half of the fields were blocked with the asymmetric jaw (AJ). Studies were performed to determine the value of these methods in reducing lens dose. Although the peripheral dose measurements at Dmax using a 60 degrees metal wedge for > or = 10 cm square fields were higher than for an open field or the EDW, for the small retinal fields there was no lens-dose reduction attributable to the EDW. However, the steep wedge angles achievable with the EDW were useful for optimizing the dose distribution for the most desirable field angles. As expected, the independent collimator was more effective in reducing transmitted dose to the lens than a typical Cerrobend block. Measurements required to predict dose in and out of the field are discussed along with the dosimeters employed in evaluating small fields (less than 5 cm square) with the EDW. The technical challenges of positioning, immobilization, treatment planning and treatment delivery are presented.

Beam shaping for SRT/SRS.

Field shaping for stereotactic radiosurgery and stereotactic radiotherapy has evolved from static field shaping techniques applied to static or arc fields and now includes dynamic field shaping definition which can be dynamically modified during the arc. This allows greater conformation of dose to the target volume while minimizing dose to surrounding normal tissue. This results in treatment to a single isocenter, which simplifies the treatment planning and dose delivery, thereby minimizing treatment time and improving patient comfort and satisfaction during the treatment. A number of optimization techniques remain to be investigated.

Dynamic collimator and dose rate control: enabling technology for enhanced dynamic wedge.

The key features that make dynamic dose delivery possible in the Enhanced Dynamic Wedge application are computerized position and control of the independent collimating jaws and computerized dynamic control of the linear accelerator dose rate. These features will be described and related to the current implementation of Enhanced Dynamic Wedge.

Dosimetry measurement tools for commissioning enhanced dynamic wedge.

Measurement of Enhanced Dynamic Wedge parameters requires that the dose at a measurement point be integrated during the entire exposure as the moving jaw closes to form the dose distribution. This major difference from static fields, where dose rate measurements can be made using a single moving probe, requires major modification in measurement techniques to use devices which can measure multiple points within the field simultaneously. Each of these new tools introduce unique problems in dose measurement, which must be understood prior to their use. This paper discusses these tools.

Dosimetric parameters of enhanced dynamic wedge for treatment planning and verification.

Treatment planning for Enhanced Dynamic Wedge requires a knowledge of the dosimetric parameters of the treatment fields. These dosimetric parameters include depth doses, surface doses, buildup doses, peripheral doses, beam profiles, wedge angles and wedge factors. These parameters and their application to treatment planning are evaluated and compared with standard open field and metal wedge field dosimetric parameters.

Dose to the contralateral breast: a comparison of two techniques using the enhanced dynamic wedge versus a standard wedge.

The dose to the contralateral breast has been associated with an increased risk of developing a second breast malignancy. Varying techniques have been devised and described in the literature to minimize this dose. Metal beam modifiers such as standard wedges are used to improve the dose distribution in the treated breast, but unfortunately introduce an increased scatter dose outside the treatment field, in particular to the contralateral breast. The enhanced dynamic wedge is a means of remote wedging created by independently moving one collimator jaw through the treatment field during dose delivery. This study is an analysis of differing doses to the contralateral breast using two common clinical set-up techniques with the enhanced dynamic wedge versus the standard metal wedge. A tissue equivalent block (solid water), modeled to represent a typical breast outline, was designed as an insert in a Rando phantom to simulate a standard patient being treated for breast conservation. Tissue equivalent material was then used to complete the natural contour of the breast and to reproduce appropriate build-up and internal scatter. Thermoluminescent dosimeter (TLD) rods were placed at predetermined distances from the geometric beam's edge to measure the dose to the contralateral breast. A total of 35 locations were used with five TLDs in each location to verify the accuracy of the measured dose. The radiation techniques used were an isocentric set-up with co-planar, non divergent posterior borders and an isocentric set-up with a half beam block technique utilizing the asymmetric collimator jaw. Each technique used compensating wedges to optimize the dose distribution. A comparison of the dose to the contralateral breast was then made with the enhanced dynamic wedge vs. the standard metal wedge. The measurements revealed a significant reduction in the contralateral breast dose with the enhanced dynamic wedge compared to the standard metal wedge in both set-up techniques. The dose was measured at varying distances from the geometric field edge, ranging from 2 to 8 cm. The average dose with the enhanced dynamic wedge was 2.7-2.8%. The average dose with the standard wedge was 4.0-4.7%. Thermoluminescent dosimeter measurements suggest an increase in both scattered electrons and photons with metal wedges. The enhanced dynamic wedge is a practical clinical advance which improves the dose distribution in patients undergoing breast conservation while at the same time minimizing dose to the contralateral breast, thereby reducing the potential carcinogenic effects.

Clinical application of enhanced dynamic wedge in three-dimensional treatment planning: a case report.

The introduction of three dimensional treatment planning has brought on new treatment planning challenges. New tools, such as the Enhanced Dynamic Wedge, may help to reduce the complexity of some of these multi-dimensional treatment plans, as well the resultant potential errors that may occur. The treatment planning issues and the Enhanced Dynamic Wedge's ability to address those issues as applied to one three dimensional treatment planning case will be presented.

Commissioning the Varian Enhanced Dynamic Wedge using the RAHD treatment planning system.

Procedures to commission and verify the Varian Enhanced Dynamic Wedge for use with the RAHD Treatment Planning System are presented. Emphasis is placed on minimizing the time and equipment required to verify that acceptable beam data is used in the planning process.

The quality assurance of enhanced dynamic wedges.

Dynamic wedge distributions are produced by closing one jaw continuously while simultaneously controlling dose as each position of the jaw. This method of producing wedge distributions requires more frequent Quality Assurance checks, such as verification of wedge profile, wedge factor and verification of the accuracy of the digital position readout for the jaws used for dynamic wedge. "Hard" wedges require only the verification of wedge factor and the verification of reproducibility of mechanical position in the beam. This paper will discuss methods and equipment used for the Quality Assurance of Enhanced Dynamic Wedges.

New application of enhanced dynamic wedge for tangent breast irradiation.

Dose uniformity within the treatment volume for tangent breast irradiation can be significantly improved through dynamic compensating collimation using all four independent jaws to define a superposition of sequentially reduced Enhanced dynamic wedge fields. The enhanced dynamic wedge angle is determined which optimizes dose uniformity in the central axis transverse plane, then the sequential reduction of the superior and inferior jaws is determined to optimize the sagittal dose uniformity. This technique could be applied under computer control through a record and verify system.

Electron arc irradiation of the postmastectomy chest wall: clinical results.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Since 1980 electron arc irradiation of the postmastectomy chest wall has been the preferred technique for patients with advanced breast cancer at our institution. Here we report the results of this technique in 140 consecutive patients treated from 1980 to 1993. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Thoracic computerized tomography was used to determine internal mammary lymph node depth and chest wall thickness, and for computerized dosimetry calculations. Total doses of 45-50 Gy in 5 to 5 1/2 weeks were delivered to the chest wall and internal mammary lymph nodes via electron arc and, in most cases, supraclavicular and axillary nodes were treated with a matching photon field. Patients were assessed for acute and late radiation changes, local and distant control of disease, and survival. Patients had a minimum follow-up of 1 year after completion of radiation treatment, and a mean follow up interval of 49 months and a median of 33 months. All patients had advanced disease: T stages 1, 2, 3, and 4 represented 21%, 39%, 21% and 19% of the study population, with a mean number of positive axillary lymph nodes of 6.5 (range, 0-29). Analysis was performed according to adjuvant status (no residual disease, n = 90), residual disease (positive margin, n = 15, and primary radiation, n = 2), or recurrent disease (n = 33). RESULTS: Acute radiation reactions were generally mild and self limiting. A total of 26% of patients developed moist desquamation, and 32% had brisk erythema. Actuarial 5 year local-regional control, freedom from distant failure, and cause-specific survival was 91%, 64%, and 75% in the adjuvant group; 84%, 50%, and 53% in the residual disease group; and 63%, 34%, and 32% in the recurrent disease group, respectively. In univariate Cox regressions, the number of positive lymph nodes was predictive for local failure in the adjuvant group (P = 0.037). Chronic complications were minimal with 11% of patients having arm edema, 17% hyperpigmentation, and 13% telangectasia formation. CONCLUSION: These data demonstrate that local-regional control with electron are therapy of the postmastectomy chest wall is comparable to photon techniques. Acute radiation reactions are well tolerated and mostly of minor extent. A previous report demonstrated a significant reduction in the dose-volume relationship of the lung using the electron arc compared with two photon techniques. Consequently, with careful attention to treatment planning and dosimetry, electron arc therapy of the postmastectomy chest wall is safe and effective. The radiation dose to heart and lung is minimized without compromise on local control.

Field edge smoothing for multileaf collimators.

PURPOSE: To smooth the scalloped dose pattern that occurs for stepped leaves at a treatment field edge defined by a multileaf collimator. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Fields with centers shifted slightly in space were superimposed to blur the staggered dose distribution at the field edge. Film dosimetry was used to monitor changes. The dose distribution for a single field position was compared to the distribution for one and three shifts. Three depths were examined and divergent alloy blocks were included in the comparison. RESULTS: The structure that appears at an edge for a single field when leaves are staggered was nearly eliminated when the field was shifted three times to give a total of four different positions. However, shifting the field one time so that two fields were superimposed gave an intermediate result with only slight improvement in the undulating dose distribution. For the four superimposed fields, the 50% isodose pattern converged to a smoothed line running along the center of the original undulating pattern. The 80 and 20% isodoses did not converge to the center of their scalloped patterns. Instead, these isodose lines were spread leaving a larger penumbra width than a divergent alloy block. CONCLUSIONS: Shifting and adding fields is an effective method for smoothing the staggered dose distribution that results when the leaves of a multileaf collimator are stepped to form an irregular field pattern. However, the width of the penumbra for the combined fields is wider than the penumbra for a cerrobend block.

Multi-fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy.

Precision and accuracy of a patient's treatment are key advantages of single-fraction stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for arteriovenous malformations (AVMS) and some small brain metastases. These advantages are equally valuable in fractionated treatment of the pituitary, brain metastases and brain boost fields. The need to implement the preciseness from stereotactic radiosurgery to fractionated treatments was recognized. Using our experience with single-fraction stereotactic radiosurgery as a model, we developed a multi-fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy technique that allows us to immobilize a patient daily and implement important existing devices such as the Brown-Roberts-Wells (BRW) angiographic localizer, CT scan localizer, and non-coplanar shaped field treatment planning. Development of this technique also allows us to achieve reproducible patient positioning based on immobilization techniques using polyurethane foam immobilization and heat moldable plastic technology without the necessity of the invasive technique of skull fixation. The development, implementation and dosimetry of this technique will be discussed in this paper.

Design and production of wax compensators for electron treatments of the chest wall.

The primary aim of electron treatment planning for the post mastectomy chest wall is to encompass the volume between the skin surface and the lung-rib interface while limiting dose to the lung. Electron energies for treatment of the chest wall are chosen based on the thickness of tissue between these two areas. Surgical defects or surface irregularities often result in differing thicknesses of tissue across the treatment volume, and patient-specific compensation is necessary to achieve the desired dose distribution. This is true whether the treatment plan is designed using fixed or rotational electrons to treat the chest wall. These clinical requirements are often met using custom shaped wax of varying thickness which conforms to the chest surface. This paper will discuss the treatment planning process used to design these compensators, creation and use of an exact duplicate of the patient's chest wall to aid in the production of these compensators, the production process itself, and verification of the completed compensator.