Variation in mutation rates caused by RB69pol fidelity mutants can be rationalized on the basis of their kinetic behavior and crystal structures.

We have previously observed that stepwise replacement of amino acid residues in the nascent base-pair binding pocket of RB69 DNA polymerase (RB69pol) with Ala or Gly expanded the space in this pocket, resulting in a progressive increase in misincorporation. However, in vivo results with similar RB69pol nascent base-pair binding pocket mutants showed that mutation rates, as determined by the T4 phage rI forward assay and rII reversion assay, were significantly lower for the RB69pol S565G/Y567A double mutant than for the Y567A single mutant, the opposite of what we would have predicted. To investigate the reasons for this unexpected result, we have determined the pre-steady-state kinetic parameters and crystal structures of relevant ternary complexes. We found that the S565G/Y567A mutant generally had greater base selectivity than the Y567A mutant and that the kinetic parameters for dNMP insertion, excision of the 3'-terminal nucleotide residue, and primer extension beyond a mispair differed not only between these two mutants but also between the two highly mutable sequences in the T4 rI complementary strand. Comparison of the crystal structures of these two mutants with correct and incorrect incoming dNTPs provides insight into the unexpected increase in the fidelity of the S565G/Y567A double mutant. Taken together, the kinetic and structural results provide a basis for integrating and interpreting in vivo and in vitro observations.

The reopening rate of the fingers domain is a determinant of base selectivity for RB69 DNA polymerase.

Two divalent metal ions are required for nucleotide incorporation by DNA polymerases. Here we use the bacteriophage RB69 DNA polymerase (RB69 pol) and the metal ion exchange-inert nucleotide analogue rhodium(III) deoxythymidine triphosphate (Rh.dTTP) to investigate the requirements of metal binding to the "A" site and to the "B" site, independently. We show that while binding of a metal ion to the A site is required for the nucleotidyl transfer reaction to occur, this metal binding is insufficient to initiate the prechemistry enzyme isomerization that has been observed with this polymerase. Moreover, we show that binding of a deoxynucleoside triphosphate (dNTP), in the absence of a catalytic metal ion, is sufficient to induce this conformational change. In this report, we also present several lines of evidence (from pulse-chase, rapid chemical quench-flow, and stopped-flow fluorescence experiments) for the reverse rate of the enzyme isomerization, closed to open, of a DNA polymerase complex. The implications of these data for the fidelity of DNA polymerization by RB69 pol are discussed.

Effect of A and B metal ion site occupancy on conformational changes in an RB69 DNA polymerase ternary complex.

Rapid chemical quench assays, as well as equilibrium and stopped-flow fluorescence experiments, were performed with an RB69 DNA polymerase (RB69 pol)-primer-template (P/T) complex containing 2-aminopurine (dAP) and a metal exchange-inert Rh(III) derivative of a deoxynucleoside triphosphate (Rh.dTTP). The objective was to determine the effect of catalytic metal ion (A site) occupancy on the affinity of an incoming Rh.dTTP for the RB69 pol-P/T binary complex and on the rate of the conformational change induced by Rh.dTTP binding. With Ca(2+) in the A site, the affinity of the incoming Rh.dTTP for the RB69 pol-P/T binary complex and the conformational change rate can be determined in the absence of chemistry. When Mg(2+) was added to a ternary complex containing Rh.dTTP opposite dAP, the templating base, nucleotidyl transfer occurred, but the rate of product formation was only one-tenth of that found with Mg.dTTP, as determined by rapid chemical quench assays. Rates of conformational change subsequent to formation of a ternary complex, in the absence of chemistry, were estimated from the rate of change in dAP fluorescence with an increase in the Rh.dTTP concentration. We have shown that there is an initial rapid quenching of dAP fluorescence followed by a second phase of dAP quenching, which has nearly the same rate as that of dTMP incorporation, as estimated from rapid chemical quench experiments. We have also demonstrated that the affinity of Rh.dTTP for occupancy of the B metal ion site is dependent on the presence of Ca(2+). However, a saturating Rh.dTTP concentration in the absence of Ca(2+) results in full quenching of dAP fluorescence, whereas a saturating Ca(2+) concentration in the absence of Rh.dTTP gives only partial quenching of dAP fluorescence. The implications of these results for the mechanism of Fingers closing, metal ion binding, and base selectivity are discussed.

Importance of hydrogen bonding for efficiency and specificity of the human mitochondrial DNA polymerase.

To assess the contribution to discrimination afforded by base pair hydrogen bonding during DNA replication by the human mitochondrial DNA polymerase, we examined nucleoside mimics lacking hydrogen bond forming capability but retaining the overall steric shape of the natural nucleotide. We employed oligonucleotide templates containing either a deoxyadenosine shape mimic (dQ) or a deoxythymidine shape mimic (dF). Additionally, the nucleoside triphosphate analogs difluorotoluene deoxynucleoside triphosphate, 9-methyl-1-H-imidazo[(4,5)-b]pyridine deoxyribose triphosphate, and 4-methylbenzimidazole deoxyribose triphosphate (dZTP; another dATP shape mimic) were assayed. We used pre-steady state methods to determine the kinetic parameters governing nucleotide incorporation, k(pol) and K(d). In general, the loss of hydrogen bonding potential led to 2-3 kcal/mol reduction in ground state binding free energy, whereas effects on the maximum rate of polymerization were quite variable, ranging from negligible (dATP:dF) to nearly 4 kcal/mol (dZTP:dT). Although we observed only a 46-fold reduction in discrimination when dF was present in the template, there was a complete elimination of discrimination when dQ was present in the template. Our data with dF indicate that hydrogen bonding contributes 2.2 kcal/mol toward the efficiency of incorporation, whereas data with dQ (which may overestimate the effect due to poor steric mimicry) suggest a contribution of up to 6.8 kcal/mol. Taken together, the data suggest that sterics are necessary but not sufficient to achieve optimal efficiency and fidelity for DNA polymerase. Base pair hydrogen bonding contributes at least a third of the energy underlying nucleoside incorporation efficiency and specificity.

Base pair hydrogen bonds are essential for proofreading selectivity by the human mitochondrial DNA polymerase.

We have characterized the role of Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding in the 3'-terminal base pair on the 3'-5' exonuclease activity of the human mitochondrial DNA polymerase. Nonpolar nucleoside analogs of thymidine (dF) and deoxyadenosine (dQ) were used to eliminate hydrogen bonds while maintaining base pair size and shape. Exonuclease reactions were examined using pre-steady state kinetic methods. The time dependence of removal of natural nucleotides from the primer terminus paired opposite the nonpolar analogs dF and dQ were best fit to a double exponential function. The double exponential kinetics as well as the rates of excision (3-6 s(-1) fast phase, 0.16-0.3 s(-1) slow phase) are comparable with those observed during mismatch removal of natural nucleotides even when the analog was involved in a sterically correct base pair. Additionally, incorporation of the next correct base beyond a nonpolar analog was slow (0.04-0.22 s(-1)), so that more than 95% of terminal base pairs were removed rather than extended. The polymerase responds to all 3'-terminal base pairs containing a nonpolar analog as if it were a mismatch regardless of the identity of the paired base, and kinetic partitioning between polymerase and exonuclease sites failed to discriminate between correct and incorrect base pairs. Thus, sterics alone are insufficient, whereas hydrogen bond formation is essential for proper proofreading selectivity by the mitochondrial polymerase. The enzyme may use the alignment and prevention of fraying provided by proper hydrogen bonding and minor groove hydrogen bonding interactions as critical criteria for correct base pair recognition.

Fidelity and processivity of reverse transcription by the human mitochondrial DNA polymerase.

We have characterized, by transient-state kinetic methods, the polymerase and exonuclease activities of the human mitochondrial DNA polymerase (pol gamma) during reverse transcription, employing a synthetic oligonucleotide consisting of a DNA primer and an RNA template. In comparison with the kinetic parameters observed with a DNA template, the rate of correct deoxynucleotide incorporation was reduced 25-fold (5.5+/-0.2 s(-1)), whereas the dissociation constant (Kd) for nucleotide binding was increased 4-fold (12+/-1 microm). In addition, discrimination against mismatches was reduced approximately 20-fold to only 15,000 on average. The proofreading exonuclease favored the removal of an incorrect nucleotide (0.0021+/-0.0002 s(-1) for correct versus 0.034+/-0.004 s(-1) for incorrect), and the partitioning between incorporation beyond a mismatch (5.5x10(-5)+/-0.4x10(-5) s(-1)), and exonuclease removal of that mismatch favors removal of the mismatch. These data suggest that the "reverse transcriptase activity" of mitochondrial polymerase could be physiologically relevant. However, the enzyme stalls and is unable to efficiently incorporate beyond a single nucleotide with an RNA template. Additionally, we present a refined method for calculating net discrimination, which more accurately describes the contributions of correct and incorrect incorporation. The biological and biotechnological significance of these results are discussed.

Fidelity of the human mitochondrial DNA polymerase.

We have quantified the fidelity of polymerization of DNA by human mitochondrial DNA polymerase using synthetic DNA oligonucleotides and recombinant holoenzyme and examining each of the possible 16-base pair combinations. Although the kinetics of incorporation for all correct nucleotides are similar, with an average Kd of 0.8 microM and an average k(pol) of 37 s(-1), the kinetics of misincorporation vary widely. The ground state binding Kd of incorrect bases ranges from a low of 25 microM for a dATP:A mispair to a high of 360 microM for a dCTP:T mispair. Similarly, the rates of incorporation of incorrect bases vary from 0.0031 s(-1) for a dCTP:C mispair to 1.16 s(-1) for a dGTP:T mispair. Due to the variability in the kinetic parameters for misincorporation, the estimates of fidelity range from 1 error in 3563 nucleotides for dGTP:T to 1 error in 2.3 x 10(6) nucleotides for dCTP:C. Interestingly, the discrimination against a dGTP:T mismatch is 16.5 times lower than that of a dTTP:G mismatch due to a tighter Kd for ground state binding and a faster rate of incorporation of the dGTP:T mismatch relative to the dTTP:G mismatch. We calculate an average fidelity of 1 error in 440,000 nucleotides.