Eye muscle antibodies and subtype of thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy.

The eye changes associated with Graves' hyperthyroidism can be classified into two subtypes, congestive ophthalmopathy (CO), in which inflammatory changes in the periorbital tissues predominate, and ocular myopathy (OM), in which eye muscle damage is the main feature. Antibodies against the flavoprotein (Fp) subunit of succinate dehydrogenase (SDH), the 64-kd protein, and G2s, a thyroid and eye muscle shared protein of unknown function, are good markers of eye muscle cell damage in patients with OM. Another antigen associated with ophthalmopathy is the flavine adenine nucleotide (FAD) cofactor of several mitochondrial enzymes, including SDH. We tested for serum antibodies against purified human recombinant Fp, FAD, and a G2s fusion protein, in patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) and control patients and subjects, in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Antibodies against Fp were detected in 32% of patients with TAO, 30% with Graves' hyperthyroidism (GH), 16% with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), in 14% of patients with multi-nodular goiter (MNG), and in 6% of normal subjects. Antibodies against FAD were found in 24%, 30%, 24%, and 14%, respectively, of these patients and in 12% of the normals, while antibodies against G2s were detected in 50% of patients with TAO, 40% with GH, 40% with HT, in 29% of patients with MNG, and in 7% of normals. We also tested for antibodies against SDH, FAD, and G2s in 12 patients with GH who developed CO (6 patients) or OM (6 patients) after treatment with antithyroid drugs. Of the 6 patients who developed OM, antibodies against SDH preceded the onset of eye disease in 4 and coincided with it in 2, antibodies against G2s preceded eye muscle disease in 5 and coincided with it in 1 patient while antibodies against FAD preceded the development of OM in 5 patients. Of the 6 patients who developed CO, antibodies against SDH were detected in only one patient and borderline levels were demonstrated in 1, while anti-FAD and anti-G2s each preceded the onset of eye signs in 6 patients. Positive sera from another group of patients with TAO, and a second group of normal subjects, were tested at increasing serum dilutions. Sera from the two groups showed similar dilution patterns, except for a few patients with TAO in whom increasing dilutions was associated with increased, then decreased, antibody levels. In this experiment the prevalences of the two antibodies were much greater in patients with TAO namely, 67% for anti-Fp and 89% for anti-G2s, while the prevalences in the normals were 11% and 22%, respectively. The reason for this apparent discrepancy is not clear but may reflect subject and assay differences. Because Fp is found within the mitochondrial membrane it is likely that the corresponding antibodies are produced after eye muscle necrosis, and do not play a role in its pathogenesis. The primary reaction in the eye muscle may be T-cell autoimmunity against G2s, although this has not been proven. The mechanism for the production of antibodies against G2s, FAD, and Fp in subjects who do not have ophthalmopathy is unclear. The significance of such antibodies in control subjects is presently being addressed in our laboratory.

Experimental model for ophthalmopathy in BALB/c and outbred (CD-1) mice genetically immunized with G2s and the thyrotropin receptor.

In an attempt to develop an animal model for thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) we have genetically immunized BALB/c and outbred (CD-1) mice with cDNAs encoding the thyroid and eye muscle shared protein G2s and full length human thyrotropin receptor (TSHr). Firstly, BALB/c mice were immunized with cDNAs for G2s and the TSHr, alone or in tandem with cDNAs for interleukin (IL)4 or IL12. Control mice were immunized with empty vehicle only. Sera from the great majority of experimental mice contained antibodies against a G2s fusion protein and the flavoprotein (Fp) subunit of mitochondrial succinate dehydrogenase, the "64 kDa protein", with the greatest levels being found at sacrifice (17 wk). Antibody levels in mice immunized with G2s + TSHr or G2s + IL12 were generally higher than those in mice immunized with G2s only. TSHr antibodies (TRAb), measured as TSH binding inhibition, were detected in only two mice. On histological examination of the orbits, mild edema, eye muscle fiber separation and mast cell infiltration in and around the eye muscles were found in the majority of experimental mice, but not in control mice. Splenocytes were transferred from selected G2s-immunized mice to normal syngeneic litter mates. None of the transfer mice had serum antibodies against G2s, Fp or TSHr but their orbital tissue showed the same degree of mast cell infiltration as primary mice. No major histological changes were observed in the thyroid or other skeletal muscle in either primary or transfer mice. Similar results were observed in CD-1 mice although, overall, the model was better expressed than in BALB/c mice. In these mice, serum anti-G2s antibody levels were not significantly different between the various experimental groups except at 16 wk, when they were slightly greater than in control animals. Anti-Fp antibodies were detected at 12, 14 and 16 wk, in all experimental groups, including those immunized with G2s only, and were greatest in mice immunized with TSHr alone. TRAb levels were greatest in mice immunized with both G2s and the TSHr in the presence of TL4, but not IL12. The finding of negative anti-G2s but positive anti-Fp antibodies in some CD-1 mice suggests that eye muscle damage and Fp release must have been mediated by T lymphocytes, rather than antibodies, targeting G2s or some other as yet unidentified cell membrane antigen. Histological changes in the orbit were similar to those observed in BALB/c mice although mast cell numbers were greater, in both primary and transfer mice. Overall, the greatest histological changes were observed in CD-1 mice immunized with both G2s + TSHr + IL4. None of the animals became overtly hyperthyroid or hypothyroid during the course of the study although several of the CD-1 mice had abnormal TSH or T4 levels. These results indicate that we have established a valid model for human ophthalmopathy using the novel thyroid and eye muscle expressed protein G2s, now recognized as a fragment of the winged-helix transcription factor Foxp1, and TSHr, and that G2s and the TSHr are both primary antigens in TAO. Reactivity against a TSHr-like protein may be the first event leading to ophthalmopathy in humans with TAO and experimental mice and eye muscle damage may result from autoimmunity against G2s and Fp as a result of "antigen spreading".