Negotiating horizontality in medical South-South cooperation: The Cuban mission in Rio de Janeiro's urban peripheries.

For more than 50 years, Cuba has been one of the most important players in the field of international medical cooperation in the Global South. Between 2013 and 2016, Cuba maintained one of its largest cooperations with Brazil: nearly 11,400 Cuban physicians were sent to work within the framework of the Brazilian health programme 'More-Doctors-for-Brazil', which was implemented to improve Brazil's precarious public health sector. This paper inquires into the manifold challenges of horizontal connectivity in this medical South-South cooperation. We will trace these back to deep-rooted contentions about the epistemological approaches to medical practice and professional recognition within and between Cuban and Brazilian arenas of public health, which do not, however, conform to a simplistic socialism-capitalism dichotomy. Rather, this particular South-South cooperation reveals significant differences in how powerful the postcolonial legacies of medical assistance remain in Global Health settings. This paper explores how these legacies may impact on the moral and professional legitimacy of the individuals involved in South-South partnership. Using ethnographic findings in newly established family clinics situated in urban poverty regions in Rio de Janeiro's North, we will also show how prolonged local interactions may create new spaces of horizontal encounters and connectivity in international medical cooperation.

Negotiating horizontality in medical South–South cooperation: the Cuban mission in Rio de Janeiro’s urban peripheries

For more than 50 years, Cuba has been one of the most important players in the field of international medical cooperation in the Global South. Between 2013 and 2016, Cuba maintained one of its largest cooperations with Brazil: nearly 11,400 Cuban physicians were sent to work within the framework of the Brazilian health programme ‘More-Doctors-for-Brazil’, which was implemented to improve Brazil’s precarious public health sector. This paper inquires into the manifold challenges of horizontal connectivity in this medical South–South cooperation. We will trace these back to deep-rooted contentions about the epistemological approaches to medical practice and professional recognition within and between Cuban and Brazilian arenas of public health, which do not, however, conform to a simplistic socialism–capitalism dichotomy. Rather, this particular South–South cooperation reveals significant differences in how powerful the postcolonial legacies of medical assistance remain in Global Health settings. This paper explores how these legacies may impact on the moral and professional legitimacy of the individuals involved in South–South partnership. Using ethnographic findings in newly established family clinics situated in urban poverty regions in Rio de Janeiro’s North, we will also show how prolonged local interactions may create new spaces of horizontal encounters and connectivity in international medical cooperation.

Analysis of the experience of Cuban physicians in a Brazilian metropolis in accordance with the Paideia Method. / Análise da experiência de médicos cubanos numa metrópole brasileira segundo o Método Paideia.

We had hoped that the Mais Médicos Program (More Doctors Program) would have generated several changes and reflections in each municipality in which it was deployed. In order to observe those changes, we sought to analyze the experience of Cuban physicians in the Mais Médicos program from an actor-centered perspective, based on the Paideia Method - an approach that seeks to enhance the ability of the subjects to analyze and intervene in their practice. We performed semi-structured interviews to analyze our research object that consisted in the experience of those actors included professionally in the Mais Médicos program in a metropolis with unique characteristics. In order to assess the interviews, we applied Content Analysis followed by Thematic Analysis. From the discourse of the actors, of which illustrative excerpts are transcribed in this article, we can affirm that the program's potential surpassed any initial barriers, presenting itself as fine-tuning instrument for replacing the biomedical model in line with the Paideia Method.

Análise da experiência de médicos cubanos numa metrópole brasileira segundo o Método Paideia / Analysis of the experience of Cuban physicians in a Brazilian metropolis in accordance with the Paideia Method

Resumo Esperávamos que o Programa Mais Médicos (PMM) tivesse provocado mudanças e reflexões diversas em cada município onde foi inserido. A fim de observar tais mudanças, buscamos analisar a experiência dos médicos cubanos de trabalho no PMM numa perspectiva centrada em atores, orientados pelo Método Paideia – metodologia que busca aumentar a capacidade dos sujeitos de analisar e intervir sobre a práxis. Lançamos mão de entrevistas semiestruturadas para perscrutar nosso objeto de pesquisa, que se constitui na experiência desses atores sociais inseridos profissionalmente no PMM numa metrópole com características singulares. Trabalhamos o material empírico instruídos pela Análise de Conteúdo e procedemos a Análise Temática. A partir do discurso dos sujeitos podemos dizer que as potencialidades do programa ultrapassaram barreiras iniciais, apresentando-se como uma ferramenta de tensão para a superação do modelo biomédico, em consonância com o método Paideia.

Abstract We had hoped that the Mais Médicos Program (More Doctors Program) would have generated several changes and reflections in each municipality in which it was deployed. In order to observe those changes, we sought to analyze the experience of Cuban physicians in the Mais Médicos program from an actor-centered perspective, based on the Paideia Method – an approach that seeks to enhance the ability of the subjects to analyze and intervene in their practice. We performed semi-structured interviews to analyze our research object that consisted in the experience of those actors included professionally in the Mais Médicos program in a metropolis with unique characteristics. In order to assess the interviews, we applied Content Analysis followed by Thematic Analysis. From the discourse of the actors, of which illustrative excerpts are transcribed in this article, we can affirm that the program's potential surpassed any initial barriers, presenting itself as fine-tuning instrument for replacing the biomedical model in line with the Paideia Method.