Temporal trends and metric variation in the mandibles and dentition of Australopithecus afarensis.

The Pliocene hominin samples from Hadar and Laetoli are thought to represent one species, Australopithecus afarensis, that exhibits stasis throughout its temporal range and has high levels of skeletal sexual dimorphism. In this paper, we test the hypothesis of stasis in dental and mandibular dimensions using nonparametric rank correlation methods to detect temporal trends and randomization tests to evaluate their statistical significance. We then use two methods (CV resampling; Fligner-Killeen test) to compare overall levels of variation in the fossil sample to those of extant hominoid species. Together, these analyses allow us to gauge the effects of changes through time on variation in mandibles and teeth of A. afarensis.P(3)mesiodistal length, M(3)size, and canine shape change through time but do not appear unusually variable in the sample as a whole. These temporal trends possibly reflect differences between the Laetoli and Hadar site-samples. For mandibles, a pronounced trend towards greater corpus size occurs late in the temporal sequence and contributes to high levels of variation compared to African apes. These results show that significant directional changes do occur in the A. afarensis mandibles and teeth, and in these elements, at least, the species is not static. Temporal variation is clearly an important component of overall variation in the A. afarensis lineage, even though other factors, such as sexual dimorphism, may also play a part.

The recognition and evaluation of homoplasy in primate and human evolution.

Homoplasy has been a prominent issue in primate systematics and phylogeny for as long as people have been studying human evolution. In the past, homoplasy, in the form of parallel evolution, was often considered the dominant theme in primate evolution. Today, it receives blame for difficulties in phylogenetic analysis, but is essential in the study of adaptation. This paper reviews the history of study of homoplasy, methods of defining homoplasy, and methodological and biological factors that generate homoplasy. A post hoc definition of homology and homoplasy, based on patterns of character distributions and their congruence or incongruence on a cladogram, is the most consistent method of recognizing these phenomena. Defined this way, homology and homoplasy are mutually exclusive. However, when different levels of analysis are examined, it is seen that homoplasy at one level, such as adult phenotype, often exists simultaneously with homology at a different level, such as developmental process. Thus, in some cases, patterns of homoplasy may point to underlying similarities that reflect the shared heritage of a particular clade. This is an old concept that is being renewed on the strength of recent trends in developmental biology. Factors that influence homoplasy include character definition and a host of biological factors, such as developmental constraints, allometry, and adaptation. These interact with one another to provide explanations of homoplastic patterns. Because of the repetition of events, explanations of homoplastic features are often more reliable than those for homologous features, and serve as effective tests for hypotheses of evolutionary process. In some cases, particular explanations of homoplasy lead to generalizations about the likelihood of homoplasy in a type of structure. The structure may be adaptive or highly epigenetic, or it may belong to an anatomical system considered to be more prone to homoplasy than others. However, our review shows that these generalizations are usually based on theory, and contradictory expectations can be developed under different theoretical models. More rigorous empirical studies are necessary to discover what, if any, generalizations can be made about the likelihood of homoplasy in different types of characters.

A simple index using video image analysis to predict disease outcome in primary breast cancer.

Image analysis was used to investigate the prognostic significance of immunostaining for oestrogen receptor (ER), p53 tumour-suppressor protein and tumour cell proliferation (MIB-1) in a random cohort of 200 primary breast cancer patients with between 4 and 7 years of clinical follow-up. Image measurements of the percentage of immunopositive cancer cell nuclei (% positive nuclear area) were recorded for the above tumour features for each patient. Assessment of relative risk using Cox's univariate analysis indicated that tumour size, number of cancer-involved nodes, MIB-1 and ER % positive nuclear area were significantly associated with breast cancer disease outcome, i.e., relapse-free survival and overall survival. In multivariate analysis, tumour size, number of involved nodes, ER and MIB-1 % positive nuclear area were retained as independent predictors of prognosis, depending on the image measurement cut-point used. A prognostic model, which can be used without reference to nodal involvement, was constructed for tumour size, ER cut-point of 30% positive nuclear area and MIB-1 cut-point of 10% positive nuclear area. Kaplan-Meier analysis of this image-based prognostic index identified 4 risk groups with predicted 5-year overall survival rates of 93%, 83%, 76.7% and 61.5%. We conclude that image measurements of ER and proliferative rate can be combined with tumour size to construct a prognostic index which reliably predicts disease outcome in primary breast cancer without knowledge of the nodal status of the patient.

Homoplasy and adaptation in the atelid postcranium.

Homoplasy is a ubiquitous phenomenon in phylogenetic investigations, but it is rarely investigated on its own. As a case study in the pattern and basis of homoplasy in primates, the atelid postcranium is discussed here. Characters available from Ford's ([1986] in Erwin J, Swindler DR, eds: Comparative Primate Biology I: Systematics, Evolution, and Anatomy (New York: Alan R. Liss), p 73-135; [1994] in Fleagle JG, Kay RF, eds: Anthropoid Origins (New York: Plenum Press), p 595-674) analyses of New World monkeys are mapped onto alternative phylogenetic trees for the family Atelidae to contrast patterns of character evolution and to develop explanatory hypotheses for differences in the trees. In an unrooted phylogenetic network, pitheciines do not group together because those pitheciines that routinely adopt hind limb suspensory postures (Chiropotes, Cacajao) share traits with atelines. Ford's (1986) work on phylogeny has shown that these traits are homoplastic and also identified potential synapomorphies of a clade comprised of modern pitheciins and atelines. However, following that work, congruence between studies of craniodental and molecular data suggested a still broader definition of atelids (including Callicebus and Cebupithecia), and in this case only one trait may define atelids, and several traits arise in parallel. The homoplastic characters in this phylogeny suggest that the phylogenetic signal in this set of postcranial data is overwhelmed by parallel adaptations to the use of climbing behaviors in all of Ford's atelids and suspensory postures in a more restricted set of taxa. These parallelisms probably indicate a bias of selective pressures in the South American environment, especially given the frequent, independent evolution of suspensory mammals there. This highlights the fact that homoplasy can be a dominant source of similarity in data partitions strongly influenced by a particular behavioral regime, in this case positional behavior.

A large male hominin cranium from Sterkfontein, South Africa, and the status of Australopithecus africanus.

Stw 505 is the most complete hominin cranium discovered in Sterkfontein Member 4 since Broom's excavations. It was found in situ in Member 4 breccia in 1989 and is larger, on the whole, than any other cranium from Sterkfontein that has comparable parts. Displacement due to breakage, as well as plastic deformation, has affected Stw 505 in several areas, especially the face and the vault. Diagnosticmorphology is nevertheless abundant in the specimen. In several areas-the distinct anterior pillar, the straight inferior border of the zygoma, the pattern of cresting on the naso-alveolar clivus, the basal aspect of the temporal bone-Stw 505 closely matches the morphology of specimens of Australopithecus africanus and is distinct from other hominins. Some isolated characters overlap with other groups, mainly early Homo and/or A. robustus. However, only the hypodigm of A. africanus can accommodate the entire suite of morphology.In some cases, Stw 505 introduces more variation into the Sterkfontein sample. For example, prominent superciliary eminences occupy the medial portions of the supraorbital region and flow medially into a strongly protruding glabellar mound. These characteristics are probably attributable to sexual dimorphism. In many respects, Stw 505 highlights similarities between A. africanus and early Homo. Comparison with other species suggests that males of A. africanus do not show derived features of A. robustus that are not also present in females, and that cranial differences between A. afarensis and A. africanus have, if anything, been understated.

Sexual dimorphism in the face of Australopithecus africanus.

Recently discovered crania of Australopithecus africanus from Sterkfontein Member 4 and Makapansgat enlarge the size range of the species and encourage a reappraisal of both the degree and pattern of sexual dimorphism. Resampling methodology (bootstrapping) is used here to establish that A. africanus has a greater craniofacial size range than chimpanzees or modern humans, a range which is best attributed to a moderately high degree of sexual dimorphism. Compared to other fossil hominins, this variation is similar to that of Homo habilis (sensu lato) but less than that of A. boisei. The finding of moderately high dimorphism is corroborated by a CV-based estimate and ratios between those specimens considered to be male and those considered to be female. Inferences about the pattern of craniofacial dimorphism in the A. africanus face currently rely on the relationship of morphology and size. Larger specimens, particularly Stw 505, show prominent superciliary eminences and glabellar regions, but in features related in part to canine size, such as the curvature of the infraorbital surface, large and small specimens of A. africanus are similar. In this respect, the pattern resembles that of modern humans more so than chimpanzees or lowland gorillas. A. africanus may also show novel patterns of sexual dimorphism when compared to extant hominines, such as in the form of the anterior pillar. However, males of the species do not exhibit characteristics of more derived hominins, such as A. robustus.

Interviewer predictions of applicant qualifications and interviewer validity: aggregate and individual analyses.

The relative effects of varied interviewee cues on line managers' hiring decisions were examined, as was the relative predictability of various criteria by line managers' interview impressions. Aggregate and individual regression analyses revealed that 3 nursing directors' impressions of 186 nursing applicants shaped their hiring recommendations more than did the applicants' resume credentials. Moreover, managers' interview impressions significantly predicted employees' job attitudes, though predictions of attitudes did not exceed predictions of performance. Finally, individual managers based hiring decisions on different interview impressions, and these impressions forecast employees' job attitudes with differential validity. Implications for future interviewing research are discussed.