Effect of group antenatal care versus individualized antenatal care on birth preparedness and complication readiness: a cluster randomized controlled study among pregnant women in Eastern Region of Ghana.

BACKGROUND: As utilization of individual antenatal care (I-ANC) has increased throughout sub-Saharan Africa, questions have arisen about whether individual versus group-based care might yield better outcomes. We implemented a trial of group-based antenatal care (G-ANC) to determine its impact on birth preparedness and complication readiness (BPCR) among pregnant women in Ghana. METHODS: We conducted a cluster randomized controlled trial comparing G-ANC to routine antenatal care in 14 health facilities in the Eastern Region of Ghana. We recruited women in their first trimester to participate in eight two-hour interactive group sessions throughout their pregnancies. Meetings were facilitated by midwives trained in G-ANC methods, and clinical assessments were conducted in addition to group discussions and activities. Data were collected at five timepoints, and results are presented comparing baseline (T0) to 34 weeks' gestation to 3 weeks post-delivery (T1) for danger sign recognition, an 11-point additive scale of BPCR, as well as individual items comprising the scale. RESULTS: 1285 participants completed T0 and T1 assessments (N = 668 I-ANC, N = 617, G-ANC). At T1, G-ANC participants were able to identify significantly more pregnancy danger signs than I-ANC participants (mean increase from 1.8 to 3.4 in G-ANC vs. 1.7 to 2.2 in I-ANC, p < 0.0001). Overall BPCR scores were significantly greater in the G-ANC group than the I-ANC group. The elements of BPCR that showed the greatest increases included arranging for emergency transport (I-ANC increased from 1.5 to 11.5% vs. G-ANC increasing from 2 to 41% (p < 0.0001)) and saving money for transportation (19-32% in the I-ANC group vs. 19-73% in the G-ANC group (p < 0.0001)). Identifying someone to accompany the woman to the facility rose from 1 to 3% in the I-ANC group vs. 2-20% in the G-ANC group (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: G-ANC significantly increased BPCR among women in rural Eastern Region of Ghana when compared to routine antenatal care. Given the success of this intervention, future efforts that prioritize the implementation of G-ANC are warranted. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT04033003 (25/07/2019). PROTOCOL AVAILABLE: Protocol Available at: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9508671/ .

Knowledge, Acceptance, and Uptake of Family Planning: A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial of Group Antenatal Care in Ghana.

The use of family planning (FP) methods significantly contributes to improved outcomes for mothers and their offspring. However, the use of FP remains low, particularly in low- and middle-income countries. A cluster randomized controlled clinical trial was implemented in Ghana, comparing group antenatal care (ANC) with routine care. The group ANC intervention included eight meetings where the seventh group meeting incorporated information and discussion regarding methods of FP. Data collection occurred at five time points: baseline (T0), 34 weeks' gestation (T1), 6-12 weeks post birth (T2), 5-8 months post birth, and 11-14 months post birth (T4). At T1, there was a significantly greater increase in the knowledge of FP methods as well as the intention to use FP after the birth among the intervention group. The uptake of FP was significantly higher in the intervention group for all post-birth timepoints except for T4 where the control group had significantly higher rates. The reasons for the diminishing effect are unclear. An increasing uptake of FP methods requires a multifaceted approach that includes increasing accessibility, knowledge, and acceptability as well as addressing societal and cultural norms.

Midwife-led obstetric triage to increase providers' knowledge and improve timeliness of care: A pre and posttest design.

BACKGROUND: Research in low- and middle-income countries has shown that maternal mortality is directly related to inadequate or absent obstetric (OB) triage systems. Standard triage systems and knowledge on triaging for obstetric emergencies are often absent or lacking in most healthcare systems in Liberia. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this research was to address the third delay defined as receiving adequate, quality care when a facility is reached by increasing knowledge through the establishment of a midwife-led, hospital-based OB triage system to stratify care based on risk and imminence of birth and to improve timely assessment at two district referral hospitals. METHODS: A quasi-experimental study design using a pre/post survey was employed for a midwife-led OB triage training course. Using a train-the-trainer model, five midwives were trained as champions, who in turn trained an additional 62 providers. Test results were analyzed with the R statistical software using paired sample t-test and descriptive statistics. RESULTS: Pretest results revealed a knowledge and practice gap among OB providers on key components of the standard triage package. However, post-test mean scores were significantly higher (M = 79.6, SD = 2.32) than pre-test mean scores (M = 59.0, SD = 2.30) for participants following a 2-day training (p = <0.001). DISCUSSION: Following a structured OB triage training, participants showed significant improvement in post-test OB triage scores. CONCLUSION: Standard OB triage protocols incorporated into the policies and procedures of obstetric wards have the potential to improve knowledge and practice, addressing the third delay and reducing preventable, obstetrics-related deaths.

Ghanaian women's experience of intimate partner violence (IPV) during group antenatal care: a brief report from a cluster randomised controlled trial.

Intimate partner violence (IPV) impacts women of reproductive age globally and can lead to significant negative consequences during pregnancy. This study describes an exploratory aim of a cluster randomised controlled trial designed to assess the outcomes of Group Antenatal Care (ANC) in Ghana. The purpose was to understand the effect of a healthy relationship Group ANC module on experiences of IPV and safety planning as well as to explore the relationship between self-efficacy on the experiences of IPV and safety planning. Data were collected at baseline and at 11-14 months postpartum (post). Survey measures captured reported experiences of violence, self-efficacy, and safety. The chi-square test was used to compare baseline and post scores, and a logistic regression was performed to ascertain the effects of self-efficacy on the experiences of IPV in both groups. The sample included 1,751 participants, of whom 27.9% reported IPV at baseline. Between baseline and postpartum, there was a small increase in reported emotional (6.2% vs. 4.6%) and sexual (5.4% vs. 3.2%) violence in the intervention group compared to the control group. Logistic regression demonstrated that an increasing self-efficacy score was associated with an increased likelihood of experiencing IPV. There were no changes in safety knowledge. This study found higher rates of reported sexual and emotional violence post-intervention among the intervention group. Group ANC may be just one part of a portfolio of interventions needed to address IPV at all socio-ecological levels.Paper ContextMain findings: There was no reduction in experiences of intimate partner violence or increases in safety planning among Ghanaian pregnant women participating in a Group Antenatal Care session focused on healthy relationships and safety planning.Added knowledge: Group Antenatal Care has been identified as an effective modality for providing antenatal care and facilitating conversations about sensitive topics such as intimate partner violence and safety. However, this study highlights the importance of developing multifaceted approaches to decrease the risk of intimate partner violence among women, especially during the critical times of pregnancy and postpartum.Global health impact for policy and action: Effective global health action and policy must extend beyond educational efforts, incorporating multifaceted strategies that include healthcare provider training, robust community engagement, and legislation aimed at preventing intimate partner violence, with a special focus on safeguarding the well-being of women during pregnancy and the postpartum period.

Facilitators and barriers to home blood pressure monitoring among pregnant women in Ghana: a mixed-methods analysis of patient perspectives.

BACKGROUND: The benefit of home blood pressure monitoring during pregnancy and in low-resource settings is incompletely understood. The objective of this study was to explore the experiences, barriers, and facilitators of home blood pressure monitoring among pregnant women in Ghana. METHODS: This concurrent triangulation mixed-methods study was conducted at an urban tertiary hospital in Ghana. Participants were recruited from adult pregnant women presenting for routine antenatal care. Upon enrollment, participants' demographics and history were collected. At the next study visit, participants received audiovisual and hands-on training on using an automatic blood pressure monitor; they then monitored and logged their blood pressure daily at home for 2-4 weeks. At the final study visit, verbally administered surveys and semi-structured interviews assessed participant's experiences. Quantitative data were analyzed using R version 4.2.2, and frequencies and descriptive statistics were calculated. Qualitative data were imported into DeDoose 9.0.78 for thematic analysis. RESULTS: Of 235 enrolled participants, 194 completed surveys; of those, 33 completed in-depth interviews. Participants' mean age was 31.6 (SD 5.3) years, 32.1% had not previously given birth, and 31.1% had less than a senior high school education. On a 4-point Likert scale, the majority reported they "definitely" were able to remember (n = 134, 69.1%), could find the time (n = 124, 63.9%), had the energy (n = 157, 80.9%), could use the blood pressure monitor without problems (n = 155, 79.9%), and had family approval (n = 182, 96.3%) while engaging in home blood pressure monitoring. 95.88% (n = 186) believed that pregnant women in Ghana should monitor their blood pressure at home. Qualitative thematic analysis demonstrated that most participants liked home blood pressure monitoring because of increased knowledge of their health during pregnancy. While most participants found measuring their blood pressure at home doable, many faced challenges. Participants' experiences with five key factors influenced how easy or difficult their experience was: 1) Time, stress, and daily responsibilities; 2) Perceived importance of BP in pregnancy; 3) Role of family; 4) Capability of performing monitoring; 5) Convenience of monitoring. CONCLUSIONS: Among pregnant women in urban Ghana, home blood pressure monitoring was perceived as positive, important, and doable; however, challenges must be addressed.

Improving health literacy through group antenatal care: results from a cluster randomized controlled trial in Ghana.

BACKGROUND: Although the majority of Ghanaian women receive antenatal care (ANC), many exhibit low health literacy by misinterpreting and incorrectly operationalizing ANC messages, leading to poor maternal and newborn health outcomes. Prior research in low-resource settings has found group antenatal care (G-ANC) feasible for women and providers. This study aims to determine the effect of G-ANC on increasing maternal health literacy. We hypothesized that pregnant women randomized into G-ANC would exhibit a greater increase in maternal health literacy than women in routine, individual ANC. METHODS: A 5-year cluster randomized controlled trial was conducted in 14 rural and peri-urban health facilities in the Eastern Region of Ghana. Facilities were paired based on patient volume and average gestational age at ANC enrollment and then randomized into intervention (G-ANC) vs. control (routine, individual ANC); 1761 pregnant women were recruited. Data collection occurred at baseline (T0) and post-birth (T2) using the Maternal Health Literacy scale, a 12-item composite scale to assess maternal health literacy. Logistic regression compared changes in health literacy from T0 to T2. RESULTS: Overall, women in both the intervention and control groups improved their health literacy scores over time (p < 0.0001). Women in the intervention group scored significantly higher on 3 individual items and on overall composite scores (p < 0.0001) and were more likely to attend 8 or more ANC visits. CONCLUSION: While health literacy scores improved for all women attending ANC, women randomized into G-ANC exhibited greater improvement in overall health literacy post-birth compared to those receiving routine individual care. Life-saving information provided during ANC must be presented in an understandable format to prevent women and newborns from dying of preventable causes. TRIAL REGISTRY: Ethical approval for the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Boards of the University of Michigan (HUM#00161464) and the Ghana Health Service (GHS-ERC: 016/04/19).

The use of a mobile obstetric emergency system to improve obstetric referrals in Bong County, Liberia: A pre-post study.

OBJECTIVE: Liberia experiences an unmet need for cesarean section with about 5% population coverage, lower than 9%-19% coverage associated with improved maternal and newborn outcomes. Delays in the referral process for comprehensive emergency obstetric and newborn care (CEmONC) services due to ineffective communication between a rural health facility (RHF) and a district hospital contribute to the low CS rate. This study examined the association between mobile obstetric emergency system (MORES) implementation and referral time for obstetric emergencies as well as maternal/newborn outcomes. METHODS: A pre-post descriptive analysis was conducted on data collected from 20 rural health facilities (RHFs) and two hospitals in Bong County. Women with referral data from both RHFs and hospitals were matched and information including transfer time, reasons for referral, and maternal and newborn outcomes were extracted. Descriptive analysis and logistic regression models examined the relationship between the intervention's implementation and mode of delivery, maternal outcome, newborn outcome, and transfer time from RHF to district hospital. Ethics approval was obtained from two study centers. RESULTS: Women had higher odds of undergoing a CS at endline (OR: 1.86 95% CI: 0.99-3.46) compared to baseline. Additionally, newborns had lower odds of showing non-vigorous symptoms (OR: 0.31; 95% CI: 0.14-0.68), defined as a newborn with poor respiratory effort, muscle tone, or heart rate. There was no significant association between the intervention's implementation and transfer time. CONCLUSION: The MORES intervention is a promising means to increase timely care seeking along the referral pathway which may enhance access to cesarean section as well as improved newborn outcome in low- and middle-income countries.

Ability and accuracy of patient-performed blood pressure monitoring among pregnant women in urban Ghana.

BACKGROUND: Patient-performed blood pressure monitoring in pregnancy is rarely performed in low- and middle-income country settings, including Ghana. The clinical efficacy of home blood pressure monitoring relies on a pregnant patient being able to independently execute the correct steps to position and use a blood pressure monitor and to achieve accurate blood pressure measurements. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to (1) assess whether pregnant women can correctly use an automatic blood pressure monitor to check their blood pressure before and after a brief training and (2) determine whether blood pressure values measured by pregnant women using an automatic monitor are similar to values measured by a healthcare provider using a standard clinic monitor. STUDY DESIGN: This was a cross-sectional study conducted at the Korle Bu Teaching Hospital, a tertiary hospital in Accra, Ghana. Participants were adult pregnant women presenting for their first prenatal care visit. Data collection was performed by 2 Ghanaian physicians. Information on demographics, obstetrical history, and past medical history was collected. A brief training was provided on the correct use of the blood pressure monitor, including a verbal script, annotated photographs, and a hands-on demonstration. Pre- and posttraining assessments using a 9-item checklist of correct preparation, position, and use of an automatic blood pressure monitor were performed. Following a modified British Hypertension Society protocol, a series of 4 blood pressure measurements were taken, alternating between provider performed using a clinic monitor and patient performed using an automatic monitor intended for individual use and validated in pregnancy. RESULTS: Among 176 participants, the mean age was 31.5 years (±5.6), and 130 (73.9%) were multiparous. Regarding socioeconomic characteristics, 128 (72.7%) were married, 171 (97.2%) had public insurance, and 87 (49.7%) had completed ≤9 years of formal education. Regarding clinical blood pressure issues, 19 (10.9%) had a history of a hypertensive disorder in a previous pregnancy, and 6 (3.4%) had chronic hypertension. Before receiving any training, 21 participants (12.1%) performed all 9 steps correctly to prepare, position, and use the automatic blood pressure monitor. Comparing pretraining vs posttraining ability, statistically significant increases were seen in the correct performance of each step and the mean number of steps performed correctly (6.1±1.8 vs 9.0±0.2, respectively; P<.001) and proportion performing all 9 steps correctly (12.1% vs 96.6%, respectively; P<.001). The mean difference between doctor-performed and patient-performed blood pressure measurements was 5.6±4.8 mm Hg for systolic blood pressure values and 3.4±3.08 mm Hg for diastolic blood pressure values, with most differences within 5 mm Hg for both systolic blood pressure values (102/176 [58.0%]) and diastolic blood pressure values (141/176 [80.1%]). CONCLUSION: After a brief training, pregnant women in Ghana demonstrated that they are able to use an automatic blood pressure monitor to check their blood pressure correctly and accurately.

Acceptability of a Whatsapp Triage, Referral, and Transfer System for Obstetric Patients in Rural Liberia.

Background: Maternal mortality continues to disproportionately affect low- and middle-income countries, including Liberia. Though the relationship between obstetric triage systems and improved maternal outcomes is well documented, standardized triage protocols are lacking in rural Liberia. Mobile health interventions are a promising method to triage obstetric patients. Objectives: This study explores the acceptability of a WhatsApp Triage, Referral, and Transfer (WAT-RT) system among Liberian midwives and community health assistants. Methods: Individual interviews and focus group discussions were conducted among midwives (n = 18) and community health assistants (n = 112). Interviews were designed to understand the current referral system in rural Liberia, how a WAT-RT System can address referral limitations, and the acceptability of the WAT-RT System. Data were audio recorded, transcribed, and translated into English. Data analysis was conducted via NVivo12 with independent and cooperative techniques among multiple researchers. Findings: The current referral system is not standardized with limitations including a lack of triage protocols, transportation difficulties, and inconsistent communication of patient information, which could be addressed by a WAT-RT System. The acceptability for the WAT-RT System was high. Facilitators to implementation included utilizing a pre-existing communication and referral infrastructure, access and competency surrounding mobile phones, and increased opportunities for training and inter-provider collaboration. Barriers included disproportionate phone access between midwives and community health assistants, network reliability, and a lack of data standards. Recommendations for successful implementation included centralizing phone financing and standardizing triage protocols. Conclusions: The WAT-RT System demonstrated high acceptability among frontline health care providers in rural Liberia. Barriers to program success could be reasonably addressed with simple interventions and planning. Multiple benefits included addressing care delays for obstetric patients, promoting bidirectional provider communication, and increasing the quality of obstetric triage. Future studies should focus on piloting the WAT-RT System among this population and recruiting other key stakeholders to determine intervention feasibility.

Charge midwives' awareness of and their role in promoting respectful maternity care at a tertiary health facility in Ghana: A qualitative study.

BACKGROUND: Evidence suggests that the implementation of respectful maternity care (RMC) interventions is one of the surest and most effective means of minimising mistreatment during intrapartum care services. However, to ensure the successful implementation of RMC interventions, maternity care providers would have to be aware of RMC, its relevance, and their role in promoting RMC. We explored the awareness and role of charge midwives in promoting RMC at a tertiary health facility in Ghana. METHODS: The study adopted an exploratory descriptive qualitative study design. We conducted nine interviews with charge midwives. All audio data were transcribed verbatim and exported to NVivo-12 for data management and analyses. RESULTS: The study revealed that charge midwives are aware of RMC. Specifically, ward-in-charges perceived RMC as consisting of showing dignity, respect, and privacy, as well as providing women-centred care. Our findings showed that the roles of ward-in-charges included training midwives on RMC and leading by example, showing empathy and establishing friendly relationships with clients, receiving and addressing clients' concerns, and monitoring and supervising midwives. CONCLUSION: We conclude that charge midwives have an important role to play in promoting RMC, which transcends simply providing maternity care. Policymakers and healthcare managers should ensure that charge midwives receive adequate and regular training on RMC. This training should be comprehensive, covering aspects such as effective communication, privacy and confidentiality, informed consent, and women-centred care. The study also underscores a need for policymakers and health facility managers to prioritise the provision of resources and support for the implementation of RMC policies and guidelines in all healthcare facilities. This will ensure that healthcare providers have the necessary tools and resources to provide RMC to clients.