Completing the audit cycle improves surgical standards in lung cancer. Why do some patients still not receive the best care?

INTRODUCTION: Intraoperative gold standards in the management of lung cancer include performing anatomical resection and mediastinal lymphadenectomy). Our aim was to measure improvement in quality of surgery by reauditing anatomical resection and lymph node excision in patients undergoing lung cancer surgery as per gold standards. METHODS: A complete audit cycle was performed-an initial retrospective analysis of 100 consecutive patients with primary lung cancer operated on by a single surgeon (July 2009-October 2010), followed by a prospective reaudit of 102 patients (November 2010-October 2011). Clinical and pathological data were collected from clinical notes, surgical database, and histopathology reports. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to identify further areas of potential improvement. RESULTS: The number of nonanatomical resections dropped from 12% to 6% (p = not significant). The rate of performing excision of at least 1, 2, and 3 mediastinal (N2) lymph node stations improved from 86% to 91%, 63% to 77%, and 40% to 63%, respectively (p = 0.003). On multivariate analysis, failure to perform anatomical resection was related to use of video assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) techniques, previous malignancy, and high-predicted surgical risk by European Society Objective Score .01. Less complete intraoperative lymph node excision was associated with cases performed by VATS and in octogenarians. CONCLUSIONS: There is continued adherence to the guidelines, when considering cases in terms of anatomical resections, and marked improvement in complying with the gold standards for lymph node excision. The use of the audit tool has contributed to improved quality of surgical care in patients operated for lung cancer.

The left thoracotomy approach for excision of distal tracheal carcinoma in the presence of right-sided aorta.

Tracheal primary carcinoma is a rare malignancy, and we believe that its presence in a patient with a right-sided aorta has not been described before. We report a case of a primary tracheal squamous carcinoma in a patient with a four-branched right-sided aortic arch. The patient underwent a tracheal resection approached by a left thoracotomy. The surgical exposure was excellent once the ligamentum arteriosum had been divided. All the aortic arch branches and the phrenic, vagus and recurrent laryngeal nerves were identified and preserved.

Initial experience with the use of biological implants for soft tissue and chest wall reconstruction in thoracic surgery.

BACKGROUND: Synthetic materials have traditionally been used for tissue reconstruction in thoracic surgery. New biomaterials have been tested in other areas of surgery with good results. The aim of our study is to evaluate our initial experience using prostheses in extended thoracic surgery. METHODS: A review was performed of all patients who underwent extended surgical procedures requiring soft tissue reconstruction with bioprosthetic materials after thoracic surgery from August 2009 to August 2011. A total of 44 consecutive patients were included. Operations involved radical pleurectomy and decortication for mesothelioma (n = 29), extended operations for thoracic malignancies (n = 8), surgery for trauma or perforated organs or complications (n = 6), and for benign infectious causes (n = 1). RESULTS: A total of 76 patches were used in 44 patients (median of 2; range 1 to 3 per patient). Median hospital stay was 13 (range 5 to 149) days. Three patients died during the postoperative period (6.8%); pulmonary embolism 5 days after intrapericardial pneumonectomy with chest wall reconstruction, fatal pneumonia 26 days after radical pleurectomy and decortication for mesothelioma, and bronchopleural fistula 11 days after pneumonectomy with diaphragm and atrium excision for lung cancer after initial chemoradiotherapy. No other surgical exploration or removal of patches has been required for infection. CONCLUSIONS: Our initial experience of using bioprosthetic patches for soft tissue reconstruction in thoracic surgery has proven satisfactory with overall acceptable results. The infection rates are low even when a proportion of procedures were performed under contaminated environments. Biologic prosthesis should be part of the surgical options to reconstruct soft tissues in thoracic surgery.

Accuracy of two scoring systems for risk stratification in thoracic surgery.

We investigate the suitability of the two existing risk stratification systems available for predicting mortality in a cohort of patients undergoing lung resection under a single surgeon. Data from the 290 consecutive patients who underwent pulmonary resection between January 2008 and January 2011 were extracted from a prospective clinical data base. In-hospital mortality risk scores are calculated for every patient by using Thoracoscore and ESOS.01 and were compared with actual in-hospital mortality. The receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve was used to establish how well the systems rank for predicting patient mortality. Actual in-hospital mortality was 3.1% (n = 9). Thoracoscore and ESOS values (mean ± SEM) were 4.93 ± 0.32 and 4.08 ± 0.41, respectively. The area under the ROC curve values for ESOS and Thoracoscore were 0.8 and 0.6, respectively. ESOS was reasonably accurate at predicting the overall mortality (sensitivity 88% and specificity 67%), whereas Thoracoscore was a weaker predictor of mortality (sensitivity 67% and specificity 53%). The ESOS score had better predictive values in our patient population and might be easier to calculate. Because of their low specificity, the use of these scores should be limited to the assessment of outcomes of surgical cohorts, but they are not designed to predict risks for individual patients.

Fast-track video-assisted bullectomy and pleurectomy for pneumothorax: initial experience and description of technique.

OBJECTIVE: Pleurectomy+/-bullectomy by video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) is an established surgical procedure for pneumothorax. Early ambulation and discharge should be a reasonable goal. This study explores the feasibility of day-case surgery and identifies the obstacles requiring further work to facilitate day-case pneumothorax surgery. METHODS: Between June 2007 and May 2008, 16 consecutive patients underwent video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery bullectomy+/-pleurectomy (under the care of a single surgeon) with immediate connection to an ambulatory drainage system in the theatre following surgery. Analgesia comprised temporary paravertebral with early conversion to oral opiate+/-paracetamol. There were 13 males (81%), average age 23 (range: 17-29) years, and three females (19%), average age 35 (range: 22-46) years. Twelve patients (75%) had left-sided disease, of which nine (56%) underwent elective surgery. All patients had previously suffered at least one primary spontaneous pneumothorax. Patients with probable secondary pneumothorax were excluded from the study. Length of stay (LOS) was compared with a control group of patients conventionally treated prior to the study. RESULTS: In 13 patients (81%), early discharge was achieved 1 (range: 1-2 days) day post-op, whilst connected to an ambulatory drainage system. In three patients, early discharge was not achieved. One of these patients had the chest drain removed prematurely and remained an inpatient for 3 days with aspiration and observation for a small pneumothorax. The two remaining patients required extended inpatient admissions due to postoperative non-surgical complications. In the 13 patients discharged immediately, the time to drain removal (in clinic) was electively 7 days (range: 2-11 days). Two patients required re-admission: one for contralateral spontaneous pneumothorax and another for an ipsilateral basal pneumothorax treated with a drain. CONCLUSION: We have shown early discharge with ongoing ambulatory drainage following VATS pleurectomy+/-bullectomy in patients with primary pneumothorax to be feasible with paravertebral in the theatre and rapid conversion to oral analgesia. Patients managed intercostal drains at home. Limiting factors such as postoperative nausea and pain control usually can be sufficiently managed in the outpatient. Shorter stays may have a beneficial financial result. Long-term follow-up and a quantification of the patients experience is warranted.