Adjuvant radiation after modified radical mastectomy for breast cancer fails to prolong survival.

Recent literature has reported improved local disease control and overall survival in premenopausal node-positive (stage II, and III) breast cancer patients undergoing modified radical mastectomy (MRM) using radiation therapy (RT) combined with chemotherapy. To assess the efficacy of postoperative RT in our own community, we analyzed all patients undergoing MRM for carcinoma utilizing an extensive database from the three major teaching hospitals in Tulsa, OK, between 1965 and 1993. A total of 5257 patients underwent MRM during this time period. One hundred thirty-seven patients were excluded for insufficient data or because they were found to be at stage IV, leaving a total study population of 5125. Overall survival (OS), overall mean survival (MS), disease-free survival (DFS), and locoregional DFS (LRDFS) were analyzed for all patients and were further analyzed according to stage, lymph node involvement, and menopausal status. Median follow-up was 103 months. Statistical analysis was performed using Kaplan-Meier and t-tests. The DFS at 10 years was 65 per cent in the RT group and 80 per cent in the patients who did not receive RT (P = 0.00). No improved DFS was obtained in the radiation-treated patients, regardless of stage, lymph node involvement, or menopausal status. Similarly, the LRDFS at 10 years was 91 per cent in the RT group and 96 per cent in the patients who did not receive RT (P = 0.00). No improved LRDFS was obtained in the radiation-treated patients, regardless of stage, lymph node involvement, or menopausal status. The overall MS was 97 months in the RT group and 104 months in the patients who did not receive RT (P = 0.00). Comparisons of overall MS rates revealed apparent survival benefits from RT in the premenopausal node-negative group, postmenopausal one to four-positive-node group, and all stage I patients. This apparent survival advantage was not confirmed by Kaplan-Meier curves of OS. No other overall MS differences were detected according to stage, lymph node, or menopausal status. Using Kaplan-Meier survival curves, the OS in the RT group at 10 years was 46 per cent, and 63 per cent in the patients who did not receive RT (P = 0.00). No improved OS was obtained in the radiation-treated patients, regardless of stage, lymph node involvement, or menopausal status. These findings from a large breast cancer database failed to demonstrate any meaningful benefit from RT after MRM and serve to further question the efficacy of this treatment modality in postmastectomy breast cancer patients.

Phyllodes tumors of the breast: a review of 32 cases.

Most general surgeons involved in breast cancer care have limited experience with phyllodes tumors. We analyzed a comprehensive database incorporating 8567 breast cancer cases treated surgically in the Tulsa, Oklahoma, region between 1969 and 1993. This yielded 32 cases of phyllodes tumors (0.37%) in 31 patients. The median age was 57 years (range, 18-91). There were 9 low-grade (28%), 2 intermediate-grade (6%), and 21 high-grade (66%) lesions. Size distribution consisted of 23 (72%) lesions 5 cm or less and 9 (28%) greater than 5 cm (mean, 3; range, 1.2-17.5 cm). Of 137 resected nodes in 13 patients, none were positive for metastatic disease. Surgical management consisted of wide excision or mastectomy. No patients received adjuvant chemoradiation therapy. The disease-free, locoregional disease-free, and overall mean survival rates were 80, 81, and 97 months, respectively. Ten-year disease-free survival (DFS), locoregional disease-free survival (LRDFS), and overall survival (OS) rates were 66, 72, and 55 per cent, respectively. Although there was a tendency toward a higher rate of locoregional recurrences and metastases with high-grade lesions, this was not statistically significant and did not affect DFS, LRDFS, or OS rates. Similarly, size of lesion did not affect DFS, LRDFS, or OS rates. Three patients (9.6%) had metastatic disease at presentation, and a further two (6.4%) developed metastases during follow-up. Overall, nine (28.1%) recurrences developed in eight patients, seven locoregional and two distant. Four patients (12.9%) died with evidence of disease. These findings indicate prolonged survival in this patient population with cystosarcoma phyllodes. Wide local excision of primary and recurrent lesions remains the mainstay of therapy. Neither regional lymph node dissection nor adjuvant chemoradiation adds significant benefit.

Melanoma vaccines as a therapeutic option.

BACKGROUND: In 1998, 41,600 new cases of melanoma with 7,300 deaths were expected. Worldwide, the incidence has risen 5% a year against a backdrop of generally decreasing cancer trends. Later stages of melanoma carry a severe prognosis. The need for newer, more effective therapeutic strategies for cancer is obvious. For melanoma, early diagnosis and surgical treatment are the only options that are currently curative. Chemotherapy and radiation therapy are of limited efficacy. METHODS: We reviewed the various forms of immunotherapy, concentrating on vaccine therapy. We then reviewed the history of our own vaccine in the context of the field of immunotherapy, and compared efficacy, immune response, production methods, and survival. RESULTS: Survival is improved among recipients of melanoma vaccine when compared with patients receiving conventional therapy. CONCLUSIONS: Imnmunotherapy in the form of melanoma vaccines is better than conventional therapy and is trending toward purer antigenic preparations.

Comparison of melanoma antigens in whole tumor vaccine to those from IIB-MEL-J cells.

Immunotherapy for melanoma shows promise. Our previous whole tumor (WT) vaccine was noted to have positive clinical effects. We have now developed a new, safer melanoma vaccine that is derived from IIB-MEL-J tissue culture (TC) cells. In this study, we compare by Western blot analyses the antigens in the WT vaccine to antigens in the TC vaccine. Sera from 12 WT vaccine recipients, 8 melanoma patients who received no immunotherapy, and 8 controls served as a source of antibodies to investigate potential antigens in the vaccines. Three major antigenic peptides with approximate molecular weighs of 46, 40, and 36 kDA were present in both vaccines, while two other antigenic peptides with approximate molecular weighs of 68 and 48 kDA were present only in the TC vaccine. The reaction was similar between the patients who received the WT vaccine and those who did not receive the vaccine. Some of the individuals who did not have melanoma showed some reaction, but not to the extent of the melanoma patients. The intensity of immunostaining was greater for the TC vaccine when compared to the WT vaccine, indicating that these proteins are in a higher concentration in the TC vaccine. This new vaccine from IIB-MEL-J tissue culture cells provides a higher yield and a much more consistent source of potentially clinically relevant antigens without risk of infection or contamination by other irrelevant materials.

Longitudinal cholecystectomy study: patterns of care in a total community experience.

The purpose of this study was to determine outcomes and safety of laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) versus open cholecystectomy (OC) in a community setting at multiple open staff hospitals with multiple surgeons. This second-year study retrospectively examined all cholecystectomy records in one city at each of five hospitals over a 1-year period beginning in April 1991 through March 1992. All charts were examined for type of surgery, rate of conversion to open procedure, sex, weight, previous abdominal surgery, surgeon, hospital, preoperative workup, operative time, antibiotic prophylaxis, cholangiograms, concurrent procedures, drains, hospital stay, common duct stones and their follow-up, pathology, reoperations, complications, and mortality. One thousand eight hundred one gallbladders were removed. One thousand three hundred four (72.4%) were successfully removed at LC. One hundred eighty-three (10.2%) others were attempted laparoscopically and converted to open cholecystectomy (CC), which represented 12.3% of the attempted LCs. Three hundred fourteen (17.4%) were removed via a standard OC. The mean operative times were 72.3 minutes for LC, 100.1 minutes for CC, and 86.2 minutes for OC. Cholangiography was attempted in 916 (70.3%) LCs, 144 (78.7%) CCs, and 250 (79.6%) OCs, with similar operative times, except in LC, when done via the GB, operative time was 65.2 versus 73.4 minutes when done via the cystic duct. Diagnosis of acute cholecystitis occurred in 306 (23.5%) LCs, 119 (65.0%) CCs, and 145 (46.2%) OCs. Complications requiring reoperation occurred in 30 (2.3%) LCs, 5 (2.7%) CCs, and 5 (1.6%) OCs. Common bile duct (CBD) injuries occurred in 5 (34%) LCs, with 4 converted to CC and 1 repaired 5 days later. Trocar site hernias occurred in 11 (0.8%) LCs. Thirty-nine surgeons participated in the study with mean numbers of 33.4 LC cases, 5.5 CC cases, and 7.2 OC cases, with ranges of 1 to 165 LC cases, 1 to 17 CC cases, and 1 to 24 OC cases. Death occurred in 12 (0.9%) LC cases, 4 (2.2%) CC cases, and 25 (8.0%) OC cases. The mean hospital stay was 39.6 hours for LC, 156.5 hours for CC, and 198.3 hours for OC.

Laparoscopic cholecystectomy: an initial community experience.

The initial 950 consecutive laparoscopic cholecystectomies performed in one city at four hospitals by 30 general surgeons are reported, covering a period from April 4, 1990 to April 3, 1991. There were two operative deaths (0.2%), three common bile duct lacerations (0.3%), two subhepatic abscesses, two bowel perforations, and three bile leaks, two requiring laparotomy. Seven episodes of bleeding occurred, of which five required laparotomy, but none involved a major vessel. Sixty-five procedures were converted to open (6.7%). The mean operative time was 85.4 min. Intraoperative cholangiography was adequately completed in 49.8% and not attempted in 30.3%. Thirteen patients (2.7%) were found to have common duct stones. The pathologic diagnoses were chronic cholecystitis in 784 patients (82.5%), acute cholecystitis in 145 (15.3%), and cancer of the gallbladder in one (0.1%). Hospital stays ranged from 4 h to 31 days (mean 49.5 h). This procedure can be learned and performed safely in a community setting.

Melanoma tumor vaccine: five-year follow-up.

For many years, various melanoma vaccines have been employed. This is a unique melanoma vaccine in that it is a subcellular tumor homogenate and no adjuvants have been added. This vaccine has been given to 129 stage I and 61 stage II melanoma patients. All were followed at least 5 years and had 87.5% and 63.9% 5-year survival rates, respectively. Sixty-four stage I males and 65 stage I females had 84% and 90% 5-year survival rates, respectively. We saw no difference between those with or without lymph node dissection. Thirty-six stage II males and 25 stage II females had 66.7% and 60% 5-year survival rates, respectively. Of stage II patients, 23 had only one positive node, 22 had two to four positive nodes, and 9 had five or more positive nodes with 69%, 63%, and 55% 5-year survival rates, respectively. Large published series were used as historical controls [6,27,28], and significant differences were noted when compared to our stage II patients (P = 0.001)--those with two to four positive nodes (P = 0.03), and those with five or more positive nodes (P = 0.04). We conclude that there is a significant increase in survival for these stage II patients, at high risk of recurrence, receiving a tumor homogenate vaccine. This vaccine warrants further analysis, development, and use in a phase III randomized clinical trial.