Failure of molecular dynamics to provide appropriate structures for quantum mechanical description of the aqueous chloride ion charge-transfer-to-solvent ultraviolet spectrum.

The lowest band in the charge-transfer-to-solvent ultraviolet absorption spectrum of aqueous chloride ion is studied by experiment and computation. Interestingly, the experiments indicate that at concentrations up to at least 0.25 M, where calculations indicate ion pairing to be significant, there is no notable effect of ionic strength on the spectrum. The experimental spectra are fitted to aid comparison with computations. Classical molecular dynamic simulations are carried out on dilute aqueous Cl-, Na+, and NaCl, producing radial distribution functions in reasonable agreement with experiment and, for NaCl, clear evidence of ion pairing. Clusters are extracted from the simulations for quantum mechanical excited state calculations. Accurate ab initio coupled-cluster benchmark calculations on a small number of representative clusters are carried out and used to identify and validate an efficient protocol based on time-dependent density functional theory. The latter is used to carry out quantum mechanical calculations on thousands of clusters. The resulting computed spectrum is in excellent agreement with experiment for the peak position, with little influence from ion pairing, but is in qualitative disagreement on the width, being only about half as wide. It is concluded that simulation by classical molecular dynamics fails to provide an adequate variety of structures to explain the experimental CTTS spectrum of aqueous Cl-.

Ultraviolet spectroscopy of pressurized and supercritical carbon dioxide.

Carbon dioxide (CO2) is prevalent in planetary atmospheres and sees use in a variety of industrial applications. Despite its ubiquitous nature, its photochemistry remains poorly understood. In this work we explore the density dependence of pressurized and supercritical CO2 electronic absorption spectra by vacuum ultraviolet spectroscopy over the wavelength range 1455-2000 Å. We show that the lowest absorption band transition energy is unaffected by a density increase up to and beyond the thermodynamic critical point (137 bar, 308 K). However, the diffuse vibrational structure inherent to the spectrum gradually decreases in magnitude. This effect cannot be explained solely by collisional broadening and/or dimerization. We suggest that at high densities close proximity of neighboring CO2 molecules with a variety of orientations perturbs the multiple monomer electronic state potential energy surfaces, facilitating coupling between binding and dissociative states. We estimate a critical radius of ~4.1 Å necessary to cause such perturbations.

Ultraviolet charge-transfer-to-solvent spectroscopy of halide and hydroxide ions in subcritical and supercritical water.

The temperature dependence of the vacuum ultraviolet charge-transfer-to-solvent (CTTS) absorption spectra of aqueous halide and hydroxide ions was measured for the first time up to 380 °C in subcritical and supercritical water. With increasing temperature, absorption spectra are observed to broaden and redshift, much in agreement with previous measurements below 100 °C. These changes are discussed alongside classic cavity models of the solvated species, which tie in the configuration of the adjoining polarized medium and its critical role in light absorption for electronic transitions. The data seemingly confirm the validity of the "diffuse" model pioneered by Platzman and Franck and later revised by Stein and Treinin, which has largely gone untested for nearly 60 years due to lack of experimental data in this extended temperature range. A gradual increase in anion cavity size is inferred as a function of increasing temperature while the enthalpy and entropy of hydration are largely unaffected. The changes in solvation properties are considered in the context of recent studies of the ultraviolet spectroscopy of subcritical and supercritical water and historic studies of the CTTS absorption. The "diffuse" polarizable continuum model succeeds in describing the absorption due to lack of well-defined ion hydration shells for these ions. CTTS spectra for iodide in supercritical water show no energy shift as a function of pressure/density, suggesting dielectric saturation of the I- anion by the adjacent H2O molecules at all experimental pressures/densities.

Vacuum ultraviolet spectroscopy of the lowest-lying electronic state in subcritical and supercritical water.

The nature and extent of hydrogen bonding in water has been scrutinized for decades, including how it manifests in optical properties. Here we report vacuum ultraviolet absorption spectra for the lowest-lying electronic state of subcritical and supercritical water. For subcritical water, the spectrum redshifts considerably with increasing temperature, demonstrating the gradual breakdown of the hydrogen-bond network. Tuning the density at 381 °C gives insight into the extent of hydrogen bonding in supercritical water. The known gas-phase spectrum, including its vibronic structure, is duplicated in the low-density limit. With increasing density, the spectrum blueshifts and the vibronic structure is quenched as the water monomer becomes electronically perturbed. Fits to the supercritical water spectra demonstrate consistency with dimer/trimer fractions calculated from the water virial equation of state and equilibrium constants. Using the known water dimer interaction potential, we estimate the critical distance between molecules (ca. 4.5 Å) needed to explain the vibronic structure quenching.

The AHA Moment: Assessment of the Redox Stability of Ionic Liquids Based on Aromatic Heterocyclic Anions (AHAs) for Nuclear Separations and Electric Energy Storage.

Because of their extended conjugated bond network, aromatic compounds generally have higher redox stability than less saturated compounds. We conjectured that ionic liquids (ILs) consisting of aromatic heterocyclic anions (AHAs) may exhibit improved radiation and electrochemical stability. Such properties are important in applications of these ILs as diluents in radionuclide separations and electrolytes in the electric energy storage devices. In this study, we systematically examine the redox chemistry of the AHAs. Three classes of these anions have been studied: (i) simple 5-atom ring AHAs, such as the pyrazolide and triazolides, (ii) AHAs containing an adjacent benzene ring, and (iii) AHAs containing electron-withdrawing groups that were introduced to reduce their basicity and interaction with metal ions. It is shown that fragmentation in the reduced and oxidized states of these AHAs does not generally occur, and the two main products, respectively, are the H atom adduct and the imidyl radical. The latter species occurs either as an N σ-radical or as an N π-radical, depending on the length of the N-N bond, and the state that is stabilized in the solid matrix is frequently different from that having the lowest energy in the gas phase. In some instances, the formation of the sandwich π-stack dimer radical anions has been observed. For trifluoromethylated anions, H adduct formation did not occur; instead, there was facile loss of fluoride from their fluorinated groups. The latter can be problematic in nuclear separations, but beneficial in batteries. Overall, our study suggests that AHA-based ILs are viable candidates for use as radiation-exposed diluents and electrolytes.

Design of an ultrashort optical transmission cell for vacuum ultraviolet spectroscopy of supercritical fluids.

We present the design and characteristics of an ultrathin flow cell optimized for vacuum ultraviolet transmission spectroscopy experiments on supercritical fluids. The cell operates satisfactorily at pressures up to 300 bar and temperatures up to 390 °C. The variable path length concept of the cell allows for optical transmission studies of analytes ranging from dense condensed-phase systems to gas-phase systems. The path length of the cell can be adjusted from hundreds of nanometers to hundreds of micrometers by an exchange of a variable thickness spacer sandwiched between two sapphire windows. In the path length range from nanometers to single micrometers, metal vapor deposited on one or both of the two sandwiched optical windows constitute the spacer. Spacers with thicknesses of 2 µm and greater can be constructed from simple commercially available metal foils. The cell has been used to measure the lowest-lying absorption band of water in both the vapor and condensed phases from room temperature up to and above the critical point. It has also found application in the studies of aqueous ions and nonaqueous liquids including various common organic solvents and carbon dioxide.

Radiation stability of cations in ionic liquids. 5. Task-specific ionic liquids consisting of biocompatible cations and the puzzle of radiation hypersensitivity.

In 1953, an accidental discovery by Melvin Calvin and co-workers provided the first example of a solid (the α-polymorph of choline chloride) showing hypersensitivity to ionizing radiation: under certain conditions, the radiolytic yield of decomposition approached 5 × 10(4) per 100 eV (which is 4 orders of magnitude greater than usual values), suggesting an uncommonly efficient radiation-induced chain reaction. Twenty years later, the still-accepted mechanism for this rare condition was suggested by Martyn Symons, but no validation for this mechanism has been supplied. Meanwhile, ionic liquids and deep eutectic mixtures that are based on choline, betainium, and other derivitized natural amino compounds are presently finding an increasing number of applications as diluents in nuclear separations, where the constituent ions are exposed to ionizing radiation that is emitted by decaying radionuclides. Thus, the systems that are compositionally similar to radiation hypersensitive solids are being considered for use in high radiation fields, where this property is particularly undesirable! In Part 5 of this series on organic cations, we revisit the phenomenon of radiation hypersensitivity and explore mechanistic aspects of radiation-induced reactions involving this class of task-specific, biocompatible, functionalized cations, both in ionic liquids and in reference crystalline compounds. We demonstrate that Symons' mechanism needs certain revisions and rethinking, and suggest its modification. Our reconsideration suggests that there cannot be conditions leading to hypersensitivity in ionic liquids.

Charge Trapping in Photovoltaically Active Perovskites and Related Halogenoplumbate Compounds.

Halogenoplumbate perovskites (MeNH3PbX3, where X is I and/or Br) have emerged as promising solar panel materials. Their limiting photovoltaic efficiency depends on charge localization and trapping processes that are presently insufficiently understood. We demonstrate that in halogenoplumbate materials the holes are trapped by organic cations (that deprotonate from their oxidized state) and Pb(2+) cations (as Pb(3+) centers), whereas the electrons are trapped by several Pb(2+) cations, forming diamagnetic lead clusters that also serve as color centers. In some cases, paramagnetic variants of these clusters can be observed. We suggest that charge separation in the halogenoplumbates resembles latent image formation in silver halide photography. Electron and hole trapping by lead clusters in extended dislocations in the bulk may be responsible for accumulation of trapped charge observed in this photovoltaic material.

Radiation stability of cations in ionic liquids. 4. Task-specific antioxidant cations for nuclear separations and photolithography.

Three families of "task-specific" antioxidant organic cations that include designated sites to facilitate deprotonation following electronic excitation and ionization have been introduced. The deprotonation from the excited state is reversible, leading to minimal damage of the cation, whereas the deprotonation from the oxidized cation yields persistent aroxyl and trityl radicals. This protection improves radiation stability of ionic compounds in 2.5 MeV electron beam radiolysis. Apart from the use of such cations as structural components of room temperature ionic liquid (IL) diluents for nuclear separations, their ionic compounds involving bases of superacids are well suited for use as chemically amplified acid generator resists in electron beam lithography and extreme ultraviolet photolithography.

Radiation stability of cations in ionic liquids. 2. Improved radiation resistance through charge delocalization in 1-benzylpyridinium.

Hydrophobic room-temperature ionic liquids (ILs) hold promise as replacements for molecular diluents for processing of used nuclear fuel as well as for the development of alternative separations processes, provided that the solvent can be made resistant to ionizing radiation. We demonstrate that 1-benzylpyridinium cations are uniquely suited as radiation resistant cations due to the occurrence of charge delocalization in both their reduced and oxidized forms in the ILs. It is suggested that the excess electron and hole in the latter ILs are stabilized through the formation of π-electron sandwich dimers that are analogous to the well-known dimer radical cations of aromatic molecules. This charge delocalization dramatically reduces the yield of fragmentation by deprotonation and the loss of benzyl arms, thereby providing a synthetic path to radiation resistant ILs that are suitable for nuclear fuel processing.

Radiation stability of cations in ionic liquids. 1. Alkyl and benzyl derivatives of 5-membered ring heterocycles.

In order to use hydrophobic room temperature ionic liquids (ILs) as diluents in nuclear separations for advanced fuel cycles, it is desirable to reduce the breakdown of the constituent ions caused by ionizing radiation. In this series, we survey radiation stability for different classes of organic cations used to formulate ILs. While radiolysis of 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium cations has been extensively studied, there have not been complementary studies of 1-benzyl derivatives of these cations nor organic cations that are derived from 5-membered ring heterocycles other than imidazole, such as 1,2,4-triazole and thiazole. In part 1, we establish the fragmentation pathways for such cations and quantify product yields for 2.5 MeV electron beam radiolysis of these aromatic cations. Radiolytic reduction of 1-benzyl cations derived from imidazole and 1,2,4-triazole is shown to cause the elimination of benzyl radicals from their electron adducts, whereas this elimination does not occur in the thiazole derivatives due to stabilization of the excess electron as a dimer radical cation. No such elimination occurs in the corresponding 1-alkyl derivatives, but there is significant C-N and C-C bond fragmentation in the aliphatic arms. As such bond dissociation reactions are irreversible, there is significant loss of 1-alkyl cations during the radiolysis. For 1-benzyl derivatives, this electronic excitation causes fragmentation of the C-N bonds in the benzyl arms with the release of the corresponding base and the benzyl carbocation that can subsequently attack this base or add to another cation. Such systems exhibit more predictable fragmentation patterns and yield well-defined products; some of the systems also exhibit increased radiation resistance. The C-N bond fragmentation in the reduced cations can be further suppressed through the use of appropriate electron scavengers, including acids and aromatic imide anions. The observed trends are rationalized using density functional theory calculations, and the implications of these results for the design of IL diluents are examined.

Radiation stability of cations in ionic liquids. 3. Guanidinium cations.

Due to their superb structural versatility, guanidinium cations find increasing use as constituent ions in room temperature ionic liquids (ILs). This versatility allows fine-tuning of hydrophobicity, which is an important concern for the use of ILs as diluents for metal ion separations. However, the presence of six C-N bonds in such cations poses a question, whether the guanidinium based ILs can be considered as diluents for nuclear separations, given that the radiation emitted by the decaying radionuclides can break these relatively weak bonds over the use cycle of the solvent. As nothing is presently known about the radiolytic stability of the guanidinium cations, we addressed this question using 2-dialkylamino-1,3-dimethylimidazolidine based cations (R = Et, Pr, and Bu) as a representative model for the entire class of such cations, and assessed their stability in 2.5 MeV electron beam radiolysis. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and mass spectrometry have been used to establish chemical mechanisms for radiation damage in guanidinium cations. Our conclusion is that radiation stability of these cations is not significantly different from that of more familiar aliphatic and aromatic IL cations. In fact, these cations yield exceptionally stable radicals, and fragmentation occurs only in their radiolytically generated excited states. The predominant chemical pathway for the cation decomposition is the elimination of their aliphatic arms, with radiolytic yields of 0.65 to 1.06 to 1.46 per 100 eV from R = Et to R = Bu, respectively. The total loss of the parent cation was estimated as 2.62, 1.65, and 1.98 species per 100 eV. While this attrition is not negligible, it is comparable to other organic cations that have fewer fissile C-N bonds. Many of the products are either modified guanidinium ions or protonated bases that are not expected to interfere with radionuclide separations.

Photo- and radiation-chemistry of halide anions in ionic liquids.

One- and two- photon excitation of halide anions (X(-)) in polar molecular solvents results in electron detachment from the dissociative charge-transfer-to-solvent state; this reaction yields a solvated halide atom and a solvated electron. How do such photoreactions proceed in ionic liquid (IL) solvents? Matrix isolation electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy has been used to answer this question for photoreactions of bromide in aliphatic (1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium) and aromatic (1-alkyl-3-methyl-imidazolium) ionic liquids. In both classes of ILs, the photoreaction (both 1- and 2-photon) yields bromine atoms that promptly abstract hydrogen from the alkyl chains of the IL cation; only in concentrated bromide solutions (containing >5-10 mol % bromide) does Br2(-•) formation compete with this reaction. In two-photon excitation, the 2-imidazolyl radical generated via the charge transfer promptly eliminates the alkyl arm. These photolytic reactions can be contrasted with radiolysis of the same ILs, in which large yield of BrA(-•) radicals was observed (where A(-) is a matrix anion), suggesting that solvated Br(•) atoms do not occur in the ILs, as such a species would form three-electron σ(2)σ(*1) bonds with anions present in the IL. It is suggested that chlorine and bromine atoms abstract hydrogen faster than they form such radicals, even at cryogenic temperatures, whereas iodine mainly forms such bound radicals. These XA(-•) radicals convert to X2(•-) radicals in a reaction with the parent halide anion. Ramifications of these observations for photodegradation of ionic liquids are discussed.

Ionic liquids based on polynitrile anions: hydrophobicity, low proton affinity, and high radiolytic resistance combined.

Ionic liquids (IL) are being considered as replacements for molecular diluents in spent nuclear fuel reprocessing. This development is hampered by the dearth of constituent anions that combine high hydrophobicity, low metal cation and proton affinity, and radiation resistance. We demonstrate that polynitrile anions have the potential to meet these challenges. Unlike the great majority of organic anions, such polynitrile anions are resistant to oxidative fragmentation during radiolysis, yielding stable N- and C-centered radicals. Moreover, their radical dianions (generated by reduction of the anions) generally undergo protonation in preference to elimination of the cyanide. This is in contrast to fluorinated anions (another large class of anions with low proton affinity), for which radiation-induced release of fluoride is a common occurrence. The "weak spot" of the polynitrile anions appears to be their excited-state dissociation, but at least one of these anions, 1,1,2,3,3-pentacyanopropenide, is shown to resist fragmentation in room temperature radiolysis. We suggest beginning the exploration of ionic liquids based on such polynitrile anions.

Toward radiation-resistant ionic liquids. Radiation stability of sulfonyl imide anions.

Room-temperature hydrophobic ionic liquids (ILs) are considered for processing of spent nuclear fuel, including as possible replacements for molecular diluents in liquid-liquid extraction. This application requires radiation stability of the constituent ions. Previous research indicated that most of the anions that are currently used in the synthesis of ILs are prone to fragmentation under prolonged radiation exposure, which causes deterioration of the corresponding ILs. An exception to this general rule is phthalimide; unfortunately, this anion is too basic to be useful for extraction solvents, as these separations involve acidic conditions. The acidity of the imide can be increased by replacing the carbonyl groups by sulfonyl groups, which incidentally transform these imides into familiar artificial sweeteners such as saccharin. In the present study, we use electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and mass spectrometry to assess the radiation stability of ILs based on such "sweet" sulfonyl imide anions. Our results suggest that saccharinate and o-benzenedisulfonimide are remarkably stable to radiation-induced fragmentation.

Radiation-induced fragmentation of diamide extraction agents in ionic liquid diluents.

N,N,N',N'-Tetraalkyldiglycolamides are extracting agents that are used for liquid-liquid extraction of trivalent metal ions in wet processing of spent nuclear fuel. This application places such agents in contact with the decaying radionuclides, causing radiolysis of the agent in the organic diluent. Recent research seeks to replace common molecular diluents (such as n-dodecane) with hydrophobic room-temperature ionic liquids (ILs), which have superior solvation properties. In alkane diluents, rapid radiolytic deterioration of diglycolamide agents can be inhibited by addition of an aromatic cosolvent that scavenges highly reactive alkane radical cations before these oxidize the extracting agent. Do aromatic ILs exhibit a similar radioprotective effect? To answer this question, we used electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy to study the fragmentation pathways in radiolysis of neat diglycolamides, their model compounds, and their solutions in the ILs. Our study indicates that aromatic ILs do not protect these types of solutes from extensive radiolytic damage. Previous research indicated a similar lack of protection for crown ethers, whereas the ILs readily protected di- and trialkyl phosphates (another large class of metal-extracting agents). Our analysis of these unanticipated failures suggests that new types of organic anions are required in order to formulate ILs capable of radioprotection for these classes of solutes. This study is a cautionary tale of the fallacy of analogical thinking when applied to an entirely new and insufficiently understood class of chemical materials.

Electron localization and radiation chemistry of amides.

Alkylamides (such as N,N'-dimethylformamide, N,N'-diethylformamide, and N,N'-dimethylacetamide) are aprotic solvents that are widely used in organic synthesis. These polar molecules have no electron affinity, and it is believed that irradiated liquid and solid amides stabilize excess electrons as cavity-type species analogous to hydrated and ammoniated electrons. In this study, we use isotope substitution and EPR spectroscopy to demonstrate that, in frozen amides, the suspected "cavity electron" is, in fact, a solvent-stabilized monomer anion. Our observations call into question other attributions of such features in the literature, both in low temperature solids and room temperature liquids. We also provide a general scheme describing amide radiolysis, as the related amides are used as metal ion extracting agents in nuclear separations.

Radiation and radical chemistry of NO3(-), HNO3, and dialkylphosphoric acids in room-temperature ionic liquids.

Hydrophobic room-temperature ionic liquids (ILs) are considered as possible replacements for molecular diluents for nuclear separations, as well as the basis of new separations processes. Such applications may put the solvents both in high radiation fields and in contact with aqueous raffinate containing 1-6 M HNO(3). In this study, we address the effect of the extracted nitrate and nitric acid on the radiation chemistry of hydrophobic ILs composed of 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium cations (and closely related systems). We demonstrate that the nitrate anion competes with the solvent cation as an electron scavenger, with most of the primary radical species converted to NO(3)(•2-) and NO(2)(•) that initiate a complex sequence of radical reactions. In hydrophobic ILs equilibrated with 3 M HNO(3), nearly all electrons released by the ionizing radiation are converted to NO(2)(•). While the reductive pathway is strongly affected by the nitrate and there is also some N-O bond scission via direct excitation, the extent of interference with the oxidative pathway is relatively small; the cation damage is not dramatically affected by the presence of nitrate as most of the detrimental radiolytic products are generated via the oxidative pathway. These results are contrasted with the behavior of dialkylphosphoric acids (a large class of extraction agents for trivalent metal ions). We demonstrate that IL solvents protect these dialkylphosphoric acids against radiation-induced dealkylation.

Radiation induced redox reactions and fragmentation of constituent ions in ionic liquids. 1. Anions.

Room temperature ionic liquids (IL) find increasing use for the replacement of organic solvents in practical applications, including their use in solar cells and electrolytes for metal deposition, and as extraction solvents for the reprocessing of spent nuclear fuel. The radiation stability of ILs is an important concern for some of these applications, as previous studies suggested extensive fragmentation of the constituent ions upon irradiation. In the present study, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy has been used to identify fragmentation pathways for constituent anions in ammonium, phosphonium, and imidazolium ILs. Many of these detrimental reactions are initiated by radiation-induced redox processes involving these anions. Scission of the oxidized anions is the main fragmentation pathway for the majority of the practically important anions; (internal) proton transfer involving the aliphatic arms of these anions is a competing reaction. For perfluorinated anions, fluoride loss following dissociative electron attachment to the anion can be even more prominent than this oxidative fragmentation. Bond scission in the anion was also observed for NO(3)(-) and B(CN)(4)(-) anions and indirectly implicated for BF(4)(-) and PF(6)(-) anions. Among small anions, CF(3)SO(3)(-) and N(CN)(2)(-) are the most stable. Among larger anions, the derivatives of benzoate and imide anions were found to be relatively stable. This stability is due to suppression of the oxidative fragmentation. For benzoates, this is a consequence of the extensive sharing of unpaired electron density by the π-system in the corresponding neutral radical; for the imides, this stability could be the consequence of N-N σ(2)σ(*1) bond formation involving the parent anion. While fragmentation does not occur for these "exceptional" anions, H atom addition and electron attachment are prominent. Among the typically used constituent anions, aliphatic carboxylates were found to be the least resistant to oxidative fragmentation, followed by (di)alkyl phosphates and alkanesulfonates. The discussion of the radiation stability of ILs is continued in the second part of this study, which examines the fate of organic cations in such liquids.