There is a need for new systemic sclerosis subset criteria. A content analytic approach.

OBJECTIVES: Systemic sclerosis (SSc) is heterogenous. The objectives of this study were to evaluate the purpose, strengths and limitations of existing SSc subset criteria, and identify ideas among experts about subsets. METHODS: We conducted semi-structured interviews with randomly sampled international SSc experts. The interview transcripts underwent an iterative process with text deconstructed to single thought units until a saturated conceptual framework with coding was achieved and respondent occurrence tabulated. Serial cross-referential analyses of clusters were developed. RESULTS: Thirty experts from 13 countries were included; 67% were male, 63% were from Europe and 37% from North America; median experience of 22.5 years, with a median of 55 new SSc patients annually. Three thematic clusters regarding subsetting were identified: research and communication; management; and prognosis (prediction of internal organ involvement, survival). The strength of the limited/diffuse system was its ease of use, however 10% stated this system had marginal value. Shortcomings of the diffuse/limited classification were the risk of misclassification, predictions/generalizations did not always hold true, and that the elbow or knee threshold was arbitrary. Eighty-seven percent use more than 2 subsets including: SSc sine scleroderma, overlap conditions, antibody-determined subsets, speed of progression, and age of onset (juvenile, elderly). CONCLUSIONS: We have synthesized an international view of the construct of SSc subsets in the modern era. We found a number of factors underlying the construct of SSc subsets. Considerations for the next phase include rate of change and hierarchal clustering (e.g. limited/diffuse, then by antibodies).

Endothelial dysfunction is present only in the microvasculature and microcirculation of early diffuse systemic sclerosis patients.

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate endothelial function and vascular stiffness in large, medium, small and microcirculatory blood vessels in very early diffuse systemic sclerosis (SSc). METHODS: We studied consecutive early diffuse SSc patients, defined as <2 years from first SSc symptom who did not have a prior cardiovascular event. Age, gender and race-matched controls were recruited. All underwent assessment of aortic pulse wave velocity (PWV), carotid intima-media thickness (IMT) brachial flow-mediated dilation (FMD), digital peripheral artery tonometer (EndoPAT) assessment and laser speckle contrast imaging (LSCI). RESULTS: Fifteen early diffuse SSc and controls were evaluated. The average age was 49 years, 63% were female and 93% were Caucasian. There were no differences in body mass index, hypertension, diabetes or hyperlipidaemia between controls and SSc patients. Mean SSc disease duration was 1.3 years. In the large central vessels, there was no difference in aortic PWV (p=0.71) or carotid IMT (p=0.92) between SSc patients and controls. Similarly, there was no difference in endothelial dysfunction with brachial artery FMD after ischaemia (p=0.55) and nitroglycerin administration (p=0.74). There were significantly lower values for digital EndoPAT measures (p=0.0001) in SSc patients. LSCI revealed a distinct pattern of microcirculatory abnormalities in response to ischaemia in SSc patients compared to controls. Imaging demonstrated a blunted microcirculatory hyperaemia of the hand with greater subsequent response to nitroglycerin. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that the earliest endothelial changes occur in smaller arterioles and microvascular beds, but not in medium or macrovascular beds, in early diffuse SSc.

X chromosome gene methylation in peripheral lymphocytes from monozygotic twins discordant for scleroderma.

Scleroderma (SSc) is a rare connective tissue disease characterized by fibrosis, microvasculopathy and autoimmune features. The role of genetics is limited in SSc, as suggested by similar concordance rates in monozygotic and dizygotic twin pairs, while environmental factors may act through epigenetic changes, as demonstrated for specific genes. Further, sex chromosome changes have been reported in SSc and may explain the female preponderance. In the present study we compared the methylation profile of all X chromosome genes in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from monozygotic twins discordant (n=7) and concordant (n=1) for SSc. Methylated DNA immunoprecipitations from each discordant twin pair were hybridized to a custom-designed array included 998 sites encompassing promoters of all X chromosome genes and randomly chosen autosomal genes. Biostatistical tools identified sites with an elevated probability to be consistently hypermethylated (n=18) or hypomethylated (n=25) in affected twins. Identified genes include transcription factors (ARX, HSFX1, ZBED1, ZNF41) and surface antigens (IL1RAPL2, PGRMC1), and pathway analysis suggests their involvement in cell proliferation (PGK1, SMS, UTP14A, SSR4), apoptosis (MTM1), inflammation (ARAF) and oxidative stress (ENOX2). In conclusion, we propose that X chromosome genes with different methylation profiles in monozygotic twin pairs may constitute candidates for SSc susceptibility.

Minimally important difference in diffuse systemic sclerosis: results from the D-penicillamine study.

OBJECTIVE: To estimate minimally important differences (MIDs) in scores for the modified Rodnan Skin Score (mRSS) and Health Assessment Questionnaire-Disability Index (HAQ-DI) in a clinical trial on diffuse systemic sclerosis (SSc). PARTICIPANTS AND METHODS: 134 people participated in a 2-year, double-blind, randomised clinical trial comparing efficacy of low-dose and high-dose D-penicillamine in diffuse SSc. At 6, 12, 18 and 24 months, the investigator was asked to rate the change in the patient's health since entering the study: markedly worsened, moderately worsened, slightly worsened, unchanged, slightly improved, moderately improved or markedly improved. Patients who were rated as slightly improved were defined as the minimally changed subgroup and compared with patients rated as moderately or markedly improved. RESULTS: The MID estimates for the mRSS improvement ranged from 3.2 to 5.3 (0.40-0.66 effect size) and for the HAQ-DI from 0.10 to 0.14 (0.15-0.21 effect size). Patients who were rated to improve more than slightly were found to improve by 6.9-14.2 (0.86-1.77 effect size) on the mRSS and 0.21-0.55 (0.32-0.83 effect size) on the HAQ-DI score. CONCLUSION: MID estimates are provided for improvement in the mRSS and HAQ-DI scores, which can help in interpreting clinical trials on patients with SSc and be used for sample size calculation for future clinical trials on diffuse SSc.

Assessment of disease severity and prognosis.

The Subcommittee members initially agreed on the concepts of disease activity, damage and severity, defining severity as the total effect of disease on organ function. It was decided to start with the assessment of severity using the Medsger's severity scale. A revised version of this scale was constructed. The rationale for the exclusion of other variables was provided.

Rigorous new approach to constructing a gold standard for validating new diagnostic criteria, as exemplified by the eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome.

BACKGROUND: Constructing diagnostic criteria, a common problem in clinical medicine, is particularly difficult for diseases that lack a pathognomonic "gold standard." To develop an improved strategy for constructing such criteria, we used the eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome as an example. The goal, for research classifications, was to construct validated clinically sensible criteria and to develop improved methods that can be used for other disorders. METHODS: Using a "pattern-based" approach with data from several separate sources, a committee of investigators first prepared and informally tested criteria for the diagnosis of eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome. A gold standard challenge set of reports of cases and noncases was independently generated and separately validated by an external panel of clinical experts. The criteria were then tested using the gold standard set, and interobserver variability and diagnostic accuracy were determined. RESULTS: Interobserver variability showed the following mean proportionate agreements: 98.7% for the presence of specific criteria elements, 99% to 100% for diagnosis, and 97% to 98% for diagnostic pattern. kappa Values were correspondingly high. Diagnostic accuracy showed sensitivity at 88%, specificity at 97%, and overall accuracy at 92%. CONCLUSIONS: The proposed criteria are accurate and reproducible, and can be used in future clinical investigations of the eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome. The new strategy and methods developed for this challenge can be valuable for solving analogous problems in constructing criteria for other clinical disorders.

D-penicillamine in systemic sclerosis? Yes!

The use of D-penicillamine in systemic sclerosis (SSc) has been controversial. We have reviewed the major published studies on this drug in SSc with diffuse cutaneous (dc) involvement and summarized our own recent experience in dcSSc patients treated with and without D-penicillamine. We conclude that D-penicillamine favourably alters the natural history of skin involvement in dcSSc, even when used in low dose. Furthermore, recurrence of diffuse skin change after discontinuation of D-penicillamine and improvement in skin thickening after reinitiation of the drug support its effectiveness. We believe that the rheumatologic community should use D-penicillamine in patients with early dcSSc.

Autoreactive T cells to topoisomerase I in monozygotic twins discordant for systemic sclerosis.

OBJECTIVE: To examine T and B cell responses to topoisomerase I (topo I) in a monozygotic twin pair discordant for systemic sclerosis (SSc). METHODS: The peripheral blood T cell proliferative responses induced by topo I and in vitro anti-topo I antibody production in cultures of T and B cells were examined in an SSc patient with serum anti-topo I antibody and in her healthy monozygotic twin. Topo I-reactive T cell lines were generated from the twin pair and analyzed for antigenic specificity, major histocompatibility complex class II restriction, and T cell receptor (TCR) gene usage. RESULTS: T cell proliferative responses to topo I were detected in both the SSc patient and her healthy twin, although the kinetics of the T cell response were accelerated in the patient compared with the healthy twin. The estimated frequency of circulating topo I-reactive T cells was 1/6,700 in the SSc patient and 1/39,000 in the healthy twin. Anti-topo I antibody production was observed in cultures of T and B cells from the SSc patient, but not in those from the healthy twin. When the cells from the twins were mixed in different combinations, T cells from the healthy twin did stimulate the SSc patient's B cells to produce anti-topo I antibody through a CD40-dependent mechanism. Topo I-reactive T cell lines generated from the twins had similar characteristics, including a CD4+ phenotype, restriction by HLA-DR, recognition of epitopes within amino acid residues 209-386 of topo I, and dominant usage of the TCR Vbeta20 gene segment. CONCLUSION: These results indicate that topo I-reactive T cells were activated and clonally expanded in the SSc patient. However, there were no substantial differences in either phenotypic or functional properties of topo I-reactive T cells obtained from the SSc patient and those obtained from her healthy identical twin. It is likely, therefore, that the anti-topo I antibody response in the SSc patient is induced by in vivo activation of topo I-reactive T cells derived from the normal T cell repertoire.

Systemic sclerosis with renal crisis and pulmonary hypertension: a report of eleven cases.

OBJECTIVE: To describe a series of systemic sclerosis (SSc) patients with the unusual combination of scleroderma renal crisis (SRC) and pulmonary hypertension (PHT) without interstitial lung disease. METHODS: The medical records of 2,459 SSc patients in the University of Pittsburgh Scleroderma Databank first evaluated between 1972 and 1999 were reviewed. RESULTS: Eleven patients (0.45%) had both SRC and PHT. All had been evaluated since 1979, when angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor therapy for SRC became available. Seven had SSc with limited cutaneous involvement, and 4 had SSc with diffuse cutaneous involvement. SRC occurred first in all patients except 1, in whom the onsets of SRC and PHT were simultaneous. SRC preceded PHT by a mean of 4.3 years. Four patients had anti-Th/To antibody, 5 had anti-RNA polymerase III antibody, 2 had anti-U3 RNP antibody, and none had anticentromere or antitopoisomerase I antibody. Ten of the 11 patients died, 8 from PHT. Ten patients were being treated with ACE inhibitor drugs when PHT developed. CONCLUSION: In SSc, SRC and PHT are not mutually exclusive complications. SSc patients surviving SRC who have serum antibodies to Th/To, RNA polymerase III, or U3 RNP are at increased risk to develop PHT. ACE inhibitor therapy did not prevent the development of PHT.

Criteria for the classification of early systemic sclerosis.

We propose criteria for the early diagnosis and classification of systemic sclerosis that reflect the vascular and serological advances of the last 2 decades.

Effects of the American College of Rheumatology systemic sclerosis trial guidelines on the nature of systemic sclerosis patients entering a clinical trial.

OBJECTIVES: To compare the systemic sclerosis (SSc) patients entered into the d-penicillamine trial with SSc patients entered into previous controlled SSc trials. It was hypothesized that the d-penicillamine trial patients, who conformed to the American College of Rheumatology (ACR) guidelines for clinical trials in SSc were different from patients entered into previous trials. METHODS: Patients entering a double-blind, randomized trial of low- vs high-dose d-penicillamine were described carefully and completely. Their characteristics were then compared with previously published data on SSc and its treatment. RESULTS: One hundred and thirty-four patients had early [mean duration 9.5 (s.d. 4.2) months], diffuse [skin score 21 (8)] disease. Organ involvement in the patients was as follows: pulmonary 54%, cardiac 20%, joints 38%, muscular 20%. Thirty-three per cent had mild proteinuria and 13% were hypertensive when first seen. Compared with patients in most previous studies, these SSc patients had earlier disease and uniformly had diffuse disease. They had less muscular involvement, less dyspnoea, less abnormal pulmonary function and less cardiac and less renal involvement than patients in earlier studies. CONCLUSIONS: The use of the new ACR guidelines for SSc trials may change the nature of patient populations entering future studies.

Surgery for ischemic pain and Raynaud's' phenomenon in scleroderma: a description of treatment protocol and evaluation of results.

Although the literature suggests that palmar sympathectomy (PS) with or without vascular reconstruction may improve ischemic digital pain, fingertip ulceration, and cold intolerance in patients with scleroderma, the question regarding long-term efficacy still remains. This retrospective study of six patients (eight hands) operated on between 1995 and 1997 evaluates both early (6 months) and long-term (average, 2.5 years) outcome after PS in combination with decompression arteriolysis of the radial and ulnar arteries proximal to the wrist. When preoperative digital blood flow was inadequate based on noninvasive vascular studies and major inflow occlusion was present, vascular reconstruction was also performed when feasible. At early review, significant improvement in ischemic digital pain and moderate improvement in cold intolerance resulted in eight hands, and at final follow-up, this was sustained in seven hands. Preoperatively, digital ulcerations were present in six hands. After digital debridement and/or amputation, all wounds healed, but in one patient with bilateral disease who continued to smoke, ulcerations recurred without the need for subsequent surgery. Five of six patients were no longer dependent on narcotic analgesics, but use of vasodilator medication did not change. Five of six patients claimed significant improvement in the quality of life after surgery and reported that they would undergo the surgery again. PS in combination with radial and ulnar arteriolysis appears to be efficacious at both early and long-term review. When major inflow occlusion exists and digital blood flow is compromised, vascular reconstruction is recommended if possible. We review our treatment protocol in this complex population of patients.

The Disability Index of the Health Assessment Questionnaire is a predictor and correlate of outcome in the high-dose versus low-dose penicillamine in systemic sclerosis trial.

OBJECTIVE: To explore the clinical implications of a score of > or =1.0 on the Disability Index of the Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ DI) at the first patient visit, and to examine the implications of improvement in HAQ DI score over 2 years in a cohort of systemic sclerosis (SSc) patients with diffuse cutaneous scleroderma. METHODS: SSc skin and visceral involvement was assessed in 134 SSc patients with diffuse scleroderma (mean +/- SD disease duration of 10 +/- 4 months) when they entered a multicenter drug trial and again 2 years later. Mortality and the occurrence of scleroderma renal crisis were assessed for a mean +/- SD of 4.0 +/- 1.1 years. Logistic and linear regression analyses were used to examine the relationship of the baseline HAQ DI score to morbidity, mortality, and visceral involvement, as well as the relationship of changes in the HAQ DI score to changes in physical examination, laboratory, and functional variables over 2 years. RESULTS: A baseline HAQ DI score of > or =1.0 was predictive of mortality (odds ratio 3.22, 95% confidence interval 1.097-9.468) over 4 years. Multivariate linear regression demonstrated that a model which included the erythrocyte sedimentation rate at baseline (P = 0.005) and changes at 2 years in the swollen joint count (P = 0.002), total skin score (P = 0.005), and white blood cell count (P = 0.005) best explained the change in HAQ DI score over 2 years (R2 = 0.528). The HAQ DI score and total skin score at baseline were highly correlated (correlation coefficient 0.368), as were changes in the HAQ DI score and the total skin score over 2 years (correlation coefficient 0.492). Although the HAQ DI score was heavily influenced by hand dysfunction at baseline and at 2 years, improvement (reduction) in the HAQ DI score over 2 years was related to factors other than hand dysfunction. CONCLUSION: A baseline HAQ DI score of > or =1.0 predicted mortality over 4 years. Improvement in the HAQ DI score in these patients with diffuse scleroderma was associated with improvement in skin thickening, hand function, oral aperture, lung function, signs of arthritis, serum creatinine level, and the investigator's global assessment of improvement. The HAQ DI is a self-administered questionnaire that SSc patients can complete easily and rapidly and that gives the practicing physician important information about prognosis, patient status, and changes in disease course over time.

Improvement in skin thickening in systemic sclerosis associated with improved survival.

OBJECTIVE: The natural history of changes in skin thickening in diffuse scleroderma is quite variable, but the significance of these changes is not clear. Clinical trials are using changes in skin thickening as the primary outcome measure, and thus it would be helpful to determine the significance of improvement in skin thickening. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether improvement in skin thickening over time was associated with improved survival. METHODS: Patients with early (<3 years) diffuse scleroderma who had a baseline evaluation and a repeat skin assessment (modified Rodnan skin score) performed 2 years later (i.e., they had to live for 2 years) were identified from the prospective, observational Pittsburgh Scleroderma Databank. The percentage of improvement and rate of change in the skin score during that time were determined. Patients with an improvement in their skin thickening of >25% of their peak skin score and a rate of change of at least 5 units/year were defined as the improved group; patients with increased skin thickening or no improvement were termed the no improvement group. Demographic and clinical features, organ system involvement, and survival rates were determined and the groups were compared. Regression and Cox regression analyses were used to determine what features were associated with improved skin thickness and survival. RESULTS: Two hundred seventy-eight patients fulfilled the entry criteria, 63% in the improved group and 36% in the no improvement group. The groups were similar in terms of clinical and demographic characteristics at the initial visit. The improved group had an average improvement of 50% of their peak skin score at 2 years after the initial visit. Survival was significantly better in the improved group compared with the unimproved group at 5 and 10 years, with rates of 90% and 80%, respectively, in the improved group and 77% and 60%, respectively, in the no improvement group (P < 0.0001). There were no significant differences in the occurrence of severe organ involvement during the first 2 years to account for the later differences in survival. The duration of the use of D-penicillamine was significantly associated with improved skin thickness and improved survival. CONCLUSION: Among patients surviving the first few years of diffuse scleroderma, striking improvement in skin thickening may occur in up to two-thirds. This improvement in skin thickening is associated with improved survival. Improvement in skin thickening may be useful as a surrogate for improvement in survival in clinical trials.

Assessment of damage and activity in systemic sclerosis.

The determination of damage and activity in the course of a disease are important matters. Monitoring damage activity is critical in the evaluation of individual patients and in evaluating treatment efficacy in clinical trials. A disease damage (severity) scale has been published for systemic sclerosis. A number of potential cytokine and other soluble protein markers of disease activity for this disease have been proposed in recent publications, reviewed here.

Severe organ involvement in systemic sclerosis with diffuse scleroderma.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the natural history and timing of severe involvement of the kidney, heart, lung, gastrointestinal (GI) tract, and skin in patients with systemic sclerosis (SSc) and diffuse cutaneous involvement. METHODS: This study used the Pittsburgh Scleroderma Databank and included patients with diffuse scleroderma who were seen between January 1, 1972 and December 31, 1995. Patients had frequent follow-ups, and a 95% accountability for these patients was maintained. Severe organ involvement was defined as the presence of any of the following: 1) in the kidney, scleroderma "renal crisis"; 2) in the heart, cardiomyopathy, symptomatic pericarditis, or an arrhythmia requiring treatment; 3) in the lung, pulmonary fibrosis on chest radiograph and a forced vital capacity of <55% of predicted; 4) in the GI tract, malabsorption, repeated episodes of pseudoobstruction, or severe problems requiring hyperalimentation; and 5) in the skin, a modified Rodnan skin score >40. The timing from disease onset to survival for each case of severe organ involvement was determined. RESULTS: Of the 953 patients with diffuse scleroderma, kidney involvement developed in 177 (19%), heart involvement in 143 (15%), lung involvement in 151 (16%), GI tract involvement in 74 (8%), and skin involvement in 233 (24%). Severe skin and kidney involvement occurred during the first 3 years in 70% of those who ever developed these problems throughout a mean of 10 years of followup. Severe heart, lung, and GI tract involvement developed during the first 3 years in 45-55% of those who were ever affected. The survival of patients with severe organ involvement was poor. The 9-year cumulative survival rate of all patients with severe organ involvement was 38%, compared with 72% in patients without such involvement (P < 0.0001). CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that severe organ involvement in SSc patients with diffuse scleroderma most often occurs early in the course of the disease. Survival for patients with severe organ involvement is markedly reduced. Patients should therefore be monitored very closely during the first 3 years of disease for signs and symptoms that may signal the subsequent development of severe organ damage. Potential disease-modifying therapies must be initiated early to modify the natural history of SSc and to improve survival. Patients who survive the first few years without developing severe organ involvement are less likely to develop such life-threatening involvement later in the disease course.

Skin thickness score as a predictor and correlate of outcome in systemic sclerosis: high-dose versus low-dose penicillamine trial.

OBJECTIVE: To study the clinical implications of a skin thickness score > or =20 at first visit and of softening of sclerodermatous skin in a cohort of systemic sclerosis (SSc) patients with diffuse cutaneous scleroderma. METHODS: Skin and visceral involvement were assessed in 134 SSc patients with diffuse scleroderma (mean +/- SD duration of SSc 10 +/- 4 months) as they entered a multicenter drug trial and again at 2 years of followup. Advent of mortality and scleroderma renal crisis (SRC) were assessed during a followup of 4.0 +/- 1.1 years (mean +/- SD). Logistic and linear regression were used to examine the relationship of baseline skin score to morbidity, mortality, and visceral involvement and the relationship of changes in skin score to changes in physical examination, laboratory, and functional variables over 2 years. RESULTS: A baseline skin score > or =20 was associated with heart involvement at baseline (odds ratio [OR] 3.10, 95% confidence interval [95% CI] 1.25-7.70) and was predictive of mortality (OR 3.59, 95% CI 1.23-10.55) and SRC (OR 10.00, 95% CI 2.21-45.91) over 4 years. Multivariate linear regression demonstrated that a model with skin score at baseline (P = 0.0078) and changes in large joint contractures (P = 0.0072), tender joint counts (P = 0.0119), handspread (P = 0.0242), and Health Assessment Questionnaire disability index (HAQ-DI) (P = 0.0244) explained the change in skin score over 2 years (R2 = 0.567). Multivariate logistic regression demonstrated that the investigator's global assessment of improvement was best explained by a model with skin score and HAQ-DI (R2 = 0.455). CONCLUSION: A baseline skin score > or =20 was associated with heart involvement at baseline and predicted mortality and SRC over the subsequent 4 years. Improvement in skin score in these patients with diffuse cutaneous scleroderma was associated with improvement in hand function, inflammatory indices, joint contractures, arthritis signs, overall functional ability, and the examining investigator's global assessment of improvement.

Long-term outcomes of scleroderma renal crisis.

BACKGROUND: Although scleroderma renal crisis, a complication of systemic sclerosis, can be treated with angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors, its long-term outcomes are not known. OBJECTIVE: To determine outcomes, natural history, and risk factors in patients with systemic sclerosis and scleroderma renal crisis. DESIGN: Prospective observational cohort study. SETTING: University program specializing in scleroderma. PATIENTS: 145 patients with scleroderma renal crisis who received ACE inhibitors and 662 patients with scleroderma who did not have renal crisis. MEASUREMENTS: Among patients with renal crisis, the four outcomes studied were no dialysis, temporary dialysis, permanent dialysis, and early death. Demographic, clinical, and laboratory data were compared to identify risk factors for specific outcomes. Follow-up was 5 to 10 years. RESULTS: 61% of patients with renal crisis had good outcomes (55 received no dialysis, and 34 received temporary dialysis); only 4 of these (4%) progressed to chronic renal failure and permanent dialysis. More than half of the patients who initially required dialysis could discontinue it 3 to 18 months later. Survival of patients in the good outcome group was similar to that of patients with diffuse scleroderma who did not have renal crisis. Some patients (39%) had bad outcomes (permanent dialysis or early death). CONCLUSIONS: Renal crisis can be effectively managed when hypertension is aggressively controlled with ACE inhibitors. Patients should continue taking ACE inhibitors even after beginning dialysis in hopes of discontinuing dialysis.