Integrated surveillance of antimicrobial resistance and antimicrobial use: Evaluation of the status in Canada (2014-2019).

OBJECTIVE: Integrated surveillance of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and antimicrobial use (AMU) across One Health sectors is critically important for effective, evidence-based policy, stewardship, and control of AMR. Our objective was to evaluate progress towards achieving comprehensive, integrated AMR/AMU surveillance in Canada. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Based on an environmental scan, interviews of subject matter experts, and reports from the 2014 National Collaborating Centre for Infectious Diseases and the 2016 Canadian Council of Chief Veterinary Officers, we identified 8 core surveillance requirements and their specific components; the latter were assessed using a 2-way classification matrix, with 7 common elements ranked according to development stage. RESULTS: Components that mapped to requirements of a comprehensive, fully integrated AMR/AMU surveillance system were mostly in the lowest stages of development (Exploration or Program Adoption). However, both the establishment of the Canadian AMR Surveillance System integrated reporting and expansion of existing components under the Canadian Nosocomial Infection Surveillance Program and the Canadian Integrated Program for AMR Surveillance are improvements. Regardless, obvious gaps in Canadian AMR/AMU surveillance prevent this from being a comprehensive and integrated One Health program. CONCLUSION: Action is needed in 3 crucial areas: i) development of a complete, integrated AMR/AMU surveillance program, based on current success; ii) changes in Federal/Provincial/Territorial policies to require standardized AMR/AMU reporting; and iii) more resources for AMR/AMU surveillance (dedicated persons, funding, and enabling structures and policy). There is an urgent need for prioritization by Federal/Provincial/Territorial governments to address governance, leadership, and funding to create surveillance systems that inform stewardship and policy.

OBJECTIF: La surveillance intégrée de la résistance aux antimicrobiens (RAM) et de l'utilisation des antimicrobiens (UAM) dans les secteurs Une seule santé est d'une importance cruciale pour une politique, une gestion et une maitrise efficaces et fondées sur des preuves de la résistance aux antimicrobiens. Notre objectif était d'évaluer les progrès vers la réalisation d'une surveillance complète et intégrée de la RAM/UAM au Canada. MÉTHODES: Sur la base d'une analyse de l'environnement, d'entrevues d'experts en la matière et de rapports du Centre de collaboration nationale des maladies infectieuses de 2014 et du Conseil canadien des chefs vétérinaires de 2016, nous avons identifié huit exigences de surveillance de base et leurs composantes spécifiques ; ces derniers ont été évalués à l'aide d'une matrice de classification à deux voies, avec sept éléments communs classés selon le stade de développement. RÉSULTATS: Les composants correspondant aux exigences d'un système de surveillance de la RAM/UAM complet et entièrement intégré en étaient pour la plupart aux stades les plus bas de développement (Exploration ou Adoption de programme). Cependant, l'établissement du Système canadien de surveillance de la RAM et l'expansion des éléments existants dans le cadre du Programme canadien de surveillance des infections nosocomiales et du Programme intégré canadien de surveillance de la RAM constituent des améliorations. Quoi qu'il en soit, des lacunes évidentes dans la surveillance canadienne de la RAM/UAM l'empêchent d'être un programme Une seule santé complet et intégré. CONCLUSION: Des actions sont nécessaires dans trois domaines cruciaux : 1) le développement d'un programme de surveillance complet et intégré de la RAM/AMU, basé sur le succès actuel; 2) des changements aux politiques fédéralesprovinciales-territoriales pour exiger des rapports normalisés sur la RAM/UAM; et 3) davantage de ressources pour la surveillance de la RAM/UAM (personnes dédiées, financement, structures et politiques habilitantes). Il est urgent que les gouvernements fédéral-provincial-territorial établissent des priorités pour aborder la gouvernance, le leadership et le financement afin de créer des systèmes de surveillance qui éclairent la gouvernance et les politiques.(Traduit par Dr Serge Messier).

Integrated surveillance of antimicrobial resistance and antimicrobial use: Evaluation of the status in Canada (2014-2019).

OBJECTIVE: Integrated surveillance of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and antimicrobial use (AMU) across One Health sectors is critically important for effective, evidence-based policy, stewardship, and control of AMR. Our objective was to evaluate progress towards achieving comprehensive, integrated AMR/AMU surveillance in Canada. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Based on an environmental scan, interviews of subject matter experts, and reports from the 2014 National Collaborating Centre for Infectious Diseases and the 2016 Canadian Council of Chief Veterinary Officers, we identified 8 core surveillance requirements and their specific components; the latter were assessed using a 2-way classification matrix, with 7 common elements ranked according to development stage. RESULTS: Components that mapped to requirements of a comprehensive, fully integrated AMR/AMU surveillance system were mostly in the lowest stages of development (Exploration or Program Adoption). However, both the establishment of the Canadian AMR Surveillance System integrated reporting and expansion of existing components under the Canadian Nosocomial Infection Surveillance Program and the Canadian Integrated Program for AMR Surveillance are improvements. Regardless, obvious gaps in Canadian AMR/AMU surveillance prevent this from being a comprehensive and integrated One Health program. CONCLUSION: Action is needed in 3 crucial areas: i) development of a complete, integrated AMR/AMU surveillance program, based on current success; ii) changes in Federal/Provincial/Territorial policies to require standardized AMR/AMU reporting; and iii) more resources for AMR/AMU surveillance (dedicated persons, funding, and enabling structures and policy). There is an urgent need for prioritization by Federal/Provincial/Territorial governments to address governance, leadership, and funding to create surveillance systems that inform stewardship and policy.

RéSUMé: OBJECTIF: La surveillance intégrée de la résistance aux antimicrobiens (RAM) et de l'utilisation des antimicrobiens (UAM) dans les secteurs Une seule santé est d'une importance cruciale pour une politique, une gestion et une maitrise efficaces et fondées sur des preuves de la résistance aux antimicrobiens. Notre objectif était d'évaluer les progrès vers la réalisation d'une surveillance complète et intégrée de la RAM/UAM au Canada. MéTHODES: Sur la base d'une analyse de l'environnement, d'entrevues d'experts en la matière et de rapports du Centre de collaboration nationale des maladies infectieuses de 2014 et du Conseil canadien des chefs vétérinaires de 2016, nous avons identifié huit exigences de surveillance de base et leurs composantes spécifiques; ces derniers ont été évalués à l'aide d'une matrice de classification à deux voies, avec sept éléments communs classés selon le stade de développement. RéSULTATS: Les composants correspondant aux exigences d'un système de surveillance de la RAM/UAM complet et entièrement intégré en étaient pour la plupart aux stades les plus bas de développement (Exploration ou Adoption de programme). Cependant, l'établissement du Système canadien de surveillance de la RAM et l'expansion des éléments existants dans le cadre du Programme canadien de surveillance des infections nosocomiales et du Programme intégré canadien de surveillance de la RAM constituent des améliorations. Quoi qu'il en soit, des lacunes évidentes dans la surveillance canadienne de la RAM/UAM l'empêchent d'être un programme Une seule santé complet et intégré. CONCLUSION: Des actions sont nécessaires dans trois domaines cruciaux : 1) le développement d'un programme de surveillance complet et intégré de la RAM/AMU, basé sur le succès actuel; 2) des changements aux politiques fédérales/provinciales/territoriales pour exiger des rapports normalisés sur la RAM/UAM; et 3) davantage de ressources pour la surveillance de la RAM/UAM (personnes dédiées, financement, structures et politiques habilitantes). Il est urgent que les gouvernements fédéral/provincial/territorial établissent des priorités pour aborder la gouvernance, le leadership et le financement afin de créer des systèmes de surveillance qui éclairent la gouvernance et les politiques.

One Health Evaluation of Antimicrobial Use and Resistance Surveillance: A Novel Tool for Evaluating Integrated, One Health Antimicrobial Resistance and Antimicrobial Use Surveillance Programs.

We describe the development, application and utility of our novel, One Health Evaluation of Antimicrobial Use and Resistance Surveillance (OHE-AMURS) tool that we created to evaluate progress toward integrated, One Health surveillance of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and antimicrobial use (AMU) as a complex system in Canada. We conducted a qualitative inquiry into the current state of policy and programs for integrated AMR/AMU surveillance using explicit and tacit knowledge. To assess the "messy" state of public health surveillance program development, we synthesized recommendations from previous reports by the National Collaborating Centre for Infectious Diseases and the Canadian Council of Chief Veterinary Officers; conducted an environmental scan to find all federal, provincial, and territorial AMR/AMU surveillance programs in Canada; and conducted semi-structured interviews with Canadian subject matter experts. To integrate evidence from these different sources we adapted two published tools to create a new evaluation matrix, deriving 36 components of the ideal integrated AMR/AMU surveillance system. Our two-way matrix tool allowed us to examine seven common, foundational elements of sustainable programs for each component, and assign a stage of development/sustainability ranking for each component according to the matrix definitions. Our adaptable novel tool allowed for granular and repeatable assessment of the many components of a complex surveillance system. The assessment proved robust and exacting to ensure transparency in our methods and results. The matrix allows flexible assignment of program components based on program principles, and stages can be adapted to evaluate any aspect of an AMR/AMU surveillance or other multi-faceted, multi-jurisdictional system. Future refinement should include an assessment of the scope of surveillance components.

Enhancing nitrification at low temperature with zeolite in a mining operations retention pond.

Ammonium nitrate explosives are used in mining operations at Diavik Diamond Mines Inc. in the Northwest Territories, Canada. Residual nitrogen is washed into the mine pit and piped to a nearby retention pond where its removal is accomplished by microbial activity prior to a final water treatment step and release into the sub-Arctic lake, Lac de Gras. Microbial removal of ammonium in the retention pond is rapid during the brief ice-free summer, but often slows under ice cover that persists up to 9 months of the year. The aluminosilicate mineral zeolite was tested as an additive to retention pond water to increase rates of ammonium removal at 4°C. Water samples were collected across the length of the retention pond monthly over a year. The structure of the microbial community (bacteria, archaea, and eukarya), as determined by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis of PCR-amplified small subunit ribosomal RNA genes, was more stable during cold months than during July-September, when there was a marked phytoplankton bloom. Of the ammonia-oxidizing community, only bacterial amoA genes were consistently detected. Zeolite (10 g) was added to retention pond water (100 mL) amended with 5 mM ammonium and incubated at 12°C to encourage development of a nitrifying biofilm. The biofilm community was composed of different amoA phylotypes from those identified in gene clone libraries of native water samples. Zeolite biofilm was added to fresh water samples collected at different times of the year, resulting in a significant increase in laboratory measurements of potential nitrification activity at 4°C. A significant positive correlation between the amount of zeolite biofilm and potential nitrification activity was observed; rates were unaffected in incubations containing 1-20 mM ammonium. Addition of zeolite to retention ponds in cold environments could effectively increase nitrification rates year-round by concentrating active nitrifying biomass.