Mammography-oncogenecity at low doses.

Controversy exists regarding the biological effectiveness of low energy x-rays used for mammography breast screening. Recent radiobiology studies have provided compelling evidence that these low energy x-rays may be 4.42 +/- 2.02 times more effective in causing mutational damage than higher energy x-rays. These data include a study involving in vitro irradiation of a human cell line using a mammography x-ray source and a high energy source which matches the spectrum of radiation observed in survivors from the Hiroshima atomic bomb. Current radiation risk estimates rely heavily on data from the atomic bomb survivors, and a direct comparison between the diagnostic energies used in the UK breast screening programme and those used for risk estimates can now be made. Evidence highlighting the increase in relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of mammography x-rays to a range of x-ray energies implies that the risks of radiation-induced breast cancers for mammography x-rays are potentially underestimated by a factor of four. A pooled analysis of three measurements gives a maximal RBE (for malignant transformation of human cells in vitro) of 4.02 +/- 0.72 for 29 kVp (peak accelerating voltage) x-rays compared to high energy electrons and higher energy x-rays. For the majority of women in the UK NHS breast screening programme, it is shown that the benefit safely exceeds the risk of possible cancer induction even when this higher biological effectiveness factor is applied. The risk/benefit analysis, however, implies the need for caution for women screened under the age of 50, and particularly for those with a family history (and therefore a likely genetic susceptibility) of breast cancer. In vitro radiobiological data are generally acquired at high doses, and there are different extrapolation mechanisms to the low doses seen clinically. Recent low dose in vitro data have indicated a potential suppressive effect at very low dose rates and doses. Whilst mammography is a low dose exposure, it is not a low dose rate examination, and protraction of dose should not be confused with fractionation. Although there is potential for a suppressive effect at low doses, recent epidemiological data, and several international radiation risk assessments, continue to promote the linear no-threshold (LNT) model. Finally, recent studies have shown that magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is more sensitive than mammography in detecting invasive breast cancer in women with a genetic sensitivity. Since an increase in the risk associated with mammographic screening would blur the justification of exposure for this high risk subgroup, the use of other (non-ionising) screening modalities is preferable.

Experimental techniques for studying bystander effects in vitro by high and low-LET ionising radiation.

Ionising radiation can induce responses within non-exposed neighbouring (bystander) cells which potentially have important implications on the estimates of risk from low dose or low dose rate exposures of ionising radiations. A range of strategies have been developed for investigating bystander effects in vitro for both high-LET alpha particles or low-LET ultrasoft X rays using either partial shielding (grids, half-shields and slits) or by using a co-culture system where two physically separated populations of cells can be cultured together, allowing one population of cells to be irradiated while the second population remains unirradiated. The techniques described provide a useful tool to study bystander effects and complement microbeam studies. Studies using these systems show significant increases in the unirradiated bystander cells for various end points including the induction of chromosomal instability in haemopoetic stem cells and transformation in CGL1 cells.

Enhanced biological effectiveness of low energy X-rays and implications for the UK breast screening programme.

Recent radiobiological studies have provided compelling evidence that the low energy X-rays as used in mammography are approximately four times--but possibly as much as six times--more effective in causing mutational damage than higher energy X-rays. Since current radiation risk estimates are based on the effects of high energy gamma radiation, this implies that the risks of radiation-induced breast cancers for mammography X-rays are underestimated by the same factor. The balance of risk and benefit for breast screening have been re-analysed for relative biological effectiveness (RBE) values between 1 and 6 for mammography X-rays. Also considered in the analysis is a change in the dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor (DDREF) from 2 to 1, women with larger than average breasts and implications for women with a family history of breast cancer. A potential increase in RBE to 6 and the adoption of a DDREF of unity does not have any impact on the breast screening programme for women aged 50-70 years screened on a 3 yearly basis. Situations for which breast screening is not justified due to the potential cancers induced relative to those detected (the detection-to-induction ratio (DIR)) are given for a range of RBE and DDREF values. It is concluded that great caution is needed if a programme of early regular screening with X-rays is to be used for women with a family history of breast cancer since DIR values are below 10 (the lowest value considered acceptable for women below 40 years) even for modest increases in the RBE for mammography X-rays.

The neoplastic transformation potential of mammography X rays and atomic bomb spectrum radiation.

Considerable controversy currently exists regarding the biological effectiveness of 29 kVp X rays which are used for mammography screening. This issue must be resolved to enable proper evaluation of radiation risks from breast screening. Here a definitive assessment of the biological effectiveness of 29 kVp X rays compared to the quality of radiation to which the atomic bomb survivors were exposed is presented for the first time. The standard radiation sources used were (a) an atomic bomb simulation spectrum and (b) 2.2 MeV electrons from a strontium-90/yttrium-90 (90Sr/90Y) radioactive source. The biological end point used was neoplastic transformation in vitro in CGL1 (HeLa x human fibroblast hybrid) cells. No significant difference was observed for the biological effectiveness of the two high-energy sources for neoplastic transformation. A limiting relative biological effectiveness (RBE(M)) of 4.42 +/- 2.02 was observed for neoplastic transformation by 29 kVp X rays compared to these two sources. This compares with values of 4.67 +/- 3.93 calculated from previously published data and 3.58 +/- 1.77 when the reference radiation was 200 and 220 kVp X rays. This suggests that the risks associated with mammography screening may be approximately five times higher than previously assumed and that the risk-benefit relationship of mammography exposures may need to be re-examined.

Carcinogenic risk of hot-particle exposures.

It has been suggested that spatially non-uniform radiation exposures, such as those from small radioactive particles ('hot particles'), may be very much more carcinogenic than when the same amount of energy is deposited uniformly throughout a tissue volume. This review provides a brief summary of in vivo and in vitro experimental findings, and human epidemiology data, which can be used to evaluate the veracity of this suggestion. Overall, this supports the contrary view and indicates that average dose, as advocated by the ICRP, is likely to provide a reasonable estimate of carcinogenic risk (within a factor of approximately +/- 3). There are few human data with which to address this issue. The limited data on lung cancer mortality following occupational inhalation of plutonium aerosols, and the incidence of liver cancer and leukaemia due to thorotrast administration for clinical diagnosis, do not appear to support a significant enhancement factor. Very few animal studies, including mainly lung and skin exposures, provide any indication of a hot-particle enhancement for carcinogenicity. Some recent in vitro malignant transformation experiments provide evidence foran enhanced cell transformation for hot-particle exposures but, properly interpreted, the effect is modest. Few studies extend below absorbed doses of approximately 0.1 Gy.

An 11 year follow-up of individual radiation responses as assessed by micronuclei induction in peripheral blood lymphocytes.

In this short note we describe the results of a unique 11 year follow-up of the induction of micronuclei by radiation in three individuals. These individuals were all part of two larger studies carried out in 1987 and 1998 respectively, each having similar population characteristics. No significant differences in the average radiation response of these two populations were observed, nor were there any apparent differences in the 1987 and 1998 responses of two of the three individuals reassessed. Data from the third individual (and from a wider study reported elsewhere) do, however, provide some evidence for an age dependence. It is concluded that significant individual variations in the age-dependent responses to radiation may exist, and that while for some individuals there is no increase in radiosensitivity with age, for others there is. Such age dependences may be diluted by studying age-related responses in whole populations of limited size rather than by following individuals over a long period of time. The results reported here are from a limited data set and it is important that further studies are carried out to provide evidence for or against the existence of an age-dependent response to radiation in some individuals.

238Pu alpha-particle-induced C3H10T1/2 transformants are less tumorigenic than the X-ray-induced equivalent.

Transformation is a complex multistage process in vitro by which benign cells gradually acquire characteristics of tumour cells. Transformed C3H10T1/2 cells appear in vitro as multilayers of cells termed foci. A variety of transformed phenotypes are observed in vitro and in this study samples of these phenotypes were developed as cell lines and assessed for their ability to induce tumours in C3H mice. It was found that, while a high proportion of X-ray-induced transformants were tumorigenic, most of the alpha-particle-induced transformants were non-tumorigenic. Although tumours produced by the X-ray-induced transformants appeared earlier, they grew at similar rates to the alpha-particle-induced equivalent. Foci were classified as fully or partially tumorigenic depending on whether the foci produced at least one tumour in the mice injected (partially tumorigenic) or produced tumours in all mice injected (fully tumorigenic). It was found that tumours from the partially tumorigenic foci grew slower or appeared later than those of the fully tumorigenic foci. It is hypothesized that the apparent low tumorigenicity of positively transformed alpha-particle-induced foci is due to an increase in genomic instability of progeny focus cells compared with X-ray-induced foci leading to a larger non-viable population of cells in the alpha-particle-induced foci.

Transformation of C3H 10T1/2 cells by low doses of ionising radiation: a collaborative study by six European laboratories strongly supporting a linear dose-response relationship.

For the assessment of radiation risk at low doses, it is presumed that the shape of the low-dose-response curve in humans for cancer induction is linear. Epidemiological data alone are unlikely to ever have the statistical power needed to confirm this assumption. Another approach is to use oncogenic transformation in vitro as a surrogate for carcinogenesis in vivo. In mid-1990, six European laboratories initiated such an approach using C3H 10T1/2 mouse cells. Rigid standardisation procedures were established followed by collaborative measurements of transformation down to absorbed doses of 0.25 Gy of x-radiation resulting in a total of 759 transformed foci. The results clearly support a linear dose-response relationship for cell transformation in vitro with no evidence for a threshold dose or for an enhanced, supralinear response at doses approximately 200-300 mGy. For radiological protection this represents a large dose, and the limitations of this approach are apparent. Only by understanding the fundamental mechanisms involved in radiation carcinogenesis will further knowledge concerning the effects of low doses become available. These results will, however, help validate new biologically based models of radiation cancer risk thus providing increased confidence in the estimation of cancer risk at low doses.

Micronucleus induction in human lymphocytes: comparative effects of X rays, alpha particles, beta particles and neutrons and implications for biological dosimetry.

The cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay in peripheral blood lymphocytes has the potential for being a simple and rapid method of biological dosimetry. This technique has been used to study the induction of micronuclei in the blood from 12 donors after exposure to a range of radiations with track-averaged LET values ranging from 0.26 to 44 keV microns -1. Data based on the average response of the 12 individuals for 250 kVp X rays were found to agree well with results published previously from other laboratories using similar techniques. Low dose-limiting RBE values relative to 250 kVp X rays for the radiations studied were found to be 0.50 for strontium/yttrium-90 beta particles, 6.9 for 20-23 keV microns -1 alpha particles and 17 for 24 keV neutrons. The pattern of the variation of individual radiosensitivity was found to be complex and dependent on dose, and the evaluation of individual radiosensitivity based on the response at one dose only can be misleading. It is concluded that, although the cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay in blood lymphocytes is a radiobiologically appropriate technique to use for biological dosimetry, its practical implementation may be limited by a need to perform individual pre-exposure calibrations.

Cell survival measurements in an argon, aluminium and sulphur filtered neutron beam: a comparison with 24 keV neutrons and relevance to boron neutron capture therapy.

Boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) has been advanced as a suitable alternative therapy for the treatment of glioma. BNCT involves the selective uptake of a tumour with a boron-bearing substance and subsequent irradiation with a beam of neutrons. Previous attempts with BNCT have utilized thermal neutrons, but this involves resection of the scalp prior to treatment and is only possible with superficial tumours. An alternative is to use a beam of intermediate-energy neutrons which will produce a peak in the thermal neutron fluence at depth in tissue and so enable deep-seated tumours to be treated. A neutron beam with a mean energy of approximately 9 keV, obtained by filtering neutrons from a reactor with aluminium, argon and sulphur, has been used to explore the radiobiological advantage over thermal and 24 keV neutrons for BNCT. Irradiation of V79 and HeLa cells at various positions in a polythene phantom suggest that the beam is less cytotoxic for a given neutron fluence than the 24 keV neutron beam previously considered as an alternative to thermal neutrons for BNCT. However, optimization of boron distribution via the development of new compounds still appears to be necessary for BNCT to become a safe alternative option for the treatment of glioma.

Direct comparison between protons and alpha-particles of the same LET: I. Irradiation methods and inactivation of asynchronous V79, HeLa and C3H 10T1/2 cells.

A direct comparison was carried out of the biological effectiveness of protons and alpha-particles of the same linear energy transfer (LET) under identical conditions with a variety of in vitro biological systems. Monolayers of mammalian cells were irradiated with accelerated beams of protons (1.2 and 1.4 MeV) and alpha-particles (30 and 35 MeV) corresponding to LETs of 23 and 20 keV microns-1 for each particle type. For V79-4 cells it was observed that the linear term of the dose-response for cell inactivation by protons was significantly greater than that for alpha-particles of the same LET. For HeLa and HeLa S3 cells, also, the linear term appeared to be greater for protons, but this was not observed with more limited data for C3H 10T1/2 cells. The result for V79 cells is in agreement with the report of Belli et al. (1989) who observed that the biological effectiveness of protons rose sharply between 17 and 30 keV microns-1 in strong contrast to alpha-particles which reached a peak effectiveness at greater than 100 keV microns-1. These results place new constraints on the biologically relevant features of the microscopic structure of radiation tracks, and have implications for the mechanistic and practical comparison between radiations.

A review of boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) and the design and dosimetry of a high-intensity, 24 keV, neutron beam for BNCT research.

This paper reviews the development of boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) and describes the design and dosimetry of an intermediate energy neutron beam, developed at the Harwell Laboratory, principally for BNCT research. Boron neutron capture therapy is a technique for the treatment of gliomas (a fatal form of brain tumour). The technique involves preferentially attaching 10B atoms to tumour cells and irradiating them with thermal neutrons. The thermal neutron capture products of 10B are short range and highly damaging, so they kill the tumour cells, but healthy tissue is relatively undamaged. Early trials required extensive neurosurgery to exposure the tumour to the thermal neutrons used and were unsuccessful. It is thought that intermediate-energy neutrons will overcome many of the problems encountered in the early trials, because they have greater penetration prior to thermalization, so that surgery will not be required. An intermediate-energy neutron beam has been developed at the Harwell Laboratory for research into BNCT. Neutrons from the core of a high-flux nuclear reactor are filtered with a combination of iron, aluminium and sulphur. Dosimetry measurements have been made to determine the neutron and gamma-ray characteristics of this beam, and to monitor them throughout the four cycles used for BNCT research. The beam is of high intensity (approximately 2 x 10(7) neutrons cm-2 s-1, equivalent to a neutron kerma rate in water of 205 mGy h-1) and nearly monoenergetic (93% of the neutrons have energies approximately 24 keV, corresponding to 79% of the neutron kerma rate).

The radiobiology of 24 keV neutrons. Measurement of the relative biological effect free-in-air, survival and cytogenetic analysis of the biological effect at various depths in a polyethylene phantom and modification of the depth-dose profile by boron 10 for V79 Chinese hamster and HeLa cells.

HeLa human carcinoma cells and V79 Chinese hamster fibroblasts have been irradiated in vitro with a beam of neutrons with a nearly pure 24 keV spectrum. The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of the filtered neutron beam relative to 60Co gamma radiation was determined by irradiation of cell cultures "free-in-air". The values obtained for the RBE at 37% survival were 5.8 +/- 0.8, at a dose of 0.69 +/- 0.06 Gy for the HeLa cells and 3.14 +/- 1.1 at a dose of 1.09 +/- 0.091 Gy for the V79 cells. Cytogenetic analysis of the damage in irradiated V79 cells gave an RBE of 6.7 +/- 1.4. Irradiation in a polyethylene phantom markedly attenuated the beam's biological effect. For both cell lines 2 cm of polyethylene virtually eliminated cell killing. Addition of boron 10 to the medium led to increased cell killing and a value of 4 was obtained for the RBE of the 10B(n, alpha)7Li reaction in HeLa cells.

The interpretation of dose calculations and cell-survival measurements for the boron neutron capture therapy of brain tumours with 24 keV neurons.

Monte-Carlo computer codes have been used to estimate the distribution of doses to borated and unborated tissues in head-sized phantoms when exposed to beams of 2 keV and 24 keV neutrons. For the application of such beams to boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) these calculations show the superiority of 2 keV neutrons over 24 keV neutrons and the importance of using large-area beams. A 24 keV neutron beam has been used to irradiate HeLa cell cultures in vitro, with and without the addition of 10B, at various depths within a narrow polyethylene phantom. Survival data obtained from these experiments have been used to estimate depth-damage profiles for normal (unboronated) and tumour (boronated) brain tissues when exposed to 24 keV neutrons. A good differential between damage to normal and tumorous tissue is obtained under suitable irradiation conditions. Although lower-energy neutrons are probably preferable, these results demonstrate the possibility of using beams of 24 keV neutrons for the BNCT of brain tumours.

Inactivation of Chinese hamster V79/4(AH1) and HeLa cells by 24 keV neutrons.

Cell survival studies have been carried out with a filtered neutron beam providing a nearly pure, high intensity source of 24 keV neutrons. These suggest that 24 keV neutrons behave as high LET radiation. The RBE at 37 per cent survival was approximately 2.2 for V79 Chinese hamster cells while HeLa cells gave a value of 2.9.