Antiscalants for mitigating silica scaling in membrane desalination: Effects of molecular structure and membrane process.

Silica scaling is a major type of mineral scaling that significantly constrains the performance and efficiency of membrane desalination. While antiscalants have been commonly used to control mineral scaling formed via crystallization, there is a lack of antiscalants for silica scaling due to its unique formation mechanism of polymerization. In this study, we performed a systematic study that investigated and compared antiscalants with different functional groups and molecular weights for mitigating silica scaling in membrane distillation (MD) and reverse osmosis (RO). The efficiencies of these antiscalants were tested in both static experiments (for hindering silicic acid polymerization) as well as crossflow, dynamic MD and RO experiments (for reducing water flux decline). Our results show that antiscalants enriched with strong H-accepters and H-donors were both able to hinder silicic acid polymerization efficiently in static experiments, with their antiscaling performance being a function of both molecular functionality and weight. Although poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) with abundant H-accepters exhibited high antiscaling efficiencies during static experiments, it displayed limited performance of mitigating silica scaling during MD and RO. Poly (ethylene glycol) diamine (PEGD), which has a PEG backbone but is terminated by two amino groups, was efficient to both hinder silicic acid polymerization and reduce water flux decline in MD and RO. Antiscalants enriched with H-donors, such as poly(ethylenimine) (PEI) and poly(amidoamine) (PAMAM), were effective of extending the water recovery of MD but conversely facilitated water flux decline of RO in the presence of supersaturated silica. Further analyses of silica scales formed on the membrane surfaces confirmed that the antiscalants interacted with silica via hydrogen bonding and showed that the presence of antiscalants governed the silica morphology. Our work indicates that discrepancy in antiscalant efficiency exists between static experiments and dynamic membrane filtration as well as between different membrane processes associated with silica scaling, providing valuable insights on the design principle and mechanisms of antiscalants tailored to silica scaling.

Contrasting Behaviors between Gypsum and Silica Scaling in the Presence of Antiscalants during Membrane Distillation.

Mineral scaling is a major constraint that limits the performance of membrane distillation (MD) for hypersaline wastewater treatment. Although the use of antiscalants is a common industrial practice to mitigate mineral scaling, the effectiveness and underlying mechanisms of antiscalants in inhibiting different mineral scaling types have not been systematically investigated. Herein, we perform a comparative investigation to elucidate the efficiencies of antiscalant candidates with varied functional groups for mitigating gypsum scaling and silica scaling in MD desalination. We show that antiscalants with Ca(II)-complexing moieties (e.g., carboxyl group) are the most effective to inhibit gypsum scaling formed via crystallization, whereas amino-enriched antiscalants possess the best performance to mitigate silica scaling created by polymerization. A set of microscopic and spectroscopic analyses reveal distinct mechanisms of antiscalants required for those two common types of scaling. The mitigating effect of antiscalants on gypsum scaling is attributed to the stabilization of scale precursors and nascent CaSO4 nuclei, which hinders phase transformation of amorphous CaSO4 toward crystalline gypsum. In contrast, antiscalants facilitate the polymerization of silicic acid, immobilizing active silica precursors and retarding the gelation of silica scale layer on the membrane surface. Our study, for the first time, demonstrates that antiscalants with different functionalities are required for the mitigation of gypsum scaling and silica scaling, providing mechanistic insights on the molecular design of antiscalants tailored to MD applications for the treatment of wastewaters containing different scaling types.