Neonatal tolerance to alloantigens is induced by enriched antigen-presenting cells.

Spleen and bone marrow cells from normal or Rag-1-deficient donors are equally competent in their ability to induce neonatal transplantation tolerance in semi-allogeneic hosts, and the latter are also capable of tolerizing fully allogeneic recipients. Both types of donor cells resulted in comparable levels of haemopoietic chimerism in tolerant animals. Lymphoid hyperactivity, however, was absent in animals tolerized with Rag-1-deficient cells. The authors conclude that neonatal tolerance induced with haemopoietic cells requires no donor lymphocytes, and is thus not the result of deficient antigen presentation. Furthermore, the state of tolerance can be dissociated from the lymphoid hyperactivity that requires donor lymphocytes and is regularly scored in conventionally tolerized animals.

Differential sensitivity of B lymphocyte populations to IgM receptor ligation is determined by local factors.

Ligation of surface IgM on B cells responding to lipopolysaccharide (LPS) suppresses terminal differentiation and high-rate Ig secretion with no effect on proliferation. As shown here, different B cell populations show characteristic mean values of ligand concentration required for 50% inhibition, with Gaussian distributions of sensitivity to IgM receptor ligation that reflect cellular heterogeneity of 'al-or-none' inhibitions in single cells. Differential sensitivity of B cell populations to IgM ligation seems to be locally determined by the cellular environment and unrelated to the 'maturity' of the responding cells. Thus, while long-lived peritoneal B cells are 3- to 5-fold more resistant than splenic B cells, there is no difference in sensitivity between short- and long-lived B cells in the spleen. Furthermore, while B cells in bone marrow and spleen differ in sensitivity by two orders of magnitude, B cells differentiated in vitro from bone marrow pre-B cells are as resistant as splenic B cells. Moreover, bone marrow cell culture supernatants restore a high level of sensitivity in such cell populations. Differential sensitivity to IgM receptor ligation is reproduced by multivalent nominal antigen, in cell populations that show identical dose-response inhibition curves to direct activation of protein kinase C by phorbol esters. We conclude that the level of sensitivity to IgM ligation is independent of the life span or maturity of the B cell, but differentially regulated in vivo by putative tissue factors.

B lymphocyte sensitivity to IgM receptor ligation is independent of maturation stage and locally determined by macrophage-derived IFN-beta.

Compartmentation of B lymphocyte populations is associated with differences in both development stage and sensitivity to Ig (sIg)-dependent triggering. In order to characterize the factors that contribute in setting the level of sensitivity of a B cell, we quantified sIgM-dependent regulation of Ig secretion in purified mature and immature B cells after ex vivo and in vivo modification of their environment. These analyses formally demonstrate that the bone marrow (BM) microenvironment locally induces high B cell sensitivity to sIgM ligation irrespective of differentiation stage. We further provide evidence that BM macrophages create a dominant environment that enhances B cell sensitivity to B cell receptor triggering. Finally, using ex vivo assays as well as type I IFN receptor-deficient mice we show that IFN-beta produced by resident BM macrophages is necessary and sufficient to define B cell sensitivity. Implications of these findings for the understanding of B cell selection processes are discussed.

Establishment of tissue-specific tolerance is driven by regulatory T cells selected by thymic epithelium.

Grafts of thymic epithelium (TE) rudiments restore T cell development and function in allogeneic athymic mice. These TE chimeras are specifically tolerant to grafts of peripheral tissues (e.g. skin and heart) from the TE donor strain, although they harbor peripheral immunocompetent T cells capable of rejecting those grafts. Initial analysis has shown that TE chimeras also harbor TE-selected CD4 T lymphocytes that inhibit graft rejection by tissue-reactive T cells in immunocompetent recipients. Peripheral tolerance in TE chimeras is thus maintained by dominant mechanisms dependent on regulatory CD4 T lymphocytes. Here we show that TE-selected regulatory T cells recruit nontolerant tissue-reactive CD4 and CD8 T cells to express similar regulatory functions. Only recent thymic emigrants, but not peripheral resident mature T cells are susceptible to this process of functional education, which also requires exposure to specific antigens and occurs entirely in the periphery. We propose that these mechanisms play a major role in establishing and maintaining natural self tolerance to tissue-specific antigens.

A model for developmentally acquired thymus-dependent tolerance to central and peripheral antigens.

Current models of tolerance to peripheral, tissue-specific antigens contain some major caveats. First, they consider peripheral tolerance independently from intrathymic T cell selection, a dichotomy that is challenged by observations on TE-induced tolerance. Second, they do not account for the fact that vertebrates are more readily tolerised in development than in adult life. Third, they do not explain the fact that embryonic/neonatal tolerance to foreign tissues can only be induced by HC or TE. A model of thymic selection and peripheral tolerance is developed here that resolves those problems, by assuming two classes of T cell effector functions, one being regulatory and the other aggressive. Three postulates are required: (1) both epithelial and hemopoietic cellular compartments of the thymic stroma can support both positive and negative selection of T cells, but with vastly different avidity requirements and efficiency; (2) positively selected T cells with the highest avidity that escape deletion are activated intrathymically and irreversibly committed for regulatory effector functions; (3) the functional phenotype of all other thymic emigrants is determined in the periphery upon encounter with antigen. Functional commitment in the periphery depends on the maturity stage (RTE or PMR) of the immunocompetent cell, on the nature of the antigen-presenting cells, and on the effector classes of other T lymphocytes interacting on the same presenting cell. This model explains a number of observations on experimental autoimmune disease and transplantation tolerance, and it contains several readily testable predictions.

Evidence for a thymus-dependent form of tolerance that is not based on elimination or anergy of reactive T cells.

The avian embryo has provided an appropriate model to study the ontogeny of the primary lymphoid organs, thymus and bursa of Fabricius. By using the quail-chick marker system the embryonic origin of the highly intricate cell components which form these organs could be traced back to the initial endodermal, mesodermal and ectodermal germ layers. The timing and dynamics of the incoming and outcoming flows of hemopoietic cells which characterize their lymphopoietic activity could be revealed in both quail and chick embryos. This knowledge served as a basis for an investigation on the role of the epithelial component of the thymus (derived from the pharyngeal endoderm) on tolerance to tissue graft and, by extension, tolerance to self. When this work was undertaken, the prevailing view was that exposure of the developing immune system to foreign antigens in the embryo allows them to be assimilated to self components in the mature animal. In fact, this was found to be true for allogeneic grafts between MHC-distinct chickens, of certain tissues, such as for instance wing tissues. However, in heterospecific transplantations, i.e. when a limb bud was grafted from quail to chick embryos, the chick host acutely rejected the foreign limb soon after birth. In contrast, grafts of the quail thymic epithelial (TE) rudiment resulted in the development of a chimeric thymus in which the foreign epithelial component was not only tolerated but able to induce full tolerance of the grafted wing from the same donor. By monitoring the amount of quail TE implanted we showed in addition that only part of the peripheral T-cell population had to differentiate in the context of the quail epithelial cells to induce tolerance to quail tissues. This pointed to the generation in the thymus of regulatory T cells, coexisting with specific anti-quail reactive T cells, but able to inhibit them from reacting against the quail wing antigenic determinants. A mammalian model was then devised to further study this mechanism of tolerance that we have qualified as "dominant" by opposition to the current model based on either clonal elimination or anergy which can be considered as recessive or passive. Nude mice of MHC type A were grafted with TE of E10 type B embryos. They became reconstituted for T-cell function but tolerant for B skin allografts. Spleen cells from such tolerant animals injected to naive A nude mice reconstituted T cell function in the recipient and transferred the tolerance to B skin grafts. Reducing the number of donor cells resulted in the segregation of the two phenomena. For low numbers the recipients were restored but not tolerant, thus showing the coexistence in the tolerant donor of anti-B reactive T cells together with regulatory cells able to abolish their reactivity against B determinants. Other experiments demonstrated that TE-induced tolerance does not rely on clonal deletion or anergy. This was shown on systems where elimination of cells directed toward superantigens was screened. It turned out that tolerance to skin grafts and superantigen T-cell deletion are unrelated phenomena. These observations strongly suggest that tolerance to self results at least in part from the interplay between cells potentially harmful for self component and others which exert a strong control on their reactivity. The latter cell type depends upon interactions of thymocytes with the endodermal component of the thymus.

Regulatory T cells in thymic epithelium-induced tolerance. I. Suppression of mature peripheral non-tolerant T cells.

Athymic mice grafted at birth with allogeneic thymic epithelium (TE) display life-long tolerance to tissue grafts of the TE donor strain, in spite of harboring peripheral T cells capable of rejecting those grafts. Tolerance is maintained in these chimeras by TE-specific regulatory CD4 T cells. We presently address the quantification and the mechanisms of this dominant tolerance process. C57BL/6 mice containing variable but defined numbers of peripheral, resident T cells received cell transfers of graded numbers of peripheral T cells from B6(BALB E10) chimeras (C57BL/6 nude mice grafted with TE from 10-day-old BALB/c embryos), resulting in a series of animals containing a wide range of donor (tolerant) versus host (non-tolerant) T cell chimerism. Increasing the relative representation of donor T cells results in a progressive delay in the rejection of BALB/c skin grafts, life-long tolerance being achieved at a ratio of tolerant and non-tolerant T cell populations of 1. In recipients displaying full tolerance, graft-reactive non-tolerant T cells were not deleted, anergized or committed to noninflammatory functions. Thus, sorted host T cells from tolerant recipients readily rejected BALB/c skin grafts upon transfer to immunodeficient animals. Finally, measurements of "helper" and inflammatory activities, as well as interleukin-4 and interferon-gamma production, failed to discriminate between T cell populations from tolerant and non-tolerant animals after specific in vitro stimulation. We conclude that: (a) TE-selected regulatory T cells can suppress, in a quantitative manner, in vivo T cell responses against major and minor histocompatibility antigens expressed by the TE and, (b) this suppressive activity neither inactivates mature non-tolerant T cells, nor does it seem to drive their differentiation along noninflammatory pathways.

Lymphocytes selected in allogeneic thymic epithelium mediate dominant tolerance toward tissue grafts of the thymic epithelium haplotype.

Athymic mice grafted at birth with allogeneic thymic epithelium (TE) from day 10 embryos before hematopoietic cell colonization reconstitute normal numbers of T cells and exhibit full life-long tolerance to skin grafts of the TE haplotype. Intravenous transfers of splenic cells, from these animals to adult syngeneic athymic recipients, reconstitute T-cell compartments and the ability to reject third-party skin grafts. The transfer of specific tolerance to skin grafts of the TE donor strain, however, is not observed in all reconstituted recipients, and the fraction of nontolerant recipients increases with decreasing numbers of cells transferred. Furthermore, transfers of high numbers of total or CD4+ T cells from TE chimeras to T-cell receptor-anti-H-Y antigen transgenic immunocompetent syngeneic hosts specifically hinder the rejection of skin grafts of the TE haplotype that normally occurs in such recipients. These observations demonstrate (i) that mice tolerized by allogeneic TE and bearing healthy skin grafts harbor peripheral immunocompetent T cells capable of rejecting this very same graft; and (ii) that TE selects for regulatory T cells that can inhibit effector activities of graft-reactive cells.

Differential contribution of thymic outputs and peripheral expansion in the development of peripheral T cell pools.

The number of peripheral T cells in mice increases up to 100-fold in the first few weeks of life. We have followed the fate of Thy-1 congenic T cells transferred into newborn recipients, to evaluate the relative contribution of thymic output versus peripheral expansion in the constitution of peripheral T cell pools during post-natal development. The results show that in normal animals there is essentially no peripheral expansion of T cells, which show slow turnover rates (1 to 2 months) along that time period. The rates of cell accumulation in the periphery require, therefore, an average of 1 x 10(6)-2 x 10(6) mature thymic emigrants/day for the first 3 weeks of life.

Suppression of B cell differentiation by ligation of membrane-bound IgM.

Using B cells from the transgenic mouse line B6-Sp6 and control littermates, stimulated by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) under novel culture conditions that provide for the response of all B cells, we show here that specific ligation of the surface IgM molecules always results in inhibition of terminal differentiation and immunoglobulin secretion by activated cells, regardless of the ligand. Thus, monoclonal antibodies to (a) the CH region of Ig (anti-mu and anti-allotype), (b) the C kappa region, (c) the V region (anti-idiotype) of surface IgM, as well as (d) multivalent antigen (2,4,6-trinitrophenyl-bovine serum albumin), all show similar effects and dose-response curves. IgD-negative transgenic B cells are equally sensitive to IgM ligation-dependent inhibition, as control (IgD-positive) B cells. The allotype specificity of this inhibition, assessed by using anti-mu allotype reagents to inhibit and assay the responses, suggests that B cells expressing transgenic or endogenous IgM in transgenic B6-Sp6 mice are largely independent populations. These observations establish that anti-IgM antibodies in conjunction with appropriate LPS stimulation, provide a universal model system for functional characterization of B cell responses.