Recommended Best Practices in Freeze Dryer Equipment Performance Qualification: 2022.

Best practices for performing freeze dryer equipment qualification are recommended, focusing on identifying methods to quantify shelf thermal uniformity (also known as "shelf surface uniformity"), equipment capability, and performance metrics of the freeze dryer essential to the pharmaceutical Quality by Design paradigm. Specific guidelines for performing shelf temperature mapping, freeze dryer equipment limit testing (the capability curve), and condenser performance metrics have been provided. Concerning shelf temperature mapping and equipment capability measurements, the importance of paying attention to the test setup and the use of appropriate testing tools are stressed. In all the guidelines provided, much attention has been paid to identifying the balance between obtaining useful process knowledge, logistical challenges associated with testing in the production environment vs that at laboratory scale, and the frequency of the testing necessary to obtain such useful information. Furthermore, merits and demerits of thermal conditions maintained on the cooled surfaces of the freeze dryer condenser have been discussed identifying the specific influence of the condenser surface temperature on the process conditions using experimental data to support the guidelines. Finally, guidelines for systematic leak rate testing criteria for a freeze dryer are presented. These specific procedural recommendations are based on calculations, measurements, and experience to provide useful process and equipment knowledge.

The graphical design space for the primary drying phase of freeze Drying: Factors affecting the dried product layer resistance.

An emerging approach to process development of a lyophilized pharmaceutical product is to construct a graphical design space for primary drying as an aid to process optimization. The purpose of this paper is to further challenge the assumption in earlier work that the maximum values of the resistance of dried product layer, Rp, is approximately constant and is independent of process conditions within the "acceptable" region of the design space. Three model formulations containing bovine serum albumin as the model protein were chosen to represent: (a) an amorphous system, (b) a crystalline system, and (c) a mixed system where both an amorphous and a crystalline component were present. Low temperature differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and freeze dry microscopy (FDM) experiments were conducted to estimate critical product temperature. A conservative lyophilization cycle was conducted for each formulation to collect mass flow data and individual design spaces were then established. A series of lyophilization cycles were then conducted using process conditions that resided within the individual design space and the resultant product temperature and resistance of dried product layer (Rp) values were compared between the individual cycles within each formulation. The data indicated that the Rp was component dependent with the mannitol formulation exhibiting higher Rp values than the sucrose formulation. Interestingly, when mannitol was retained amorphous, the formulation exhibited a lower Rp, similar to that of the sucrose formulation. The mixed formulation exhibited intermediate Rp values. Crystallization of mannitol is hypothesized to facilitate a decrease in the size of the ice porous structure by making the water vapor flow path tortuous, thereby increasing the Rp of mannitol formulations. Within the "acceptable" zone of the individual design space, Rp was dependent on the process condition with more aggressive shelf temperature cycles resulting in lower Rp. Specific Surface Area measurements of freeze-dried solids demonstrated that more aggressive conditions resulted in smaller surface area. Freeze-dried solids of crystalline formulations consistently exhibited higher specific surface area than the amorphous formulations.

Stability of antibody drug conjugate formulations evaluated using solid-state hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry.

Antibody drug conjugates (ADCs) have been at the forefront in cancer therapy due to their target specificity. All the FDA approved ADCs are developed in lyophilized form to minimize instability associated with the linker that connects the cytotoxic drug and the antibody during shipping and storage. We present here solid-state hydrogen-deuterium exchange with mass spectrometric analysis (ssHDX-MS) as a tool to analyze protein structure and matrix interactions for formulations of an ADC with and without commonly used excipients. We compared results of the ssHDX-MS with accelerated stability results using size-exclusion chromatography and determined that the former technique was able to successfully identify the destabilizing effects of mannitol and polysorbate 80. In comparison, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy results were inconclusive. The agreement between ssHDX-MS and stressed stability studies supports the potential of ssHDX-MS as a method of predicting relative stability of different formulations.

Equipment Capability Measurement of Laboratory Freeze-Dryers: a Comparison of Two Methods.

The objective of this investigation was to evaluate two methods for measuring the maximum sublimation rate that a freeze-dryer will support-the minimum controllable pressure method and the choke point method. Both methods gave equivalent results, but the minimum controllable pressure method is preferred, since it is easier, faster, and less subjective. The ratio of chamber pressure to condenser pressure corresponding to the onset of choked flow was considerably higher in this investigation (up to about 20:1) than in previously published reports. This ratio was not affected by the location of the pressure gauge on the condenser; that is, on the foreline of the vacuum pump versus on the body of the condenser itself. The total water loss due to sublimation as measured by tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy was consistently within 5% of gravimetrically determined weight loss, regardless of whether the measurement took place during choked versus non-choked process conditions.

Stability of Freeze-Dried Protein Formulations: Contributions of Ice Nucleation Temperature and Residence Time in the Freeze-Concentrate.

Controlling ice nucleation, at a fixed higher temperature, results in larger ice crystals, which can reduce the ice/freeze-concentrate interface area where proteins can adsorb and partially unfold. Moreover, limited work has been done to address any effects on short-term stability due to a slow ramp or long isothermal hold after the ice nucleation step. The objective was to evaluate the effect of the ice nucleation temperature and residence time in the freeze-concentrate on in-process or storage stability of representative proteins, human IgG, and recombinant human serum albumin. The results suggest a higher ice nucleation temperature can minimize aggregation of protein pharmaceuticals, which are labile at ice/aqueous interface. Apart from the ice nucleation step, the present study identified the residence time in the freeze-concentrate as the critical factor that influences protein stability post ice nucleation. At a temperature where enough mobility exists (i.e., above Tg' of the formulation), the long residence time in the freeze-concentrate can result in significant protein aggregation during the process. In addition to stability, the findings revealed that not only the ice nucleation temperature but also the thermal history of the formulation post ice nucleation defines the surface area of ice and the porous structure of the freeze-dried cake.

Freeze-Dryer Equipment Capability Limit: Comparison of Computational Modeling With Experiments at Laboratory Scale.

The equipment capability curve is one of the bounding elements of the freeze-drying design space, and understanding it is critical to process design, transfer, and scale-up. The second bounding element of the design space is the product temperature limit beyond which the product collapses. The high cost associated with freeze-drying any product renders it crucial to operate using the most efficient cycle within the limits of the equipment and the product. In this work, we present a computational model to generate the equipment capability curve for 2 laboratory scale freeze-dryers and compare the results to experimentally generated equipment capability curves. The average deviations of the modeling results from the experiments for the 2 lyophilizers modeled are -4.8% and -7.2%. In addition, we investigate the effect of various numerical and geometric parameters on the simulated equipment capability. Among the numerical parameters, the chamber wall thermal boundary conditions exert the largest influence with a maximum value of 12.3%. Among the geometric parameters, the inclusion of the isolation valve reduces the equipment capability by 23.7%. Larger isolation valves, required for controlled nucleation technology, choke the flow in the duct at lower sublimation rates, thereby lowering the equipment capability limit.

Experimental Aspects of Measuring the Vial Heat Transfer Coefficient in Pharmaceutical Freeze-Drying.

One of the current methods for cycle optimization in primary drying to is develop a graphical design space based on quality by design (QbD). In order to construct the design space, the vial heat transfer coefficient (Kv) is needed. This paper investigated experimental factors that can affect the Kv result, examined the relationship between the batch average Kv and Kv values for individual vials, and recommended best practices for measuring Kv. Factors investigated included the technique for measuring ice temperature, shelf temperature, the use of a radiation shield on the door of the freeze-dry chamber, and shelf spacing. All experiments reported here used a chamber pressure of 100 mTorr. The most important factor was the technique for ice temperature measurement, where it is important to assure that any restrictions to vapor flow at the top of the vial are the same between monitored and non-monitored vials. Another factor that was found to play a role was the shelf temperature whereby the lower the shelf temperature, the larger the "edge effect," and the larger the average Kv. Factors that were found to not have a significant effect were the use of a radiation shield inside the chamber door and the shelf spacing. Being aware of these factors and knowing best practices when determining the vial heat coefficient will lead to more accurate design spaces and better cycle optimization.

The Influence of Mannitol Hemihydrate on the Secondary Drying Dynamics of a Protein Formulation: A Case Study.

The objective of this research was to study the atypical secondary drying dynamics observed during the freeze-drying of a formulation consisting of mannitol, disaccharide, and sodium chloride, where "bursts" of water vapor release were observed during secondary drying as detected by comparative pressure measurement. "Thief" samples were removed at the end of primary drying and during secondary drying as the shelf temperature was increased in a stepwise fashion. These samples were examined by X-ray powder diffraction and thermal analysis. From the X-ray powder diffraction data, we determined that mannitol crystallized predominantly as its hemihydrate. The physical state of mannitol changed from the hemihydrate form to anhydrous forms during secondary drying. Investigation of the effect of excipients on mannitol crystallization demonstrated that sodium chloride (at 225 mM, 1.3% w/v) had the greatest influence on hemihydrate crystallization, followed by trehalose and sucrose. However, only negligible hemihydrate formation was observed when mannitol was freeze-dried either by itself or in the presence of 150 mM sodium chloride and no hemihydrate in the presence of 75 mM sodium chloride. In general, a combination of a disaccharide and sodium chloride promoted the hemihydrate formation to a greater extent than the individual components. Comparative pressure measurement was demonstrated to be an effective tool to monitor mannitol hemihydrate dehydration during secondary drying.

Lyophilized Drug Product Cake Appearance: What Is Acceptable?

Cake appearance is an important attribute of freeze-dried products, which may or may not be critical with respect to product quality (i.e., safety and efficacy). Striving for "uniform and elegant" cake appearance may continue to remain an important goal during the design and development of a lyophilized drug product. However, "sometimes" a non-ideal cake appearance has no impact on product quality and is an inherent characteristic of the product (due to formulation, drug product presentation, and freeze-drying process). This commentary provides a summary of challenges related to visual appearance testing of freeze-dried products, particularly on how to judge the criticality of cake appearance. Furthermore, a harmonized nomenclature and description for variations in cake appearance from the ideal expectation of uniform and elegant is provided, including representative images. Finally, a science and risk-based approach is discussed on establishing acceptance criteria for cake appearance.

Process and Formulation Effects on Protein Structure in Lyophilized Solids Using Mass Spectrometric Methods.

Myoglobin (Mb) was lyophilized in the absence (Mb-A) and presence (Mb-B) of sucrose in a pilot-scale lyophilizer with or without controlled ice nucleation. Cake morphology was characterized using scanning electron microscopy, and changes in protein structure were monitored using solid-state Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, solid-state hydrogen-deuterium exchange-mass spectrometry, and solid-state photolytic labeling-mass spectrometry (ssPL-MS). The results showed greater variability in nucleation temperature and irregular cake structure for formulations lyophilized without controlled nucleation. Controlled nucleation resulted in nucleation at ∼(-5°C) and uniform cake structure. Formulations containing sucrose showed better retention of protein structure by all measures than formulations without sucrose. Samples lyophilized with and without controlled nucleation were similar by most measures of protein structure. However, ssPL-MS showed the greatest photoleucine incorporation and more labeled regions for Mb-B lyophilized with controlled nucleation. The data support the use of solid-state hydrogen-deuterium exchange-mass spectrometry and ssPL-MS to study formulation and process-induced conformational changes in lyophilized proteins.

A proposed rationale and test methodology for establishment of acceptance criteria for vacuum integrity testing of pharmaceutical freeze dryers.

A scientific rationale is proposed for the establishment of acceptance criteria for leak rates in pharmaceutical freeze dryers. A method was developed to determine the quantity of air that could leak into any lyophilizer from the outside while still maintaining Class 100/Grade A microbial conditions. A lyophilizing product is assumed most vulnerable to microbial contamination during secondary drying, when mass transfer of water vapor from product to condenser is minimal. Using the void volume of the dryer, calculated from change in internal pressure when a known volume of air is introduced, and the potential maximum bioburden of the leaked air (based on measured values), calculations can determine the allowable leaked volume of air, the flow rate required to admit that volume in a given time frame, and the pressure rise that would result from the leak over a given testing period. For the dryers in this study, using worst-case air quality conditions, it was determined that a leak resulting in a pressure rise of 0.027 mbar over a 30 min period would allow the dryers to remain in secondary drying conditions for 62 h before the established action level of one colony forming unit for each cubic meter of air space would be reached.

Experimental determination of the key heat transfer mechanisms in pharmaceutical freeze-drying.

The study is aimed at quantifying the relative contribution of key heat transfer modes in lyophilization. Measurements of vial heat transfer rates in a laboratory-scale freeze-dryer were performed using pure water, which was partially sublimed under various conditions. The separation distance between the shelf and the vial was systematically varied, and sublimation rates were determined gravimetrically. The heat transfer rates were observed to be independent of separation distance between the vial and the shelf and linearly dependent on pressure in the free molecular flow limit, realized at low pressures (<50 mTorr). However, under higher pressures (>120 mTorr), heat transfer rates were independent of pressure and inversely proportional to separation distance. Previous heat transfer studies in conventional freeze-drying cycles have attributed a dominant portion of the total heat transfer to radiation, the rest to conduction, whereas convection has been found to be insignificant. Although the measurements reported here confirm the significance of the radiative and gas conduction components, the convective component has been found to be comparable to the gas conduction contribution at pressures greater than 100 mTorr. The current investigation supports the conclusion that the convective component of the heat transfer cannot be ignored in typical laboratory-scale freeze-drying conditions.

Quality by design in formulation and process development for a freeze-dried, small molecule parenteral product: a case study.

A case study has been developed to illustrate one way of incorporating a Quality by Design approach into formulation and process development for a small molecule, freeze-dried parenteral product. Sodium ethacrynate was chosen as the model compound. Principal degradation products of sodium ethacrynate result from hydrolysis of the unsaturated ketone in aqueous solution, and dimer formation from a Diels-Alder condensation in the freeze-dried solid state. When the drug crystallizes in a frozen solution, the eutectic melting temperature is above -5°C. Crystallization in the frozen system is affected by pH in the range of pH 6-8 and buffer concentration in the range of 5-50 mM, where higher pH and lower buffer concentration favor crystallization. Physical state of the drug is critical to solid state stability, given the relative instability of amorphous drug. Stability was shown to vary considerably over the ranges of pH and buffer concentration examined, and vial-to-vial variability in degree of crystallinity is a potential concern. The formulation design space was constructed in terms of pH and drug concentration, and assuming a constant 5 mM concentration of buffer. The process design space is constructed to take into account limitations on the process imposed by the product and by equipment capability.

Controlled nucleation in freeze-drying: effects on pore size in the dried product layer, mass transfer resistance, and primary drying rate.

A novel and scalable method has been developed to enable control of the ice nucleation step for the freezing process during lyophilization. This method manipulates the chamber pressure of the freeze dryer to simultaneously induce nucleation in all product vials at a desired temperature. The effects of controlled nucleation on the drying rate of various formulations including 5% (w/w) mannitol, 5% (w/w) sucrose, and a mixture of 3% (w/w) mannitol and 2% (w/w) sucrose were studied. For a 5% (w/w) mannitol, uncontrolled ice nucleation occurred randomly at product temperatures between -8.0°C and -15.9°C as the vials were cooled to -40°C. Controlled ice nucleation was achieved at product temperatures between -2.3°C and -3.7°C. The effect of nucleation control on the effective pore radius (r(e) ) of the cake was determined from the product temperature profiles using a pore diffusion model in combination with a nonlinear parameter estimation approach reported earlier. Results show that the value of r(e) for 5% (w/w) mannitol was enlarged from 13 to 27 µm by uniformly inducing nucleation at higher temperatures. Applying the resistance parameters obtained from the pore diffusion model for 5% (w/w) mannitol, optimized cycles were theoretically generated and experimentally tested, resulting in a 41% reduction in primary drying time.

Computational analysis of fluid dynamics in pharmaceutical freeze-drying.

Analysis of water vapor flows encountered in pharmaceutical freeze-drying systems, laboratory-scale and industrial, is presented based on the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) techniques. The flows under continuum gas conditions are analyzed using the solution of the Navier-Stokes equations whereas the rarefied flow solutions are obtained by the direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) method for the Boltzmann equation. Examples of application of CFD techniques to laboratory-scale and industrial scale freeze-drying processes are discussed with an emphasis on the utility of CFD for improvement of design and experimental characterization of pharmaceutical freeze-drying hardware and processes. The current article presents a two-dimensional simulation of a laboratory scale dryer with an emphasis on the importance of drying conditions and hardware design on process control and a three-dimensional simulation of an industrial dryer containing a comparison of the obtained results with analytical viscous flow solutions. It was found that the presence of clean in place (CIP)/sterilize in place (SIP) piping in the duct lead to significant changes in the flow field characteristics. The simulation results for vapor flow rates in an industrial freeze-dryer have been compared to tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy (TDLAS) and gravimetric measurements.

Rapid freeze-drying cycle optimization using computer programs developed based on heat and mass transfer models and facilitated by tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy (TDLAS).

Computer programs in FORTRAN were developed to rapidly determine the optimal shelf temperature, T(f), and chamber pressure, P(c), to achieve the shortest primary drying time. The constraint for the optimization is to ensure that the product temperature profile, T(b), is below the target temperature, T(target). Five percent mannitol was chosen as the model formulation. After obtaining the optimal sets of T(f) and P(c), each cycle was assigned with a cycle rank number in terms of the length of drying time. Further optimization was achieved by dividing the drying time into a series of ramping steps for T(f), in a cascading manner (termed the cascading T(f) cycle), to further shorten the cycle time. For the purpose of demonstrating the validity of the optimized T(f) and P(c), four cycles with different predicted lengths of drying time, along with the cascading T(f) cycle, were chosen for experimental cycle runs. Tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy (TDLAS) was used to continuously measure the sublimation rate. As predicted, maximum product temperatures were controlled slightly below the target temperature of -25 degrees C, and the cascading T(f)-ramping cycle is the most efficient cycle design. In addition, the experimental cycle rank order closely matches with that determined by modeling.

Ice nucleation temperature influences recovery of activity of a model protein after freeze drying.

The objective of this study was to determine whether a relationship exists between ice nucleation temperature and recovery of activity of a model protein, lactate dehydrogenase, after freeze drying. Aqueous buffer systems containing 50 microg/mL of protein were frozen in vials with externally mounted thermocouples on the shelf of a freeze dryer, then freeze dried. Various methods were used to establish a wide range of ice nucleation temperatures. An inverse relationship was found between the extent of supercooling during freezing and recovery of activity in the reconstituted solution. The data are consistent with a mechanism of inactivation resulting from adsorption of protein at the ice/freeze-concentrate interface during the freezing process.

Evidence of partial unfolding of proteins at the ice/freeze-concentrate interface by infrared microscopy.

The goal of this research was to use infrared spectroscopy in combination with a freeze drying stage to gain a better understanding of the mechanism of loss of protein integrity due to the stresses associated with freezing. Infrared spectra were collected in triplicate for the interstitial space between ice crystals and through ice crystals in a partially frozen system. Spectra were collected for lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and human immune globulin (IgG) both in the presence and absence of an added surfactant (polysorbate 80). Spectra collected in the interstitial space, distant from the surface of ice crystals, were very similar to spectra collected from the initial solution regardless of the presence of a surfactant. Spectra collected through ice crystals, without added surfactant, were significantly different than spectra collected from the initial solution. An increase in bands characteristic of intermolecular beta-sheet structures (main component of aggregates) were present in these spectra. The presence of surfactant in both protein formulations resulted in a decrease in intermolecular beta-sheet signals in spectra of the proteins on the ice crystal surface. Additionally, much of the native state structure of LDH initially lost on the surface of ice crystals returned when surfactant was added to the formulation prior to freezing.

Thermal analysis of frozen solutions: multiple glass transitions in amorphous systems.

Frozen aqueous solutions of sucrose exhibit two "glass transition-like" thermal events below the melting endotherm of ice when examined by DSC, but the physical basis of these events has been a source of some disagreement. In this study, a series of sugars, including sucrose, lactose, trehalose, maltose, fructose, galactose, fucose, mannose, and glucose were studied by modulated DSC and freeze-dry microscopy in order to better understand whether sucrose is unique in any way with respect to this behavior, as well as to explore the physical basis, and the pharmaceutical significance of these multiple transitions. Double transitions were found to be a common feature of all sugars examined. The results are consistent with both thermal events being glass transitions in that (1) both events have second-order characteristics that appear in the reversing signals, (2) annealing experiments reveal that enthalpy recovery is associated with each transition, and (3) Lissajous plots indicate that no detectable latent heat of melting is associated with either transition. The data in this study are consistent with the idea that the lower temperature transition arises from a metastable glassy mixture containing more water than that in the maximally freeze-concentrated solute. Freeze-dry microscopy observations show that for all of the sugars examined, it is the higher temperature transition that is associated with structural collapse during freeze-drying. There is no apparent pharmaceutical significance associated with the lower-temperature transition.

Influence of ethanol on physical state of freeze-dried mannitol.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study is to characterize freeze-dried mannitol prepared from an ethanol-containing solution as a function of the ethanol ratio, mannitol concentration, and annealing in the freeze-drying cycle. METHODS: The characteristics of the freeze-dried mannitol were evaluated by X-ray diffractometry (XRD) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The reconstitution time was measured for the freeze-dried solids as well as the residual moisture and ethanol by Karl-Fischer titration and gas chromatography, respectively. RESULTS: The XRD pattern of 5% (w/v) mannitol freeze-dried from aqueous solution with no annealing cycle showed all the five characteristic peaks at 13.6 degrees and 17.2 degrees 2theta for the alpha polymorph, at 14.6 degrees and 23.4 degrees 2theta for the beta polymorph and at 9.7 degrees 2theta for the delta polymorph. The addition of ethanol to the initial solutions resulted in only a peak at 9.7 degrees 2theta, indicating the presence of only the delta polymorph, regardless of the ethanol ratio in the initial solutions used [10, 20, 30, and 40% (v/v)]. However, annealing during freeze-drying influenced the XRD pattern; in particular, for the solid prepared from the 10% ethanol solution. Annealing of the 10% ethanol solution promoted the formation of the alpha polymorph and produced a different peak that might be attributable to another polymorph. In DSC thermograms, an endotherm and a subsequent exotherm were found in the temperature range of 150 degrees C to 160 degrees C, which corresponded to the transition of the delta form to alpha or beta forms. The magnitude of this transition was smaller as the ethanol ratio increased for the solids from ethanol-containing solutions with an annealing cycle. In other words, annealing of the ethanol-containing solutions promoted delta polymorph formation in the lyophiles. In addition, the mannitol concentration affected the polymorphism in freeze-dried solids prepared from aqueous and 10% ethanol solutions. Addition of ethanol in the initial solution, in particular, at a lower ethanol level (10% v/v), and a higher concentration of mannitol could also promote the generation of lumps in freeze-dried solids during reconstitution, and result in longer reconstitution time. The residual moisture levels were less than 0.5%, and residual ethanol levels were less than 0.1%, irrespective of the formulation used. CONCLUSIONS: The physical state and reconstitution time of the freeze-dried mannitol appears to be a complex function of the ethanol and mannitol concentrations in the initial solution before freeze-drying and of annealing during the freeze-drying process.