Contribution of aromatic-aromatic interactions to the anomalous pK(a) of tyrosine-9 and the C-terminal dynamics of glutathione S-transferase A1-1.

Most cytosolic glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) exploit a hydrogen bond between an active site Tyr and the bound glutathione (GSH) cofactor to lower the pK(a) of the GSH and generate the nucleophilic thiolate anion, GS(-). In human (hGSTA1-1) and rat (rGSTA1-1) homologues, the active site Tyr-9 has a low pK(a) of 8.1-8.3, for which the functional significance is unknown. Crystal structures of GSTA1-1 suggest that weakly polar interactions between the electropositive ring edge of Phe-10 and the pi-cloud of Tyr-9, in the apoenzyme, could stabilize the tyrosinate anion and also modulate the pK(a) of GSH. Upon binding a product GSH conjugate, Phe-10 moves away from Tyr-9, allowing the highly dynamic C-terminus to "close" over the active site. To explore the role of Phe-10 in modulating the Tyr-9 pK(a) and in ligand binding, rGSTA1-1 mutants F10Y, F10L, and F10A were characterized. The pK(a)s of Tyr-9 in the apoenzymes were 8.2 +/- 0.2, 8.7 +/- 0.2, and 9.3 +/- 0.1, respectively, for F10Y, F10L, and F10A, compared to 8.3 +/- 0.2 for the "wild type". The experimentally determined pK(a)s qualitatively paralleled the energies required to remove a proton predicted by ab initio calculations using model compounds constrained to the coordinates of rGSTA1-1. The pK(a) of GSH in the binary complex was significantly less affected by these substitutions. In contrast, F220I and F220Y C-terminal mutations caused the pK(a) of Tyr-9 to decrease modestly. For the binary complex with S-hexyl-GSH, which induces the "closed" conformation, Tyr-9 retains a low pK(a) and the Phe-10 substitutions have significant effects. Presumably, Phe-10 plays a critical structural role in stabilizing the closed conformation. The mutations F10L and F10A also slowed the rate of GSH conjugate binding by 10-20-fold, as measured by stopped-flow fluorescence. The effects of Phe-10 substitution were large for both steps of the biphasic binding reaction, suggesting the importance of aromatic interactions throughout the reaction coordinate. A unified view of the C-terminal dynamics of GSTA1-1 is discussed, which emphasizes the coupling between Tyr-9 ionization, active site solvation, and C-terminal dynamics.

The C-terminus of glutathione S-transferase A1-1 is required for entropically-driven ligand binding.

Binding of a hydrophobic glutathione product conjugate to rGST A1-1 proceeds via a two-step mechanism, including rapid ligand docking, followed by a slow isomerization to the final [GST.ligand] complex, which involves the localization of the flexible C-terminal helix. These kinetically resolved steps have been observed previously by stopped-flow fluorescence with the wild-type rGST A1-1, which contains a native Trp-21 approximately 20 A from the ligand binding site at the intrasubunit domain-domain interface. To confirm this binding mechanism, as well as elucidate the effects of truncation of the C-terminus, we have further characterized the binding and dissociation of the glutathione-ethacrynic acid product conjugate (GS-EA) to wild-type, F222W:W21F, and Delta209-222 rGST A1-1 and wild-type hGST A1-1. Although modest kinetic differences were observed between the hGST A1-1 and rGST A1-1, stopped-flow binding studies with GS-EA verified that the two-step mechanism of ligand binding is not unique to the GST A1-1 isoform from rat. An F222W:W21F rGST A1-1 double mutant provides a direct fluorescence probe of changes in the environment of the C-terminal residue. The observation of two relaxation times during ligand binding and dissociation to F222W:W21F suggests that the C-terminus has an intermediate conformation following ligand docking, which is distinct from its conformation in the apoenzyme or localized helical state. For the wild-type, Delta209-222, and F222W:W21F proteins, variable-temperature stopped-flow experiments were performed and activation parameters calculated for the individual steps of the binding reaction. Activation parameters for the binding reaction coordinate illustrate that the C-terminus provides a significant entropic contribution to ligand binding, which is completely realized within the initial docking step of the binding mechanism. In contrast, the slow isomerization step is enthalpically driven. The partitioning of entropic and enthalpic components of binding energy was confirmed by isothermal titration calorimetry with wild-type and Delta209-222 rGST A1-1.

Localization of the C-terminus of rat glutathione S-transferase A1-1: crystal structure of mutants W21F and W21F/F220Y.

Twelve C-terminal residues of human glutathione S-transferase A1-1 form a helix in the presence of glutathione-conjugate, or substrate alone, and partly cover the active site. According to X-ray structures, the helix is disordered in the absence of glutathione, but it is not known if it is helical and delocalized, or in a random-coil conformation. Mutation to a tyrosine of residue 220 within this helix was previously shown to affect the pK(a) of Tyr-9 at the active site, in the apo form of the enzyme, and it was proposed that an on-face hydrogen bond between Tyr-220 and Tyr-9 provided a means for affecting this pK(a). In the current study, X-ray structures of the W21F and of the C-terminal mutation, W21F/F220Y, with glutathione sulfonate bound, show that the C-terminal helix is disordered (or delocalized) in the W21F crystal but is visible and ordered in a novel location, a crystal packing crevice, in one of three monomers in the W21F/F220Y crystal, and the proposed hydrogen bond is not formed. Fluorescence spectroscopy studies using an engineered F222W mutant show that the C-terminus remains delocalized in the absence of glutathione or when only the glutathione binding site is occupied, but is ordered and localized in the presence of substrate or conjugate, consistent with these and previous crystallographic studies. Proteins 2001;42:192-200.

The catalytic Tyr-9 of glutathione S-transferase A1-1 controls the dynamics of the C terminus.

The glutathione S-transferase enzymes (GSTs) have a tyrosine or serine residue at their active site that hydrogen bonds to and stabilizes the thiolate anion of glutathione, GS(-). The importance of this hydrogen bond is obvious, in light of the enhanced nucleophilicity of GS(-) versus the protonated thiol. Several A-class GSTs contain a C-terminal segment that undergoes a ligand-dependent local folding reaction. Here, we demonstrate the effects of the Y9F substitution on binding affinity for glutathione conjugates and on rates of the order-disorder transition of the C terminus in rat GST A1-1. The equilibrium binding affinity of the glutathione conjugate, GS-NBD (NBD-Cl, 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1, 3-diazole), was decreased from 4.09 microm to 0.641 microm upon substitution of Tyr-9 with Phe. This result was supported by isothermal titration calorimetry, with K(d) values of 1.51 microm and 0.391 microm for wild type and Y9F, respectively. The increase in binding affinity for the mutant is associated with dramatic decreases in rates for the C-terminal order-disorder transition, based on a stopped-flow kinetic analysis. The same effects were observed, qualitatively, for a second GSH conjugate, GS-ethacrynic acid. Apparently, the phenolic hydroxyl group of Tyr-9 is critical for orchestrating C-terminal dynamics and efficient product release, in addition to its role in lowering the pK(a) of GSH.

The locally denatured state of glutathione S-transferase A1-1: transition state analysis of ligand-dependent formation of the C-terminal helix.

On the basis of available x-ray structures, A-class glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) contain at their C-termini a short alpha-helix that provides a 'lid' over the active site in the presence of the reaction products, glutathione-conjugates. However, in the ligand-free enzyme this helix is disordered and crystallographically invisible. An aromatic cluster including Phe-10, Phe-220, and the catalytic Tyr-9 within the C-terminal strand control the order of this helix. Here, preliminary x-ray crystallographic analyses of the wild type and F220Y rGSTA1-1 in the presence of GSH are described. Also, a transition state analysis is presented for ligand-dependent formation of the helix, based on variable temperature stopped-flow fluorescence. Together, the results suggest that the ligand-dependent ordering of the C-terminal strand occurs with a transition state that is highly desolvated, but with few intramolecular hydrogen bonds or electrostatic interactions. However, substitutions at Phe-220 modulate the activation parameters through interactions with the side chain of Tyr-9.

Stopped-flow kinetic analysis of the ligand-induced coil-helix transition in glutathione S-transferase A1-1: evidence for a persistent denatured state.

Structural studies have suggested that the glutathione S-transferase (GST) A1-1 isozyme contains a dynamic C-terminus which undergoes a ligand-dependent disorder-order transition and sequesters substrates within the active site. Here, the contribution of the C-terminus to the kinetics and thermodynamics of ligand binding and dissociation has been determined. Steady-state turnover rates of the wild type (WT) and a C-terminal truncated (Delta209-222) rGST A1-1 with ethacrynic acid (EA) were measured in the presence of variable concentrations of viscogen. The results indicate that a physical step involving segmental protein motion is at least partially rate limiting at temperatures between 10 and 40 degrees C for WT. Dissociation rates of the glutathione-ethacrynic acid product conjugate (GS-EA), determined by stopped-flow fluorescence, correspond to the steady-state turnover rates. In contrast, the chemical step governs the turnover reaction by Delta209-222, suggesting that the slow rate of product release for WT is controlled by the dynamics of the C-terminal coil-helix transition. In addition, the association reaction of WT rGST A1-1 with GS-EA established that the binding was biphasic and included ligand docking followed by slow isomerization of the enzyme-ligand complex. In contrast, binding of GS-EA to Delta209-222 was a monophasic, bimolecular reaction. These results indicate that the binding of GS-EA to WT rGST A1-1 proceeds via an induced fit mechanism, with a slow conformational step that corresponds to the coil-helix transition. However, the biphasic dissociation kinetics for the wild type, and the recovered kinetic parameters, suggest that a significant fraction of the [GST.GS-EA] complex ( approximately 15%) retains a persistent disordered state at equilibrium.

Thiol ester hydrolysis catalyzed by glutathione S-transferase A1-1.

rGSTA1-1 has been shown to catalyze the hydrolysis of the thiol ester glutathionyl ethacrynate (E-SG). In contrast, neither the retro-Michael addition with the substrate EA-SG, to yield GSH and ethacrynic acid (EA), nor the conjugation reaction between GSH and EA to yield the thiol ester E-SG was catalyzed to any measurable extent under similar conditions. The steady state kcat and KM for hydrolysis of E-SG by wild type rGSTA1-1 were 0.11 +/- 0.009 min-1 and 15.7 +/- 1.6 mM, respectively. The site-directed mutant, Y9F, in which the catalytic Tyr-9 is substituted with Phe, was completely inactive in this reaction. To uncover a mechanistic signature that would distinguish between direct hydrolysis and covalent catalysis involving acylation of Tyr-9, solvent isotope exchange and mass spectrometry experiments were performed. No 18O incorporation into the starting thiol ester was detected with initial velocity solvent isotope exchange experiments. However, covalent adducts corresponding to acylated protein also were not observed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, even with an assay that minimized the experimental dead time and which allowed for detection of N-acetyltyrosine acylated with EA in a chemical model system. The kon and koff rate constants for association and dissociation of E-SG were determined, by stopped flow fluorescence, to be 5 x 10(5) s-1 M-1 and 6.7 s-1, respectively. Together with the isotope partitioning results, these rate constants were used to construct partial free energy profiles for the GST-catalyzed hydrolysis of E-SG, assuming that Tyr-9 acts as a general acid-base catalyst. The "one-way flux" of the thiol esterase reaction results directly from the thermodynamic stability of the products after rate-limiting attack of the thiol ester by H2O or Tyr-9, and is sufficient to drive the hydrolysis to completion, in contrast to GST-catalyzed breakdown of other GSH conjugates.