Application and use of isothermal calorimetry in pharmaceutical development.

There are many steps involved in developing a drug candidate into a formulated medicine and many involve analysis of chemical interaction or physical change. Calorimetry is particularly suited to such analyses as it offers the capacity to observe and quantify both chemical and physical changes in virtually any sample. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) is ubiquitous in pharmaceutical development, but the related technique of isothermal calorimetry (IC) is complementary and can be used to investigate a range of processes not amenable to analysis by DSC. Typically, IC is used for longer-term stability indicating or excipient compatibility assays because both the temperature and relative humidity (RH) in the sample ampoule can be controlled. However, instrument design and configuration, such as titration, gas perfusion or ampoule-breaking (solution) calorimetry, allow quantification of more specific values, such as binding enthalpies, heats of solution and quantification of amorphous content. As ever, instrument selection, experiment design and sample preparation are critical to ensuring the relevance of any data recorded. This article reviews the use of isothermal, titration, gas-perfusion and solution calorimetry in the context of pharmaceutical development, with a focus on instrument and experimental design factors, highlighted with examples from the recent literature.

Quantitative analysis of solid-state processes studied with isothermal microcalorimetry.

Quantitative analysis of solid-state processes from isothermal microcalorimetric data is straightforward if data for the total process have been recorded and problematic (in the more likely case) when they have not. Data are usually plotted as a function of fraction reacted (α); for calorimetric data, this requires knowledge of the total heat change (Q) upon completion of the process. Determination of Q is difficult in cases where the process is fast (initial data missing) or slow (final data missing). Here we introduce several mathematical methods that allow the direct calculation of Q by selection of data points when only partial data are present, based on analysis with the Pérez-Maqueda model. All methods in addition allow direct determination of the reaction mechanism descriptors m and n and from this the rate constant, k. The validity of the methods is tested with the use of simulated calorimetric data, and we introduce a graphical method for generating solid-state power-time data. The methods are then applied to the crystallization of indomethacin from a glass. All methods correctly recovered the total reaction enthalpy (16.6 J) and suggested that the crystallization followed an Avrami model. The rate constants for crystallization were determined to be 3.98 × 10(-6), 4.13 × 10(-6), and 3.98 × 10(-6) s(-1) with methods 1, 2, and 3, respectively.

Development of an isothermal heat-conduction photocalorimeter.

Assessing photostability (particularly of pharmaceuticals) is of growing importance, but hampered by a lack of reliable, rapid experimental testing protocols and instrumentation. In particular, most approaches require irradiation of the sample separately from the analytical measurement, which increases both experimental complexity and the number of assumptions that must be made when calculating stability. One technique that may obviate this is photocalorimetry, principally because the reporter of change (heat) is measured directly as a sample is irradiated. Although not a new idea, the design challenges of photocalorimeters are complex, primarily because light power is being introduced to the calorimeter which can thus both saturate the amplifiers and swamp the response of the sample. Careful instrument design is thus paramount. The aim of this work was to develop a robust, compact, and easy to use photocalorimeter with the immediate focus of developing photostability assays for pharmaceuticals. The final instrument design, arrived at through a series of iterative design modifications, is based on a twin differential heat-conduction principle and achieves an average base line deflection of -0.04+/-0.11 microW with light irradiating the sample cell. The performance capabilities of the instrument were demonstrated using a model system; the photodegradation of 2-nitrobenzaldehyde in solution.

Application of chemometric analysis to complexity in isothermal calorimetric data.

The interpretation of complexity in isothermal calorimetric data is demanding. The observed power signal is a composite of the powers arising from each of the individual events occurring (which can involve physical, as well as chemical, change). The challenge, therefore, lies in deconvoluting the observed data into their component parts. Here, we discuss the potential use of chemometric analysis, because it offers the significant advantage of being model-free, using principal component analysis to deconvolute data. Using model data, we discovered that the software required a minimum trivariate data matrix to be constructed. Two variables, power and time, were available from the raw data. Selection of a third variable was more problematic, but it was found that by running multiple experiments the small variation in the number of moles of compound in each experiment was sufficient to allow a successful analysis. In general we noted that it required a minimum 2n + 2 repeat experiments to allow analysis (where n is the number of reaction processes). The data outputted from the chemometric software were of the form intensity (arbitrary units) versus time, reflecting the fact that the software was written for analysis of spectroscopic data. We provide a mathematical treatment of the data that allows recovery of both reaction enthalpy and rate constants. The study demonstrates that chemometric analysis is a promising approach for the interpretation of complex calorimetric data.

A comparison of chemical reference materials for solution calorimeters.

Solution calorimeters are based on semi-adiabatic or isothermal heat-conduction principles and differ in the way they record data. They also have different measuring sensitivities and require different quantities of solute and solvent. As such, the choice of chemical test substance is not straightforward. Usually the dilution of KCl is recommended; it is possible to purchase a reference sample of KCl that has a certified enthalpy of solution and this standard material is usually used to test semi-adiabatic instruments. Here, we review the suitability of a range of chemical test substances (KCl, sucrose and Tris) for an isothermal heat-conduction solution calorimeter. It was found that KCl was not the best test material because its relatively high enthalpy of solution (DeltasolH) necessitated the use of small samples (2 mg), resulting in a relatively large standard deviation (sigman-1) in the values recorded (DeltasolH=17.14+/-0.49 kJ mol-1); furthermore, KCl data must be corrected to account for the effect of dilution, although the correction was found to be small (0.07 kJ mol-1) under the experimental conditions employed here. Sucrose appears to be a much more robust test material for isothermal heat-conduction instruments because its lower enthalpy of solution allows the use of much larger samples (20 mg), which minimises experimental errors. The DeltasolH value returned (6.14+/-0.08 kJ mol-1) is in excellent agreement with the literature. It is also cheap, readily available and requires minimal preparation although its widespread use would require the preparation of a certified reference sample.

Interaction of phloretin and 6-ketocholestanol with DPPC-liposomes as phospholipid model membranes.

Phloretin and 6-ketocholestanol are penetration enhancers for percutaneous delivery of certain topically applied drugs. In the present study some physicochemical experiments have been performed to elucidate the mechanism of action of phloretin and 6-ketocholestanol. The penetration enhancing effect of phloretin and 6-ketocholestanol is believed to be due to their increase of the fluidity of the intercellular lipid bilayers of the stratum corneum. Phospholipid vesicles were chosen as a simple model to represent these bilayers. The effect of phloretin and 6-ketocholestanol on phase transition temperature and enthalpy was studied using differential scanning calorimetry. Beside of that the size of liposomes was monitored when the amount of penetration enhancer in the liposome preparation was changed. Addition of increasing amounts of phloretin and 6-ketocholestanol to the bilayer resulted in lowering of phase transition temperatures and increasing the enthalpy. Additionally the size of the liposomes was increased when penetration enhancer was added. The results suggest that phloretin as well as 6-ketocholestanol would interact with stratum corneum lipids in a similar manner, both reduce the diffusional resistance of the stratum corneum to drugs with balanced hydrophilic-lipophilic characteristics.

Stability assessment of pharmaceuticals by isothermal calorimetry: two component systems.

Isothermal calorimetry offers the potential to determine rapidly the stability of formulated pharmaceuticals because it is indifferent to physical form and sensitive enough to detect extremely small powers; ca. 50 nW at 25 degrees C. However, its use in this area is not widespread, principally because the power-time data obtained often comprise contributions from more than one process and are thus difficult to analyse quantitatively. In this work, we demonstrate how power-time data recorded for systems in which two components are degrading in parallel (in this case, binary mixtures of selected parabens) can be analysed using a kinetic-based model; the methodology allows the determination of the first-order rate constant and reaction enthalpy for each process, so long as one rate constant is at least twice the magnitude of the other. It was found that the reactions did not need to run to completion in order for the analysis to be successful; a minimum of 15 min of data were required for samples with one degrading component and a minimum of 4 h of data were required for samples with two degrading components. It was observed that the rate constants for paraben degradation in binary systems were significantly lower than expected. This was ascribed to the fact that the parabens degrade to a common product and is an important factor that should be accounted for when the two or more parabens are formulated together.

Antimicrobial properties of silver-containing wound dressings: a microcalorimetric study.

The studies reported here have been undertaken to assess the potential use of isothermal microcalorimetry in studying the antimicrobial efficacy of wound dressings that contain antimicrobial agents. The microcalorimetric technique allows non-invasive and non-destructive analysis to be performed directly on a test sample, regardless of whether it is homogeneous or heterogeneous in nature. Microcalorimetry is an established procedure that offers quantitative measurements and has the distinct advantage over traditional antimicrobial test methodologies in that calorimetric measurements are made continuously over real-time, thus the dynamic response of microorganisms to an antimicrobial agent is observed in situ. The results described in this paper are for interaction of two silver-containing wound care products AQUACEL Ag Hydrofiber (ConvaTec, Deeside, UK) and Acticoat 7 with SILCRYST (Smith and Nephew Healthcare, UK) with the wound pathogenic organisms Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Both dressings are shown, microcalorimetrically, to have the capacity to kill these common wound pathogens within 1-2 h of contact. A dose-response study was conducted with the AQUACEL Ag dressing. Microcalorimetry is shown to be rapid, simple and effective in the study of the antimicrobial properties of gel forming wound dressings.