Can Awaji ALS criteria provide earlier diagnosis than the revised El Escorial criteria?

BACKGROUND: Recently, new electrophysiological ALS criteria incorporating fasciculation potentials (FPs) as evidence for lower motor neuron signs (Awaji Criteria (AC)) was proposed to provide earlier detection of early-stage ALS than revised El Escorial electrophysiological criteria (REEC). However, serial electrophysiological analysis is lacking to ascertain the original intention. The objective for this study was to elucidate whether electrophysiological criteria set for AC detects ALS earlier than REEC's counterpart in patients with ALS. METHODS: Of the 51 patients who were clinically suspected of ALS, 35 patients prospectively received serial electrophysiological studies every 3 months until (1) both electrophysiological AC and REEC criteria were met in more than two muscles representing both of the cervical and lumbosacral segments or (2) either clinically definite or clinically probable REEC criteria was met. The intervals were determined between the initial disease onset and when the respective electrophysiological criteria were met. RESULTS: Electrophysiological diagnostic criteria were met in 94.3% by AC and 40% by REEC at the initial visits. The intervals between the disease onset and the time of meeting the electrophysiological criteria were shorter in AC (mean: 9.0 months) than in REEC (mean: 15.2 months) (P<0.01). Eleven patients who met only AC electrophysiological criteria on the initial study subsequently met REEC electrophysiological criteria with the mean interval of 3.8 months. A higher percentage of bulbar-type ALS (83.3%) met AC than limb-onset ALS (43.4%) (P<0.05). FPs tended to be more frequently observed than fib/psw in the muscles outside the region of initial clinical onset. CONCLUSION: Electrophysiological criteria of AC were met earlier than that of REEC in ALS patients, especially in patients with bulbar onset. Early recognition of ALS by AC may allow effective therapeutic intervention in the early disease stage.

Peripheral nerve excitability measures at different target levels: the effects of aging and diabetic neuropathy.

Threshold tracking testing has provided novel insights of peripheral nerve excitability in normal and pathologic conditions. However, little has been known on the nerve excitability properties of axons with different stimulation thresholds and the effects of aging and peripheral neuropathy to those. We performed multiple nerve excitability tests in normal controls divided into three age groups and in patients with diabetic neuropathy, which were recorded at three target levels (10%, 40%, and 60% of the maximum motor response amplitudes). In all the control groups, tracking at low target level shows smaller threshold change by hyperpolarizing stimuli and greater threshold change by depolarizing stimuli, suggestive of greater transient Na current. Normal elderly showed greater threshold change by hyperpolarizing pulse than younger subjects at high target level, likely reflecting decrease of axon diameters. Patients with diabetic neuropathy showed smaller threshold changes by both depolarizing and hyperpolarizing pulses ("fanning-in"), more noticeably at the lower target level, suggestive of the combined effects of membrane depolarization and greater decrease of axonal diameters in smaller fibers. Given the reported unpredictable electrical recruitment order in the diseased conditions and difference of nerve excitability measures in threshold electrotonus at different target levels, comparing threshold electrotonus values between normal and diseased axons may be problematic by comparing axons with different nerve excitability characteristics.

Utility of recovery cycle with two conditioning pulses for detection of impaired axonal slow potassium current in ALS.

OBJECTIVE: Slow potassium current (I(Ks)) is important in controlling nerve excitability and its impairment is known in various neurological diseases, including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). I(Ks) gives rise to the late subexcitability phase of the recovery cycle, which can be amplified by the use of multiple conditioning pulses. The clinical utility of this technique has not previously been explored. METHODS: Nerve excitability tests, including recovery cycles with single and double conditioning pulses 4ms apart (RC and RC2, respectively) were performed in patients with ALS and control subjects. Late subexcitability values obtained by RC and RC2 were compared in both groups. RESULTS: RC2 was well tolerated in all the subjects. The threshold changes in late subexcitability by RC2 were greater than those by RC in both groups (mean (%): RC, 16.0/13.3; RC2, 34.9/29.4 (Control/ALS)). The ALS group showed lower threshold changes than controls by both methods. Statistical analysis between the ALS and control groups provided smaller P value by RC2 (P=0.018) than by RC (P=0.046). Also, RC2 provided non-significant, but slightly more distinguishing non-parametric rank analysis and greater Area Under the Curve (AUC) by Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC). RC2 produced more identifiable single peak for late subexcitability than RC in an ALS patient whose late subexcitability was decreased. CONCLUSIONS: Two conditioning stimuli provide greater threshold change for late subexcitability and possibly clearer identification of a peak threshold change than conventional recovery cycle. The findings obtained by this new protocol reinforce the previously reported impairment of I(Ks) in ALS. SIGNIFICANCE: Amplification of I(Ks) by double conditioning pulses is applicable in humans and may help elucidating its clinical significance in pathophysiology in neurological diseases.

Threshold-dependent effects on peripheral nerve in vivo excitability properties in the rat.

Various factors, including maturity, have been shown to influence peripheral nerve excitability measures, but little is known about differences in these properties between axons with different stimulation thresholds. Multiple nerve excitability tests were performed on the caudal motor axons of immature and mature female rats, recording from tail muscles at three target compound muscle action potential (CMAP) levels: 10%, 40% ("standard" level), and 60% of the maximum CMAP amplitude. Compared to lower target levels, axons at high target levels have the following characteristics: lower strength-duration time constant, less threshold reduction during depolarizing currents and greater threshold increase to hyperpolarizing currents, most notably to long hyperpolarizing currents in mature rats. Threshold-dependent effects on peripheral nerve excitability properties depend on the maturation stage, especially inward rectification (Ih), which becomes inversely related to threshold level. Performing nerve excitability tests at different target levels is useful in understanding the variation in membrane properties between different axons within a nerve. Because of the threshold effects on nerve excitability and the possibility of increased variability between axons and altered electric recruitment order in disease conditions, excitability parameters measured only at the "standard" target level should be interpreted with caution, especially the responses to hyperpolarizing currents.