Effects of target-amplitude and background-contrast uncertainty predicted by a normalized template-matching observer.

When detecting targets under natural conditions, the visual system almost always faces multiple, simultaneous, dimensions of extrinsic uncertainty. This study focused on the simultaneous uncertainty about target amplitude and background contrast. These dimensions have a large effect on detection and vary greatly in natural scenes. We measured the human performance for detecting a sine-wave target in white noise and natural-scene backgrounds for two levels of prior probability of the target being present. We derived and tested the ideal observer for white-noise backgrounds, a special case of a template-matching observer that dynamically moves its criterion with the background contrast (the DTM observer) and two simpler models with a fixed criterion: the template-matching (TM) observer and the normalized template-matching (NTM) observer that normalizes template response by background contrast. Simulations show that, when the target prior is low, the performance of the NTM observer is near optimal and the TM observer is near chance, suggesting that manipulating the target prior is valuable for distinguishing among models. Surprisingly, we found that the NTM and DTM observers better explain human performance than the TM observer for both target priors in both background types. We argue that the visual system most likely exploits contrast normalization, rather than dynamic criterion adjustment, to deal with simultaneous background contrast and target amplitude uncertainty. Finally, our findings show that the data collected under high levels of uncertainty have a rich structure capable of discriminating between models, providing an alternative approach for studying high dimensions of uncertainty.

Stereo slant discrimination of planar 3D surfaces: Frontoparallel versus planar matching.

Binocular stereo cues are important for discriminating 3D surface orientation, especially at near distances. We devised a single-interval task where observers discriminated the slant of a densely textured planar test surface relative to a textured planar surround reference surface. Although surfaces were rendered with correct perspective, the stimuli were designed so that the binocular cues dominated performance. Slant discrimination performance was measured as a function of the reference slant and the level of uncorrelated white noise added to the test-plane images in the left and right eyes. We compared human performance with an approximate ideal observer (planar matching [PM]) and two subideal observers. The PM observer uses the image in one eye and back projection to predict a test image in the other eye for all possible slants, tilts, and distances. The estimated slant, tilt, and distance are determined by the prediction that most closely matches the measured image in the other eye. The first subideal observer (local planar matching [LPM]) applies PM over local neighborhoods and then pools estimates across the test plane. The second suboptimal observer (local frontoparallel matching [LFM]) uses only location disparity. We find that the ideal observer (PM) and the first subideal observer (LPM) outperforms the second subideal observer (LFM), demonstrating the additional benefit of pattern disparities. We also find that all three model observers can account for human performance, if two free parameters are included: a fixed small level of internal estimation noise, and a fixed overall efficiency scalar on slant discriminability.

Rapid Motion Adaptation Reveals the Temporal Dynamics of Spatiotemporal Correlation between ON and OFF Pathways.

At the early stages of visual processing, information is processed by two major thalamic pathways encoding brightness increments (ON) and decrements (OFF). Accumulating evidence suggests that these pathways interact and merge as early as in primary visual cortex. Using regular and reverse-phi motion in a rapid adaptation paradigm, we investigated the temporal dynamics of within and across pathway mechanisms for motion processing. When the adaptation duration was short (188 ms), reverse-phi and regular motion led to similar adaptation effects, suggesting that the information from the two pathways are combined efficiently at early-stages of motion processing. However, as the adaption duration was increased to 752 ms, reverse-phi and regular motion showed distinct adaptation effects depending on the test pattern used, either engaging spatiotemporal correlation between the same or opposite contrast polarities. Overall, these findings indicate that spatiotemporal correlation within and across ON-OFF pathways for motion processing can be selectively adapted, and support those models that integrate within and across pathway mechanisms for motion processing.

Audiovisual associations alter the perception of low-level visual motion.

Motion perception is a pervasive nature of vision and is affected by both immediate pattern of sensory inputs and prior experiences acquired through associations. Recently, several studies reported that an association can be established quickly between directions of visual motion and static sounds of distinct frequencies. After the association is formed, sounds are able to change the perceived direction of visual motion. To determine whether such rapidly acquired audiovisual associations and their subsequent influences on visual motion perception are dependent on the involvement of higher-order attentive tracking mechanisms, we designed psychophysical experiments using regular and reverse-phi random dot motions isolating low-level pre-attentive motion processing. Our results show that an association between the directions of low-level visual motion and static sounds can be formed and this audiovisual association alters the subsequent perception of low-level visual motion. These findings support the view that audiovisual associations are not restricted to high-level attention based motion system and early-level visual motion processing has some potential role.