Toxicologic Pathology Forum: Opinion on Approaches for Reporting Toxic and Adverse Dose Levels in Nonclinical Toxicology Studies Supporting the Development of Anticancer Pharmaceuticals.

The advancement of an investigational new drug in humans is a significant developmental milestone. In first-in-human (FIH)-enabling toxicology studies, the highest dose without a test article-related adverse effect (no-observed-adverse-effect-level [NOAEL]) serves as the basis for deriving a safe FIH starting dose. For anticancer pharmaceuticals, the FIH dose may be calculated using the highest non-severely toxic dose (HNSTD) in nonrodent models or the dose severely toxic to 10% (STD10) in rodents. Given the practice of reporting the NOAEL, but the lack of regulatory requirements to do so for anticancer pharmaceuticals, we conducted an informal survey of 20 companies to answer the question "How is our industry reporting toxic/adverse dose levels in FIH-enabling toxicology studies for anticancer indications?" The data indicated 4 reporting approaches, each providing a path to regulatory acceptance. Within the integrated toxicology study report, 45% of respondents report the HNSTD/STD10, 25% report the NOAEL, 20% report both the HNSTD/STD10 and NOAEL, and 10% do not define either, reserving definitions for regulatory submissions. One reporting approach may be preferred over another for reasons including consistency across indications, repurposing pharmaceuticals, regulatory feedback, or simplicity. The reporting approach should be defined in advance of study initiation, and the pathologist should provide context to support the chosen approach.

Society of Toxicologic Pathology Nonhuman Primate Special Interest Group: Idiopathic Femoral Head Chondrolysis in Nonclinical Research Macaques.

Idiopathic femoral head chondrolysis is a recognized condition in human adolescents and has previously been reported in two macaques at a biomedical research facility. A cluster of coxofemoral joint abnormalities consistent with this condition affecting seven cynomolgus macaques over a four-month period in 2016 and 2017 was observed at a single, nonclinical contract research facility, prompting enhanced physical examination screening efforts during animal receipt and pre-study evaluation to identify additional affected animals. This article summarizes the results of this investigation from November 2016 to March 2021, yielding 97 total cases for an overall incidence of 0.54% (97/17,898 macaques). Affected animals were presented with one or more of the following unilateral or bilateral findings on physical examination and/or diagnostic imaging: lameness, palpable coxofemoral joint abnormalities, femoral head atrophy with variable loss of articular cartilage and irregularity of the femoral head surface, enlarged joint space with effusion, and increased radiographic density of the femoral head. This condition prevented use of affected animals on study for 54% of the cases (52/97 animals). Recognition of this idiopathic condition is important in drug safety evaluation studies to distinguish it from test article-related effects.

Idiopathic Aneurysms of the Ascending Aorta in the Mouse and Rat.

Aneurysms of the ascending aorta, unrelated to xenobiotic administration, are described in 5 rats and 2 mice in nonclinical safety studies conducted at Charles River Laboratories (CRL) sites over the past 10 years. The most prominent microscopic finding was focal dilation with disruption of the wall of the ascending aorta with chronic adventitial inflammation or fibroplasia. The pathogenesis of this finding is unknown. There were no associated macroscopic findings, clinical abnormalities, or vascular lesions elsewhere. The results of a search of historical control data from toxicology studies of 1 day to 72 weeks' duration performed at CRL for aortic findings from 5900 mice and 23,662 rats are also reported. Aortic lesions are uncommon in mice and rats used in nonclinical safety studies, but toxicologic pathologists should be aware that aneurysms of the ascending aorta with fibroplasia and inflammation in the aortic wall and adventitia may occur spontaneously or iatrogenically, as they have the potential to impact interpretation in toxicology studies.

Ketamine/Xylazine Anesthesia-Related Corneal Lesions in Rats With Surgically Implanted Venous Catheters Utilized in Nonclinical Intravenous Studies.

Nonclinical rodent studies with repeat slow intravenous dosing, such as safety assessments of anticancer therapeutics, often require the use of animals with surgically implanted catheters. Catheterization is a relatively short surgical procedure but requires use of anesthesia. Ketamine/xylazine injectable anesthesia is typically used because it has advantages over inhalation anesthesia including ease of administration, safety and predictability of effects, and relatively low cost. However, ketamine/xylazine anesthesia in rodents can also be associated with the development of undesirable corneal lesions of uncertain mechanism such as mineralization of Bowman's membrane or stroma, erosion/ulceration, inflammation, fibroplasia, and neovascularization. Such findings have the potential to confound study interpretation in programs for which the cornea is a potential target tissue. This case report describes the occurrence of ketamine/xylazine-related corneal lesions observed in surgically catheterized rats in a 16-day toxicity study for an oncology compound.

Scientific Regulatory Policy Committee Points to Consider*: Nuisance Factors, Block Effects, and Batch Effects in Nonclinical Safety Assessment Studies.

Detection of test article-related effects and the determination of the adversity of those changes are the primary goals of nonclinical safety assessment studies for drugs and chemicals in development. During these studies, variables that are not of primary interest to investigators may change and influence data interpretation. These variables, often referred to as "nuisance factors," may influence other groups of data and result in "block or batch effects" that complicate data interpretation. Definitions of the terms "nuisance factors," "block effects," and "batch effects," as they apply to nonclinical safety assessment studies, are reviewed. Multiple case examples of block and batch effects in safety assessment studies are provided, and the challenges these bring to pathology data interpretation are discussed. Methods to mitigate the occurrence of block and batch effects in safety assessment studies, including statistical blocking and utilization of study designs that minimize potential confounding variables, incorporation of adequate randomization, and use of an appropriate number of animals or repeated measurement of specific parameters for increased precision, are reviewed. [Box: see text].

Toxicologic Pathology Forum*: Commentary on "Opinion on Designation of Adverse and Nonadverse Histopathological Findings in Toxicity Studies: The Pathologist's Dilemma".

In the article "Opinion on Designation of Adverse and Nonadverse Histopathological Findings in Toxicity Studies: The Pathologist's Dilemma," the authors Gopinath and Mowat provide a framework for designation of adversity supplemented with photomicrographic examples. Given that adversity designation can significantly impact the no observed adverse effect level and clinical trial design, it is important to carefully consider all of the criteria by which such assignments are made. We highlight some of the specific assertions within the article that could benefit from a more detailed discussion. Our primary criticism surrounds the authors' primary reliance on histopathology in isolation for adversity designation, which in our opinion provides an overly simplified depiction of the process. We provide additional perspective on how context beyond histopathology often plays a critical role in adversity designation and highlight areas where inclusion of some of these scenarios would have provided the reader a more realistic view of the complex process of assigning adversity. * This is an opinion article submitted to the Toxicologic Pathology Forum. It represents the views of the authors. It does not constitute an official position of the Society of Toxicologic Pathology, British Society of Toxicological Pathology, or European Society of Toxicologic Pathology, and the views expressed might not reflect the best practices recommended by these Societies. This article should not be construed to represent the policies, positions, or opinions of their respective organizations, employers, or regulatory agencies.

A Comparison of Spontaneous Tumors in Tg.rasH2 Mice in 26-week Carcinogenicity Studies Conducted at a Single Test Facility during 2004 to 2012 and 2013 to 2018.

This article presents the historical control data of spontaneous tumors in Tg.rasH2 published in 2013 (2004-2012) and compares and contrasts it to more recent data collected from 2013 to 2018, reporting differences in the average percentage incidences or incidence ranges as well as the incidence of new tumors. In 2013, we published a comprehensive review of spontaneous tumors in Tg.rasH2 mice used in 26-week carcinogenicity studies, which included data from control dose groups from 26 studies and a total of 710 mice per sex. The total database, now including the more recent data, has nearly doubled the number of animals, completing to date a total of 52 studies in males and 51 studies in females for a total of 1,615 male mice and 1,560 female mice, respectively. In this article, we compare the data collected from 2004 to 2012 against the data collected from 2013 to 2018 and the overall tumor incidence change.

Good Laboratory Practice in the Academic Setting: Fundamental Principles for Nonclinical Safety Assessment and GLP-Compliant Pathology Support When Developing Innovative Biomedical Products.

Development of new biomedical products necessitates nonclinical safety assessment in animals as a means of assessing potential risk to human patients. Pivotal nonclinical safety studies that support human clinical trials are performed according to Good Laboratory Practice (GLP) guidelines, which are designed to ensure that the study was conducted under carefully controlled conditions using standardized and validated procedures that will yield a reliable, reproducible, and traceable data set. The GLP guidelines established by different regulatory agencies address organizational structure, personnel responsibilities, personnel training practices, quality assurance (ensuring compliance), facilities, equipment, standard operating procedures, study documentation (record keeping), and record and sample retention. Academic institutions engaging in nonclinical safety assessment on-site have multiple options for implementing a GLP quality system. This article outlines the rationale supporting the use of a GLP-compliant or GLP-like quality system in academia and reviews key concepts needed to efficiently and effectively implement GLP in the academic setting. Emphasis is given to provision of GLP-compliant pathology support as (1) pathology data are an essential component of GLP nonclinical safety testing, (2) familiarity with pathology-related GLP procedures typically is gained first outside the academic setting, and (3) microscopic pathology diagnoses and interpretations require special accommodations to ensure that they are undertaken in a GLP-compliant fashion.

Blood-Brain Barrier Transport, Plasma Pharmacokinetics, and Neuropathology Following Chronic Treatment of the Rhesus Monkey with a Brain Penetrating Humanized Monoclonal Antibody Against the Human Transferrin Receptor.

A monoclonal antibody (mAb) against the blood-brain barrier (BBB) transferrin receptor (TfR) is a potential agent for delivery of biologic drugs to the brain across the BBB. However, to date, no TfRMAb has been tested with chronic dosing in a primate model. A humanized TfRMAb against the human (h) TfR1, which cross reacts with the primate TfR, was genetically engineered with high affinity (ED50 = 0.18 ± 0.04 nM) for the human TfR type 1 (TfR1). For acute dosing, the hTfRMAb was tritiated and injected intravenously (IV) in the Rhesus monkey, which confirmed rapid delivery of the humanized hTfRMAb into both brain parenchyma, via transport across the BBB, and into cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), via transport across the choroid plexus. For chronic dosing, a total of 8 adult Rhesus monkeys (4 males, 4 females) were treated twice weekly for 4 weeks with 0, 3, 10, or 30 mg/kg of the humanized hTfRMAb via a 60 min IV infusion for a total of 8 doses prior to euthanasia and microscopic examination of brain and peripheral organs. A pharmacokinetics analysis showed the plasma clearance of the hTfRMAb in the primate was nonlinear, and plasma clearance was increased over 20-fold with chronic treatment of the low dose, 3 mg/kg, of the antibody. Chronic treatment of the primates with the 30 mg/kg dose caused anemia associated with suppressed blood reticulocytes. Immunohistochemistry of terminal brain tissue showed microglia activation, based on enhanced IBA1 immuno-staining, in conjunction with astrogliosis, based on increased GFAP immuno-staining. Moderate axonal/myelin degeneration was observed in the sciatic nerve. Further studies need to be conducted to determine if this neuropathology is induced by the antibody effector function, or is an intrinsic property of targeting the TfR in brain. The results indicate that chronic treatment of Rhesus monkeys with a humanized hTfRMAb may have a narrow therapeutic index, with associated toxicity related to microglial activation and astrogliosis of the brain.

Use of Severity Grades to Characterize Histopathologic Changes.

The severity grade is an important component of a histopathologic diagnosis in a nonclinical toxicity study that helps distinguish treatment-related effects from background findings and aids in determining adverse dose levels during hazard characterization. Severity grades should be assigned based only on the extent (i.e., amount and complexity) of the morphologic change in the examined tissue section(s) and be clearly defined in the pathology report for critical lesions impacting study interpretation. However, the level of detail provided and criteria by which severity grades are assigned can vary, which can lead to inappropriate comparisons and confusion when evaluating pathology results. To help address this issue, a Working Group of the Society of Toxicologic Pathology's Scientific and Regulatory Policy Committee was formed to provide a "points to consider" article on the assignment and application of pathology severity grades. Overall, the Working Group supports greater transparency and consistency in the reporting of grading scales and provides recommendations to improve selection of diagnoses requiring more detailed severity criteria. This information should enhance the overall understanding by toxicologic pathologists, toxicologists, and regulatory reviewers of pathology findings and thereby improve effective communication in regulatory submissions.

Scientific and Regulatory Policy Committee Review: Review of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Guidance on the GLP Requirements for Peer Review of Histopathology.

In 2014, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) issued guidance no. 16, Guidance on the GLP Requirements for Peer Review of Histopathology. The stated purpose of the guidance document is "to provide guidance to pathologists, test facility management, study directors and quality assurance personnel on how the peer review of histopathology should be planned, managed, documented, and reported in order to meet Good Laboratory Practice (GLP) expectations and requirements." On behalf of and in collaboration with the global societies of toxicologic pathology, the Society of Toxicologic Pathology initiated a review of OECD guidance no. 16. The objectives of this review are to provide a unified interpretation of the guidance, to recommend compliant processes for organizations to implement, and to avoid inconsistent process adaptations across the industry. This review of the guidance document is the product of a global collaboration with other societies of toxicologic pathology and provides a section-by-section international consensus view and interpretation of the OECD guidance on peer review.

Influence of surgically implantable telemetry solutions on in-life and post-mortem toxicology endpoints.

INTRODUCTION: Understanding the appropriate application of telemetry and other technologies for nonclinical investigation of functional safety issues in the context of ongoing toxicology evaluations is a current industry challenge. One major issue is related to the potential impact of surgical implantation of a telemetry device on contemporarily established measures of drug toxicity, and potential for confounding pathological issues related to the systemic and local response of the experimental animal to the presence of a foreign body. This study was designed to evaluate the potential local and systemic impact of different implanted telemetry devices with varying requisite degrees of surgical complexity on general toxicology study endpoints. METHODS: Sixteen male beagle dogs 1) no surgical instrumentation [n=4], 2) Jacketed External Telemetry (JET) with femoral artery blood pressure implant (PA-C10 LA) [n=4], or 3) fully implantable (DSI-D70-CCTP) devices [n=8], were assigned to experimental groups and evaluated within the context of a standard repeat-dose toxicology design to determine the potential impact of these treatments on routine in-life and post-mortem toxicological endpoints. RESULTS: Device implantation, regardless of the level of invasiveness/complexity was without effect on any in-life safety parameter, including clinical chemistry and hematology, assessed in the experimental design. Histopathological findings were limited to the expected, primarily minimal to mild localized effects characteristic of a foreign body reaction (fibrosis, inflammation) in the area immediately in contact with the body of the transmitter device and associated sites of ECG lead and pressure catheter interface with local tissues. DISCUSSION: This study represents the first definitive evaluation of the influence of variably invasive telemetry device implantation on standardized, essential toxicology endpoints in the context of a simulated repeated dose experimental design. The data suggest that, when carefully evaluated, the local effects of implanted telemetry devices can be managed in the context of a standard Investigational New Drug (IND)-enabling toxicology study. This study provides support for the potential incorporation of unrestrained cardiovascular assessments via implanted or external telemetry into standard multi-dose toxicology studies.

Occurrence of spontaneous amphophilic-vacuolar renal tubule tumors in Sprague-Dawley rats from subchronic toxicity studies.

The low background incidence of tumors in rodents from subchronic toxicity studies makes it difficult to assess their relevance, especially when present only in treated animals. This report investigates the occurrence of renal tubule tumors (RTTs), specifically the amphophilic-vacuolar (AV) phenotypic variant, in young Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats from a survey of laboratories conducting subchronic toxicity studies spanning a period of 10 years (2002-2012). This survey establishes a general profile of tumor occurrence; it does not estimate overall incidence or prevalence. AV tumors are spontaneous, nontreatment-related tumors of familial origin, and morphologically distinct from conventional RTTs induced by exposure to renal carcinogens. They are composed of distinct lobules of large, round to polyhedral cells with vacuolated amphophilic to eosinophilic cytoplasm and prominent nucleoli. Data from five collaborating laboratories, representing 37 qualifying studies, are presented. In total, 58 renal tubule neoplasms were recorded in this data set. The AV tumor variant was reported more commonly than the conventional RTT (n = 45 and 13, respectively), and it was recorded in both experimental (n = 32) and control (n = 13) groups. AV tumors occurred more often in females (n = 34) than in males (n = 11); conventional RTTs were recorded more often in males (n = 9) than in females (n = 4). AV tumors often occurred in more than one rat within the same study (up to 7) and were documented to occur in rats as young as 7 to 10 weeks of age. Results from this survey indicate that AV tumors are being reported more commonly in recent years; the majority (n = 33) were reported in studies commencing since 2009. In conclusion, this study reaffirms that AV tumors are spontaneous, nontreatment-related lesions, and suggests that they may be more common than conventional RTTs in young SD rats. The authors propose that AV tumors be recorded separately from conventional RTTs in order to clearly distinguish these two renal tubule neoplasms from one another and allow for appropriate interpretation of a compound's potential carcinogenic effect in the kidney.

Instilled or injected purified natural capsaicin has no adverse effects on rat hindlimb sensory-motor behavior or osteotomy repair.

BACKGROUND: A novel formulation of > or = 98% pure capsaicin (4975) is currently undergoing clinical investigation using novel routes of delivery to provide selective analgesia lasting weeks to months with a single dose. We conducted this study to assess the safety and effects of instilled and injected 4975 in rat models of wound healing osteotomy repair and sensory-motor nerve function. METHODS: Adult male and female Sprague-Dawley rats were used. To assess the effects of 4975 on nerve or muscle, 0.0083 or 0.025 mg 4975 or vehicle (25% polyethylene glycol-300) was applied to exposed sciatic nerve, or 0.1 mg 4975 or vehicle was injected into the surrounding muscle (Group 1). To assess the effect of 4975 on bone healing, an osteotomy was made in one femur and 0.5 mg of 4975 or vehicle was instilled into the site (Group 2). Behavioral testing was performed on both groups of rats and histological evaluation of the sciatic nerve, and surrounding soft tissue and bone was done at days 3, 14, and 28 after surgery. Femurs from osteotomy rats were assessed using peripheral quantitative computed tomography and biomechanical testing. Standard statistical tests were used to compare groups. RESULTS: Rats with direct application of 4975 to the sciatic nerve and surrounding muscle were no different from the controls in nociceptive sensory responses (F = 0.910, P = 0.454), grip strength (F = 0.550, P = 0.654), or histology of the muscle or sciatic nerve. In osteotomy rats, there were no statistical differences between 4975 and vehicle-treated rats for bone area (H = 2.858, P = 0.414), bone mineral content (F = 0.945, P = 0.425), or bone mineral density (F = 0.87, P = 0.462) and no difference in soft tissue healing. There were neither differences in bone stiffness (F = 1.369, P = 0.268) nor were there noticeable differences in the macro- or microscopic appearance of the right femur osteotomy healing site and surrounding soft tissues between the control group and the 4975-treated animals. CONCLUSION: A single, clinically relevant application of instilled or injected 4975 has no observable adverse effect on wound and bone healing after osteotomy or on the structural integrity of exposed muscle and nerve.

Malignant granulosa-theca cell tumor in a two-year-old Miniature Horse.

A 2-year-old female Miniature Horse that presented with a history of progressive weight loss, depression, and diarrhea was diagnosed at necropsy with a highly malignant abdominal neoplasm involving the left ovary, kidneys, adrenal glands, intestines, and various abdominal and thoracic lymph nodes. Microscopic examination of these masses revealed large pleomorphic cells that stained positive for vimentin and inhibin and negative for epithelial membrane antigen and placental alkaline phosphatase. Ultrastructural examination of the cells revealed a high nucleocytoplasmic ratio and indented euchromatic nuclei with large nucleoli. Based on the gross, microscopic, immunohistochemical, and ultrastructural features, the neoplasm was identified as a malignant granulosa-theca cell tumor, a rare neoplasm in young horses.