PHASMARHABDITIS CALIFORNICA (NEMATODA: RHABDITIDAE) HAS REDUCED ESTABLISHMENT SUCCESS AND PROGENY PRODUCTION IN THE PRESENCE OF PRISTIONCHUS ENTOMOPHAGUS (NEMATODA: DIPLOGASTRIDAE).

Phasmarhabditis (syn. Pellioditis) californica is a facultative parasite that has been marketed as a popular biocontrol agent against pestiferous slugs in England, Scotland, and Wales. The necromenic nematode Pristionchus entomophagus has also been recovered from slugs infected with Ph. californica. In this study, we experimentally investigated the outcome of single and mixed applications of Pr. entomophagus and Ph. californica on the slug Deroceras reticulatum (Müller). Host mortality was comparable for single and mixed applications of Ph. californica, with time to death significantly shorter in both treatment groups compared with controls. However, trials with Pr. entomophagus alone did not cause any significant host mortality relative to controls. Compared with the single Ph. californica applications, mixed applications resulted in 67% fewer infective juveniles establishing in the host, and subsequently far fewer infective juveniles were recovered in the next generation. In contrast, the establishment rate and progeny production in Pr. entomophagus were not impacted by the presence of Ph. californica (i.e., mixed applications). Hence, the presence of Pr. entomophagus had a deleterious effect on the establishment success and progeny production of Ph. californica. Our findings reveal an asymmetrical, antagonistic interaction between Ph. californica and Pr. entomophagus and highlight the importance of understanding the ecological relationships between co-occurring species. A decrease in parasite establishment success and progeny production has the potential to directly impact the persistence, sustainability, and efficacy of Ph. californica as a biological control agent.

Efficacy of commercially available entomopathogenic nematodes against insect pests of canola in Alberta, Canada.

Certain entomopathogenic nematodes (EPNs) in the families Steinernematidae and Heterorhabditidae are among the most studied biocontrol tools, some of which are commercially available against pest insects. Their use against foliar and subterranean insect pests is largely unexplored in the Canadian Prairies. We conducted a laboratory-based study to produce baseline information on the biocontrol potential of a few commercial EPN species. Percent mortality of flea beetles, diamondback moths (DBMs), lygus, cabbage root maggots, and black cutworms (BCWs) was assessed after 72 hours exposure to Steinernema carpocapsae, S. kraussei, S. feltiae, and Heterorhabditis bacteriophora at varying concentrations (25, 50, 100, and 200 infective juveniles (IJs) per larvae, pupae, or cm2 of soil surface). Irrespective of concentration level, S. carpocapsae and S. kraussei caused significant mortality in DBM and BCW larvae compared with H. bacteriophora.S. kraussei, and S. feltiae were more efficient than S. carpocapsae in controlling root maggot larvae. H. bacteriophora caused zero mortality to root maggots at any concentration. Root maggot pupae were resistant to entry to EPN species tested, likely due to hard outer covering. Compared with root maggot pupae, a moderate level of mortality was observed in DBM pupae, suggesting differential ability of the tested EPNs in killing different life stages of certain pests. All nematode species tested caused low mortality (≤10%) in flea beetle adults. The findings of this investigation form fundamental data essential for carrying out field-based studies on canola and other related crops aimed at control and management of these pest species.

CHEMOTAXIS RESPONSE OF PHASMARHABDITIS CALIFORNICA (FAMILY: RHABDITIDAE) AND PRISTIONCHUS ENTOMOPHAGUS (FAMILY: NEODIPLOGASTERIDAE) TO THE MUCUS OF FOUR SLUG SPECIES.

The chemotaxis responses of soil nematodes have been well studied in bacteriophagic nematodes, plant-parasitic nematodes, entomopathogenic nematodes, and to a lesser extent malacopathogenic nematodes. Free-living stages of parasitic nematodes often use chemotaxis to locate hosts. In this study, we compared the chemotaxis profile of 2 slug-associated nematodes with overlapping host ranges. Phasmarhabditis californica is a facultative parasite that has been shown to express strain-dependent variation in chemoattraction profile. We tested 4 slug species to determine the attraction index of a Canadian strain of Ph. californica and a sympatric necromenic nematode, Pristionchus entomophagus. When tested against a control (distilled water), Ph. californica showed a clear (positive) attraction towards the mucus of slugs Ambigolimax valentianus, Arion rufus, and Arion fasciatus, but not Deroceras reticulatum. However, when given a choice between the mucus of D. reticulatum and Ar. fasciatus in a pairwise test, Ph. californica was strongly attracted to the former. Other pairwise comparisons did not reveal a clear preference for either slug species in the following pairs: D. reticulatum-Ar. rufus, Am. valentianus-Ar. rufus, D. reticulatum-Am. valentianus. The chemotaxis assay for Pr. entomophagus showed an attraction toward D. reticulatum and Ar. fasciatus (tested against controls); the attraction index for Am. valentianus was positive, but this was not statistically significant. In contrast, the attraction index for Ar. rufus was negative, suggesting possible repulsion to the mucus of this slug species. Given that Pr. entomophagus and Ph. californica occupy overlapping habitats, utilize similar hosts, and exhibit similar chemotaxis profiles, there is a potential for direct interaction between these 2 nematodes. Like other members of the genus Pristionchus, Pr. entomophagus may be able to prey upon the co-occurring Ph. californica, such antagonistic interactions could have important implications for the coexistence of these 2 species and Ph. californica in particular as a biocontrol agent against pestiferous slugs.

Pestiferous slugs and their associated nematodes in agricultural fields, greenhouses, and nurseries in Alberta, Canada.

Some slug species are considered a nuisance in agriculture and horticulture worldwide, causing economic losses to growers. Phasmarhabditis is a genus of bacteria-feeding nematodes that can parasitize slugs and snails and thus potentially serve as a biological control agent. Canada had no record of Phasmarhabditis until a survey conducted in 2019 reported a Canadian strain of Phasmarhabditis californica from a single Arion rufus slug. To build on this discovery, we surveyed three major agricultural sites, ten greenhouses, and nurseries in Alberta from June to September 2021 to collect pest slug species and investigate their associated nematodes, specifically P. californica. Slugs were collected from the field and returned to the laboratory to check for emerging nematodes on White traps. We collected 1331 slugs belonging to nine species, with Deroceras reticulatum being the most common. Only 45 (3.38%) slug samples were positive for nematodes, and the majority were identified to species level: Alloionema appendiculatum, Caenorhabditis briggsae, Caenorhabditis elegans, Panagrolaimus subelongatus, and Mesorhabditis spiculigera. We did not isolate P. californica from any of the slugs collected from these survey sites, which included the original site where P. californica was discovered. However, four D. reticulatum slugs retrieved from a residential garden sample were infected with P. californica. These findings suggest the possibility of a fragmented distribution of P. californica across Alberta. Future research should focus on extensively surveying agriculture and horticulture sites and residential gardens in different provinces across Canada.