Cost-effectiveness of a graded exercise therapy program for patients with chronic shoulder complaints.

OBJECTIVES: The present study evaluated the cost-effectiveness of a behavioral graded exercise therapy (GET) program compared with usual care (UC) in terms of the performance of daily activities by patients with chronic shoulder complaints in primary care. METHODS: A total of 176 patients were randomly assigned either to GET (n=87) or to UC (n=89). Clinical outcomes (main complaints, shoulder disability [SDQ] and generic health-related quality of life [EQ-5D], and costs [intervention costs, direct health care costs, direct non-health-related costs, and indirect costs]) were assessed during the 12-week treatment period and at 52 weeks of follow-up. RESULTS: Results showed that GET was more effective than UC in restoring daily activities as assessed by the main complaints instrument after the 12-week treatment period (p = .049; mean difference, 7.5; confidence interval [CI], 0.0-15.0). These effects lasted for at least 52 weeks (p = .025; mean difference 9.2; CI, 1.2-17.3). No statistically significant differences were found on the SDQ or EQ5D. GET significantly reduced direct health care costs (p = .000) and direct non-health care costs (p = .029). Nevertheless, total costs during the 1-year follow-up period were significantly higher (p = .001; GET = Euro 530 versus UC = Euro 377) due to the higher costs of the intervention. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios for the main complaints (0-100), SDQ (0-100), and EQ-5D (-1.0-1.0) were Euro 7, Euro 74, and Euro 5278 per unit of improvement, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: GET proved to be more effective in the short- and long-term and reduces direct health care costs and direct non-health care costs but is associated with higher costs of the intervention itself.

A behavioural treatment for chronic shoulder complaints: concepts, development, and study design.

This paper discusses the rationale for and content of a newly developed treatment for shoulder complaints, and describes a randomised study which is currently being conducted to test effectiveness of the treatment. In current practice, approximately 50% of all patients with shoulder complaints mention limitations in the performance of daily activities and persisting pain after six months. To improve the functional ability of patients with chronic shoulder complaints, despite their pain, we have developed an operant behavioural and time-contingent graded exercise therapy programme for use in a primary care setting. We present the theory and conceptual model underlying this programme, report on its development and content, and describe the design of a randomised clinical trial to evaluate the programme's effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. One hundred and thirty-two patients who suffer from shoulder complaints for at least 3 months are being recruited in general practice. After inclusion in the study, patients are allocated randomly to the graded exercise therapy programme or to usual care. Questionnaires will be used to measure factors like severity of the main complaint, functional limitations of daily activities, perceived recovery, global health status, shoulder pain, generic health-related quality of life, and costs. These factors will be assessed at baseline, during treatment (6 weeks), and after treatment (12, 26, and 52 weeks).