Call rate of oyster toadfish (Opsanus tau) is affected by aggregate sound level but not by specific vessel passagesa).

Anthropogenic sound is a prevalent environmental stressor that can have significant impacts on aquatic species, including fishes. In this study, the effects of anthropogenic sound on the vocalization behavior of oyster toadfish (Opasnus tau) at multiple time scales was investigated using passive acoustic monitoring. The effects of specific vessel passages were investigated by comparing vocalization rates immediately after a vessel passage with that of control periods using a generalized linear model. The effects of increased ambient sound levels as a result of aggregate exposure within hourly periods over a month were also analyzed using generalized additive models. To place the response to vessel sounds within an ecologically appropriate context, the effect of environmental variables on call density was compared to that of increasing ambient sound levels. It was found that the immediate effect of vessel passage was not a significant predictor for toadfish vocalization rate. However, analyzed over a longer time period, increased vessel-generated sound lowered call rate and there was a greater effect size from vessel sound than any environmental variable. This demonstrates the importance of evaluating responses to anthropogenic sound, including chronic sounds, on multiple time scales when assessing potential impacts.

Exposure of fish to high-intensity sonar does not induce acute pathology.

This study investigated immediate effects of intense sound exposure associated with low-frequency (170-320 Hz) or with mid-frequency (2.8-3.8 kHz) sonars on caged rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss, channel catfish Ictalurus punctatus and hybrid sunfish Lepomis sp. in Seneca Lake, New York, U.S.A. This study focused on potential effects on inner ear tissues using scanning electron microscopy and on non-auditory tissues using gross and histopathology. Fishes were exposed to low-frequency sounds for 324 or 628 s with a received peak signal level of 193 dB re 1 microPa (root mean square, rms) or to mid-frequency sounds for 15 s with a received peak signal level of 210 dB re 1 microPa (rms). Although a variety of clinical observations from various tissues and organ systems were described, no exposure-related pathologies were observed. This study represents the first investigation of the effects of high-intensity sonar on fish tissues in vivo. Data from this study indicate that exposure to low and midfrequency sonars, as described in this report, might not have acute effects on fish tissues.

The effects of anthropogenic sources of sound on fishes.

There is increasing concern about the effects of pile driving and other anthropogenic (human-generated) sound on fishes. Although there is a growing body of reports examining this issue, little of the work is found in the peer-reviewed literature. This review critically examines both the peer-reviewed and 'grey' literature, with the goal of determining what is known and not known about effects on fish. A companion piece provides an analysis of the available data and applies it to estimate noise exposure criteria for pile driving and other impulsive sounds. The critical literature review concludes that very little is known about effects of pile driving and other anthropogenic sounds on fishes, and that it is not yet possible to extrapolate from one experiment to other signal parameters of the same sound, to other types of sounds, to other effects, or to other species.

Development of ultrasound detection in American shad (Alosa sapidissima).

It has recently been shown that a few fish species, including American shad (Alosa sapidissima; Clupeiformes), are able to detect sound up to 180 kHz, an ability not found in most other fishes. Initially, it was proposed that ultrasound detection in shad involves the auditory bullae, swim bladder extensions found in all members of the Clupeiformes. However, while all clupeiformes have bullae, not all can detect ultrasound. Thus, the bullae alone are not sufficient to explain ultrasound detection. In this study, we used a developmental approach to determine when ultrasound detection begins and how the ability to detect ultrasound changes with ontogeny in American shad. We then compared changes in auditory function with morphological development to identify structures that are potentially responsible for ultrasound detection. We found that the auditory bullae and all three auditory end organs are present well before fish show ultrasound detection behaviourally and we suggest that an additional specialization in the utricle (one of the auditory end organs) forms coincident with the onset of ultrasound detection. We further show that this utricular specialization is found in two clupeiform species that can detect ultrasound but not in two clupeiform species not capable of ultrasound detection. Thus, it appears that ultrasound-detecting clupeiformes have undergone structural modification of the utricle that allows detection of ultrasonic stimulation.

Amphibious auditory responses of the American alligator (Alligator mississipiensis).

Animals that thrive both on land and underwater are faced with the task of interpreting stimuli in different media. This becomes a challenge to the sensory receptors in that stimuli (e.g., sound, motion) may convey the same type of information but are transmitted with different physical characteristics. We used auditory brainstem responses to examine hearing abilities of a species that makes full use of these two environments, the American alligator (Alligator mississipiensis). In water, alligators responded to tones from 100 Hz to 2,000 Hz, with peak sensitivity at 800 Hz. In air, they responded to tones from 100 Hz to 8,000 Hz, with peak sensitivity around 1,000 Hz. We also examined the contribution to hearing of an air bubble that becomes trapped in the middle ear as the animal submerges. This bubble has been previously implicated in underwater hearing. Our studies show that the trapped air bubble has no affect on auditory thresholds, suggesting the bubble is not an important adaptation for underwater hearing in this species.

Hair cell death in a hearing-deficient canary.

Cell death has been documented in bird auditory inner ear epithelia after induced damage. This cell death is quickly followed by an increase in supporting cell division and regeneration of the epithelium, thereby suggesting a possible relationship between these two processes. However, aspects of this relationship still need to be better understood. The Belgian Waterslager (BWS) canary is an ideal system in which to study cell death and subsequent cell division. In contrast to mixed breed (MB) canaries, cell division normally occurs in the auditory end organ of the BWS without any external manipulation. In addition, some of the cells in the auditory epithelium may be dying through an apoptotic-like process. In the present study two methods were used to quantify dying cells in the BWS and MB canary auditory epithelia: morphological criteria and TUNEL. Results confirm that some of the abnormal hair cells in the BWS auditory epithelium are apoptotic-like. The presence of both cell death and cell division indicates that these processes act concurrently in the adult end organ. Future studies are needed to determine if cell death is a stimulus for the observed cell division.

Neural response directionality correlates of hair cell orientation in a teleost fish.

The otolithic end organs in the ears of teleost fishes play important roles in hearing. Although previous studies have shown that afferent fibers innervating otolithic organs are directionally sensitive to acoustic stimulation, no study has demonstrated that directionality of the otolithic afferent neurons derives directly from morphological polarity of the hair cells that they innervate. In this study we investigated whether or not there exists such a structure and function relationship in one of the otolithic organs, the saccule, by using intracellular and extracellular tracing, histochemistry, and confocal imaging techniques. We observed a variety of morphologies of dendritic terminals of saccular ganglion neurons. Arbor innervation areas of these saccular neurons ranged from 893 microm2 to 21,393 microm2, and the number of dendritic endings fell into a range between 10 and 54. We found that the response directionality of saccular ganglion neurons correlates significantly with the morphological polarization of the hair cells in the regions that they innervate. Therefore, we provide direct evidence to support the hypothesis that fish are able to encode directional information about a sound source, particularly in elevation, using arrays of hair cells in the otolithic organs that are oriented specifically along the sound propagation axis.

Ultrasound detection by clupeiform fishes.

It has previously been shown that at least one species of fish (the American shad) in the order clupeiforms (herrings, shads, and relatives) is able to detect sounds up to 180 kHz. However, it has not been clear whether other members of this order are also able to detect ultrasound. It is now demonstrated, using auditory brainstem response (ABR), that at least one additional species, the gulf menhaden (Brevoortia patronus), is able to detect ultrasound, while several other species including the bay anchovy (Anchoa mitchilli), scaled sardine (Harengula jaguana), and Spanish sardine (Sardinella aurita) only detect sounds to about 4 kHz. ABR is used to confirm ultrasonic hearing in the American shad. The results suggest that ultrasound detection may be limited to one subfamily of clupeiforms, the Alosinae. It is suggested that ultrasound detection involves the utricle of the inner ear and speculate as to why, despite having similar ear structures, only one group may detect ultrasound.

Comparison of the inner ear ultrastructure between teleost fishes using different channels for communication.

The anatomy and ultrastructure of the inner ear of three species of gouramis which differ widely in acoustic behavior were studied using scanning electron microscopy. Of the three species. Trichopsis possess a pectoral sound-producing mechanism while Macropodus and Betta lack sonic organs. The general structure of the inner ear and the shapes of the sensory epithelia are very similar, although they do differ on the posterior part of the saccular macula which is more S-shaped in Trichopsis and Macropodus than in Betta. The maculae on the three species do not differ either in ciliary bundle type (cells with long kinocilia on the periphery of the maculae and cells with short kinocilia in the central region) or in hair cell orientation pattern. Quantitative measurements of hair cell densities and the size of the sensory epithelia of the saccule did not show significant differences between species. Data presented correlate with physiological results from other investigators showing similar auditory sensitivity in Trichopsis and Macropodus. The similarity in structure and function of the inner ears of gouramis on one hand, and the occurrence of sound-generating organs in just one genus, suggests that hearing evolved prior to vocalization and thus acoustic communication in this taxon.

Sciaenid inner ears: a study in diversity.

Sciaenid fishes (Family Sciaenidae) could potentially serve as models for understanding the relationship between structure and function in the teleost auditory system, as they show a broad range of variation in not only the structure of the ear but also in the relationship between the ear and swim bladder. In this study, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used to investigate inner ear ultrastructure of the Atlantic croaker (Micropogonias undulatus), spotted seatrout (Cynoscion nebulosus), kingfish (Menticirrhus americanus) and spot (Leiostomus xanthurus). These species reflect the diversity of otolith and swim bladder morphology in sciaenids. The distribution of different hair cell bundle types, as well as hair cell orientation patterns on the saccular and lagenar maculae of these fishes were similar to one another. The rostral ends of the saccular sensory epithelia (maculae) were highly expanded in a dorsal-ventral direction in the Atlantic croaker and spotted seatrout as compared to the kingfish and spot. Also, ciliary bundles of the saccular maculae contained more stereocilia in the Atlantic croaker and spotted seatrout as compared with kingfish and spot. The shapes of the lagenar maculae were similar in all four species. In the Atlantic croaker and spotted seatrout lagenar maculae, the number of stereocilia per bundle was greater than those for the kingfish and spot. Given that saccular macula shape and numbers of stereocilia per bundle correlate with swim bladder proximity to the ear in the studied species, it is possible that inner ear ultrastructure could be indicative of auditory ability in fishes.

Acoustic detection and communication by decapod crustaceans.

This paper reviews behavioral, physiological, anatomical, and ecological aspects of sound and vibration detection by decapod crustaceans. Our intent is to demonstrate that despite very limited work in this area in the past 20 years, evidence suggests that at least some decapod crustaceans are able to detect and use sounds in ways that parallel detection and processing mechanisms in aquatic and terrestrial vertebrates. Some aquatic decapod crustaceans produce sounds, and many are able to detect substrate vibration at sensitivities sufficient to tell of the proximity of mates, competitors, or predators. Some semi-terrestrial crabs produce and use sounds for communication. These species detect acoustic stimuli as either air- or substrate-borne energies, socially interact in acoustic "choruses," and probably use "calls" to attract mates.

Hair cell heterogeneity and ultrasonic hearing: recent advances in understanding fish hearing.

The past decade has seen a wealth of new data on the auditory capabilities and mechanisms of fishes. We now have a significantly better appreciation of the structure and function of the auditory system in fishes with regard to their peripheral and central anatomy, physiology, behaviour, sound source localization and hearing capabilities. This paper deals with two of the newest of these findings, hair cell heterogeneity and the detection of ultrasound. As a result of this recent work, we now know that fishes have several different types of sensory hair cells in both the ear and lateral line and there is a growing body of evidence to suggest that these hair cell types arose very early in the evolution of the octavolateralis system. There is also some evidence to suggest that the differences in the hair cell types have functional implications for the way the ear and lateral line of fishes detect and process stimuli. Behavioural studies have shown that, whereas most fishes can only detect sound to 1-3 kHz, several species of the genus Alosa (Clupeiformes, i.e. herrings and their relatives) can detect sounds up to 180 kHz (or even higher). It is suggested that this capability evolved so that these fishes can detect one of their major predators, echolocating dolphins. The mechanism for ultrasound detection remains obscure, though it is hypothesized that the highly derived utricle of the inner ear in these species is involved.

Evolution of hearing in vertebrates: the inner ears and processing.

This paper considers aspects of the evolution of the vertebrate auditory system from an 'ichthyocentric' perspective. It is argued that all vertebrate auditory systems are required to do certain basic tasks including acoustic feature discrimination, sound source localization, frequency analysis, and auditory scene analysis, among others. These sorts of capabilities arose very early in the evolution of the vertebrates and have been modified by selection in different species. In some cases the same structures have been involved in detection and analysis throughout the vertebrates, while in other cases the mechanism by which the same type of analysis takes place may have changed.

Structure and function in the saccule of the goldfish (Carassius auratus): a model of diversity in the non-amniote ear.

The vertebrate inner ear is comprised of a remarkable diversity of cell types, including several types of sensory hair cells. In amniotes (reptiles, birds, and mammals), the morphological and physiological characteristics that distinguish these cell types have been well documented, while cellular variation in the ears of non-amniotes (all other vertebrate groups) has remained underrecognized. Since non-amniotes have become increasingly popular models for developmental and genetic research, a more comprehensive understanding of structure and function in the inner ears of these species is warranted. This paper first reviews the large body of data describing the morphology and physiology of hair cells and afferent neurons in the inner ear of the goldfish (Carassius auratus). In particular, we examine the structure of the goldfish saccule, an endorgan that has been the subject of numerous investigations on audition. New data on the structural variation of synaptic bodies in saccular hair cells are also presented, and the functional implications of these data are discussed. Finally, we conclude that hair cell structure varies along the length of the goldfish saccule in a manner consistent with known physiological characteristics of the endorgan. The saccule provides an excellent model for investigating structure-function relationships in the vertebrate inner ear, as well as the development of auditory and vestibular sensory epithelia.

Dendritic arbors on the saccule and lagena in the ear of the goldfish, Carassius auratus.

The ear of the goldfish (Carassius auratus) contains three otolithic endorgans: the saccule, lagena, and utricle. The saccule has an auditory function in most teleost fishes for whom data are available, and there is evidence that the lagena is also an auditory endorgan in the goldfish. This study was conducted to compare the innervation of the saccule and the lagena to one another and to previously published data from goldfish and other species. We placed cobaltous-lysine in saccular and lagenar nerves in vivo and permitted uptake over 18-24 h. A total of 59 saccular and 59 lagenar dendritic arbors were labeled in 10 fishes. Our data indicate that arbors on the saccule and lagena have similar morphologies, but differ in relative size. Saccular arbors tend to be smaller than lagenar arbors, with median arbor widths of 50 micrometer on the saccule and 74 micrometer on the lagena. Fiber diameters on the two endorgans are similar. A regional analysis of the saccule indicated that a wide range of arbor sizes are found along the rostral-caudal axis, with larger arbors more common caudally. Our data do not support the presence of two distinct categories of saccular afferents with non-overlapping distributions. Moderate arbor widths (50-99 micrometer) were most common in all regions of the lagena. Maximum arbor width and hair cell density do not appear to be correlated with one another on either the saccule or the lagena. Comparisons with published data from goldfish and oscar revealed similarities and differences that may be attributable to variations in label uptake or transport as well as potential species differences.

Proliferation of vertebrate inner ear supporting cells.

Using two S phase markers, we determined the cell-cycle behavior of inner ear supporting cells from two species, the chicken and the oscar. The results indicate that chicken utricular supporting cells divide once and do not return to the cell cycle for at least 7 days. In contrast, supporting cell progeny in the oscar saccule return to S phase after 5 days. While both the chicken utricle and oscar saccule show ongoing supporting cell proliferation, these data indicate that there may be a dedicated recycling population of supporting cells in the oscar saccule but not in the chicken utricle that is responsible for hair cell production. An expulsion of proliferative cell progeny in the chicken utricle after 7 days may be a driving force for proliferation, as well as an explanation for why hair cell numbers do not increase in the chicken utricle with age. This was not seen in the oscar saccule, possibly explaining how this end organ increases in size throughout the adult life of the animal. The absence of S phase cell expulsion, however, does not rule out the role of cell death in the oscar saccule.

Detection of ultrasonic tones and simulated dolphin echolocation clicks by a teleost fish, the American shad (Alosa sapidissima).

The authors previously reported that American shad (Alosa sapidissima) can detect sounds from 100 Hz to 180 kHz, with two regions of best sensitivity, one from 200 to 800 Hz and the other from 25 to 150 kHz [Mann et al., Nature 389, 341 (1997)]. These results demonstrated ultrasonic hearing by shad, but thresholds at lower frequencies were potentially masked by background noise in the experimental room. In this study, the thresholds of the American shad in a quieter and smaller tank, as well as thresholds for detecting stimulated echolocation sounds of bottlenosed dolphins was determined. Shad had lower thresholds for detection (from 0.2 to 0.8 kHz) in the quieter and smaller tank compared with the previous experiment, with low-frequency background noise but similar thresholds at ultrasonic frequencies. Shad were also able to detect echolocation clicks with a threshold of 171 dB re: 1 microPa peak to peak. If spherical spreading and an absorption coefficient of 0.02 dB/m of dolphin echolocation clicks are assumed, shad should be able to detect echolocating Tursiops truncatus at ranges up to 187 m. The authors propose that ultrasonic hearing evolved in shad in response to selection pressures from echolocating odontocete cetaceans.

Encoding of acoustic directional information by saccular afferents of the sleeper goby, Dormitator latifrons.

This paper reports on directional response properties of saccular afferents of the sleeper goby, Dormitator latifrons, to 100-Hz acoustic particle motions with a focus on testing the hypothesis that the response directionality of a fish's auditory afferents derives from the morphological polarity of sensory hair cells in the otolithic organs. Spontaneous rates (SR) and best sensitivities (BS) of saccular afferents ranged from 0 to 162 spikes/sec and from 0.2-to 100-nm RMS displacement. SR did not vary with BS. Most saccular afferents were phase-locked to sinusoidal stimulation and had sustained temporal response patterns with some adaptation. All saccular afferents were directionally sensitive to the stimulus, and the sharpness of directional response curves was determined by a directionality index (DI). The DI ranged from 0.64 to 1.50 (mean = 1.02, SE = 0.02, n = 100) and gradually decreased with stimulus level throughout afferents' response dynamic range. Many afferents had approximately symmetric directional response curves relative to their best response axes (BRA). BRA of most afferents remained constant with stimulus level. The BRA distribution had a peak along an axis that correlates closely with the morphological polarity of saccular hair cells. Therefore, our results strongly support the hypothesis.

Morphological polarizations of sensory hair cells in the three otolithic organs of a teleost fish: fluorescent imaging of ciliary bundles.

It has been suggested that the morphological polarity of sensory hair cells in the otolithic organs plays important roles in directional hearing in fish. In this study, we examined the hair cell polarization patterns in the saccule, utricle, and lagena of a teleost fish, the sleeper goby (Dormitator latifrons). In contrast to using traditional scanning electron microscopy, we employed a simple and rapid method that enabled us to map the hair cell polarization patterns using immunocytochemical and confocal imaging techniques. The hair cells in the caudal part of the saccular epithelium are oriented dorsally and ventrally, with some variations in the caudal end. The hair cells in the rostral part have diverse morphological polarizations. The utricular hair cells fall into internal and external groups which have opposing polarizations. The lagenar hair cells are found in anterior and posterior groups with approximately opposite polarizations. The saccular and lagenar epithelia are oriented perpendicular to the horizontal plane of the fish, while the utricular epithelium lies on the horizontal plane. Thus, the sleeper goby's ear is morphologically capable of being a three-dimensional sound detector.