A sociodemographic and economic comparison of breast reconstruction, mastectomy, and conservative surgery.

BACKGROUND: There are a variety of surgical choices for women with early-stage breast cancer, including breast-conserving surgery, mastectomy, or mastectomy plus reconstructive surgery. This report examines some of the factors that affect these choices and the costs of the various treatment options. METHODS: Data from the Virginia Cancer Registry were linked to insurance claims from the Trigon Blue Cross and Blue Shield Company for women with local and regional staged breast cancer from 1989 to 1991 in Virginia. Multivariate analyses and cost studies were performed. RESULTS: There were 592 women who underwent breast-conserving surgery (BCS, 26%), mastectomy (58%), or mastectomy plus reconstruction (16%). Increasing age reduced the use of reconstruction. The choice of reconstruction was not affected by tumor size, nodal status, or race. Sixty percent of women had immediate breast reconstruction at the time of mastectomy; the majority had the implant procedure. The cost of BCS ($21,582) was higher than that of mastectomy ($16,122, P < .01). The costs for BCS and mastectomy were significantly lower than for mastectomy plus reconstruction ($31,047, P < .05). The 2-year cost for immediate reconstruction was $8200 less than for delayed procedures and was similar to the cost of BCS. CONCLUSIONS: Age was the driving force in reconstruction decisions. Clinical factors such as tumor size and nodal status were more important for the choice between BCS and mastectomy. There are significant cost differences between the various procedures. For a similar cosmetic outcome, BCS is less expensive than breast reconstruction. When reconstruction is required, a simultaneous procedure is less expensive.

Interleukin-1alpha and collagenase activity are elevated in chronic wounds.

Interleukin-1-alpha (IL-1alpha) is a member of a family of proinflammatory polypeptide mediators that has been shown in vitro to stimulate collagenase production. Collagenase is a proteolytic enzyme classified as one of the matrix metalloproteinases (MMP-1) that specifically recognizes and cleaves collagen. Therefore, the objective of this study was to compare the levels of these two proteins in chronic wounds as possible factors in the pathogenesis of chronic wounds. Fluids from 10 chronic wounds were collected before and after a 1-week treatment with a hydroactive dressing (Cutinova cavity). In addition, fluids were collected from 20 acute wounds for comparison. IL-1alpha and MMP-1 levels were quantified using sandwich ELISA. Collagenase activity was measured using a radiolabeled collagen as substrate. Clinically, the chronic wounds showed decreased area (-21.0 cm2) and reduced volume (-134.5 cm3) by 4 weeks after treatment with the hydroactive dressing. There were no significant differences in the protein concentrations between acute wound fluids (21.0 +/- 3.0 mg/ml) and chronic wound fluids before and after treatment with the hydroactive dressing (18.3 +/- 5.5 and 25.2 +/- 7.6 mg/ml, respectively). Levels of IL-1alpha in the acute wound fluids were low (0.019 pg/mg), whereas in the chronic wound fluid before treatment they had been significantly elevated (44.9 + 21.8 pg/mg). Following treatment with the hydroactive dressing, the IL-1alpha levels dropped to 10.3 + 3.3 pg/mg (p < 0.05). Collagenase activity was not detectable in acute wound fluid, elevated in pretreatment chronic wounds (12.9 + 3.4 units), and decreased in chronic wounds after treatment (11.4 + 3.3 units). This study correlated clinical healing of chronic wounds with biochemical changes in the ulcer microenvironment. As the chronic wounds began to heal, there was a significant decrease in the IL-1alpha levels and collagenase activity, thus suggesting that these two proteins may contribute to the lack of healing characteristic of chronic wounds.