Bacteriological follow-up of tuberculosis treatment: a comparative study of smear microscopy and culture results at the second month of treatment.

SETTING: Significance of a positive bacillary examination of sputum at 2 months of treatment in relation to the viability of the bacilli and the final treatment result. OBJECTIVE: To compare the results of smear microscopy and sputum culture at the second month of tuberculosis treatment and to follow the progress of the patients. METHODS: Follow-up of 297 patients with smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis in Madagascar, 152 of whom were smear-positive at 2 months of treatment and 145 smear-negative. The number of bacilli was recorded, as were the culture results and the final outcome of treatment. RESULTS: Among the 152 patients who were smear-positive at the second month, 77 (51%) were culture-negative; there were 12 (8%) treatment failures and four relapses (4.6%). Among the 145 smear-negative patients, 22 (15%) were culture-positive, of which one was a treatment failure (1%). CONCLUSION: The majority of failures and relapses were observed in the group of smear-positive patients. It is important to reinforce the surveillance of these patients in order to reduce the number lost to follow-up. Furthermore, a positive smear microscopy at the end of the second month is not sufficiently specific for early identification of treatment failures. It is preferable to wait until the fifth month, as the great majority of patients who are positive at 2 months achieve cure. The treatment strategy currently recommended in Madagascar is satisfactory.

[Central inter-laboratory quality control for microscopic diagnosis of tuberculosis in Madagascar in 2000]. / Contrôle de qualité inter-laboratoires centraux pour le diagnostic microscopique de la tuberculose à Madagascar en 2000.

Since June 1997, a quarterly quality control of sputum smear exam for the tubercle diagnosis, depending on double reading of slides, was implemented between both central laboratories of the Mycobacteria National Reference Centre in Madagascar (mycobactoria laboratories of Institut Pasteur Madagascar [IPM] and Institut Hygiène Sociale [IHS]--Health Ministry). In 2000, four controls were done, in the course of which 240 slides were coloured by auramine, coming both from IPM and IHS, and another 80 slides from IHS were coloured by Ziehl-Neelsen. All the results were in agreement for the samples stained with auramine, while two false negatives were found for the samples stained with Ziehl-Neelsen. The maintenance of this quality control between the two laboratories is necessary to insure the reliability of their results and the controls that they make for the peripheral laboratories.

[Mycobacterium tuberculosis resistance to antitubercular agents in Antananarivo in 2000]. / Résistance de Mycobacterium tuberculosis aux antituberculeux à Antananarivo en 2000.

In 1991, the National Tuberculosis control Program (NTP) of Madagascar adopted the short treatment course and the Directly Observed Treatment Strategy (DOTS), according to the recommendations of the OMS/UICTMR. Development of M. tuberculosis primary resistance to the four antituberculosis drugs (streptomycin [S], rifampicine [R], isoniazid [H], ethambutol [E]) is an indicator of the NTP efficiency. We report results from a five-year survey among patients with new smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis. Acquired resistance is assessed among recurrent cases. During the first survey, carried out in 1994-1995 in four large cities, multidrug resistance (MDR) rate to the major antituberculosis drug H and R was low, 0.25% for primary MDR and 5% for acquired MDR. No primary MDR was found in Antananarivo; on the other hand, acquired resistance rate was the highest there (22%). Because of logistical reasons, the second survey (1999-2000) was only carried out in the capital, Antananarivo. Results obtained among 789 new patients with smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis and 79 recurrents cases in 9 diagnostic centres showed low primary and acquired resistance of 11.1% to any drug. Primary resistance to one drug was 10.6%, mainly due to streptomycin 8.5%. MDR rates are comparable with those observed in 1994-1995: 0.1% for primary MDR and 4% for acquired MDR. These results show that ten years after the new NTP implementation, only a few MDR strains are circulating in Antananarivo, which suggests that NTP has been effective.

[Epidemiologic surveillance system and control of malaria in the central highlands of Madagascar: results 1999-2000]. / Système de surveillance épidémiologique et d'alerte du paludisme sur les Hautes Terres Centrales de Madagascar: résultats 1999-2000.

The central highlands in Madagascar are characterized by an unstable occurrence of malaria with the risk of sporadic outbreaks. In major parts of the region DDT indoor spraying campaigns have been carried out from 1993 to 1998. This strategy was in 1999 replaced by another anti-vector intervention program targeting residual foci as detected by a surveillance and early warning system. This system is based on monitoring of presumptive malaria cases in the communities by which the number of presumptive cases exceeded a defined warning threshold value per month. The system was in the follow-up period shown to be very sensitive to variation of the coverage of anti-vector interventions: the number of presumptive cases decreased in the villages in which indoor spraying had been carried out and a minor increase was observed in those villages, where indoor spraying has been suspended. An increase of malaria cases was observed in 44 (20.8%) out of 212 study sites in the same period. The increase was in particular predominant in areas at lower attitude at the outer zones of the central highlands.

[Laboratory network for the microscopic diagnosis of tuberculosis in Madagascar: quality control of slides]. / Réseau des laboratoires de microscopie pour le diagnostic de la tuberculose à Madagascar: contrôle de qualité des lames en 1999.

As part of the National Tuberculosis Program (NTP), a quality control of the slides (search of acido-fast bacilli in the sputa) of the Treatment and Diagnosis Centers (TDC) forming the National Laboratory Network is carried out each year. In 1999, 76 TDC out of the 174 (44%) had been controlled using the method of double reading of the smears. The global concordance of the results in the 76 TDC is satisfactory (98%). Reability was 91% for the positive smears and 92% for the negative smears. A good quality of smears was observed in 53% of the centers. The TDC reliable at 100% for both positive and negative smears were 51 (67%) of which 36 (47%) had also a good quality of smears. Those later were mainly found in Toamasina, Fianarantsoa, Antananarivo and Mahajanga.

[Leprosy surgery: retrospective study in Madagascar]. / La chirurgie de la lèpre: étude rétrospective à Madagascar.

Leprosy is endemic in Madagascar and the diagnosis of leprosy is still done lately. Thus, many patients suffer from multiple and/or severe disabilities. Since a long time, many leprologists argue that surgery is necessary and useful in the treatment of these disabilities. We report the results of a retrospective study done in 25 patients reevaluated 2 to 7 years after surgery. Of these patients: 17 patients (68%) have success, 7 patients (28%) have a partial improvement and only 1 case (4%) had no benefit. These results are encouraging and suggest that surgery must be proposed more often to treat in leprosy disabilities.

[Leprosy situation in the southeastern region of Madagascar from 1996 to 1998]. / Situation de la lèpre dans une région du Sud-Est de Madagascar de 1996 à 1998.

Leprosy is endemic in Madagascar. The authors report the results of an epidemiologic study performed between 1996 and 1998 in Farafanguna, localized in the South-Eastern of the country. During this period, 217 new cases have been diagnosed. Of the 130 cases included in the study, 69.23% were children aged lower than 15 years and 76.91% suffered from a multibacillary form. More than 50% of the cases belonged to a large family (6 persons or more) and at least one family case was found in more than 60% of cases. These results enhance the severity of the disease in the country and show the presence of multiple risk factors (promiscuity, family cases and multibacillary forms).

[Epidemiological aspects of tuberculosis in middle west of Madagascar]. / Aspects épidémiologiques de la tuberculose dans le Moyen-ouest malgache.

We conducted a 5-year (1989-1993) retrospective analysis on a series of patients screened and treated for tuberculosis in order to determine the epidemiological aspects of the disease in mid-western Madagascar. Pulmonary forms affected 97% of patients, and predominantly men (sex ratio: 1.4); 83% of patients with pulmonary tuberculosis were coughing up acido-alcoholo-resitant bacilli. Haemoptysis and general deterioration, the most frequently met pathological signs, were observed respectively in 62% and 24% of cases. This explains the high rate of hospitalisation (42%), especially for patients with difficult access to services. Significantly, in terms of socio-professional category, live-stock breeders and farmers represented 32% of notified cases, and cattle-traders 18%. We draw attention to the possible role played by Mycobacterium bovis in human case-findings in a region characterised by cattle-breeding.

[First cases of cholera observed in children at the Befelatanana General Hospital--Antananarivo University Hospital Center (Madagascar)]. / Premiers cas de choléra observés chez l'enfant à l'Hôpital général de Befelatanana--Centre Hospitalier Universitaire d'Antananarivo (Madagascar).

Ravages caused by cholera among children are well known. The disease invaded Madagascar in 1999 May. This retrospective study reported the first childhood cholera cases. The survey was carried out at the Befelatanana Hospital during the period of cholera outbreak from April 23th to July 31st. The purpose of the study was to specify clinical, epidemiological and bacteriological characteristics of the disease. 5 out of 178 suspected cholera cases were less than 15 years old. 2 young girls out these 5 children, inhabitants of Antananarivo-City were hospitalized for acute diarrhoea with serious dehydratation. Their disease was confirmed by bacteriology. Vibrio cholera O1 strain, serovar Ogawa was identified. Epidemiological investigation allowed to identify the contamination modal in the file no 1. The authors conclude that cholera is an important problem of public health in developing country like Madagascar. Disease control needs environmental sanitation and good individual hygiene practices.

[Microscopy laboratories for the diagnosis of tuberculosis in Madagascar: quality control]. / Réseau des laboratoires de microscopie pour le diagnostic de la tuberculose à Madagascar: contrôle de qualité.

As part of the National Tuberculosis Program (NTP), a quality control of the slides (search of acido-fast-bacilli in the sputa) of the Treatment and Diagnosis Centers (TDC) forming the National Laboratory Network was carried out in 1996. 60 TDC of the 165 TDC (36%) had been controlled according to the system of double reading of the smears. The global concordance of the results in the 60 TDC is satisfactory since it was of 94%. Reliability of smears positive was of 83%. For the negative smears reliability, 14% of the TDC had a low or insufficient level. A good quality of smears was observed in 40% of the centers. The TDC that had both positive and negative reliability at 100% were 23 (38%) of which 13 had good quality of smears. Those were especially found in Antananarivo, Toliara, Fianarantsoa and Mahajanga.

[Tuberculosis in the province of Mahajanga]. / La tuberculose dans la province de Mahajanga.

Comparative study of compulsory declarations registered at the provincial level and at the central level between January 1st 1993 and 31st December 1994 showed a high prevalence of tuberculosis in the province of Mahajanga and an under-declaration of cases at the provincial level was almost 25% with regard to data collected at the central level. Smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis patients were the most frequent (86%), which showed respect towards the National Control Programme instructions. Extrapulmonary tuberculosis were under-estimated (less than 10%) because of the weak diagnosis means. Smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis under treatment in the city of Mahajanga were cured globally at 80%. The difference between the centres diminished between 1992 and 1993, then it persisted requiring the improvement of tubercular management conditions within the province structures and most particularly within the city of Mahajanga structures which are at the present taking charge of more than 50% of the province tubercular.

[Role of catholic centers in the control of tuberculosis]. / Place des centres catholiques dans la lutte contre la tuberculose.

This study briefly reports the results of a survey conducted by the National Tuberculosis Control Programme (NTCP) to asses the Catholic Centres and particularly the leper colonies activities of tuberculosis control. Among the 34 Catholic Centres taking care of the lepers, 11 take part in the NTCP. Within less than 3 years, most of these centres have taken charge of twice more tuberculous patients: the number of cases increased from 540 to 1045. Leprosy prevalence is constantly decreasing, thus multibacillary leprosy cases declared by these centres decreased of 28% from 1992, to 1994. Centres which did not begin conversion would feel this necessity soon. Germs responsible for leprosy and for tuberculosis are "first cousins". Technical and operational approaches for the control of both affections are very much alike. Those considerations logically induce to propose the conversion of antileprosy centres for tuberculosis control. Other arguments are partially exposed in this work. The Central Division knows the existence of 28 Catholic Centres throughout the country, taking charge of tuberculous patients. In 1994, they put more than 1600 patients under treatment, thus 15% of the tubercular in Madagascar. Those Catholic Centres implementing tuberculosis control programme ought set up a "federation" as a privileged interlocutor for the NTCP and for the financial backers when allowing support. Responsibles of the Programme expect to convince Centres of the necessity of conversion and of the interest of tuberculosis control.

[The National Tuberculosis Control Program in Madagascar]. / Le Programme National de Lutte Antituberculeuse (PNLAT) à Madagascar.

In 1991, the National Tuberculosis Control Program could start in Madagascar, thanks to the financial support of the French Cooperation. Within 3 years, this allocation of resources allowed the management, respecting the new standards, of 56% of the country's health structures and of more than 75% of the sick. The number of detected and treated patients increased of 80%. During the same period, the recovery rate increased from less than 35% to more than 65%. Those primary results were satisfactory in terms of working but they were not enough in epidemiological terms as the aims were still far: the detection rate of smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis was 40% whereas it ought be 60%, and their recovery rate was 65% whereas it ought to be over 80%. The geographic extension of the Program and its progress depend on a structural strengthening needing an obvious political will and on the intervention of financial partners cooperating with France and willing to set up a long lasting partnership.

[Role of the Lutheran Non-Governmental Health Organization in tuberculosis control]. / Rôle del l'Organisation Non Gouvernementale Luthérienne à but Sanitaire (SALFA) dans la lutte antituberculeuse.

Ever since its establishment in Madagascar, the Lutheran Church has been very active in medical field. In 1983, the creation of a medical non governmental organization called SALFA (Sampanasa Loteriana momba ny Fahasalamana) gave a new impulse. Since 1987, the SALFA has been seriously involved in the management of tuberculous patients. This document is a synthesis of actions conducted by SALFA whose experience in tuberculosis control is widely recognized by the Health Department and specially by the National Tuberculosis Control Program (NTCP). With an annual average of 1250 tuberculosis taken in charge, this NGO assumes 10% of the whole of the Program work. The diagnosis work is good (more than 85% Of PMT+) and therapeutic follow up of patients is excellent (more than 80% of the cured); those two elements of screening-treatment, basis of all tuberculosis control program incited us to describe this exemplary program.