How reliable is Ki-67 immunohistochemistry in grade 2 breast carcinomas? A QA study of the Swiss Working Group of Breast- and Gynecopathologists.

UNLABELLED: Adjuvant chemotherapy decisions in breast cancer are increasingly based on the pathologist's assessment of tumor proliferation. The Swiss Working Group of Gyneco- and Breast Pathologists has surveyed inter- and intraobserver consistency of Ki-67-based proliferative fraction in breast carcinomas. METHODS: Five pathologists evaluated MIB-1-labeling index (LI) in ten breast carcinomas (G1, G2, G3) by counting and eyeballing. In the same way, 15 pathologists all over Switzerland then assessed MIB-1-LI on three G2 carcinomas, in self-selected or pre-defined areas of the tumors, comparing centrally immunostained slides with slides immunostained in the different laboratoires. To study intra-observer variability, the same tumors were re-examined 4 months later. RESULTS: The Kappa values for the first series of ten carcinomas of various degrees of differentiation showed good to very good agreement for MIB-1-LI (Kappa 0.56-0.72). However, we found very high inter-observer variabilities (Kappa 0.04-0.14) in the read-outs of the G2 carcinomas. It was not possible to explain the inconsistencies exclusively by any of the following factors: (i) pathologists' divergent definitions of what counts as a positive nucleus (ii) the mode of assessment (counting vs. eyeballing), (iii) immunostaining technique, and (iv) the selection of the tumor area in which to count. Despite intensive confrontation of all participating pathologists with the problem, inter-observer agreement did not improve when the same slides were re-examined 4 months later (Kappa 0.01-0.04) and intra-observer agreement was likewise poor (Kappa 0.00-0.35). CONCLUSION: Assessment of mid-range Ki-67-LI suffers from high inter- and intra-observer variability. Oncologists should be aware of this caveat when using Ki-67-LI as a basis for treatment decisions in moderately differentiated breast carcinomas.

Immunohistochemical dual staining as an adjunct in assessment of mitotic activity in melanoma.

BACKGROUND: The mitotic rate was introduced as a major prognostic criterion for the staging of thin (≤1.0 mm) melanoma by the 2009 American Joint Committee on Cancer Staging and Classification (seventh edition). The detection of a single mitotic figure changes the tumor stage in thin melanoma. We sought to address the value of a dual staining to facilitate the determination of the mitotic rate and to assign the mitotic activity to melanocytes. METHODS: The mitotic rate of melanoma cells was determined by dual phosphohistone-H3 (PHH3)/Melan-A immunohistochemistry. Results were compared with PHH3 staining alone and conventional hematoxylin and eosin (H&E)-stained slides of 15 melanomas with a tumor thickness <1.0 mm. RESULTS: PHH3 staining clearly labeled cells in the mitotic cell cycle. The mitotic rate in the PHH3/Melan-A dual stain was equal to that derived by H&E staining. Time required for counting mitotic figures was significantly reduced. CONCLUSIONS: The evaluation of mitotic rate with an immunohistochemical dual stain is faster (mean 63.0%) and more reliable than evaluation by routine H&E staining alone. Dual staining immunohistochemistry may be a useful additional tool to standardize the determination of mitotic rate and may be helpful in evaluation of challenging cases.

Blastic natural killer cell lymphoma/leukemia: a report of seven cases.

Only a few blastic natural killer (NK) cell leukemias and lymphomas have been reported. As such, the clinicopathologic spectrum of this disease is incompletely understood. We report 7 cases of blastic NK cell lymphoma/leukemia. All patients were men, 5 white and 2 Arab American. All cases exhibited blastic morphologic features and were CD3- and CD56+ with germline T-cell receptor genes. Five cases were CD4+ and involved the skin. Both CD4- cases never involved the skin. Other markers of mature NK cells such as CD16, CD57, and TIA-1 were expressed infrequently. Three cases were CD33+. One CD33+ case had a clonal rearrangement of the immunoglobulin heavy chain gene. Skin and lymph nodes were involved most often, with frequent evolution to a leukemic phase. Initial responses to therapy were achieved in most patients, but the tumors invariably recurred.