FMR protein: Evidence of an emerging role in retinal aging?

Aging is a multifactorial process that affects the entire organism by cumulative alterations. Visual function impairments that go along with aging are commonly observed, causing lower visual acuity, lower contrast sensitivity, and impaired dark adaptation. Electroretinogram analysis revealed that the amplitudes of rod- and cone-mediated responses are reduced in aged mice and humans. Reports suggested that age-related changes observed in both rod and cone photoreceptor functionality were linked to oxidative stress regulation or free radical production homeostasis. Interestingly, several recent reports linked the fragile X mental retardation protein (FMRP) cellular activity with oxidative stress regulation in several tissue including brain tissue where FMRP participates to the response to stress via protein translation in neurite or is involved in free radical production and abnormal glutathione homeostasis. Based on these recent literatures, we raised the question about the effect of FMRP absence in the aging retina of Fmr1-/y compared to their WT littermates. Indeed, up to now, only young or adult mice (<6 months) were investigated and have shown a specific retinal phenotype. Herein, we demonstrated that Fmr1-/y mice do not present the aging effect on retinal function observed in WT littermates since ERG a- and b-waves amplitudes as well as oscillatory potentials amplitudes were not collapsed with age (12/18 months old). Absence of FMRP and its consequences seem to protect the retina against aging effect, rising a pivotal role of FMRP in retinal aging process.

Calpains are activated by light but their inhibition has no neuroprotective effect against light-damage.

Calpain had been shown to be highly activated at one day after exposure to the damaging light (Perche et al. (2007)Caspase-dependent apoptosis in light-induced retinal degeneration. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 48:2753-2759.), suggesting that they might play a critical role in photoreceptor apoptosis induced by light. Therefore in the present study we investigate the role of calpain in light-induced photoreceptor cell death. In a first set of experiments, untreated albino Wistar rats were sacrificed at 0, 2, 4, 6, 12, 24 h of light exposure and at one day after the light was turned off (D1) to measure retinal calpain activity and to study calpain expression. In a second set of experiments, after control electroretinograms (ERGs), rats were uninjected or injected intravitreally with DMSO or the calpain inhibitor Mu-Phe-hPhe-FMK, before being exposed to the damaging light for 24 h. ERGs were then recorded at one day (D1) and fifteen days (D15) after the end of light exposure. Rats were sacrificed at D1 for apoptotic cell detection or D15 for histological analysis (ONL thickness). Calpain activity and expression significantly increased in Untreated retinas, from 0 h to D1. DMSO has no effect on calpain activity. Mu-Phe-hPhe-FMK significantly inhibited retinal calpain activity by 85% at 2 h of light exposure and still 48% at D1. However, Mu-Phe-hPhe-FMK has no effect on light-induced retinal degeneration as evidence by equivalent loss of function, equivalent loss of photoreceptor cells and an equivalent number of apoptotic cells in Mu-Phe-hPhe-FMK and DMSO retinas. Therefore, calpains are up-regulated by light stress but they do not have a pivotal role in photoreceptor apoptosis.

Transient protective effect of caspase inhibitors in RCS rat.

In most retinal degenerations in humans and in animal models, photoreceptor cells die by apoptosis. Although the biochemical features are similar in all apoptotic cells, different molecular events lead the cell to death. In the present study we used a rat model of inherited retinal degeneration, the RCS rats, to investigate the involvement of the proteases, caspases and/or calpains, in photoreceptor apoptosis. In the first experiments, rats were untreated or injected intravitreally at post natal day 27 (P27) with the large broad spectrum caspase inhibitor, ZVAD, the calpain inhibitor, MuhPhe, or with the vehicle, DMSO. Retinal status was evaluated at P35 and P42 by electroretinography, morphometry and apoptotic nuclei detection. DMSO and MuhPhe had no effect on RCS retinas as evidenced by equivalent loss of function and equivalent number of apoptotic cells than in untreated group. ZVAD transiently reduced apoptotic cells and preserved photoreceptor function at P35 but not at P42. These results suggest that caspases but not calpains are involved in retinal degeneration in the RCS. In the second experiments, RCS rats were injected twice at P27 and P35 with ZVAD or DMSO. Although ZVAD-treated retinas were preserved at P35 compared to the DMSO controls, the second injection of ZVAD did not extend the preserving effect to P42. Moreover, a single injection of ZVAD at P35 had no preserving effect at P42. All these data taken together suggest that caspases do not play a pivotal role after P35. In a fourth set of experiments, we used specific caspase inhibitors to elucidate which caspase was activated. The caspase-1/4 inhibitor (YVAD) or the caspase-3/7 inhibitor (DEVD) were injected intravitreally at P27 and retinal status was evaluated at P35 and P42. Electroretinograms and apoptotic nuclei detection demonstrated that YVAD and DEVD preserved photoreceptors at P35 but not at P42. These results suggest that both caspase-1/4 and caspase-3/7 play a major role in the apoptotic pathway between P27 and P35 in retinal degeneration of RCS rats. In this study, we show that 1/ the photoreceptor apoptotic process in the RCS rat involves caspases but not calpains, and 2/ the retinal degeneration seems to be composed of different phases involving different molecular players. Indeed, we have demonstrated that caspases are playing a major role at P35, but not at P42.