The role of aromatic groups in the Tobey-Simon additivity rule for vinylic protons.

The Tobey-Simon (additivity) rule for aromatic groups which was devised about 40 years ago has been found to need revision. The rule shows an aromatic group attached to a C==C double bond as causing a downfield chemical shift of a cis-related vinylic proton and a small upfield shift of a trans-related proton. A search of data in the recent literature has shown that this rule should apply mainly to monosubstituted phenyl groups and some polynuclear aromatics. In contrast with them, 2,6-disubstituted phenyl, 2,4,6-trisubstituted phenyl and 9-anthracenyl groups cause cis-related vinylic protons to resonate upfield of comparable trans-related protons. Further, the current rule for o-substituted phenyl groups has been found to be inaccurate. In writing a rule for aromatic groups, therefore, greater attention needs to be given to the diversity of effects that these groups have on chemical shifts of vinylic protons.

Adducts of thianthrene- and phenoxathiin cation radical tetrafluoroborates to 1-alkynes. Structures and formation of 1-(5-thianthreniumyl)- and 1-(10-phenoxathiiniumyl)alkynes on alumina leading to alpha-ketoylides and alpha-ketols.

[structure: see text] Thianthrene cation radical tetrafluoroborate (Th*+ BF4(-)) added to the terminal alkynes 1-pentyne, 1-hexyne, 1-heptyne, 1-octyne, 1-nonyne, and 1-decyne to form trans-1,2-bis(5-thianthreniumyl)alkene tetrafluoroborates (1-6). Similarly, addition of phenoxathiin cation radical tetrafluoroborate (PO*+ BF4(-)) to the same alkynes gave 1,2-bis(10-phenoxathiiniumyl)alkene tetrafluoroborates (7-12). The trans configuration of two of the adducts (1 and 4) was shown with X-ray crystallography. When solutions of 1-6 in chloroform were stirred with activated alumina, cis elimination of a proton and thianthrene (Th) occurred with the formation of 1-(5-thianthreniumyl)alkyne tetrafluoroborates (1a-6a). Similar treatment of 8-12 caused elimination of a proton and phenoxathiin (PO) with formation of 1-(10-phenoxathiiniumyl)alkene tetrafluoroborates (8a-12a). Stirring of 1a-6a with alumina for short periods of time caused their conversion into 5-[(alpha-keto)alkyl]thianthrenium ylides (1b-6b) and alpha-ketols, RC(O)CH2OH (1c-6c).

Adducts of thianthrene- and phenoxathiin cation radical salts with symmetrical alkynes. Structure and formation of cumulenes on alumina leading to alpha-diketones, alpha-hydroxyalkynes, and alpha-acetamidoalkynes.

[reaction: see text] Thianthrene cation radical tetrafluoroborate (Th*+ BF4-) added to 2-butyne, 3-hexyne, 4-octyne, and 5-decyne in MeCN to form trans bisadducts R(Th+)C=C(Th+)R, where R = Me, Et, Pr, Bu (7a-d). Phenoxathiin cation radical tetrafluoroborate (PO*+ BF4-) added similarly to the last three alkynes to form adducts R(PO+)C=C(PO+)R, 8b-d. Cyclic monoadducts were not found. The trans structures of 7 and 8 were deduced with X-ray crystallography (7c) and NMR spectroscopy. When solutions of adducts in CHCl3 and MeCN were deposited on activated alumina, elimination of thianthrene (Th) and phenoxathiin (PO) occurred almost quantitatively. Detailed studies with (7b-d) indicated that a cumulene (15) was formed by the elimination of Th and that 15 was subsequently converted into small amounts of other products. In CHCl3, these products were the respective alkyne, thianthrene 5-oxide, an alpha-diketone (11), an alpha-hydroxyalkyne (12), and hydrogen. The same products were formed in MeCN along with an alpha-acetamidoalkyne (13). The formation of 15 and products derived from it is explained and was confirmed by preparation and reactions of 2,3,4-hexatriene.