Comparative biological responses to human Sonic, Indian, and Desert hedgehog.

A comprehensive comparison of Sonic (Shh), Indian (Ihh), and Desert (Dhh) hedgehog biological activities has not previously been undertaken. To test whether the three higher vertebrate Hh proteins have distinct biological properties, we compared recombinant forms of the N-terminal domains of human Shh, Ihh, and Dhh in a variety of cell-based and tissue explant assays in which their activities could be assessed at a range of concentrations. While we observed that the proteins were similar in their affinities for the Hh-binding proteins; Patched (Ptc) and Hedgehog-interacting protein (Hip), and were equipotent in their ability to induce Islet-1 in chick neural plate explant; there were dramatic differences in their potencies in several other assays. Most dramatic were the Hh-dependent responses of C3H10T1/2 cells, where relative potencies ranged from 80nM for Shh, to 500nM for Ihh, to >5microM for Dhh. Similar trends in potency were seen in the ability of the three Hh proteins to induce differentiation of chondrocytes in embryonic mouse limbs, and to induce the expression of nodal in the lateral plate mesoderm of early chick embryos. However, in a chick embryo digit duplication assay used to measure polarizing activity, Ihh was the least active, and Dhh was almost as potent as Shh. These findings suggest that a mechanism for fine-tuning the biological actions of Shh, Ihh, and Dhh, exists beyond the simple temporal and spatial control of their expression domains within the developing and adult organism.

Enhanced potency of human Sonic hedgehog by hydrophobic modification.

Post-translational modifications of the developmental signaling protein Sonic hedgehog (Shh) by a long-chain fatty acid at the N-terminus and cholesterol at the C-terminus greatly activate the protein in a cell-based signaling assay. To investigate the structural determinants of this activation phenomenon, hydrophobic and hydrophilic moieties have been introduced by chemical and mutagenic methods to the soluble N-terminal signaling domain of Shh and tested in both in vitro and in vivo assays. A wide variety of hydrophobic modifications increased the potency of Shh when added at the N-terminus of the protein, ranging from long-chain fatty acids to hydrophobic amino acids, with EC(50) values from 99 nM for the unmodified protein to 0.6 nM for the myristoylated form. The N-myristoylated Shh was as active as the natural form having both N- and C-terminal modifications. The degree of activation appears to correlate with the hydrophobicity of the modification rather than any specific chemical feature of the adduct; moreover, substitution with hydrophilic moieties decreased activity. Hydrophobic modifications at the C-terminus of Shh resulted in only a 2-3-fold increase in activity, and no activation was found with hydrophobic modification at other surface positions. The N-terminal modifications did not appear to alter the binding affinity of the Shh protein for the transfected receptor protein, Patched, and had no apparent effect on structure as measured by circular dichroism, thermal denaturation, and size determination. Activation of Desert Hh through modification of its N-terminus was also observed, suggesting that this is a common feature of Hh proteins.

Regular articles: conditional disruption of hedgehog signaling pathway defines its critical role in hair development and regeneration.

Members of the vertebrate hedgehog family (Sonic, Indian, and Desert) have been shown to be essential for the development of various organ systems, including neural, somite, limb, skeletal, and for male gonad morphogenesis. Sonic hedgehog and its cognate receptor Patched are expressed in the epithelial and/or mesenchymal cell components of the hair follicle. Recent studies have demonstrated an essential role for this pathway in hair development in the skin of Sonic hedgehog null embryos. We have further explored the role of the hedgehog pathway using anti-hedgehog blocking monoclonal antibodies to treat pregnant mice at different stages of gestation and have generated viable offspring that lack body coat hair. Histologic analysis revealed the presence of ectodermal placode and primodium of dermal papilla in these mice, yet the subsequent hair shaft formation was inhibited. In contrast, the vibrissae (whisker) development appears to be unaffected upon anti-hedgehog blocking monoclonal antibody treatment. Strikingly, inhibition of body coat hair morphogenesis also was observed in mice treated postnatally with anti-hedgehog monoclonal antibody during the growing (anagen) phase of the hair cycle. The hairless phenotype was reversible upon suspension of monoclonal antibody treatment. Taken together, our results underscore a direct role of the Sonic hedgehog signaling pathway in embryonic hair follicle development as well as in subsequent hair cycles in young and adult mice. Our system of generating an inducible and reversible hairless phenotype by anti-hedgehog monoclonal antibody treatment will be valuable for studying the regulation and mechanism of hair regeneration.

Mapping sonic hedgehog-receptor interactions by steric interference.

We have defined regions in the Sonic hedgehog (Shh) molecule that are important for Patched (Ptc) receptor binding by targeting selected surface amino acid residues with probes of diverse sizes and shapes and assessing the effects of these modifications on function. Eleven amino acid residues that surround the surface of the protein were chosen for these studies and mutated to cysteine residues. These cysteines were then selectively modified with thiol-specific probes, and the modified proteins were tested for hedgehog receptor binding activity and their ability to induce differentiation of C3H10T1/2 cells into osteoblasts. Based on these analyses, approximately one-third of the Shh surface can be modified without effect on function regardless of the size of the attachment. These sites are located near to where the C terminus protrudes from the surface of the protein. All other sites were sensitive to modification, indicating that the interaction of Shh with its primary receptor Ptc is mediated over a large surface of the Shh protein. For sites Asn-50 and Ser-156, function was lost with the smallest of the probes tested, indicating that these residues are in close proximity to the Ptc-binding site. The epitope for the neutralizing mAb 5E1 mapped to a close but distinct region of the structure. The structure-activity data provide a unique view of the interactions between Shh and Ptc that is not readily attainable by conventional mapping strategies.

Zinc-dependent structural stability of human Sonic hedgehog.

The role of the zinc site in the N-terminal fragment of human Sonic hedgehog (ShhN) was explored by comparing the biophysical and functional properties of wild-type ShhN with those of mutants in which the zinc-coordinating residues H140, D147, and H182, or E176 which interacts with the metal ion via a bridging water molecule, were mutated to alanine. The wild-type and E176A mutant proteins retained 1 mol of zinc/mol of protein after extensive dialysis, whereas the H140A and D147A mutants retained only 0.03 and 0.05 mol of zinc/mol of protein, respectively. Assay of the wild-type and mutant proteins in two activity assays indicated that the wild-type and E176A mutant proteins had similar activity, whereas the H140A and D147A mutants were significantly less active. These assays also indicated that the H140A and D147A mutants were susceptible to proteolysis. CD, fluorescence, and (1)H NMR spectra of the H140A, D147A, and E176A mutants measured at 20 or 25 degrees C were very similar to those observed for wild-type ShhN. However, CD measurements at 37 degrees C showed evidence of some structural differences in the H140A and D147A mutants. Guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) denaturation studies revealed that the loss of zinc from the H140A and D147A mutants destabilized the folded proteins by approximately 3.5 kcal/mol, comparable to the effect of removing zinc from wild-type ShhN by treatment with EDTA. Thermal melting curves of wild-type ShhN gave a single unfolding transition with a midpoint T(m) of approximately 59 degrees C, whereas both the H140A and D147A mutants displayed two distinct transitions with T(m) values of 37-38 and 52-54 degrees C, similar to that observed for EDTA-treated wild-type ShhN. Addition of zinc to the H140A and D147A mutants resulted in a partial restoration of stability against thermal and GuHCl denaturation. The ability of these mutants to bind zinc was confirmed using a fluorescence-based binding assay that indicated that they bound zinc with K(d) values of approximately 1.6 and approximately 15 nM, respectively, as compared to a value of

Functional antagonists of sonic hedgehog reveal the importance of the N terminus for activity.

During development, sonic hedgehog functions as a morphogen in both a short-range contact-dependent and in a long-range diffusable mode. Here, we show using a panel of sonic hedgehog variants that regions near the N terminus of the protein play a critical role in modulating these functions. In the hedgehog responsive cell line C3H10T1/2, we discovered that not only were some N-terminally truncated variants inactive at eliciting a hedgehog-dependent response, but they competed with the wild-type protein for function and therefore served as functional antagonists. These variants were indistinguishable from wild-type sonic hedgehog in their ability to bind the receptor patched-1, but failed to induce the hedgehog-responsive markers, Gli-1 and Ptc-1, and failed to promote hedgehog-dependent differentiation of the cell line. They also failed to support the adhesion of C3H10T1/2 cells to hedgehog-coated plates under conditions where wild-type sonic hedgehog supported binding. Structure-activity data indicated that the N-terminal cysteine plays a key regulatory role in modulating hedgehog activity. The ability to dissect patched-1 binding from signaling events in C3H10T1/2 cells suggests the presence of unidentified factors that contribute to hedgehog responses.

Identification of a palmitic acid-modified form of human Sonic hedgehog.

During hedgehog biosynthesis, autocatalytic processing produces a lipid-modified amino-terminal fragment (residues 24-197 in the human Sonic hedgehog sequence) that is responsible for all known hedgehog signaling activity and that is highly conserved evolutionarily. Published in vitro biochemical studies using Drosophila hedgehog identified the membrane anchor as a cholesterol, and localized the site of attachment to the COOH terminus of the fragment. We have expressed full-length human Sonic hedgehog in insect and in mammalian cells and determined by mass spectrometry that, in addition to cholesterol, the human hedgehog protein is palmitoylated. Peptide mapping and sequencing data indicate that the palmitoyl group is attached to the NH2 terminus of the protein on the alpha-amino group of Cys-24. Cell-free palmitoylation studies demonstrate that radioactive palmitic acid is readily incorporated into wild type Sonic hedgehog, but not into variant forms lacking the Cys-24 attachment site. The lipid-tethered forms of hedgehog showed about a 30-fold increase in potency over unmodified soluble hedgehog in a cell- based (C3H10T1/2 alkaline phosphatase induction) assay, suggesting that the lipid tether plays an important role in hedgehog function. The observation that an extracellular protein such as Shh is palmitoylated is highly unusual and further adds to the complex nature of this protein.