Bulky Lesion Bypass Requires Dpo4 Binding in Distinct Conformations.

Translesion DNA synthesis is an essential process that helps resume DNA replication at forks stalled near bulky adducts on the DNA. Benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) is a polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) that can be metabolically activated to benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxide (BPDE), which then can react with DNA to form carcinogenic DNA adducts. Here, we have used single-molecule florescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) experiments, classical molecular dynamics simulations, and nucleotide incorporation assays to investigate the mechanism by which the model Y-family polymerase, Dpo4, bypasses a (+)-cis-B[a]P-N 2-dG adduct in DNA. Our data show that when (+)-cis-B[a]P-N 2-dG is the templating base, the B[a]P moiety is in a non-solvent exposed conformation stacked within the DNA helix, where it effectively blocks nucleotide incorporation across the adduct by Dpo4. However, when the media contains a small amount of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), the adduct is able to move to a solvent-exposed conformation, which enables error-prone DNA replication past the adduct. When the primer terminates across from the adduct position, the addition of DMSO leads to the formation of an insertion complex capable of accurate nucleotide incorporation.

Influence of DNA Lesions on Polymerase-Mediated DNA Replication at Single-Molecule Resolution.

Faithful replication of DNA is a critical aspect in maintaining genome integrity. DNA polymerases are responsible for replicating DNA, and high-fidelity polymerases do this rapidly and at low error rates. Upon exposure to exogenous or endogenous substances, DNA can become damaged and this can alter the speed and fidelity of a DNA polymerase. In this instance, DNA polymerases are confronted with an obstacle that can result in genomic instability during replication, for example, by nucleotide misinsertion or replication fork collapse. It is important to know how DNA polymerases respond to damaged DNA substrates to understand the mechanism of mutagenesis and chemical carcinogenesis. Single-molecule techniques have helped to improve our current understanding of DNA polymerase-mediated DNA replication, as they enable the dissection of mechanistic details that can otherwise be lost in ensemble-averaged experiments. These techniques have also been used to gain a deeper understanding of how single DNA polymerases behave at the site of the damage in a DNA substrate. In this review, we evaluate single-molecule studies that have examined the interaction between DNA polymerases and damaged sites on a DNA template.

Mechanism of aromatic amine carcinogen bypass by the Y-family polymerase, Dpo4.

Bulky DNA damage inhibits DNA synthesis by replicative polymerases and often requires the action of error prone bypass polymerases. The exact mechanism governing adduct-induced mutagenesis and its dependence on the DNA sequence context remains unclear. In this work, we characterize Dpo4 binding conformations and activity with DNA templates modified with the carcinogenic DNA adducts, 2-aminofluoene (AF) or N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene (AAF), using single-molecule FRET (smFRET) analysis and DNA synthesis extension assays. We find that in the absence of dNTPs, both adducts alter polymerase binding as measured by smFRET, but the addition of dNTPs induces the formation of a ternary complex having what appears to be a conformation similar to the one observed with an unmodified DNA template. We also observe that the misincorporation pathways for each adduct present significant differences: while an AF adduct induces a structure consistent with the previously observed primer-template looped structure, its acetylated counterpart uses a different mechanism, one consistent with a dNTP-stabilized misalignment mechanism.

Nucleotide selection by the Y-family DNA polymerase Dpo4 involves template translocation and misalignment.

Y-family DNA polymerases play a crucial role in translesion DNA synthesis. Here, we have characterized the binding kinetics and conformational dynamics of the Y-family polymerase Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 DNA polymerase IV (Dpo4) using single-molecule fluorescence. We find that in the absence of dNTPs, the binary complex shuttles between two different conformations within ∼1 s. These data are consistent with prior crystal structures in which the nucleotide binding site is either occupied by the terminal base pair (preinsertion conformation) or empty following Dpo4 translocation by 1 base pair (insertion conformation). Most interestingly, on dNTP binding, only the insertion conformation is observed and the correct dNTP stabilizes this complex compared with the binary complex, whereas incorrect dNTPs destabilize it. However, if the n+1 template base is complementary to the incoming dNTP, a structure consistent with a misaligned template conformation is observed, in which the template base at the n position loops out. This structure provides evidence for a Dpo4 mutagenesis pathway involving a transient misalignment mechanism.

Carcinogenic adducts induce distinct DNA polymerase binding orientations.

DNA polymerases must accurately replicate DNA to maintain genome integrity. Carcinogenic adducts, such as 2-aminofluorene (AF) and N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene (AAF), covalently bind DNA bases and promote mutagenesis near the adduct site. The mechanism by which carcinogenic adducts inhibit DNA synthesis and cause mutagenesis remains unclear. Here, we measure interactions between a DNA polymerase and carcinogenic DNA adducts in real-time by single-molecule fluorescence. We find the degree to which an adduct affects polymerase binding to the DNA depends on the adduct location with respect to the primer terminus, the adduct structure and the nucleotides present in the solution. Not only do the adducts influence the polymerase dwell time on the DNA but also its binding position and orientation. Finally, we have directly observed an adduct- and mismatch-induced intermediate state, which may be an obligatory step in the DNA polymerase proofreading mechanism.

Single-molecule microscopy reveals new insights into nucleotide selection by DNA polymerase I.

The mechanism by which DNA polymerases achieve their extraordinary accuracy has been intensely studied because of the linkage between this process and mutagenesis and carcinogenesis. Here, we have used single-molecule fluorescence microscopy to study the process of nucleotide selection and exonuclease action. Our results show that the binding of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) to a primer-template is stabilized by the presence of the next correct dNTP, even in the presence of a large excess of the other dNTPs and rNTPs. These results are consistent with a model where nucleotide selection occurs in the open complex prior to the formation of a closed ternary complex. Our assay can also distinguish between primer binding to the polymerase or exonuclease domain and, contrary to ensemble-averaged studies, we find that stable exonuclease binding only occurs with a mismatched primer terminus.

DNA polymerase: structural homology, conformational dynamics, and the effects of carcinogenic DNA adducts.

DNA replication is vital for an organism to proliferate and lying at the heart of this process is the enzyme DNA polymerase. Most DNA polymerases have a similar three dimensional fold, akin to a human right hand, despite differences in sequence homology. This structural homology would predict a relatively unvarying mechanism for DNA synthesis yet various polymerases exhibit markedly different properties on similar substrates, indicative of each type of polymerase being prescribed to a specific role in DNA replication. Several key conformational steps, discrete states, and structural moieties have been identified that contribute to the array of properties the polymerases exhibit. The ability of carcinogenic adducts to interfere with conformational processes by directly interacting with the protein explicates the mutagenic consequences these adducts impose. Recent studies have identified novel states that have been hypothesised to test the fit of the nascent base pair, and have also shown the enzyme to possess a lively quality by continually sampling various conformations. This review focuses on the homologous structural changes that take place in various DNA polymerases, both replicative and those involved in adduct bypass, the role these changes play in selection of a correct substrate, and how the presence of bulky carcinogenic adducts affects these changes.

Single-molecule measurements of synthesis by DNA polymerase with base-pair resolution.

The catalytic mechanism of DNA polymerases involves multiple steps that precede and follow the transfer of a nucleotide to the 3'-hydroxyl of the growing DNA chain. Here we report a single-molecule approach to monitor the movement of E. coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) on a DNA template during DNA synthesis with single base-pair resolution. As each nucleotide is incorporated, the single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer intensity drops in discrete steps to values consistent with single-nucleotide incorporations. Purines and pyrimidines are incorporated with comparable rates. A mismatched primer/template junction exhibits dynamics consistent with the primer moving into the exonuclease domain, which was used to determine the fraction of primer-termini bound to the exonuclease and polymerase sites. Most interestingly, we observe a structural change after the incorporation of a correctly paired nucleotide, consistent with transient movement of the polymerase past the preinsertion site or a conformational change in the polymerase. This may represent a previously unobserved step in the mechanism of DNA synthesis that could be part of the proofreading process.

Monitoring the conformation of benzo[a]pyrene adducts in the polymerase active site using fluorescence resonance energy transfer.

Benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) is a potent environmental carcinogen that is metabolized into diol epoxides that react with exocyclic amines in DNA. These DNA adducts have been shown to block DNA replication by high-fidelity polymerases and induce both base substitution and frame-shift mutations. To improve our understanding of the molecular mechanism of B[a]P-induced mutagenesis, a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) method was developed in which the (+)- or (-)-trans-anti-B[a]P-N(2)-dG adducts, positioned in the active site of DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment), serve as donor fluorophores to an acceptor molecule positioned on the DNA primer strand. FRET was measured for a primer that ended one nucleotide before the adduct position and one that ended across from the adduct and used to estimate the distances between the two fluorophores. These estimates are consistent with prior studies that suggest the adducts are positioned in the minor groove. A comparison of the FRET for the (+)- and (-)-trans-B[a]P adducts in the Klenow active site suggested that the (+)-trans adduct is positioned approximately 2 A farther from the acceptor, consistent with the structural differences observed in duplex DNA where it has been shown that the (+)-trans adduct is oriented toward the 5'-end of the template strand while the (-)-trans adduct lies toward the 3'-end. Surprisingly, the adduct position did not change significantly when the primer was one nucleotide longer. The addition of either a correct (dCTP) or incorrect nucleotides showed only minor differences in FRET, suggesting that the adduct did not undergo a large change in the position within the polymerase active site, as expected if the adduct inhibited the polymerase conformational change.

Effect of N-2-acetylaminofluorene and 2-aminofluorene adducts on DNA binding and synthesis by yeast DNA polymerase eta.

The well-studied aromatic amine carcinogen, N-2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF), forms adducts at the C8 position of guanine in DNA. Unlike replicative polymerases, Y-family polymerases have been shown to have the ability to bypass such bulky DNA lesions. To better understand the mechanism of translesion synthesis by the yeast DNA polymerase eta (yPoleta), a gel retardation technique was used to measure equilibrium dissociation constants of this polymerase for unmodified DNA or DNA containing dG-C8-AAF or the related deacylated dG-C8-AF adduct. These results show that the binding of yPoleta to the unmodified primer-template is substantially stronger in the presence of the next correct nucleotide than when no or an incorrect nucleotide is present. In addition, binding of yPoleta to either dG-C8-AAF or AF-modified templates is also stronger in the presence of dCTP. Finally, the yPoleta complex is destabilized if the primer extends to a position across from the adduct, and stronger binding is not observed in the presence of the next correct nucleotide. Taken together, these data are consistent with the ability of yPoleta to undergo a conformational change to a closed ternary complex in the presence of the next correct nucleotide and on templates containing an AAF or AF adduct but do not rule out other possible explanations.

The role of specific amino acid residues in the active site of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I on translesion DNA synthesis across from and past an N-2-aminofluorene adduct.

Understanding how carcinogenic DNA adducts compromise accurate DNA replication is an important goal in cancer research. A central part of these studies is to determine the molecular mechanism that allows a DNA polymerase to incorporate a nucleotide across from and past a bulky adduct in a DNA template. To address the importance of polymerase architecture on replication across from this type of bulky DNA adduct, three active-site mutants of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) were used to study DNA synthesis on DNA modified with the carcinogen N-2-aminofluorene (AF). Running-start synthesis studies showed that full-length synthesis past the AF adduct was inhibited for all of the mutants, but that this inhibition was substantially less for the F762A mutant. Single nucleotide extension and steady-state kinetic experiments showed that the Y766S mutant displayed higher rates of insertion of each incorrect nucleotide relative to WT across from the dG-AF adduct. This effect was not observed for F762A or E710A mutants. Similar experiments that measured synthesis one nucleotide past the dG-AF adduct revealed an enhanced preference by the F762A mutant for dG opposite the T at this position. Finally, synthesis at the +1 and +2 positions was inhibited to a greater extent for the Y766S and E710A mutants compared with both the WT and F762A mutants. Taken together, this work is consistent with the model that polymerase geometry plays a crucial role in both the insertion and extension steps during replication across from bulky DNA lesions.

Mechanism for N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene-induced frameshift mutagenesis by Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment).

N-Acetyl-2-aminofluorene (AAF) is a chemical carcinogen that reacts with guanines at the C8 position in DNA to form a structure that interferes with DNA replication. In bacteria, the NarI restriction enzyme recognition sequence (G1G2CG3CC) is a very strong mutational hot spot when an AAF adduct is positioned at G3 of this sequence, causing predominantly a -2 frameshift GC dinucleotide deletion mutation. In this study, templates were constructed that contained an AAF adduct at this position, and primers of different lengths were prepared such that the primer ended one nucleotide before or opposite or one nucleotide after the adduct site. Primer extension and gel shift binding assays were used to study the mechanism of bypass by the Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) in the presence of these templates. Primer extension in the presence of all four dNTPs produced a fully extended product using the unmodified template, while with the AAF-modified template synthesis initially stalled at the adduct site and subsequent synthesis resulted in a product that contained the GC dinucleotide deletion. Extension product and gel shift binding analyses were consistent with the formation of a two-nucleotide bulge structure upstream of the active site of the polymerase after a nucleotide is incorporated across from the adduct. These data support a model in which the AAF adduct in the NarI sequence specifically induces a structure upstream of the polymerase active site that leads to the GC frameshift mutation and that it is this structure that allows synthesis past the adduct to occur.

Crystal structures of 2-acetylaminofluorene and 2-aminofluorene in complex with T7 DNA polymerase reveal mechanisms of mutagenesis.

The carcinogen 2-acetylaminofluorene forms two major DNA adducts: N-(2'-deoxyguanosin-8-yl)-2-acetylaminofluorene (dG-AAF) and its deacetylated derivative, N-(2'-deoxyguanosin-8-yl)-2-aminofluorene (dG-AF). Although the dG-AAF and dG-AF adducts are distinguished only by the presence or absence of an acetyl group, they have profoundly different effects on DNA replication. dG-AAF poses a strong block to DNA synthesis and primarily induces frameshift mutations in bacteria, resulting in the loss of one or two nucleotides during replication past the lesion. dG-AF is less toxic and more easily bypassed by DNA polymerases, albeit with an increased frequency of misincorporation opposite the lesion, primarily resulting in G --> T transversions. We present three crystal structures of bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase replication complexes, one with dG-AAF in the templating position and two others with dG-AF in the templating position. Our crystallographic data suggest why a dG-AAF adduct blocks replication more strongly than does a dG-AF adduct and provide a possible explanation for frameshift mutagenesis during replication bypass of a dG-AAF adduct. The dG-AAF nucleoside adopts a syn conformation that facilitates the intercalation of its fluorene ring into a hydrophobic pocket on the surface of the fingers subdomain and locks the fingers in an open, inactive conformation. In contrast, the dG-AF base at the templating position is not well defined by the electron density, consistent with weak binding to the polymerase and a possible interchange of this adduct between the syn and anti conformations.

Mechanistic insights into replication across from bulky DNA adducts: a mutant polymerase I allows an N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene adduct to be accommodated during DNA synthesis.

The molecular mechanism that allows a polymerase to incorporate a nucleotide opposite a DNA lesion is not well-understood. One way to study this process is to characterize the altered molecular interactions that occur between the polymerase and a damaged template. Prior studies have determined the polymerase-template dissociation constants and used kinetic analyses and a protease digestion assay to measure the effect of various DNA adducts positioned in the active site of Klenow fragment (KF). Here, a mutator polymerase was used in which the tyrosine at position 766 of the KF has been replaced with a serine. This position is located at the junction of the fingers and palm domain and is thought to be involved in maintaining the active site geometry. The primer-template was modified with N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene (AAF), a well-studied carcinogenic adduct. The mutant polymerase displayed a significant increase in the rate of incorporation of the correct nucleotide opposite the adduct but was much less prone to incorporate an incorrect nucleotide relative to the wild-type polymerase. Both the wild-type and the mutant polymerase bound much more tightly to the AAF-modified primer-template; however, unlike the wild-type polymerase, the binding strength of the mutant was influenced by the presence of a dNTP. Moreover, the mutant polymerase was able to undergo a dNTP-induced conformational change when the AAF adduct was positioned in the active site, while the wild-type enzyme could not. A model is proposed in which the looser active site of the mutant is able to better accommodate the AAF adduct.

Effects of benzo[a]pyrene adduct stereochemistry on downstream DNA replication in vitro: evidence for different adduct conformations within the active site of DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment).

The presence of bulky adducts in DNA is known to interfere with DNA replication not only at the site of the lesion but also at positions up to 5 nucleotides past the adduct location. Kinetic studies of primer extension by exonuclease-deficient E. coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) (KF) when (+)-trans- or (+)-cis-B[a]P-N(2)-dG adducts were positioned in the double-stranded region of the primer-templates showed that both stereoisomers significantly block downstream replication. However the (+)-cis adduct, which causes a stronger inhibition of the nucleotides insertion across from and immediately past the lesion, affected the downstream replication to a much smaller extent than did the (+)-trans adduct, especially when the B[a]P-modified dG was properly paired with a dC. The effects of mismatches across from the adduct and the sequence context surrounding the adduct were also dependent on the stereochemistry of the B[a]P adduct. Thus, the identity of the nucleotide across from the adduct that provided the best downstream replication was different for the (+)-cis and (+)-trans adducts, a factor that might differentially contribute to the mutagenic bypass of these lesions. These findings provide strong direct evidence that the conformations of the (+)-cis and (+)-trans adducts within the active site of KF are significantly different and probably differentially affect the interactions of the polymerase with the minor groove, thereby leading to different replication trends. The stereochemistry of the adduct was also found to differentially affect the sequence-mediated primer-template misalignments, resulting in different consequences during the bypass of the lesion.