Kentucky physicians' perspectives and preparedness for computing in medical education and practice.

PURPOSE: To examine the University of Kentucky College of Medicine's community-based faculty's (CBF) perspective on computing skills that students should acquire for future medical practice, and if the CBF currently use these skills in their daily practice. METHODS: A survey was mailed to 281 of the institution's CBF in the spring of 1997. The survey listed eight basic computing skills derived from our computing curricular objectives for students and asked respondents (a) if they use the skill, and (b) if students should learn the skill. RESULTS: 200 respondents returned a completed survey. 14 CBF (7.2%) indicated that they have all eight computer skills while 91 CBF (46.4%) indicated that students should learn all eight computer skills. 25 CBF (13%) indicated that they have none of the computer skills, while none of the CBF indicated students need none of the skills. A significant difference between primary care CBF and other specialist CBF was found with respect to self-report of computer use, but not regarding their opinions about students' need to learn computer skills. CONCLUSION: The majority of our CBF report using at least one computer skill in their practices. Regardless of specialty, CBF report that students should possess more computer skills than they themselves have. Medical educators should incorporate computing applications into the curriculum to provide appropriate computer training for future physicians.

Faculty development: a field of dreams.

This chapter describes the faculty development efforts of the eight schools that participated in The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation's "Preparing Physicians for the Future: Program in Medical Education." The authors define "faculty development" as the "enhancement of educational knowledge and skill of faculty members so that their educational contributions can extend to advancing the educational program rather than just teaching within it." Faculty development programs varied widely among the schools. Some schools had active programs in place, others initiated programs at the start of the project. This chapter explores the faculty development topics and methods, both shared and unique, among the eight schools. It then looks at the ways the schools motivated their faculties to participate in their programs. Finally, it describes some of the outcome measures that were used to gauge the effectiveness of the faculty development programs. The authors conclude that the eight schools' approaches and levels of commitment to their faculty development programs varied. They present lessons learned from the successes and failures of the various programs.

The relationship between medical students' academic achievement and patterns of initial postgraduate placement.

PURPOSE: To explore the relationship between various levels of academic achievement and the spectrum of initial specialty placements for graduates. METHOD: The authors studied the initial specialty placements of all 1984-1994 graduates of the University of Kentucky College of Medicine. Statistical analyses were used to determine the nature and strength of the relationships between initial specialty selection and students' achievement indicators and changes in that relationship over time. RESULTS: Students tended to aggregate across time into discernible levels of achievement. The relationships between academic achievement levels and initial specialty placements were highly variable. CONCLUSION: Although students with higher levels of achievement had broader choices available to them, graduates at every level of achievement entered a wide variety of specialties. Thus, the authors believe that academic achievement should not be used to the exclusion of other performance characteristics in determining how students and residencies should be matched.

Computer requirements for medical school students--implications for admissions.

Computers are increasingly being used in clinical practice settings. Aware of the need to educate students regarding computer applications in medicine, the University of Kentucky College of Medicine is in the midst of developing a computer curriculum. To that end, many courses and clerkships have devised software packages for transmittal of course information and for evaluation of student performance. This paper outlines requisite computer skills that applicants applying to medical school should possess, broadly reviews how those computer skills will be used in medical school, and suggests means for attaining computer competency prior to making application to medical school.

The Kentucky medical curriculum. A response to the call for educational reform: a GPEP report card.

The resources of an important educational grant provided by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, as well as designated local college and medical center funds, provided support for the renewal of the undergraduate medical education program at the University of Kentucky College of Medicine. The fully revised medical curriculum, adapted to changing professional and societal needs and completely in place by the 1994-95 academic year, was influenced by the recommendations of the General Professional Education of the Physician (GPEP) Report, issued by the Association of American Medical Colleges in 1984. This paper details each of the student-centered curricular changes in the context of the GPEP recommendation that it particularly addresses.

Developing generalists for Kentucky.

Since 1985, nearly half of the graduates of the University of Kentucky College of Medicine have chosen generalist careers, even though its students received almost no outpatient ambulatory training in primary care before 1990. This study determined the factors influencing the choice of generalist specialties in the absence of ambulatory training experience. A questionnaire was mailed to the 516 graduates of the classes of 1964 through 1989 who had entered a generalist specialty. A three-way ANOVA with one repeated measure was used to determine whether there were statistically significant differences in the responses of practitioners in the three generalist specialties (family practice, general internal medicine, or general pediatrics). Sufficiently complete responses were received from 187 graduates (116 family practitioners, 40 general pediatricians, and 31 general internists). Many of the physicians who had spent formative years in rural areas were practicing in rural communities. Many respondents had already decided upon a generalist career before entering medical school. Clerkships in internal medicine and pediatrics were an important influence, as was mentor role modeling. For pediatricians, an elective ambulatory care experience was also important. Educational experiences exert meaningful influences on students interested in a generalist career. Formal ambulatory care training experiences, while not critical for the selection of a generalist career, may heighten or confirm interest. Efforts that encourage students from rural communities to enter medical school appear to produce rural physicians.

Factors influencing medical students' choice of academic medicine as a career.

The purpose of this study was to identify the characteristics of physicians who chose academic medicine as a career. A questionnaire was sent to all graduates of the University of Kentucky College of Medicine who held full-time positions in academic medical centers (n = 143). Ninety graduates (63%) returned usable questionnaires. Most of the physicians grew up in urban areas. Seventy-seven percent of the graduates entered academic medicine directly from their residency or fellowship programs. The most important factors cited by respondents as influencing a career choice of academic medicine were an interest in teaching and a belief that their personality and skills suited them to an academic environment. An interest in doing research was not a very important factor. Respondents also indicated why they chose their particular specialty. The two most important factors were the content of the specialty and intellectual stimulation. Most of these physicians (64%) were very satisfied with their careers in academic medicine.

Demographic, educational, and psychosocial factors influencing the choices of primary care and academic medical careers.

PURPOSE: To identify demographic, psychosocial, and educational variables that differentiate physicians who have chosen careers in primary care from those who have chosen academic medicine. METHOD: Questionnaires were distributed in the spring of 1992 to 704 physicians (546 in primary care practices and 143 in academic medicine) who had graduated from the University of Kentucky College of Medicine, 1964-1991. Mann-Whitney U tests and analyses of variance were used for statistical comparisons. RESULTS: A total of 336 physicians responded: 246 in primary care and 90 in academic medicine. The primary care physicians tended to come from smaller cities than did the academic physicians (p < .0001). The primary care physicians also had made their career choices earlier than did the academic physicians (p < .0001). For the academic physicians, long-term participation in research, intellectual stimulation, content of specialty, and influence of a mentor or role model were significantly more important factors than they were for the primary care physicians, for whom length of training, direct patient contact, and threats of malpractice suits were significantly more important. CONCLUSION: The results corroborate the findings of previous studies that suggest that career-choice factors are influenced by admission procedures and curricular structures. The number of graduates choosing careers in either primary care or academic medicine may be increased by increasing their experiences in those fields. Medical schools may be able to use demographic, psychosocial, and curricular factors to fulfill their particular primary mandates, whether they be producing physicians in primary care or in academic medicine.

Preventive medicine: what do future practitioners really need? Are they getting it in medical school?

The purposes of our study were (1) to determine preventive medicine topics most relevant to clinical practice, and (2) to determine if medical education affects medical students' attitudes regarding preventive medicine. Our method of study was two surveys. The first survey asked practicing physicians to rank the 23 topics identified in the Healthy People 2000 monograph and determine their usefulness in clinical practice. The second survey assessed medical students' attitudes about preventive medicine. Practitioners ranked tobacco, cancer, and diabetes as most relevant to the actual clinical practice of medicine. There were no correlations between practitioners' gender, age, or region and their rankings of topics. In terms of specialties, surgeons felt preventive medicine was less important than did family practitioners. Medical students' attitudes about preventive practices became significantly more positive as they progressed through medical school. Survey scores also improved significantly in second year students after their preventive medicine course. Students planning to be surgeons were less positive about preventive medicine. There is a continuing need for prevention education in medical school curricula, especially about tobacco, cancer, diabetes, and nutrition. Epidemiology and disease reporting might best be presented as "how to read the literature."

Changes in the patterns of specialties selected by high and low academic performers before and after 1980.

BACKGROUND: The goal of this study was to examine whether recently observed changes in the distribution of medical school graduates' choices are linked to level of academic achievement, graduation year, or both. METHOD: The authors studied the specialty selections made by two groups of graduates of the University of Kentucky College of Medicine: 319 who were elected to Alpha Omega Alpha and 276 who ranked academically in the bottom 10% of their classes. They also divided the groups into two time frames: 1964-1979 and 1980-1991. Two-way factorial analyses of variance compared the distributions of specialty selections according to time frame and to academic group. RESULTS: Significantly higher percentages of students in the low-achievement group selected primary care specialties (F = 14.76, p < .001), and this difference between the academic groups increased in recent years: 67% versus 41% in 1980-1991 compared with 53% versus 46% in 1964-1979. CONCLUSIONS: The specialty options most readily available to academically low-achieving medical school graduates are narrowing. Low achievers may be funneled into primary care simply because they cannot compete for other specialties. The authors recommend that: (1) recruitment and selection into primary care specialties should be made only after each candidate has been assessed over a broad range of cognitive and noncognitive factors and (2) academically low-ranking graduates should not end up in primary care specialties simply because no other specialty options are available to them.

Test performance of a local examination at a nonlocal site for evaluation of surgical clerks.

Surgical clerkships frequently use locally prepared examinations or nationally available test item banks as an alternative to Surgery Shelf Examinations from the National Board of Medical Examiners (SSNBME) for student evaluation. This study examines performance of a well-designed, item-analyzed local examination (available nationally through the Association for Surgical Education) at a nonlocal site. A 100-item test with a stratified sample from a 442-item bank was administered to 72 third-year students in addition to the SSNBME. The Pearson product moment correlation coefficient between the two examinations was 0.61 (p less than 0.001). Test performance between the local site and nonlocal site was compared by the Kuder-Richardson formula 20 for subtest reliability (internal consistency) and difficulty index (percent correct responses) and the point biserial correlation coefficient (correlation of a student's performance on one item with performance on the rest of the items) for test item analysis. Data show that despite fair correlation with SSNBME, significant deteriorations in both test item performance and reliability occur with the use of a local examination at a nonlocal site. This likely results from problems with content validity at the nonlocal site. Clerkships that use local examinations or national test bank items are strongly advised to evaluate test performance and revise appropriately before using results for formal student evaluation.

A comparison of the teaching effectiveness of the didactic lecture and the problem-oriented small group session: a prospective study.

A prospective study was designed to assess the teaching effectiveness of active learning in problem-oriented small group sessions (POSGS) compared with passive learning in didactic lectures (DL). Third-year medical students participated in a POSGS on breast disease and a standardized DL on thyroid disease (N = 23) or participated in a POSGS on thyroid disease and a DL on breast disease (N = 19). Students were tested with a multiple-choice examination (MCQ) and a highly structured oral examination (OE) administered by faculty members blinded about student group. Results of a between-within analysis of variance performed separately for breast and thyroid disease yielded significant group differences because of instructional method for thyroid disease (p = 0.003) and approached significance for breast disease (p = 0.095). Although no significant interactions were detected with percentage scores, a significant interaction between group membership and test type was noted for thyroid disease when the percentage scores were transformed to Z scores. We conclude that regardless of topic or testing method, students in POSGS tended to perform better than students in a DL and that the POSGS offers significant advantages over the DL in teaching surgery to third-year medical students.