RESUMO
BACKGROUND: Often, interventions targeting the kinematic and temporal and spatial changes in gait commonly seen after a stroke are based on observations of walking. Having the capacity to objectively identify such changes and track improvements over time using reliable and valid measures is important. The Wisconsin Gait Scale (WGS), which is comprised of 14 items, was developed specifically to examine and document gait changes occurring after a stroke. The purpose of the study was to explore the interrater and intrarater reliability and minimal detectable change (MDC) of the WGS when used by physical therapists to examine gait in adults post-stroke. METHODS: Fourteen physical therapists from 3 different acute inpatient rehabilitation centers rated videotapes of the gait of 6 adults post-stroke using the WGS. To minimize subject variability from fatigue, videotapes created by using 4 cameras provided right and left lateral, anterior, and posterior views of walking on a level surface. One complete ambulation trial from each subject post-stroke, which included 4 views of the same ambulation trial, was examined by the licensed physical therapists using the WGS. An opportunity was provided to review the tool and a practice trial was performed using an additional videotape not included in the analysis. Gait was examined on 2 different occasions separated by a period of approximately 21 days to minimize the effects of recall bias. Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICC) were used to examine the interrater and intrarater reliability of the WGS. RESULTS: Interrater (ICC = 0.83) and intrarater (ICC = 0.91) reliability were both good. The standard error of the measurement (SEM) was 1.47 and the MDC95 was 4.24. There was no statistically significant difference between the scores on the WGS when comparing the 2 different sessions. CONCLUSIONS: The WGS shows promise as an instrument that can make observational gait analysis more reliable. High intrarater reliability and low SEM suggests that the WGS is stable when administered across multiple sessions by the same rater. The ICC for interrater reliability was also good, which suggests that multiple examiners can effectively use the instrument. With minimal training, the physical therapists in the study were able to produce highly reliable results using the WGS to objectively document gait dysfunction.
RESUMO
OBJECTIVE: To assess test-retest reliability of the peak resistance torque and slope of work methods of spasticity measurement of the knee flexors and extensors in children with cerebral palsy (CP). DESIGN: Test-retest reliability study. SETTING: Pediatric orthopedic hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Fifteen children with CP. INTERVENTION: Knee extensor and flexor spasticity was assessed with an isokinetic dynamometer using passive movements at 15 degrees, 90 degrees, and 180 degrees/s taken 1 hour apart. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Peak resistive torque and work were calculated. The relative and absolute test-retest reliability was calculated by using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and Bland-Altman plots, respectively. RESULTS: Relative reliability was good (ICC>.75) for slope-of-work and peak resistance torque measurements at a velocity of 180 degrees/s, whereas reliability of peak torque measurements was decreased (ICC<.51) at slower velocities for both muscle groups. The 95% limits of agreement of Bland-Altman plots contained most data points for both methods, but the width of the limits of agreement were wide. CONCLUSIONS: The measurement of spasticity of the knee extensors and flexors in children with CP using peak-resistance torque at 180 degrees/s and the slope of work method has acceptable relative test-retest reliability. However, the absolute reliability of spasticity data should be considered cautiously.
