Quality control of elective surgery for drug-resistant epilepsy in a German reference centre--a long-term outcome study.

PURPOSE: Resective epilepsy surgery is the recommended treatment for a well-defined group of patients with drug-resistant epilepsy. Long-term outcome studies are an appropriate quality control to assess the value of elective surgical procedures ethically and economically. This paper reports the long-term post-surgical follow-up of adult patients of the Kork Epilepsy Centre. METHOD: Data collection was performed by means of a questionnaire to obtain updated information about postsurgical outcome, frequency and postsurgical seizure semiology in case of relapse, postsurgical use of antiepileptic drugs, social issues and satisfaction rates. We classified seizure outcome according to the ILAE surgery outcome scale (OC 1-OC 6). RESULTS: Outcome data of 340 adult patients were obtained. Mean post-operative follow-up was 6.7 years (range 1.0-21.6 years). Seizure remission was 67% if comprising patients with postoperative auras only (OC 1+OC 2). Sixty-two per cent of patients were completely seizure free. The majority of patients (78%) underwent temporal lobe resections. Sixty-four per cent of these and 52% of the patients with extra-temporal resections became completely seizure-free (OC 1). Only 34% of the patients with negative MRI achieved complete seizure-freedom. CONCLUSION: In line with others our huge cohort sample that covers decades of experience with epilepsy surgery revealed satisfying long-term outcome results. Best results were obtained in lesional temporal lobe epilepsy, least favourable results in MRI-negative epilepsy.

The effects of cognitive rehabilitation on memory outcome after temporal lobe epilepsy surgery.

OBJECTIVE: Epilepsy surgery is a valuable treatment option for patients with pharmacoresistant epilepsy, but seizure freedom is often achieved at the cost of cognitive impairments caused by surgery. The aim of this study was to investigate the short-term effects of cognitive rehabilitation on memory outcome after temporal lobe epilepsy surgery. METHODS: Two groups of patients who underwent temporal lobe resection, one followed (n=55) and one not followed (n=57) by postoperative rehabilitation, were evaluated with respect to memory and attention before and 3 months after temporal lobe surgery. The groups came from different epilepsy centers, but were largely matched with respect to age, sex, type of surgery, and seizure outcome. RESULTS: After surgery, 78% of the patients were seizure-free. Repeated-measures MANOVA revealed a significant "side x surgery" effect on verbal recognition and a "rehabilitation x surgery" effect on verbal learning and recognition. There were no effects for loss in verbal delayed recall or figural memory. Detailed analyses indicated gains as a result of rehabilitation, particularly after right temporal lobe surgery. Attention generally improved. The risk of manifesting losses in verbal memory was about four times higher without than with rehabilitation. CONCLUSIONS: Rehabilitation can counteract the verbal memory decline that is normally seen after temporal lobe resection. Its positive effects were evident particularly with respect to the more cortically associated aspects of verbal learning rather than to the mesial aspects of long-term consolidation/retrieval. Figural memory was not affected at all, and attention improved independent of rehabilitation. Interestingly, left temporal lobe-resected patients, who were most in need of an efficacious rehabilitation, profited less than right temporal lobe-resected patients, indicating that left-sided surgery may reduce the capacity needed for efficient training of verbal memory. Thus, rehabilitation has a positive effect on memory outcome, but its usefulness for risk groups and the question of whether training should be performed after or possibly before surgery are debatable. Further research should also address different interventions, longer-term outcome, and the carryover effects on everyday functioning.

The influence of antiepileptic drugs on cognition: a comparison of levetiracetam with topiramate.

Levetiracetam (LEV) and topiramate (TPM) are considered highly effective novel antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) in the treatment of focal epilepsies. To explore potential side effects, this study investigated their influence on cognitive functions comparatively by means of a standardized neuropsychological test battery assessing several cognitive domains. In this observational study, cognitive changes were explored in 30 consecutively recruited patients with focal epilepsy treated with LEV and in 21 patients treated with TPM, comparing functions assessed prior to gradual initiation and after reaching steady state of the individual target dosage. Before titration, patient groups did not differ significantly with respect to cognitive performance. Whereas the LEV group manifested no change in cognitive performance after AED titration, the TPM group worsened in the cognitive domains of cognitive speed and verbal fluency, as well as short-term memory. These findings suggest that TPM, unlike LEV, may impair frontal lobe functions. The lack of cognitive side effects related to LEV treatment may be relevant for treatment decisions.