Cross-reactions between Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae and Mycoplasma flocculare--practical implications for the serodiagnosis of mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine.

Previous studies using hyperimmune antisera revealed significant serologic cross-reactions between Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae and M. flocculare. These findings, coupled with observations that M. flocculare infection may be widespread, indicated that antibodies to M. flocculare might be common in swine sera and thus cause nonspecific reactions in serodiagnostic tests for mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine (MPS). Information reported here indicates that this premise may be invalid. Twenty-one swine were infected experimentally with M. flocculare. Sera were collected every 2 weeks and tested against M. flocculare and M. hyopneumoniae antigens in an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Immunoassays against M. flocculare revealed that swine were slow to seroconvert, and that seroconversion was characterized by low titers. Significantly, none of the sera reacted with M. hyopneumoniae. M. hyopneumoniae reference antisera, and sera from swine naturally infected with M. hyopneumoniae and M. flocculare were also evaluated by an antibody inhibition procedure, i.e., sera were mixed with M. hyopneumoniae or M. flocculare antigen, incubated overnight and tested against M. hyopneumoniae antigen in the ELISA. Treatment with M. hyopneumoniae antigen markedly reduced or abolished seroreactivity, whereas treatment with M. flocculare antigen had little effect. These findings suggest that swine infected with M. flocculare usually do not develop sufficient levels of antibodies to detract from the specificity of the ELISA used to diagnose MPS.

Serological, pathological and cultural evaluations of swine infected experimentally with Mycoplasma flocculare.

Fourteen caesarean-derived, colostrum-deprived pigs and seven conventional swine were exposed to low passage, cloned, field isolates of Mycoplasma flocculare. Sera were collected at varying intervals postexposure (PE) and tested against M. flocculare and M. hyopneumoniae antigens in a semi-automated ELISA. Swine were killed six to 17 weeks PE and their lungs examined grossly for lesions and culturally for mycoplasmas. Pure cultures of M. flocculare were recovered from the lungs of 11 of 14 swine killed six to 12 weeks PE. Mycoplasmas were not isolated from the swine killed 15 to 17 weeks PE. Only one pig had gross lesions of pneumonia. Immunoassays revealed that swine were slow to seroconvert and titers (expressed in terms of optical density) were low. Three of 21 swine had antibodies to M. flocculare five weeks PE, five of 17 had seroconverted at seven to eight weeks and all surviving swine had antibodies to M. flocculare 76 days PE and beyond. Net optical density of positive sera was in the range of 0.201 to 0.412 (an optical density of 0.2 regarded as the breakpoint between negative and positive reactions in our ELISA). All of the sera were ELISA-negative when tested against M. hyopneumoniae antigen. This is regarded as a very significant finding. There has been concern that field sera might contain antibodies to M. flocculare and that such antibodies could render serodiagnostic tests for mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine nonspecific. Results of the present study suggest that swine infected with M. flocculare do not develop sufficient levels of antibodies to interfere with enzyme immunoassays for M. hyopneumoniae.

Evaluation of the indirect hemagglutination assay as a practical serodiagnostic test for mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine.

Sera from swine experimentally or naturally infected with Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae (the etiological agent of mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine, MPS) were tested by the indirect hemagglutination assay (IHA), the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and the complement fixation (CF) test. The IHA detected antibody at comparable times and levels to the other 2 serological tests following experimentally-induced infection. In the late antibody response (greater than or equal to 86 days post-infection), the ELISA titres were higher than either the IHA or the CF test. The IHA appeared least satisfactory when it was used to test sera from commercial swine herds. When 1000 sera were tested, the IHA was positive for only 30 (22%) of 135 sera which were positive by the ELISA and the CF test. The IHA titres were low; 20 of the 30 sera had a titre of only 10. The end-points for the IHA were difficult to read for sera of this low titre. The relationship between positive IHA results for the herd sera obtained at necropsy, and the occurrence of gross or microscopic lesions typical of MPS was poor (41 and 50% agreement, respectively). An agreement of 39% was noted between positive IHA results and the localization of mycoplasmal antigens by an indirect immunofluorescence (IIF) test. However, IHA results correlated significantly (P less than 0.05) with gross and microscopic lesions, but not with the IIF test. No significant correlation was noted between the IHA (or the other 2 serologic tests) and the cultural isolation of M. hyopneumoniae or M. flocculare. On the basis of these results, the IHA appears to have limited promise as a practical test for the diagnosis of MPS in commercial swine herds because of the low titres observed, poor correlation of the IHA and other indicators of MPS, the necessarily subjective determination of end-points, and other inherent technical limitations of the test.

Serological cross-reactivity of porcine reference antisera to Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae, M. flocculare, M. hyorhinis and M. hyosynoviae indicated by the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, complement fixation and indirect hemagglutination tests.

The enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) indicated significant cross-reactivity between the antigens of Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae ( HyoP ) and M. flocculare (Floc), another porcine mycoplasma of wide distribution but uncertain pathogenic significance, when porcine antisera of each specificity were tested against HyoP antigen. The titers of the anti-Floc sera ranged from threefold to 13-fold less than the titer of the anti- HyoP reference serum at different times after immunization. These values ranged from onefold less than to fourfold greater than the minimal positive titer of 80. The antisera to the other porcine mycoplasmal antigens [i.e. M. hyorhinis ( HyoR ) and M. hyosynoviae ( HyoS )] reacted less strongly to HyoP antigen but titers only slightly less than to slightly greater than the minimal positive titer were noted for some sera. Cross-reactivity was also detected by the complement fixation test, although the titers for this test were generally lower than for the ELISA, presumably reflecting lower sensitivity of the complement fixation test. Positive indirect hemagglutination titers to HyoP antigen were also observed for both anti-Floc sera obtained at one or more times during the immune response. With two exceptions (one anti- HyoR serum with a complement fixation titer of 16 and one anti- HyoR serum with an indirect hemagglutination titer of 10), none of the anti- HyoR or anti- HyoS sera had detectable indirect hemagglutination or complement fixation titers to HyoP antigen at any time after immunization. The levels of cross-reactivity detected by the complement fixation test and indirect hemagglutination and, especially, the ELISA would be of significance for the development of any practical sero-diagnostic test for mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine.

Comparison of the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and the indirect hemagglutination and complement fixation tests for detecting antibodies to Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae.

Caesarean-derived, colostrum-deprived swine were exposed to a broth culture of a low passage field isolate of Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae by intranasal inoculation. The intranasal-inoculated swine subsequently were commingled with their litter-mates to effect transmission via contact-exposure. Sera were collected from the swine at two to four week intervals for approximately one year postexposure and evaluated by the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), indirect hemagglutination and complement fixation tests. The intranasal-exposed swine seroconverted earlier, developed higher titers and remained indirect hemagglutination and complement fixation positive longer than the contact-exposed swine. It was concluded that the antibody response of intranasal-exposed swine was artificially high and that sera from such swine were not suitable for evaluating the sensitivity of mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine serodiagnostic tests. The indirect hemagglutination test was relatively insensitive and technically cumbersome and the least promising as a practical field test. The complement fixation test appeared to be slightly more sensitive in detecting early antibody production (especially in contact-exposed swine) but it was the least sensitive in detecting late antibodies. The ELISA was generally the most sensitive procedure. Individual high ELISA titers were from ten to 32 times greater than maximum complement fixation and indirect hemagglutination titers. The most striking difference among the three tests was the persistence of high ELISA titers late in the study. All swine were ELISA positive at necropsy approximately one year postexposure despite the fact that lungs were devoid of lesions and culturally and immunofluorescent negative for M. hyopneumoniae.

Comparison of manually performed Microtiter plate and semiautomated (cuvette) indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays for the serodiagnosis of mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine.

Standardized enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays for the serodiagnosis of mycoplasmal pneumonia of swine were developed, using the traditional Microtiter plate method and a method based on semiautomated processor-analyzer instrumentation. The results of the 2 procedures were not significantly different when the titers of positive and negative anti-Mycoplasma hyopneumoniae standard reference sera were determined in triplicate in 3 separate experiments. Although both methods yielded reproducible results, the instrument-assisted enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay would be preferable if large numbers of samples are to be tested.